I think there's 2 camps of people who will rate this book. Mary simps, who will love it regardless, and then the rest of us. Don't get me wrong I'm not a Mary hater, but as a person who doesn't live and die to cook her cook book is meh at best.
Why meh, because of all the recipes in the book, only 3 seemed like something my family and I would enjoy. I made all 3 of them. 1 was a stand out, the other 2 were good, but my real grip with this book is it's ease of use. The steps aren't always in the order I'd set them up in, the directions are overly verbose it places, as someone who's neurodiverse it was hard for me to follow along at times. Also one of the recipes just skipped a whole step (toasting the pine nuts). Basically I needed more steps and for each of them to be concise.
Honestly, my biggest gripes with this book are 1. Accessibility 2. Recipe variety 3. Ingredient requirements, some of them had one off ingredients that I generally wouldn't have and I'd just be buying for one recipe never to see the light of day again.
TLDR: If you love Mary you'll probably like it, but you may have a hard time following along.