What do you think?
Rate this book
Suing Cinderella
All's fair in love and lawsuits...
Jilted at the altar, heartbroken Scotland “Scottie” Holiday feels utterly conned by her supposed Prince Charming. In reflecting on her ethos of love, however, Scottie determines the real villain is the Kingston Company: the children’s entertainment and amusement park conglomerate responsible for all those glittery fairy tales she watched on a loop growing up. With her best friend and ruthless corporate litigator Peyton by her side, Scottie decides to sue Kingston for false advertising and emotional distress, claiming she has been duped by their magical, misleading stories of happily-never-after.
Enter Harrison Hayes, Kingston’s dashing defense attorney. A Kingston loyalist and brilliant mind, Harrison proves to be a formidable adversary, with his deep knowledge of the law (and even deeper brown eyes). Soon, there are more sparks flying in Scottie’s case of a lifetime than in Kingston’s nightly fireworks show—and staying away from each other proves a trial in more ways than one. As the gavel comes down, and their connection heats up, Scottie is forced to face the evidence and the truth. She must summon her past, cross-examine her heart, and reach her verdict on one final question: do fairy tales exist after all?
Jilted at the altar, heartbroken Scotland “Scottie” Holiday feels utterly conned by her supposed Prince Charming. In reflecting on her ethos of love, however, Scottie determines the real villain is the Kingston Company: the children’s entertainment and amusement park conglomerate responsible for all those glittery fairy tales she watched on a loop growing up. With her best friend and ruthless corporate litigator Peyton by her side, Scottie decides to sue Kingston for false advertising and emotional distress, claiming she has been duped by their magical, misleading stories of happily-never-after.
Enter Harrison Hayes, Kingston’s dashing defense attorney. A Kingston loyalist and brilliant mind, Harrison proves to be a formidable adversary, with his deep knowledge of the law (and even deeper brown eyes). Soon, there are more sparks flying in Scottie’s case of a lifetime than in Kingston’s nightly fireworks show—and staying away from each other proves a trial in more ways than one. As the gavel comes down, and their connection heats up, Scottie is forced to face the evidence and the truth. She must summon her past, cross-examine her heart, and reach her verdict on one final question: do fairy tales exist after all?
383 pages, Paperback
Published November 14, 2023
About the author
Stephanie Mack
3 books173 followersStephanie Mack is an author with a passion for storytelling—on the page, on the mic, and beyond. Her novels blend women's fiction and romantic elements with meaningful insights for readers navigating the complexities of modern life. Stephanie lives in Orange County, California, with her husband, three daughters, and beloved mini Bernedoodle.
Let's Connect!
Email: stephanie@stephaniemack.com
Instagram: @stephanienmack
Facebook: www.facebook.com/stephanienicolemack
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/stephanienmack/
www.stephaniemack.com
Let's Connect!
Email: stephanie@stephaniemack.com
Instagram: @stephanienmack
Facebook: www.facebook.com/stephanienicolemack
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/stephanienmack/
www.stephaniemack.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews
November 19, 2023
3,5 🧚♀️🤔🤔⭐️s
In general, this story was amazing and beautifully written.
The premise had originality and kept me engaged.
Scottie had been surrounded by the Kingston magic since she was a little girl. (The Kingston Company was like Disney.)
She believed in fairy tales until her soon-to-be-husband left her at the altar.
So after that terrible incident, she was so heartbroken that she decided to sue the Kingston Company being liable for peddling a false promise of happily ever after.
I enjoyed the relationships and bonds among the characters, the story’s structure, the depth, the pace, the courtroom scenes.
Regardless, there was NO romance. And if there was, it was so minor.
Scottie and Harrison were wonderful characters, but they didn’t spend time together as a couple.
They shared a very few meet cute moments, but their romantic relationship at the very end of the story was abruptly and very hastily mentioned.
In general, this story was amazing and beautifully written.
The premise had originality and kept me engaged.
Scottie had been surrounded by the Kingston magic since she was a little girl. (The Kingston Company was like Disney.)
She believed in fairy tales until her soon-to-be-husband left her at the altar.
So after that terrible incident, she was so heartbroken that she decided to sue the Kingston Company being liable for peddling a false promise of happily ever after.
I enjoyed the relationships and bonds among the characters, the story’s structure, the depth, the pace, the courtroom scenes.
Regardless, there was NO romance. And if there was, it was so minor.
Scottie and Harrison were wonderful characters, but they didn’t spend time together as a couple.
They shared a very few meet cute moments, but their romantic relationship at the very end of the story was abruptly and very hastily mentioned.
January 15, 2025
What mommy issues can do!
FMC spent her whole life under the heavy influence of Kingstone material ( an alias for Disney so the author don't get in legal trouble ;) all the movies about princesses, happily ever afters, songs about magical love... came all crushing down when her fiancé confessed at the altar that he cheated.
FMC had an emotional breakdown and knew without a doubt that her conception of what "love" is has been taught to her by Kingstone cuz she never had a present mother who would teach her what to expect from boys or men.
She decides to sue Kingstone Industry for "Emotional damage" and "Failure to make the audience aware of the unreal nature of their fairytales".
Enter: MMC the lawyer of Kingstone. The handsome devil with a pure heart of gold.
Checking the box of a book with a "Purple cover" in my Bingo Challenge of 2025.
25 ┃37┃87┃13┃68┃40┃32┃59┃76┃44
10┃86┃4 ┃45┃47┃98┃50┃14┃85┃75
88┃51┃ 9┃2┃42┃29┃ 24┃92┃ 82┃1
100┃34┃17┃96┃43┃49┃64┃70┃15┃38
84┃31┃ 62┃7┃21┃73┃28┃46┃90┃77
3⭕┃12⭕┃80┃ 69┃52⭕┃ 65⭕┃54⭕┃ 91⭕┃23⭕┃ 72⭕
18┃95┃ 22┃99┃93┃74┃41┃8┃35┃ 58
57┃94┃ 16┃56┃ 5┃60┃78┃ 26┃81┃ 61
97┃48┃ 79┃67┃ 53┃30┃ 6┃36┃89┃ 33
71┃19┃ 39┃66┃ 55┃27┃ 20┃63┃ 11┃83
January 31, 2024
This book was so much fun, unique, witty and fun. It touches deep subjects but with so much heart you can’t help but smile while reading it. Perfect for Disney fans or if you beleive in second chances like me.
March 11, 2024
"The people we love, with all that we've got, possess the power to crush us.
It's all part of the deal.
The act of faith, in hoping for anything, is to make ourselves open and vulnerable to the possibility of disenchantment."
November 13, 2023
I am truly blown away by Stephanie’s sophomore novel! When We Blinked is one I still think about and I was beyond excited to get an early copy of Suing Cinderella.
Love, abandonment, friendship and hope all with a picture perfect backdrop of everyone’s favorite amusement park… Kingston Court 😉
The way I know Stephanie put her heart into this book… it leapt of the pages!
You’re in for a treat when you pick this one up! From the very first chapter… the jaw drop, you’ll know when… the authors note that I loved SOOO MUCH! To her acknowledgments. Ok I’ll read your grocery list Stephanie, let’s be real!
Thank you for the advanced copy! I’m excited for the world to meet Scottie and Harrison!
Love, abandonment, friendship and hope all with a picture perfect backdrop of everyone’s favorite amusement park… Kingston Court 😉
The way I know Stephanie put her heart into this book… it leapt of the pages!
You’re in for a treat when you pick this one up! From the very first chapter… the jaw drop, you’ll know when… the authors note that I loved SOOO MUCH! To her acknowledgments. Ok I’ll read your grocery list Stephanie, let’s be real!
Thank you for the advanced copy! I’m excited for the world to meet Scottie and Harrison!
June 7, 2024
A fun audiobook, it has an interesting premise - suing an entertainment conglomerate for false advertising and emotional distress, after being jilted at the altar… Will she win? I personally think the ending was satisfying and as it should be. But did she win? You’ll have to read / listen to find out!👩🏻⚖️
This audio is 9.5 hours and the narrators are amazing. Yay for dual pov and two narrators. First time I’m listening to an audiobook at 2x speed, it adds to the whole drama of the story imho.
This audio is 9.5 hours and the narrators are amazing. Yay for dual pov and two narrators. First time I’m listening to an audiobook at 2x speed, it adds to the whole drama of the story imho.
January 25, 2024
TITLE: SUING CINDERELLA
AUTHOR: Stephanie Mack
PUB DATE: 11.14.2023
This book is for all the young women who believes in happy ever after and despite it all, never lost hope.
This is my first Stephanie Mack book and I’m so glad to have discovered a new author to me with this absolute joy of a book, SUING CINDERELLA. It was a fun read for me and I just love a great romcom story that is fast paced and engaging.
The story is about Scottie Holiday we gets conned in the altar by her Prince Charming. Of course, she blames Kingston for all the unrealistic expectations and fairy tale dreams she was made to believe ever since she was a little girl. So sue she must! Her best friend Payton agrees to take on Kingston. Enter Harrison Hayes the charming lawyer defending Kingston and sparks start flying.
I enjoyed this one even though it might be over the top - I enjoy a good escape read and a romcom was just what I needed. This was a fun one!
AUTHOR: Stephanie Mack
PUB DATE: 11.14.2023
This book is for all the young women who believes in happy ever after and despite it all, never lost hope.
This is my first Stephanie Mack book and I’m so glad to have discovered a new author to me with this absolute joy of a book, SUING CINDERELLA. It was a fun read for me and I just love a great romcom story that is fast paced and engaging.
The story is about Scottie Holiday we gets conned in the altar by her Prince Charming. Of course, she blames Kingston for all the unrealistic expectations and fairy tale dreams she was made to believe ever since she was a little girl. So sue she must! Her best friend Payton agrees to take on Kingston. Enter Harrison Hayes the charming lawyer defending Kingston and sparks start flying.
I enjoyed this one even though it might be over the top - I enjoy a good escape read and a romcom was just what I needed. This was a fun one!
Read
May 21, 2024🏰 What’s it about?
When Scottie is left at the altar, she spirals. And as she struggles with her dentist career she comes to the conclusion that all her woes began with her infatuation with the fairy tale princes of her childhood movies. And thus, the creator of those movies, Kingston Company (ala Disney) is the true villain for setting up unrealistic expectations. And so, with the help of her lawyer friend, they pursue a case against the company.
When Harrison, a lawyer for Kingston, is assigned the case he is irritated that he’s been handed a throwaway lawsuit… until it’s not. And when Harrison shows up to court he’s greeted by the plaintiff: Scottie, the woman he connected with in running club.
Over the course of hearings and time in the court room (and outside run ins), these two get to know more about one another and slowly adversity turns to attraction.
♥️ My thoughts:
🎧 I listened to this one on audio and both narrators did a great job of performing this story!
This one is super sweet. I enjoyed reading how Scottie compared all of her past doomed romances to fairy tale princes, some hilariously so. I also enjoyed the deep dive into the original fairy tales and how they were altered to be more palatable.
At first I lifted an eyebrow at someone suing a movie company for her personal relationship pain, but I appreciated how many characters called this out as ludicrous. And yet, it still worked!
Harrison’s backstory tugs at the heart and I loved watching his character growth throughout the story. I also adored Scottie’s dad.
😍 Also, we all need a best friend who will champion us during life’s tough times, and Payton is most certainly that.
💎 I wish we got a bit more romance page time, but overall a sweet, heart tugging romcom perfect for Disney lovers!
When Scottie is left at the altar, she spirals. And as she struggles with her dentist career she comes to the conclusion that all her woes began with her infatuation with the fairy tale princes of her childhood movies. And thus, the creator of those movies, Kingston Company (ala Disney) is the true villain for setting up unrealistic expectations. And so, with the help of her lawyer friend, they pursue a case against the company.
When Harrison, a lawyer for Kingston, is assigned the case he is irritated that he’s been handed a throwaway lawsuit… until it’s not. And when Harrison shows up to court he’s greeted by the plaintiff: Scottie, the woman he connected with in running club.
Over the course of hearings and time in the court room (and outside run ins), these two get to know more about one another and slowly adversity turns to attraction.
♥️ My thoughts:
🎧 I listened to this one on audio and both narrators did a great job of performing this story!
This one is super sweet. I enjoyed reading how Scottie compared all of her past doomed romances to fairy tale princes, some hilariously so. I also enjoyed the deep dive into the original fairy tales and how they were altered to be more palatable.
At first I lifted an eyebrow at someone suing a movie company for her personal relationship pain, but I appreciated how many characters called this out as ludicrous. And yet, it still worked!
Harrison’s backstory tugs at the heart and I loved watching his character growth throughout the story. I also adored Scottie’s dad.
😍 Also, we all need a best friend who will champion us during life’s tough times, and Payton is most certainly that.
💎 I wish we got a bit more romance page time, but overall a sweet, heart tugging romcom perfect for Disney lovers!
January 20, 2024
This is my favorite rom-com I have read in a long time. So many books in this genre are tired, recycled, unoriginal. Suing Cinderella is fresh, witty, poignant, wholesome, with a few plot twists I did not see coming. I loved the authenticity of the characters, loved the 90s/2000s pop culture references, and loved the dual narrator perspectives. This book was such a TREAT to read. I truly loved everything from the Prologue (straight fire) all the way to the Acknowledgments at the end (which actually made me choke up). If you want a book that just makes you feel good, read this!
December 28, 2023
I had loved this author's previous book WHEN WE BLINKED so I was excited to get get a copy of this one to get to early. I really enjoyed this one too. A really fun romcom! When Scotland (Scottie) is jilted at the altar, she decides to go after (sue) Kingston Company, a children's amusement park and entertainment business (think “Disney”). She says she's suffered emotional distress and the company has given children false dreams of the “happily ever after”. She hires her friend Peyton who is an attorney. Kingston has a defense attorney who she just can't stop thinking about, and the feeling just might be mutual!!
Although it may seem a little far fetched, I thought it was an entertaining, fun read. I enjoyed the original story and the characters. I'd definitely recommend this for my romcom lovers.
Thank you to the author and SuzyApprovedBookTours for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Although it may seem a little far fetched, I thought it was an entertaining, fun read. I enjoyed the original story and the characters. I'd definitely recommend this for my romcom lovers.
Thank you to the author and SuzyApprovedBookTours for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
October 5, 2023
Wonderful writing with perfect pacing. The dialogue was witty and I felt the characters were friends. More than your average rom com!!
March 10, 2026
Wow! I am blown away! Stephanie writes so fluently and descriptively so you feel as if you can see and hear what is going on. She is probably one of my favorite writers of all time (and trust me, I've read a LOT of books)! This novel was one of innocent romance under difficult circumstances. Friendship and family along with a few mentions of God are evident in this fairytale.
Is life all fairy tales?
Do you believe in magic?
Can you fall for the person you are fighting against who should be your worst enemy?
Can you forgive?
Positive messages: 4/5
Scotland learns the importance of forgiveness throughout the story as well as friendship. *SPOILER* When she blindsights her lawyer and loses them 7 million dollars, her lawyer (which is also her best friend) forgives her and continues helping her with the case.
Positive role models: 3/5
Scotland (or Scottie)'s mother left her when she was young and her father lied about her trying to contact him but at the end of the story *SPOILER* they meet again. Her father fills in for her mother over the years to help her grow up and so do all of the princesses at Kingston.
Sex, romance, and nudity: 2/5
Scottie and Harrison innocently kiss (descriptive scene) and flirt with each other throughout the book.
Language: 0/5
No cursing.
Drinking and drugs: 0/5
No drinking present.
AGE RATING: 13+
This is cute, innocent romance fairytale suitable for teenagers and young adults. There is no foul language or drinking. There is a descriptive kissing scene, which is why I would not recommend this book to tweens. Also, it can be hard to follow at some points if you are not old enough to understand how court works. Compared to When We Blinked (which was FANTASTIC) this book is much cleaner and has no sexual scenes.
Well written and a cute candy fairytale romance!
- - -A year later- - -
Wow, has my writing style changed since then 😅😅
Let me revise:
This book is very unique. Cheesy, yes. Kind of stupid? Also, yes. But you have to give it to Stephanie for coming up with a unique plot, because that's very hard to find in romance novels nowadays.
Anyhow, that's all I wanted to say.
I will leave my OG review (and rating) for memories 😂
Is life all fairy tales?
Do you believe in magic?
Can you fall for the person you are fighting against who should be your worst enemy?
Can you forgive?
Positive messages: 4/5
Scotland learns the importance of forgiveness throughout the story as well as friendship. *SPOILER* When she blindsights her lawyer and loses them 7 million dollars, her lawyer (which is also her best friend) forgives her and continues helping her with the case.
Positive role models: 3/5
Scotland (or Scottie)'s mother left her when she was young and her father lied about her trying to contact him but at the end of the story *SPOILER* they meet again. Her father fills in for her mother over the years to help her grow up and so do all of the princesses at Kingston.
Sex, romance, and nudity: 2/5
Scottie and Harrison innocently kiss (descriptive scene) and flirt with each other throughout the book.
Language: 0/5
No cursing.
Drinking and drugs: 0/5
No drinking present.
AGE RATING: 13+
This is cute, innocent romance fairytale suitable for teenagers and young adults. There is no foul language or drinking. There is a descriptive kissing scene, which is why I would not recommend this book to tweens. Also, it can be hard to follow at some points if you are not old enough to understand how court works. Compared to When We Blinked (which was FANTASTIC) this book is much cleaner and has no sexual scenes.
Well written and a cute candy fairytale romance!
- - -A year later- - -
Wow, has my writing style changed since then 😅😅
Let me revise:
This book is very unique. Cheesy, yes. Kind of stupid? Also, yes. But you have to give it to Stephanie for coming up with a unique plot, because that's very hard to find in romance novels nowadays.
Anyhow, that's all I wanted to say.
I will leave my OG review (and rating) for memories 😂
January 3, 2024
Suing Cinderella is a fun and fast paced closed door romcom. It is rare that I read a book in a day but I could not put this one down.
Most little girls group up pretending they are a Princess. They watch all the fairy tales hoping one day their dream of marrying the handsome Prince will come true.
Scotland (Scottie) Holiday's mom left her when she was seven. She grew up watching all the Kingston fairy tales dreaming of her happily ever after.
Scottie is left at the alter by her Prince Charming. She is heartbroken and without a job. Scottie blames all those fairy tales for giving her false hope. She decides to sue the conglomerate corporation Kingston for promoting unrealistic dreams. Scotties best friend and cutthroat lawyer Payton agrees to take on the case.
Harrison Hayes is the handsome defense lawyer for Kingston and this will be his first case. Sparks begin to fly between Harrison and Scottie. Can they keep away from each other until the trial is over? Will Scottie face her past and get her happily every after?
I love Scottie's relationship with her Dad. Peyton and Scottie have been friends since they were in elementary school and I enjoyed their fun banter. I also enjoyed Scottie comparing each of her old boyfriends to a Kingston Prince. I could not help but hope that Harrison and Scottie would become a couple.
Thank you Stephanie Mack and Suzy Approved Book tours for a gift copy of the book and this is my honest opinion.
Most little girls group up pretending they are a Princess. They watch all the fairy tales hoping one day their dream of marrying the handsome Prince will come true.
Scotland (Scottie) Holiday's mom left her when she was seven. She grew up watching all the Kingston fairy tales dreaming of her happily ever after.
Scottie is left at the alter by her Prince Charming. She is heartbroken and without a job. Scottie blames all those fairy tales for giving her false hope. She decides to sue the conglomerate corporation Kingston for promoting unrealistic dreams. Scotties best friend and cutthroat lawyer Payton agrees to take on the case.
Harrison Hayes is the handsome defense lawyer for Kingston and this will be his first case. Sparks begin to fly between Harrison and Scottie. Can they keep away from each other until the trial is over? Will Scottie face her past and get her happily every after?
I love Scottie's relationship with her Dad. Peyton and Scottie have been friends since they were in elementary school and I enjoyed their fun banter. I also enjoyed Scottie comparing each of her old boyfriends to a Kingston Prince. I could not help but hope that Harrison and Scottie would become a couple.
Thank you Stephanie Mack and Suzy Approved Book tours for a gift copy of the book and this is my honest opinion.
January 22, 2024
This book is just clever. It has romance, the idea of a perfect love gone wrong, and how childhood dreams can be part of adult disappointments.
It’s got legalese and courtroom drama as well as some entertaining dialogue.
I ran the gamut of emotions in this book as the main character, Scottie Holiday, decides to sue mega corporation, Kingston Company (think the mouse company everyone knows about), after her fairy tale wedding doesn’t happen.
The book is told in 2 points of view: Scottie and the lawyer for the Kingston Company, Harrison Hayes.
I thought the ending was interesting. I really loved and highly recommend not skipping the author’s note as Stephanie tells about her thoughts on fairy tale love and her writing process for this book.
It’s got legalese and courtroom drama as well as some entertaining dialogue.
I ran the gamut of emotions in this book as the main character, Scottie Holiday, decides to sue mega corporation, Kingston Company (think the mouse company everyone knows about), after her fairy tale wedding doesn’t happen.
The book is told in 2 points of view: Scottie and the lawyer for the Kingston Company, Harrison Hayes.
I thought the ending was interesting. I really loved and highly recommend not skipping the author’s note as Stephanie tells about her thoughts on fairy tale love and her writing process for this book.
January 14, 2024
This was such a fun read! I absolutely loved everything about this book. I adored the characters, I loved all of the “Disney” references, and the story itself was perfect. This story had the perfect combination of drama, romance, and twists.
I found this story to have a refreshing take on romance, as the love interests didn’t even spend time together throughout the book. Yet, somehow the premise was still believable enough for me. I loved it.
Read this if you like:
* Left at the alter trope
* Dual POV
* Witty banter
* Court room setting
This is one of my new favorites and I highly recommend picking this one up.
I found this story to have a refreshing take on romance, as the love interests didn’t even spend time together throughout the book. Yet, somehow the premise was still believable enough for me. I loved it.
Read this if you like:
* Left at the alter trope
* Dual POV
* Witty banter
* Court room setting
This is one of my new favorites and I highly recommend picking this one up.
January 22, 2024
This romcom is an interesting nod to Disney and it's fans everywhere. There are so many fun references to that culture, under the name Kingston not Disney, and also to the 90's in general. Scottie and Harrison are opposites on opposing sides of her lawsuit, but the attraction is undeniable and there's an element of respect during the proceedings. I loved reading the author's notes in the back and how she is inspired to write her stories.
I received a gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.
I received a gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.
Read
May 22, 2024I have loved fairytales since I could remember. Cinderella is one of my favorite movies. As I grew up I love retellings. Suing Cinderella was everything. The narrators did a wonderful job. The plot was fun and witty. It was lighthearted and even reminded me of Legally Blonde. It was like a rom com. The characters all had their issues but got their happily ever afters. If you love Cinderella and Legally Blonde you will love this book.
January 23, 2024
This book is for anyone who believes or has ever believed in the idea of happily ever after. This was such a clever book and I thoroughly enjoyed it from cover to cover. Scottie and Harrison were such fun characters. I enjoyed their chemistries and learning their back stories. Please don’t miss this one if you enjoy the magic of Disney!
November 15, 2023
4.5 lovely Whimsical stars
August 4, 2026
I don’t know how she does it, but she did it again. Another 5 Star read for me by Stephanie Mack.
I do have to admit, though, this one was ROUGH for me in the beginning.
At first, it came across as Disney-bashing with a strong “women don’t need men / I am woman hear me roar“ vibe, and that is just 💯 NOT my thing. 😂 I love Disney. And I’m also a woman who wants to be wooed, pursued, and rescued if the situation calls for it. I’m all for women having careers etc., but I’m equally supportive of women who genuinely want to be homemakers or dream about a knight in shining armor sweeping them off their feet.
So yes…I was nervous.
Without giving any spoilers, once we reached the Clarence Odbody scene, I knew I was going to be okay. That was the moment I realized Stephanie wasn’t actually placing all of life’s disappointments at the feet of a cartoon mouse.
From there, everything started to click.
Once the courtroom scenes begin, the story makes an important shift. The lawsuit may be the catalyst that gets the story moving, but it quickly becomes clear that the lawsuit isn’t really what the book is about. Scottie’s frustration is rooted in something much deeper (which, to me, is obvious from the get go), and I think most readers will recognize the real hurt behind her emotions. Whether or not the lawsuit itself feels believable almost becomes beside the point because it’s simply the vehicle that gets us to the conversations the book actually wants to have.
Now…let’s talk about Kingston Court.
This was probably the hardest part of the book for me to fully accept.
Because Kingston is so obviously inspired by Disney, constantly reading the fictional company name pulled me out of the story. It wasn’t because I didn’t understand why Stephanie may have changed it. There are a few differences, and there are probably legal considerations as well.
The issue was that almost everything else in the book used real-world references. Starbucks, Ben Affleck, Cheesecake Factory, The Kardashians, It’s a Wonderful Life, specific movie titles and quotes (and much more)…they’re all mentioned by name. So having this one enormous piece of the story use an alternate version felt inconsistent to me. My brain kept mentally translating “Kingston” back into “Disney,” and after a while it became distracting.
Ironically, I almost think changing more real-world references would have helped. If the world had leaned a little further into being its own fictional version of reality, Kingston would’ve felt much more natural to me instead of standing out.
Moving on…
The romance was absolutely perfect.
Despite the absurdity of their meet-cute and the lawsuit premise 😂, Stephanie somehow made the relationship feel believable from beginning to end. I loved the banter between Scottie and Harrison.
Scottie is sweet, kind, and incredibly forgiving, even when life hasn’t been particularly kind to her. At times I wanted to shake her, and at other times I just wanted to give her a hug. 💗 She’s frustrating and lovable in equal measure.
And Harrison…
As Peyton would say, “Mama likey.” 😍😂💀
Seriously though, Harrison was such a refreshing male lead. He’s confident without being cocky, bold without being reckless, and strong without becoming domineering. He knows who he is, isn’t intimidated by a strong woman, and isn’t afraid to stand his ground when it matters. Stephanie somehow managed to make him both incredibly sexy and genuinely kind, and there’s something so attractive about a man who’s both assertive and compassionate. She absolutely nailed that balance.
Then he threaded his fingers into hers…
It gave me the exact same butterflies as the hand flex scene in Pride and Prejudice. I mean…COME ON. 😂 The slow burn was slow-burning 😍. So much yearning. So much restraint. I was eating it up.
I was also pleasantly surprised by the Latino representation. It’s a very small detail, and I don’t need books to make a huge production out of those things, but finding out Harrison was Cuban was such a fun little surprise since I’m half Cuban myself. It wasn’t treated like a personality trait or a plot point. It was just part of who he was, and I appreciated that.
Stephanie Mack has such a unique writing voice. There’s something about the way she writes that mirrors the way my own brain processes thoughts and conversations. Her books always feel incredibly natural to me, and she’s very quickly climbed into my top ten favorite authors.
Thank you so much to Stephanie Mack and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC. I hope my review has been helpful.
I do have to admit, though, this one was ROUGH for me in the beginning.
At first, it came across as Disney-bashing with a strong “women don’t need men / I am woman hear me roar“ vibe, and that is just 💯 NOT my thing. 😂 I love Disney. And I’m also a woman who wants to be wooed, pursued, and rescued if the situation calls for it. I’m all for women having careers etc., but I’m equally supportive of women who genuinely want to be homemakers or dream about a knight in shining armor sweeping them off their feet.
So yes…I was nervous.
Without giving any spoilers, once we reached the Clarence Odbody scene, I knew I was going to be okay. That was the moment I realized Stephanie wasn’t actually placing all of life’s disappointments at the feet of a cartoon mouse.
From there, everything started to click.
Once the courtroom scenes begin, the story makes an important shift. The lawsuit may be the catalyst that gets the story moving, but it quickly becomes clear that the lawsuit isn’t really what the book is about. Scottie’s frustration is rooted in something much deeper (which, to me, is obvious from the get go), and I think most readers will recognize the real hurt behind her emotions. Whether or not the lawsuit itself feels believable almost becomes beside the point because it’s simply the vehicle that gets us to the conversations the book actually wants to have.
Now…let’s talk about Kingston Court.
This was probably the hardest part of the book for me to fully accept.
Because Kingston is so obviously inspired by Disney, constantly reading the fictional company name pulled me out of the story. It wasn’t because I didn’t understand why Stephanie may have changed it. There are a few differences, and there are probably legal considerations as well.
The issue was that almost everything else in the book used real-world references. Starbucks, Ben Affleck, Cheesecake Factory, The Kardashians, It’s a Wonderful Life, specific movie titles and quotes (and much more)…they’re all mentioned by name. So having this one enormous piece of the story use an alternate version felt inconsistent to me. My brain kept mentally translating “Kingston” back into “Disney,” and after a while it became distracting.
Ironically, I almost think changing more real-world references would have helped. If the world had leaned a little further into being its own fictional version of reality, Kingston would’ve felt much more natural to me instead of standing out.
Moving on…
The romance was absolutely perfect.
Despite the absurdity of their meet-cute and the lawsuit premise 😂, Stephanie somehow made the relationship feel believable from beginning to end. I loved the banter between Scottie and Harrison.
Scottie is sweet, kind, and incredibly forgiving, even when life hasn’t been particularly kind to her. At times I wanted to shake her, and at other times I just wanted to give her a hug. 💗 She’s frustrating and lovable in equal measure.
And Harrison…
As Peyton would say, “Mama likey.” 😍😂💀
Seriously though, Harrison was such a refreshing male lead. He’s confident without being cocky, bold without being reckless, and strong without becoming domineering. He knows who he is, isn’t intimidated by a strong woman, and isn’t afraid to stand his ground when it matters. Stephanie somehow managed to make him both incredibly sexy and genuinely kind, and there’s something so attractive about a man who’s both assertive and compassionate. She absolutely nailed that balance.
Then he threaded his fingers into hers…
It gave me the exact same butterflies as the hand flex scene in Pride and Prejudice. I mean…COME ON. 😂 The slow burn was slow-burning 😍. So much yearning. So much restraint. I was eating it up.
I was also pleasantly surprised by the Latino representation. It’s a very small detail, and I don’t need books to make a huge production out of those things, but finding out Harrison was Cuban was such a fun little surprise since I’m half Cuban myself. It wasn’t treated like a personality trait or a plot point. It was just part of who he was, and I appreciated that.
Stephanie Mack has such a unique writing voice. There’s something about the way she writes that mirrors the way my own brain processes thoughts and conversations. Her books always feel incredibly natural to me, and she’s very quickly climbed into my top ten favorite authors.
Thank you so much to Stephanie Mack and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC. I hope my review has been helpful.
August 8, 2026
Stephanie Mack has such a gift for creating characters and scenes that feel both completely charming and incredibly relatable. Suing Cinderella follows Scotland “Scottie” Holiday, a pediatric dentist who is a dreamer, visionary, ambitious, and—at her core—a hopeless romantic. After being jilted at the altar, Scottie decides to take on the company responsible for all those happily-ever-after stories she grew up believing in (Disney vibes!). Enter Harrison Hayes, a charming, teasing, emotionally soft, and brilliant lawyer who just happens to be on the opposite side of the case. What could possibly go wrong?
One of my favorite things about this book was Scottie herself. I loved watching her wrestle with what she thought love was supposed to look like versus what love actually is. There were so many moments where I could understand why she questioned the stories she had grown up believing, especially when she asks, “Hadn’t I bought the lie—hook, line, and engagement rock—that true love really fixed everything?” And then later, “Was I a woman with my own ideas and realistic expectations for love—or was I a product of storybook soup, spiked with poison and lies? Of tales laced with empty half truths that shape the world’s norms and kids’ dreams?” Those questions really made me stop and think about how much the stories we grow up with can shape the way we view love, relationships, and even ourselves.
I also really appreciated the storyline surrounding Scottie’s mother. Parents have such an impact on how we see the world as adults, and I thought Stephanie did a beautiful job showing how those early experiences can shape our expectations and perceptions without defining who we ultimately become. Scottie’s journey toward understanding her past, letting go of some of those assumptions, and figuring out what she truly believes was one of my favorite parts of the story.
And then there’s Harrison. I absolutely loved him! He was charming and teasing, but there was also such an emotional softness to him that made him incredibly easy to root for. He and Scottie had so much chemistry, and their banter was SO much fun. One of my favorite scenes was the run when Scottie’s shoelace breaks and Harrison switches it out for his own clean, unbroken one. It was such a small moment, but it said so much about his character and had me smiling so big.
I especially appreciated the Christian values and standards woven throughout this story. Faith never felt like an afterthought, and I loved seeing those values naturally influence the characters and their choices. The book explores heartbreak, forgiveness, expectations, family, and what it really means to believe in love again, all while pointing back to the importance of trusting God rather than the happily-ever-after the world tells us we need.
I also have to mention Stephanie Mack’s writing. The way she describes scenes and situations is such a gift, and it’s something I rarely see done this well. I could picture the moments so clearly (cue giggling while staring at my kindle), and her wit and creativity made this such a fun book to read. I can’t wait for each new release from Stephanie!
And I was so excited to see that Suing Cinderella had an epilogue! I love getting that extra glimpse into the characters’ lives after the main story wraps up, and this was the perfect finishing touch.
If you love Christian romance with witty banter, memorable characters, a little bit of courtroom drama, plenty of heart, and thoughtful reminders about love, forgiveness, and what we allow to shape our expectations, I highly recommend Suing Cinderella. This book is perfect for anyone who loves a charming romance that makes you laugh while also giving you something to think about long after you turn the last page. Five stars from me!
Thank you to the publisher, Tyndale, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
One of my favorite things about this book was Scottie herself. I loved watching her wrestle with what she thought love was supposed to look like versus what love actually is. There were so many moments where I could understand why she questioned the stories she had grown up believing, especially when she asks, “Hadn’t I bought the lie—hook, line, and engagement rock—that true love really fixed everything?” And then later, “Was I a woman with my own ideas and realistic expectations for love—or was I a product of storybook soup, spiked with poison and lies? Of tales laced with empty half truths that shape the world’s norms and kids’ dreams?” Those questions really made me stop and think about how much the stories we grow up with can shape the way we view love, relationships, and even ourselves.
I also really appreciated the storyline surrounding Scottie’s mother. Parents have such an impact on how we see the world as adults, and I thought Stephanie did a beautiful job showing how those early experiences can shape our expectations and perceptions without defining who we ultimately become. Scottie’s journey toward understanding her past, letting go of some of those assumptions, and figuring out what she truly believes was one of my favorite parts of the story.
And then there’s Harrison. I absolutely loved him! He was charming and teasing, but there was also such an emotional softness to him that made him incredibly easy to root for. He and Scottie had so much chemistry, and their banter was SO much fun. One of my favorite scenes was the run when Scottie’s shoelace breaks and Harrison switches it out for his own clean, unbroken one. It was such a small moment, but it said so much about his character and had me smiling so big.
I especially appreciated the Christian values and standards woven throughout this story. Faith never felt like an afterthought, and I loved seeing those values naturally influence the characters and their choices. The book explores heartbreak, forgiveness, expectations, family, and what it really means to believe in love again, all while pointing back to the importance of trusting God rather than the happily-ever-after the world tells us we need.
I also have to mention Stephanie Mack’s writing. The way she describes scenes and situations is such a gift, and it’s something I rarely see done this well. I could picture the moments so clearly (cue giggling while staring at my kindle), and her wit and creativity made this such a fun book to read. I can’t wait for each new release from Stephanie!
And I was so excited to see that Suing Cinderella had an epilogue! I love getting that extra glimpse into the characters’ lives after the main story wraps up, and this was the perfect finishing touch.
If you love Christian romance with witty banter, memorable characters, a little bit of courtroom drama, plenty of heart, and thoughtful reminders about love, forgiveness, and what we allow to shape our expectations, I highly recommend Suing Cinderella. This book is perfect for anyone who loves a charming romance that makes you laugh while also giving you something to think about long after you turn the last page. Five stars from me!
Thank you to the publisher, Tyndale, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
May 15, 2024
🦄🦄🦄.5/5
I loved the premise of this book! When I saw it, I was so excited to read about a romance that takes place between two individuals stuck fighting against each other in a courtroom. Instead, it was all courtroom drama and no romance.
We meet Scottie where she gets left at the altar by her cheating fiancée. While she’s wallowing in her new lifestyle of unemployment, homelessness, singleness and just plain ole sadness, she comes to the conclusion that Kingston (real life Disney) is the source of all her pain. She has this frivolous idea to sue this GINORMOUS conglomerate for convincing her that life is chalked full of love, magic and HEAs.
It took almost the entire book for me to even like or appreciate her character. In the beginning she was whiny and had no personality, because she wrapped her entire life around the idea of being a princess and going after the stereotypical fairytale. She came off as frivolous and naïve and I just couldn’t relate to her. But in the end, I did love her growth; she saw the difference between real life and an ideal, and how forgiveness comes with the price of peace for one’s future.
I did like Harrison a bit more than Scottie. Mostly because he seemed to have a more level head and was not fooled by what Kingston was presenting, but rather wanted to believe in a life full of hope, love and magic after he grow up in such a tragic way. But sometimes when he was narrating the thoughts in his head he came across as entitled and stand-off-ish. And the whole plot point of him and Gym Ashley was just cringy at best, even if I understood where the author was trying to go with it.
As for the romance, I really yearned for it. It would’ve been so good if we got it. But sadly, we had about 3 scenes they shared together where they were not battling it out in court, and by the end I felt like it was not realistic for them to be “in love” at that stage “relationship”.
If you enjoy NUMEROUS Disney and fairytale references, heavy lawyer logistics, courtroom drama, silly characters and life advice pick up this book!
I loved the premise of this book! When I saw it, I was so excited to read about a romance that takes place between two individuals stuck fighting against each other in a courtroom. Instead, it was all courtroom drama and no romance.
We meet Scottie where she gets left at the altar by her cheating fiancée. While she’s wallowing in her new lifestyle of unemployment, homelessness, singleness and just plain ole sadness, she comes to the conclusion that Kingston (real life Disney) is the source of all her pain. She has this frivolous idea to sue this GINORMOUS conglomerate for convincing her that life is chalked full of love, magic and HEAs.
It took almost the entire book for me to even like or appreciate her character. In the beginning she was whiny and had no personality, because she wrapped her entire life around the idea of being a princess and going after the stereotypical fairytale. She came off as frivolous and naïve and I just couldn’t relate to her. But in the end, I did love her growth; she saw the difference between real life and an ideal, and how forgiveness comes with the price of peace for one’s future.
I did like Harrison a bit more than Scottie. Mostly because he seemed to have a more level head and was not fooled by what Kingston was presenting, but rather wanted to believe in a life full of hope, love and magic after he grow up in such a tragic way. But sometimes when he was narrating the thoughts in his head he came across as entitled and stand-off-ish. And the whole plot point of him and Gym Ashley was just cringy at best, even if I understood where the author was trying to go with it.
As for the romance, I really yearned for it. It would’ve been so good if we got it. But sadly, we had about 3 scenes they shared together where they were not battling it out in court, and by the end I felt like it was not realistic for them to be “in love” at that stage “relationship”.
If you enjoy NUMEROUS Disney and fairytale references, heavy lawyer logistics, courtroom drama, silly characters and life advice pick up this book!
May 15, 2024
Someone’s a Disney Fan
Thoughts: 💡
Some parts of this were cute and I enjoyed the audio. There was a strong focus on family and friends which was nice. The characters have all had major heartbreaks and struggles but persevered to find their happy ending and the magic in their lives.
The legal drama was very similar to the pageantry of the Legally Blonde movies and Drop Dead Diva. The entertainment conglomerate that the MC wanted to sue was called Kensington but was very clearly the big mouse, that no one is ever allowed to name directly without forking over the big bucks. It’s very clear that the author is pro-Disney and Disney magic and goes on to sing the praises of the company in her author’s note, so if you’re a fan of the company I’m sure you will find this book very pleasant and entertaining.
There were references to real court cases, but they aren't accurately represented, namely the reference to the woman that sued McDonald’s for hot coffee. I don’t fully blame the author for that one, instead I chalk it up to one of the most successful uses of propaganda from a conglomerate. However, the propitiation of the propaganda was quite irksome to me and did negatively affect my thoughts on the book. There’s a very clear stance that Disney, God, and the power of belief are wonderful things. And the author seems to be a very positive person in general. So if those are things that you believe in as well then I’m sure you will enjoy this book.
⚠️Content Warning:⚠️
There are tidbits of church talk and scriptures with religious/ salvation talk at the very end. She basically delivers a sermon.
Stats:📊
💙💙💙💙🎧🎧🎧🎧
Clean RomCom: left at the altar, courtroom drama, forbidden crush, rivals to lovers, emotional scars, redemption, female friendship, WF + RomCom crossover
First Person, Past Tense, Dual POV
Thoughts: 💡
Some parts of this were cute and I enjoyed the audio. There was a strong focus on family and friends which was nice. The characters have all had major heartbreaks and struggles but persevered to find their happy ending and the magic in their lives.
The legal drama was very similar to the pageantry of the Legally Blonde movies and Drop Dead Diva. The entertainment conglomerate that the MC wanted to sue was called Kensington but was very clearly the big mouse, that no one is ever allowed to name directly without forking over the big bucks. It’s very clear that the author is pro-Disney and Disney magic and goes on to sing the praises of the company in her author’s note, so if you’re a fan of the company I’m sure you will find this book very pleasant and entertaining.
There were references to real court cases, but they aren't accurately represented, namely the reference to the woman that sued McDonald’s for hot coffee. I don’t fully blame the author for that one, instead I chalk it up to one of the most successful uses of propaganda from a conglomerate. However, the propitiation of the propaganda was quite irksome to me and did negatively affect my thoughts on the book. There’s a very clear stance that Disney, God, and the power of belief are wonderful things. And the author seems to be a very positive person in general. So if those are things that you believe in as well then I’m sure you will enjoy this book.
⚠️Content Warning:⚠️
There are tidbits of church talk and scriptures with religious/ salvation talk at the very end. She basically delivers a sermon.
Stats:📊
💙💙💙💙🎧🎧🎧🎧
Clean RomCom: left at the altar, courtroom drama, forbidden crush, rivals to lovers, emotional scars, redemption, female friendship, WF + RomCom crossover
First Person, Past Tense, Dual POV
January 31, 2024
When you wish upon a star…. ⭐️
I really enjoyed reading this book because the author used a few of her favourite pastimes in the story….running and Disneyland. Now we know the story is about Disneyland and all the Disney magic but all names have been changed, obviously. I loved reading about the inside secrets about Main Street, how people try to sue the park maliciously, and even how they pump scents throughout the park! I’ll be taking my Lu Lu next week for the first time and I’ll be paying close attention to detail this time!
Back to the book… The story is about a young girl named Scottie, who, like all of us, believes in fairytale romance. She thought she met her prince charming, but when he stands her up at the altar all her dreams are shattered. As a little girl she grew up going to Kingston watching their movies, buying their products, and she feels as though she bought into what they were selling, magic. So after her heartbreak, Scotty decides with the help of her best friend to sue Kingston and hold them liable for false advertisement. Scottie is told she has a great chance of winning this lawsuit but the first hurdle is getting past the opposing council. You see Scotty and Harrison Hayes had a very brief but memorable encounter, and even though Scottie is still healing her broken heart she can’t help but be smitten by the tall and handsome prince Harrison. The sweet and generous man that she met on a run is replaced with a serious attorney who won’t even look her in the eye. Scottie is determined to win this case, not just for herself, but all women who have fallen for Kingston‘s promises, but will it come at a cost? Maybe dreams can come true but you’ll have to read to find out!
I really enjoyed reading this book because the author used a few of her favourite pastimes in the story….running and Disneyland. Now we know the story is about Disneyland and all the Disney magic but all names have been changed, obviously. I loved reading about the inside secrets about Main Street, how people try to sue the park maliciously, and even how they pump scents throughout the park! I’ll be taking my Lu Lu next week for the first time and I’ll be paying close attention to detail this time!
Back to the book… The story is about a young girl named Scottie, who, like all of us, believes in fairytale romance. She thought she met her prince charming, but when he stands her up at the altar all her dreams are shattered. As a little girl she grew up going to Kingston watching their movies, buying their products, and she feels as though she bought into what they were selling, magic. So after her heartbreak, Scotty decides with the help of her best friend to sue Kingston and hold them liable for false advertisement. Scottie is told she has a great chance of winning this lawsuit but the first hurdle is getting past the opposing council. You see Scotty and Harrison Hayes had a very brief but memorable encounter, and even though Scottie is still healing her broken heart she can’t help but be smitten by the tall and handsome prince Harrison. The sweet and generous man that she met on a run is replaced with a serious attorney who won’t even look her in the eye. Scottie is determined to win this case, not just for herself, but all women who have fallen for Kingston‘s promises, but will it come at a cost? Maybe dreams can come true but you’ll have to read to find out!
December 28, 2024
As ridiculous as the concept of this book is, I found it weirdly believable! I would like to think nobody would try to sue Disney over the loss of their "happily ever after" but y'all are in this world with me and we all know people are crazy. I seriously couldn't tell through most of the book if the author was pro-Disney or anti-Disney; in fact I wasn't totally sure until the Author's Note at the end. That's part of what lent credibility to the story, I think. It is a romcom so you can absolutely predict part of the ending, though you might be surprised at how some pieces come together. I did think some of the drama felt a bit forced, like it was needed but it wasn't transitioned into the story super well.
I appreciated all the Legally Blonde references and laughed at some of the fake-Disney (Kingston) Disney references. I suppose the point wasn't to try and hide them super hard since this is princess oriented and the biggest names there are all public domain, but I kind of wished some of them were a little cleverer than Ricky the Rat and Ilsa.
I honestly disliked most of the characters. I found them all to be at best vapid and shallow, and I really didn't care if either side succeeded or failed. My coworker from Cali says the LA area really is all like that but oof, just not relatable. This is my second contemporary Cali-based book in the past couple years and I felt similarly of the other one as well so maybe it's a sign to just not read anything contemporary that's based in California.
I thought the narrators did a good job on the audiobook and recommend this to anyone who loves a solid romantic comedy.
I appreciated all the Legally Blonde references and laughed at some of the fake-Disney (Kingston) Disney references. I suppose the point wasn't to try and hide them super hard since this is princess oriented and the biggest names there are all public domain, but I kind of wished some of them were a little cleverer than Ricky the Rat and Ilsa.
I honestly disliked most of the characters. I found them all to be at best vapid and shallow, and I really didn't care if either side succeeded or failed. My coworker from Cali says the LA area really is all like that but oof, just not relatable. This is my second contemporary Cali-based book in the past couple years and I felt similarly of the other one as well so maybe it's a sign to just not read anything contemporary that's based in California.
I thought the narrators did a good job on the audiobook and recommend this to anyone who loves a solid romantic comedy.
September 28, 2025
Stephanie's first novel When We Blinked had a huge impact in my life, so I was so excited to (finally, why did it take me so long???) read her second novel and it definitely did not disappoint! In my opinion this book is so much more than any one genre or any trope and it hits hard on so many different levels! The premise itself is intriguing and compelling and had me thinking hard about what contributed to my own belief systems, dreams and expectations. I can very much relate to Scottie's expectation of a happily ever after and devastation, confusion and anger when her own HAE comes crashing down around her. Did I agree with or relate to exactly how she chose to go about dealing with those feelings at every turn, no? I don't think I was expected to as a reader, in fact I think the author is inviting us to question some of her choices. I liked that I genuinely didn't know how this story was going to end or even how I hoped it would. I loved that the romance was not the entire premise of the story, and that the chemistry between the two main characters was palpable and the banter was a delight. Scottie's inner dialogue had me laughing out loud, and the last page of the book as well as the gorgeous author's note had me in tears. I liked how Mack wove her faith into the pages without it being overwhelming.
I'm so excited to see the re-release of this book in the near future and will definitely be posting my review on Instagram to celebrate that so more to come, can't wait for Stephanie's 3rd book!!
I'm so excited to see the re-release of this book in the near future and will definitely be posting my review on Instagram to celebrate that so more to come, can't wait for Stephanie's 3rd book!!
January 1, 2024
Smart and fun, Suing Cinderella by Stephanie Mack held my attention from start to finish. Scottie Holiday’s emotional distress and subsequent legal claim lands her opposite defense attorney Harrison Hayes. Though at odds with each other, Scottie and Harrison have bubbling romantic chemistry that complicates efforts on both sides of the lawsuit. These characters (and us readers) must examine all sides of the issue/claim. As a reader and as a former legal assistant, I thought the legal content was well done. I won’t disclose which side won the big lawsuit, but I will reassure potential readers that Scottie and Harrison get their expected happily-ever-after (which pleased my romance-loving heart). I also enjoyed the friendship and humor between Scottie and Peyton – we all need a BFF!
To my knowledge, there aren’t many legal romances in the Christian Fiction genre, so Suing Cinderella by Stephanie Mack holds a certain level of uniqueness even as it utilizes the enemies-to-lovers trope. This novel could almost be placed in the clean romance realm, but there is spiritual content toward the end. I like both categories, so I wasn’t offended by the minimal spirituality in the beginning. Overall, Suing Cinderella is a clean, fun read that entertained and made me laugh. Four stars!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I was provided a copy of this book by the author or publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.
To my knowledge, there aren’t many legal romances in the Christian Fiction genre, so Suing Cinderella by Stephanie Mack holds a certain level of uniqueness even as it utilizes the enemies-to-lovers trope. This novel could almost be placed in the clean romance realm, but there is spiritual content toward the end. I like both categories, so I wasn’t offended by the minimal spirituality in the beginning. Overall, Suing Cinderella is a clean, fun read that entertained and made me laugh. Four stars!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I was provided a copy of this book by the author or publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.
August 5, 2026
Suing Cinderella tells the story of Scottie Holiday.
Yes, that is truly her name. It's no wonder she's the star of a contemporary romance novel.
All jokes aside, I enjoyed reading about Scottie's heartbreak and her path to healing herself. I found this book to be unexpectantly thought-provoking. You see, Scottie sues Disney — sorry, Kingston— for selling fake dreams. It may sound ridiculous but I have found myself mulling over similar thoughts in the past.
If we encourage young readers, or in this book's case, young children that adore animation films, to ignore gut instincts and trust that it will all end happily after, what are we truly teaching them? If someone behaves beastly toward you, it should be more than acceptable to stand up for yourself instead of treating them with kindness while they continue to abuse you. If overlooking every flaw in someone's character is needed to find "true love", then is that love "true" at all? Scottie raises some valid points, and I found myself often agreeing with her.
The book was witty and had an engaging voice. I wouldn't, however, call it a straightforward romance novel, as the romance itself felt quite rushed and wasn't fleshed out. Even so, it suited the story well and I didn't feel like I was missing out.
Scottie and Peyton, her best friend since childhood, were incredible. I loved their vibe, their friendship. That was the true love story for me.
Yes, that is truly her name. It's no wonder she's the star of a contemporary romance novel.
All jokes aside, I enjoyed reading about Scottie's heartbreak and her path to healing herself. I found this book to be unexpectantly thought-provoking. You see, Scottie sues Disney — sorry, Kingston— for selling fake dreams. It may sound ridiculous but I have found myself mulling over similar thoughts in the past.
If we encourage young readers, or in this book's case, young children that adore animation films, to ignore gut instincts and trust that it will all end happily after, what are we truly teaching them? If someone behaves beastly toward you, it should be more than acceptable to stand up for yourself instead of treating them with kindness while they continue to abuse you. If overlooking every flaw in someone's character is needed to find "true love", then is that love "true" at all? Scottie raises some valid points, and I found myself often agreeing with her.
The book was witty and had an engaging voice. I wouldn't, however, call it a straightforward romance novel, as the romance itself felt quite rushed and wasn't fleshed out. Even so, it suited the story well and I didn't feel like I was missing out.
Scottie and Peyton, her best friend since childhood, were incredible. I loved their vibe, their friendship. That was the true love story for me.
December 19, 2023
witty, fun, romantic, and heart-squeezing
Stephanie Mack is consistent in coming up with refreshing premises that I’ve personally never been exposed to before. She makes these “big ideas” believable and truthfully makes me think her storylines can REALISTICALLY happen. I noticed this in her novel When We Blinked and I’m especially noticing it now for Suing Cinderella. *spoiler* like when Peyton describes how the McDonald’s cases gave her inspiration in the delectably described nail salon. This made me truthfully believe, wow, this premise is likely, which I’m always looking for in books even if I typically read fantasy novels*spoiler*. I loved that the dialogue was believable, witty, and most of all funny between Peyton & Scottie.
Loved the Male love interest too!! A real life prince.
This was a tear-jerker for me. Maybe because of my very personal experience with foster care, maybe because of references to things I’ve experienced on my own that felt so personal. My love for Disney and how those fairy tales inspired me to keep going (Go the Distance from Hercules was an anthem for me when I needed it). Overall, I loved the observation and commentary of family dynamics, especially non-traditional family dynamics. Highly recommend!
Stephanie Mack is consistent in coming up with refreshing premises that I’ve personally never been exposed to before. She makes these “big ideas” believable and truthfully makes me think her storylines can REALISTICALLY happen. I noticed this in her novel When We Blinked and I’m especially noticing it now for Suing Cinderella. *spoiler* like when Peyton describes how the McDonald’s cases gave her inspiration in the delectably described nail salon. This made me truthfully believe, wow, this premise is likely, which I’m always looking for in books even if I typically read fantasy novels*spoiler*. I loved that the dialogue was believable, witty, and most of all funny between Peyton & Scottie.
Loved the Male love interest too!! A real life prince.
This was a tear-jerker for me. Maybe because of my very personal experience with foster care, maybe because of references to things I’ve experienced on my own that felt so personal. My love for Disney and how those fairy tales inspired me to keep going (Go the Distance from Hercules was an anthem for me when I needed it). Overall, I loved the observation and commentary of family dynamics, especially non-traditional family dynamics. Highly recommend!
May 21, 2024
Jilted at the altar, heartbroken Scotland “Scottie” Holiday feels utterly conned by her supposed Prince Charming. In reflecting on her ethos of love, however, Scottie determines the real villain is the Kingston Company: the children’s entertainment and amusement park conglomerate responsible for all those glittery fairy tales she watched on a loop growing up
She is smart and beautiful and with her best friend Peyton by her side, she decides to sue Kingston for false advertising and emotional distress, claiming she has been duped by their magical, misleading stories of happily-never-after.
Harrison Hayes, Kingston’s dashing defence attorney, is brilliant and beautiful.
I loved everything about this book: the lively narration style, the underlying moral on every page, Scottie’s sympathy and internal dialogues, her wonderful relationship with her best friend, her father’s support and her relationship with Harrison. There were so many laughs, but also emotions.
Please don’t skip the author’s note: understanding how we reached the end of the book with her words is priceless, and I won’t deny that a few tears fell upon hearing her words.
After all, aren’t we all looking for our Happily Ever After?
https://www.instagram.com/p/C7PPRtyIZ...
She is smart and beautiful and with her best friend Peyton by her side, she decides to sue Kingston for false advertising and emotional distress, claiming she has been duped by their magical, misleading stories of happily-never-after.
Harrison Hayes, Kingston’s dashing defence attorney, is brilliant and beautiful.
I loved everything about this book: the lively narration style, the underlying moral on every page, Scottie’s sympathy and internal dialogues, her wonderful relationship with her best friend, her father’s support and her relationship with Harrison. There were so many laughs, but also emotions.
Please don’t skip the author’s note: understanding how we reached the end of the book with her words is priceless, and I won’t deny that a few tears fell upon hearing her words.
After all, aren’t we all looking for our Happily Ever After?
https://www.instagram.com/p/C7PPRtyIZ...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews