For an introductory level textbook, Block, Hirt and Danielsen did well in presenting a lot of information in one volume. The case studies were superb and very helpful, however, a lot of the text came up with conclusions that didn't make sense to the beginning reader. I found myself often asking the question "Why is that an acceptable answer?" when comparing two different companies in things like NPV and ratios. The answer is "because this is (that) we go with Company A." However, this makes an assumption that the student knows what a good industry ratio is or can make a proper evaluation to reach the same conclusion. As a student of finance, I want to know WHY do we select one company over the other. Don't just give us the equation, show us the math, and then select one over the other when we don't have the context in which to make a proper analysis. My critique would be unjustified if it was an isolated case, but it happens repeatedly throughout the book, which only served to add to confusion where there shouldn't have been any with an extra paragraph explanation.
The financial calculator and Excel spreadsheet calculations were worthless in the main body of text. Though the information can and probably is useful to some students, placing it in the main body of text just made it counterproductive. Should have been added as a sidebar instead so that way those who it applies to can find the information easily, while those of us who do not need it can just skip it without missing critical information in the text.
As I stated earlier, the sidebar case studies made this book practicable for students. There is a lot of great information inside the main body if you can pick it out between the finance calculator and spreadsheet formulas, and the case studies made the material more impactful through real world examples.
Another area that is both good and bad are the problems at the end of each chapter. The problems are well written and pertinent to the learning outcomes from each chapter. However, there is no answer guide at the back of the book from which a student can check his/her work. Many times I found myself wondering if I calculated something correctly with no way of checking my work. This is a detriment.
That being said, for the 16th edition of the book I would recommend the following changes:
- Add a paragraph explanation whenever the narrative chooses between Company A and Company B explaining why the choice was made and what the proper industry average or criteria is in making that decision (provide the context).
- Eliminate the financial calculator and excel spreadsheet information from the main narrative and place in sidebar separate from the main text.
- Add a section in the back of the book with the answers to each of the summary questions in each chapter.
What I appreciated about the volume was that it was progressive in nature. Once I mastered the material in the early chapters (especially Chapter 2 regarding ratios) it made the material in the later chapters easier to understand. The content itself is good and I learned a lot when I didn't have to deal with wading through spreadsheet valuations. The summary questions were helpful.