Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

이 결혼은 어차피 망하게 되어있다 [I Gyeolhon-eun Eochapi Manghage Doeeoissda] (Comic) #2

이 결혼은 어차피 망하게 되어 있다 2 [I Gyeolhon-eun Eochapi Manghage Doeeoissda 2]

Rate this book
“세상에서 가장 잘생긴 남자와 결혼하겠어요.”
17년 전의 그날, 내 삶의 모든 것이 요동치기 시작했다.

오르테가 황실로부터 명예로운 칭호를 수여받은 17가문의 대귀족. 그중에서도 최고 반열에 속하는 가문 중 하나인 발레스테나 공작가의 하나뿐인 여식인 여섯 살 이네스는 황태자비의 자리를 거부하고 같은 대귀족 중 하나인 에스칼렌테 공작가의 후계자 카셀을 결혼 상대로 선택한다. 17년 후, 카셀은 결혼 후 빼앗길 자유를 누리기 위해 많은 여자들과 염문을 일으키며 자유분방한 생활을 이어가고, 다른 여성과의 밀회 장면을 이네스에게 들키게 된다. 이네스를 만나 해명하려던 카셀은 네게 아무런 관심이 없다는 이네스의 말에 충격을 받고, 그날 이후 자신의 몸이 이네스 외에는 전혀 반응하지 않는다는 사실에 당혹스러워 하는데…

Episodes 15-28

288 pages, Paperback

First published October 5, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Cheong-gwa

15 books8 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
305 (47%)
4 stars
215 (33%)
3 stars
95 (14%)
2 stars
17 (2%)
1 star
4 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews
Profile Image for esperanza ♡.
128 reviews31 followers
July 9, 2026
ines my princess 🖤. I love to see her slowly falling for carcel and getting the love she deserves after all of the trauma she went through in her past lifetimes.
Profile Image for Hot Mess Sommelière ~ Caro.
1,520 reviews263 followers
September 5, 2025
Idk this second volume was kinda male-gazey in a way I did not appreciate

Even though the art is very pretty inside, these have the ugliest uggo covers ever (yes I know the US release chose different covers but the German publication follows the Korean release unfortunately)
Profile Image for Jess | jadecanread.
1,506 reviews193 followers
June 8, 2026
Hmph, this lacked the umph from the first volume, but is still relatively compelling.

I'll admit, the hopping from current timeline to flashes of the past or side conversations was a little off putting and confusing.

Art wise, GORGEOUS.
Relationship progression: their relationship reaches a new milestone and level of intimacy, but Ines is still keeping Carcel at arm's length, obviously. I'm not exactly feeling any chemistry between the two, but we're still early so I'll be a little lenient.

Recap: they get married, everyone is shook at Ines's beauty, they bang for like 10 hours that night, Carcel stands up to her mom on her behalf, they move to his post city, she's recluse, he's smitten, she schemes to get the household staff on her side, he's suspicious. She brings her old attendant and Carcel is jealous. More banging. Fin.
Profile Image for Wiktoria.
90 reviews1 follower
June 27, 2024
Nikt mi nie powiedział, że tam smut jest. Niespodziankę miałam
Profile Image for Bailey.
55 reviews
March 15, 2025
Raawwwrr wie ich diesen Manhwa liebe😩😩😩
Profile Image for Arimi Reads.
1,053 reviews10 followers
April 27, 2026
Final Thoughts
This second volume should've built further upon the story in the first one. However ultimately, the plot revolved around sex and the way it can be utilised as a tool. A lot of oohing and ahhing, and nothing like the book prior.

I will not be continuing this series.

Before thoughts
Book 2 and 3 are both available for order officially on the penguin website, in english. Book one was released in 2025.

Link: https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/46861...

I am very much anticipating the release of this (17th March 2026.) I'm unsure what this book will have in terms of content but I assume it's going to be a brilliant continuation of the first book. You can check out my review here:
The Broken Ring, Volume 1: This Marriage Will Fail Anyway
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for maryam.
116 reviews262 followers
January 6, 2025
the more you continue the better it gets ongg 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Profile Image for encore_un_manga.
513 reviews19 followers
June 20, 2026
Quel plaisir de retrouver Inès et Cárcel dans ce second tome !

Maintenant qu'ils sont enfin mariés, les voilà installés dans une maison au bord de la mer, loin de toute l'agitation de la haute société. Un cadre qui pourrait sembler idéal... sauf qu'Inès n'a toujours qu'une idée en tête : préparer son futur divorce. Malgré leur mariage, elle reste hantée par ses vies passées et refuse de croire qu'elle puisse un jour être heureuse. De son côté, Cárcel est complètement sous le charme de sa femme et semble bien décidé à lui prouver qu'elle se trompe.

J'ai trouvé ce tome encore plus addictif que le précédent. Une fois commencé, impossible de le lâcher. J'adore la façon dont l'histoire mêle romance, tension et exploration du passé d'Inès. Derrière son apparente froideur, on sent toute la douleur qu'elle porte encore en elle, et cela rend son personnage particulièrement touchant. Plus on avance, plus on comprend que son projet de divorce est avant tout une manière de se protéger.

Ce que j'aime le plus, c'est la dynamique entre les deux protagonistes. Les échanges entre Inès et Cárcel sont un vrai régal. Entre les piques, les non-dits et la tension permanente qui existe entre eux, leur relation est passionnante à suivre. Cárcel est d'ailleurs une très belle surprise : amoureux, patient quand il le faut, mais aussi incroyablement fougueux lorsqu'il s'agit de sa femme. Il apporte beaucoup de légèreté face aux nombreuses blessures d'Inès.

Le tome est également plus torride par moments, donc clairement destiné à un public averti. Les scènes intimes participent vraiment à l'évolution de leur relation et à cette proximité qui s'installe progressivement entre eux.

J'ai aussi beaucoup apprécié l'arrivée de plusieurs personnages secondaires. Ils ne sont pas là pour faire de la figuration : chacun apporte quelque chose à l'intrigue et permet de révéler de nouvelles facettes d'Inès et de Cárcel. Leurs interventions provoquent des réactions, des tensions ou parfois des prises de conscience au sein du couple, ce qui rend leur relation encore plus intéressante à suivre. Comme Inès et Cárcel vivent dans une sorte de bulle au début de leur mariage, l'introduction de ces nouveaux personnages vient casser cet équilibre et apporte une dynamique supplémentaire que j'ai beaucoup aimée.

Et que dire des dessins ? Ils sont toujours aussi magnifiques. Les regards, les expressions, les décors... tout est sublime. Les émotions passent énormément par l'illustration, ce qui rend certaines scènes encore plus marquantes.

Bref, j'ai adoré cette lecture. Entre l'évolution d'Inès, la détermination de Cárcel à gagner sa confiance et cette alchimie complètement électrique entre eux, je me suis régalée du début à la fin. Et comme souvent avec cette série, la dernière page arrive beaucoup trop vite.

Vivement la suite, parce que je suis plus que jamais attachée à ce couple et j'ai hâte de voir jusqu'où leur relation va évoluer. ❤️📖
Profile Image for Azbaqiyah.
1,041 reviews2 followers
June 22, 2026
✨📖 Manhwa Review 📖✨

💍 The Broken Ring: This Marriage Will Fail Anyway Vol. 2

"This marriage will fail anyway."

If only Cárcel got the memo. 😂

After finally tying the knot, Inés and Cárcel begin their married life in the coastal city of Calztela. While everyone else is busy admiring the beautiful newlyweds, Inés is already planning for the day this marriage ends. Unfortunately for her carefully crafted plans, her husband seems increasingly determined to stay by her side.

💭 My Thoughts
This volume was such an enjoyable read because of the ongoing gag between Inés and Cárcel.

Inés: "This marriage is temporary." 😐

Cárcel: proceeds to act like a devoted husband every chance he gets 😌💙

The disconnect between what Inés thinks is happening and what Cárcel is actually feeling creates so many entertaining moments. Their interactions are funny, frustrating, sweet, and sometimes heartbreaking all at once.
As the story progresses, you can feel the emotional tension building beneath the surface. Inés is still carrying the weight of memories from her previous lives, while Cárcel is slowly becoming more invested in their relationship than either of them expected.

🌊 I also enjoyed the Calztela setting. The seaside atmosphere feels romantic, but there's always an undercurrent of sadness because of the memories tied to Inés's past.

💕 About the romance
One thing that surprised me is that despite the series' reputation, the intimate scenes weren't nearly as steamy as I expected. They're present, but the focus remains on the characters' emotions, misunderstandings, and growing relationship rather than pure passion.

Honestly, the emotional tension between them often feels stronger than the physical romance.

🎨 The Art
As always, the artwork is absolutely stunning. Every panel feels elegant and luxurious, especially Inés's outfits and the beautiful expressions that reveal emotions she rarely says aloud.

⭐ Rating: 8.5/10
A fascinating blend of romance, drama, reincarnation, and emotional healing. I came for the gorgeous art and complicated marriage, but stayed for the hilarious "we are definitely not in love" energy between Inés and Cárcel.
Profile Image for Scheylis ☾.
279 reviews4 followers
June 13, 2025
Háganse un favor y léanse este manhwa.😭🫶

¡Waoooo, simplemente waoooo! Ni siquiera me importó que Carsen fuera rubio. Y ESE FINALLLL NO JODAS.

Nos dieron arte, trama, evolución de personajes y hasta un mini capítulo de transición para aguantar la espera del próximo volumen. Todo espectacular.

En el primer volumen, algo que me tenía cansada era lo repetitivo que era lo de Inés (aunque igual lo entendía), y acá nos dieron evolución, de a poco pero nos la dieron. Porque no es que a Inés le metieron un montón de traumas y luego la mostraran como si estuviera bien… no. Acá son conscientes y trabajan su personaje paso a paso. Eso me encanta.

Ay Carsen, ay Carsen. Ya le estoy agarrando el gustito, aunque sea rubio (se sabe que soy Team pelinegros). Pero es que acá no solo lo vemos como un perro faldero que se desvive por Inés sin personalidad, porque nooo, acá nos lo muestran con carácter, con profundidad. Vemos lados suyos que antes no aparecían. Amé, me encantó y ni sé qué decir.

“Su mirada estaba llena de tristeza porque me amaba. Amaba a Inés Valeztena, siempre lo hizo.”
¿HOLAAAA? Eso no es nada… hubo tantas cosas que me tenían gritando casi en cada capítulo.

Me cansé de ocultarlo solo porque la gente lo odia, pero lo digo: me encanta el hermano de Inés. Inés y yo seríamos buenas cuñadas.

Hubo un capítulo en el que lloré de felicidad al ver a los hermanos acercándose. En el primer volumen me dolió muchísimo todo lo que vivieron y cómo eso afectó su relación. Fue tan lindo ver cómo están ahora.

La verdad, en tema de trama hay muchas cosas que me tienen en plan “wtf”, y le tengo MUCHAS ganas a lo que viene.

P.D. Si con el primer volumen ya había agradecido a las personas que censuraron, con este no sé ni qué darles. Es que no fue suficiente con censurar… ¡tuvieron que borrar pedazos enteros! 😂😂
Profile Image for Ery.
80 reviews2 followers
August 24, 2025
Endlich ist der langersehnte Band angekommen und was soll ich sagen? Ich bin nach wie vor begeistert, einen meiner liebsten Romantasy-Manhwas in Printform zu besitzen.

Im zweiten Band dreht sich alles hauptsächlich um die Hochzeit zwischen Inés und Cárcel. Ich liebe es, wie Inés hier alle überrascht und statt in ihrem schwarzen Gewand aufzutreten, einfach wie ein Diamant funkelt. Ich habe ja einen leichten Girlcrush auf Inés. Ich liebe einfach ihre Art.
Auch die Hochzeitsnacht findet statt. Danke an Papertoons, dass sie die Mature verwenden.

In der zweiten Hälfte des Bandes können wir Inés dabei begleiten, wie sie sich auf ihre zukünftige Scheidung vorbereitet und langsam die Hebel in Bewegung setzt. Außerdem erfahren wir wieder ein Stückchen mehr über Inés' vorheriges Leben.

Und Cárcel? Er verliebt sich jeden Tag aufs Neue in seine Braut. Und Inés scheint auch nicht ganz abgeneigt. :>

Ihr seht: Es bleibt spannend, und ich kann euch versprechen, dass es noch viel spannender wird. Wer die Dynamik zwischen Inés und Cárcel mag, sollte auf jeden Fall weiterlesen.

Ich hoffe allerdings, dass Papertoons in Zukunft spanische Begriffe, die auch im Original vorhanden sind, nicht übersetzt.
Profile Image for Lowin1000.
684 reviews4 followers
September 30, 2025
Rezension
[ Genre: Manhwa/ Romantasy + 18]

Ich liebe diese Reihe immer mehr ! In ,, The Broken Ring- Diese Ehe ist zum Scheitern verurteilt “ geht immer mehr in die TIEFE …!

Im ersten Band dachte ich ja, Ines Vergangenheit ist echt nicht ohne ,aber dafür eine 18+ Deklarierung. Aber JETZT weis ich warum .. Okay, die Intimszenen sind sehr hübsch gezeichnet und sehr aufschlussreich huust . Also mein 15 jähriges ich hätte gesabbert. Gut ,aber ich will hier niemanden verführen mit der Lektüre..

Auf jeden Fall gefällt mir die Entwicklung der beiden Hauptfiguren und ich hoffe so sehr, dass sie ihm eine Chance gibt .
Auch witzig wie oberflächlich die männlichen Adligen sind ,vorher haben sie Ines nicht beachtet ,als sie sich sehr geschlossen gezeigt hat ,aber an ihrem Hochzeitstag reden sie so über sie ,als wäre sie noch zu haben .

Widerlich sind diese Kerle . Dafür ist Carcel so süß und Hot .
Ich bin so gespannt, wie es im November weitergeht!

Vielen Dank für das Bereitstellen des Leseexemplars an den Verlag!

Alles Gute, eure Jassy!





Profile Image for Shiritaku.
723 reviews2 followers
August 17, 2025
Uhu, in dem Band passiert dermaßen viel! 😱
Anfangs hab ich etwas gebraucht, um wieder reinzukommen, denn es geht sofort los bzw knüpft direkt an Band 1 an. Optisch ist's richtig nice, die Zeichnungen sind sehr sauber und die Panels klar und deutlich. Die Atmosphäre der Hochzeit wird in den Bildern sehr gut wiedergegeben und so sind viele Worte gar nicht nötig. Inés’ Charakter zeigt sich hier auch etwas anders - sie wirkt nicht so kalt und unnahbar wie im ersten Band - aber natürlich hat alles seine Gründe. Man erfährt auch mehr über ihre Vergangenheit und ihre Beweggründe werden immer klarer. Cárcel verfällt ihr immer mehr, ohne das es ihm anfangs so bewusst ist - was Inés nicht sonderlich gefällt..
Der Band beinhaltet auch einige spicy Szenen.. 😌🔥 hier ist FSK 18 definitiv angebracht, haha. Ich fand's durchgehend spannend und interessant - am liebsten hätte ich sofort weitergelesen 🥹 freu mich daher unheimlich auf den nächsten Band!! 🔥
Profile Image for belle ☆ミ (thisbellereadstoo).
2,678 reviews178 followers
July 9, 2024
reread: july 2024 [chapter 15-28]

read until: chapter 46 // end of season 1

have the same thoughts as before. so, this review will be about the entirety of season 1:
ahhhh i love this couple so much. i'm so glad cárcel woke up and realized inés is who he wants. even though the couple's relationship has somewhat improved, we're not at the stage where she's reciprocating his feelings and is still trying to encourage cárcel to cheat. i love the art style as well. i just want their feelings to be mutual such that cárcel can enjoy being with her knowing that it's mutual and for inés to have a happy life in this life.

that kiss in the last chapter!!! omggggg
Profile Image for R..
2,242 reviews
April 23, 2026
Inés continues to try and secure her own position and the future freedom she craves while Cárcel struggles with his own intense emotions and realizing just how drawn and attached to Inés he truly is. While Inés keeps trying to move things in her favor, she also seems to be realizing there may be a chance for happiness in this new relationship as well. Cárcel is aware that there is some sort of reason behind his wife's actions, but isn't clear as to what her game really is. The story movement is subtle as it focuses largely on the events directly following the wedding and still in the "honeymoon phase" as they settle into their new home.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for zades.
223 reviews6 followers
December 24, 2024
novel part 6-part 8

"Cárcel thanked God for her voice. Instead of kissing her or confessing
his love for her, he wept.
Never mind love. All he needed was for Inés to open her eyes to see
him and move her lips to call his name."

you know what's crazy is carcel never hated the idea of marrying Ines. HE HAD A HUGE CRUSH ON HER FUCK!!! And the fact subconsciously thought in vol 1 that he didn't see any future where Ines is not his wife and he dare claim he's not inlove. KRAZY!!!! carcel u dog
Profile Image for annie.
605 reviews5 followers
May 20, 2026
3.5

... i think i can just stop here. unfortunately she is a little too "cunning". i am all for female leads wanting to get their way and being a girl boss, but something about her but also I think im just sick of it for now.
Profile Image for Elena L. .
1,237 reviews196 followers
July 8, 2026
a marriage by convenience and an emotionally distant female character who had previous lives. Reborn topic always intrigues me since I am curious to see how second chance will work for a character. This is about scheming, trying to change own's fate and protecting the loved ones, but also, it has plenty of spicy moments (perhaps too much oops). Both main characters are still growing on me and I just want to see a more vulnerable side of them.

[ gifted by the publisher. all thoughts are my own ]
Profile Image for Lisa | Küstenmädchen.
47 reviews
January 13, 2026
Manwha chapters 15-28, read online
Guys are married now, so everything should go smoothly from here, right? We see more about Ines motives for her now husband. I think this is an extremely interesting plotline and I’m very hyped to explore it more! 😳
Also it’s getting hot fast, guys. 🌶️
Love the different sides of Carcel that we explore! He can be a total idiot, puppy, sexy and smart at the same time. How’s that even possible?
Profile Image for Emi.
883 reviews22 followers
January 22, 2026
Se acabó la segunda temporada! Y menudo cambio respecto a la primera: Inés se ha hablandado con Cárcel y están muy bien juntos. También han pasado por mucho: malentendidos, intentos de asesinato y la alta sociedad. El príncipe sigue siendo malvado y urdiendo sus planes.

Pero la tercera temporada prometa, porque parece que aquí todo el mundo es más o menos consciente de sus vidas anteriores y hay un personaje que parece que está al tanto de todo. Me tiene muy intrigada cómo seguirá.
Profile Image for Jane.
1,309 reviews9 followers
April 1, 2026
This was a good continuation of the story. It's fun seeing these two get closer, even if that is foiling Ines' plans for freedom. There are a few things that didnt quite land, such as second wives... Given it's set in Catholic Spain, yeah, second wives wouldn't be a thing. That is definitely against canon law. Especially in the 1800's when this seems to be set. I can't wait to see where this goes.
Profile Image for zeynerden.
20 reviews1 follower
January 28, 2025
Teori zamanı: Carcel Escalante ilk hayatlarında Ines'i kurtarmak için ve Tanrının bu sefer Ines'e istediği hayatı vermesi için, daha doğrusu Ines tatmin olduğu bir hayat yaşayana ve doğal yollarla öldüğü bir senaryoya ulaşana kadar yeniden doğması adına, Tanrıyla anlaşma yaptı. O potansiyeli görüyorum bu adamda. (Honestly, man. In a good way obviously)
Profile Image for Cassandra.
3,286 reviews32 followers
March 29, 2026
4/6 so it is enjoyable and the art is beautiful but nothing about this story thus far really pulls me. But if my library gets the next volume, I will check it out.

I do think its funny that since he hasn't cheated on her she is trying to create opportunities for him to meet women to cheat on her with.

I do get a little confused about the flashbacks on which timeline we are in.
Profile Image for Ella.
466 reviews1 follower
May 19, 2026
I really need volume 3.
Like.
Right. NOW!

I really enjoy how all of Inés her plans are slowly crumbling and changing even without her own full knowledge.
Like yeah, she sees the main break, but she is also slowly falling for Cárcel and he is tearing down her defenses.

Yes, I like this series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews