Even with the full extra star given to anything related to Joss Whedon or Buffy the Vampire Slayer this book rates only four stars. I would be very dismayed if Ms. Stafford has ever had any other thing she's written published and it makes me sad that her treatment of this very intelligent and ground-breaking series was the one published. She writes like an over-enthusiastic tenth-grader talking to her friends about how super awesome her favorite show is. Compound sentences are rife with subject-verb disagreement, she relies excessively on the same transitional phrases, and spelling and grammar errors can be found on an inordinate number of pages for a professionally published book. I also take issue with the fact that her "Episode Guides" are more like reviews, showcasing her personal opinion and copious amounts of "nitpicks." These nitpicks are sometimes laughable, in that I could come up with several perfectly reasonable explanations for much of what she seems to find contradictory about the events of the show.
I find the most egregious of her excessively belabored opinions to be that Riley is "boring" and his relationship with Buffy has no chemistry. I might actually be a little more critical of her because of this opinion, because I really love that Joss gave Buffy the opportunity to see how she would related with a "nice, normal" guy. If Buffy's only relationships in the show had been with men who had superhero powers and "darkness" in them, we would never know (and neither would she) if she could have a "normal" relationship. It's precisely because the Riley relationship did not work out that we are able to accept Buffy and Spike together.
On a more positive note, the actor bio's were very thorough, it was interesting to read about the Posting Board Parties (I think BtVS might be the first show to truly embrace the online fans), and the quiz was appropriately challenging. I was a little confused by the chapter on "Little Willow" who is a prominent member of the posting board and runs many of the official websites of the cast. It was interesting to read about her, but I don't know that she is due an entire chapter in a book like this. I would be more interested in the Posting Board member who was eventually hired as a writer on Angel. I would also have liked more on Andy Hallett, Mercedes McNab, Adam Busch, Danny Strong, and Tom Lenk. In fact, I think that as the most "recurring" recurring character on Buffy, Danny definitely deserved a bio.
Having said all that; however, this is a welcome addition to any Buffy fan's collection of reference material.