Honore has always been the rebellious youngest Bainbridge sister, but in spite of her numerous social faux pas she’s still been her father’s favourite. But when her father dies unexpectedly, she’s thrust upon the care of her siblings. Her older sisters are unable to supervise her due to their pending confinements, and her brother is ashamed of her embarrassing prior alliances. She finds herself banished to the family’s country estate with the obscure cousin of her brother-in-law to serve as a chaperone and companion. Honore never intended to embarrass the family by falling in love with a traitor or a murderer, but she can’t help the longing she has to be loved and cherished as her sisters are. Unsure whether she’ll ever be able to recover her reputation, she resigns herself to a life of spinsterhood, or perhaps a marriage of convenience. That is, until Lord Ashmoor appears in her life with some shocking news.
Prior to Honore’s father’s death, Lord Ashmoor had been about to sign an agreement to marry Honore, in spite of the rumours he had heard about her reputation. An American with a rather scandalous reputation of his own, he had hoped that an alliance with the Bainbridge family would improve his standing among the gentry—especially as Bainbridge had promised to help clear Ashmoor’s family name of the long-standing rumours that had kept from entering the country before now. Now that Bainbridge is dead and the scent of scandal still hangs around his youngest daughter, Ashmoor isn’t so sure about their proposed alliance—especially when someone seems intent on spreading further rumours about Ashmoor’s family. Either he must settle for marrying a much more socially acceptable woman, or clear his family name before he considers courting Honore. But when it becomes apparent that Honore’s family estate is linked to Ashmoor’s troubles, he must work with her to improve both of their reputations.
Although I hadn’t been entirely won over by the first Daughters of Bainbridge House novel, I’m glad that I persisted with this series. One of the main reasons I kept reading in spite of a slightly lacklustre beginning was because Honore was such an intriguing character, and I wanted to see how her story would pan out. Although she continually found herself in compromising situations in the previous novels, it was clear that all she longed for was someone to cherish her—something that I’m sure all women have been guilty of at some point in their lives. Who hasn’t looked for love in all the wrong places? A Reluctant Courtship is an encouraging and affirming tale of God’s continual offer of second, third and fourth chances, in spite of the many mistakes we make in our lives.
I was worried that Honore might reform entirely and become too prim and proper for my liking. I definitely prefer flawed heroines with some spunk compared to those who never make a wrong step in their lives. So I was relieved when the message of the novel became apparent—that God accepts us as we are, flaws and all. We don’t have to be perfect in order to gain God’s forgiveness, and he understands if we still make mistakes. Honore spent a large part of the novel beating herself up for not meeting the standards she (and society) had placed on her, and I realised that this is something I’m guilty of as well. The spiritual thread of this novel isn’t overbearing, but the message of God’s unconditional love and forgiveness is a great reminder.
All of the novels in this series have contained a good mixture of romance, mystery and history, and this one is no different. In fact, A Reluctant Courtship started with the heroine hanging off a cliff, so I dare anyone to claim they aren’t gripped from the first page! It was a fantastic opening, and while the rest of the book might not have been quite so heart-pounding, the mystery was definitely intriguing. It provided the perfect excuse for Honore and Ashmoor to be thrown together time and time again, and forced them to work out their differences and bind together for a common goal. There were some great suspenseful scenes that pushed Honore and Ashmoor closer together, and I think my only complaint about the mystery side of the novel is the villain. I truly did not expect this character of being the villain, but his reasons for his actions weren’t entirely believable. In a way, I’m impressed that the author was able to keep us from suspecting this character, but I was also a little confused by his motives.
My only other complaint about this novel pertains to the historical details. I’m not sure if this is just due to my lack of knowledge about the Regency period, but there were times when I felt confused by vague mentions of conflicts with France and America. I felt the same in the previous books in the series. I know that it’s hard to properly integrate historical details without being accused of giving the reader a history lesson, but sometimes I felt like I was only being told the bare minimum that I needed in order to understand the context of the story. There were several points throughout the story where I flicked back a few pages because I was sure I’d missed a crucial detail as some of the explanations given for certain conflicts felt a little unclear. Basically, I would have liked more historical detail and backstory to the conflicts that surrounded this novel!
A Reluctant Courtship is a great conclusion to the Daughters of Bainbridge House series. Continuing the blend of history, romance and suspense that I’ve so enjoyed about these books, the final novel allows Honore to finally tell her own story and capture the hearts of many eager readers. I was glad to see Honore get her own happy ending at last, and I’m equally satisfied with the beautiful message this novel contained.
Review title provided by Revell.