Marnie Harrison has been friends with Leighton Marx ever since high school. And while their friendship hasn’t always been exactly easy, they’ve been in each other’s lives through thick and thin. Which is why, when Leighton is abducted from the Tennessee River Festival right before Marnie’s eyes, she’s absolutely beside herself. Accompanied by Leighton’s husband, Owen, she just wants to learn what has become of her best friend.
Not long after Leighton has vanished, the police come to the conclusion that she must have been caught up in a trafficking ring. For Marnie and Owen, however, the not knowing just doesn’t fly. This feeling is compounded when Marnie randomly meets Sarah at a baby shower. A friend of a friend, she swears she saw something that day at the festival that simply didn’t make sense. But just as she starts talking, Sarah shuts down, leaving Marnie questioning everything she thought she knew about that horrible day.
Determined to find the friend that she’s lost, Marnie starts digging into that last day she saw Leighton. The more she unearths, however, the more stories shift, revealing secrets and lies. Worse still, someone out there doesn’t want Marnie searching—and they’ll do almost anything to get her to stop. So when threatening messages escalate to sinister acts, she must look deep within herself and decide whether Leighton being gone is really the worst thing that could happen. Is Marnie willing to put everyone and everything she holds dear on the line? Or does she quietly accept the standing explanation and get on with her life? After all, the truth might be more than she can handle.
Oh. My. God. From the thoroughly epic twists to the groundbreaking drama, If You See Me had me under a spell. Think I’m exaggerating? Trust me, I’m not. After all, I found myself reading until three in the morning because I just had to know. Who was truly behind the dastardly crime? And what was to become of all involved? There was simply no way I was going to put it all together before the last stunning reveal.
For that reason, the twists were easily the biggest home run from this near perfect novel. Shifting the plot first one way and then back again, I not only didn’t have a clue who to trust, but the constantly morphing storyline kept my armchair sleuthing to a minimum. And while I often enjoy working out the who’s, the what’s, and the why’s ahead of time, it was bliss just being taken on this twisty, twisty rollercoaster ride.
Next up were the characters in my list of top-notch puzzle pieces to this thrilling tale of suspense. While somewhat over-the-top, they did fit in nicely to a plot that required a definite suspension of disbelief, but only in the best possible way. At the same time, the constantly flip-flopping timeline allowed for well-written backstories and deep character growth—both of which sold the ultimate direction of this dynamite plot.
As for the details of the storyline, the multiple POVs, alternating timelines, and on-point ever escalating pacing meant for a tale that I quite literally lost myself in. Starting off with a simmering level of tension, as secrets imploded and threats were laid bare the suspense and unease really took hold. Even more astounding, just when I thought it was all over, the floor fell out beneath me with precisely one more staggering twist.
All said and done, I couldn’t have been more impressed with this downright brilliant novel by Audra McElyea. With villains, innocents, and quite a few who were in between, this popcorn thriller was both a quick, easy read and one ball buster of an adrenaline boost. Take it from me, If You See Me needs to be on your TBR pile. The only remaining question is: are you on team Marnie or Leighton? Because you can’t be on both. Rating of 5 stars.
Thank you to Audra McElyea, Counterplay Press, and Thriller Book Lovers Promotions for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: December 5, 2023
Scroll down for my potentially plot spoiling trigger list.
Trigger warning: stalking, kidnapping, miscarriage, eating disorder, blackmail, infidelity, arson, depression, mention of: death of parents, attempted suicide
*Note about TW: None of the above were particularly graphic, so unless you’re particularly affected by one of them, I wouldn’t hesitate to read this book.