What do you think?
Rate this book
But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale
"If I had ten thousand lives, I would lay them all down."
In the early 1770’s, Nathan Hale is a young philosophy student at Yale. There, he, his brother, and their friend, Ben Tallmadge, are busying themselves with intellectual debate and occasional mischief.
Only too soon, their patriotic ideals of revolution and liberty would be put to the test. Forced to choose between love and duty, young Nathan has to face the harsh personal cost of deeply held beliefs as he leaves to become Washington’s spy.
In this powerful novel of friendship and sacrifice, Samantha Wilcoxson paints a vivid portrait of a young man’s principled passion and dedication to his ideals, turning the legend into flesh and blood.
This is the touching and thought-provoking story of how an ordinary boy grew into an extraordinary man – an American hero.
In the early 1770’s, Nathan Hale is a young philosophy student at Yale. There, he, his brother, and their friend, Ben Tallmadge, are busying themselves with intellectual debate and occasional mischief.
Only too soon, their patriotic ideals of revolution and liberty would be put to the test. Forced to choose between love and duty, young Nathan has to face the harsh personal cost of deeply held beliefs as he leaves to become Washington’s spy.
In this powerful novel of friendship and sacrifice, Samantha Wilcoxson paints a vivid portrait of a young man’s principled passion and dedication to his ideals, turning the legend into flesh and blood.
This is the touching and thought-provoking story of how an ordinary boy grew into an extraordinary man – an American hero.
278 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 22, 2023
28 people are currently reading
95 people want to read
About the author
Samantha Wilcoxson
20 books420 followersWriter, history enthusiast, and sufferer of wanderlust, Samantha strives to reveal the deep emotions and motivations of historical figures, enabling readers to connect with them in a unique way. She can frequently be found lakeside with a book in one hand and glass of wine in the other.
New Release: James Alexander Hamilton: Son of the American Revolution, published by Pen & Sword History
WIP: Wars of the Roses trilogy, published by Sapere Books
New Release: James Alexander Hamilton: Son of the American Revolution, published by Pen & Sword History
WIP: Wars of the Roses trilogy, published by Sapere Books
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
October 19, 2024
This is an entertaining, well-written, thoroughly researched, historical fiction novel. It vividly depicts the life of Nathan Hale, and his inspiring, heroic, and tragic life. I particularly enjoyed reading about his debate as a member of the Linonian Society at Yale, and admire his forward thinking ideas. The quotes at the beginning of each chapter were an excellent addition to the story. The author's notes are interesting and informative, and are truly appreciated. I listened to the audio book, and the narrator, Mr. Nathan Agin, whom the author informed me was named for Nathan Hale, has a captivating voice, and does an outstanding job voicing the characters. Many thanks to Ms. Wilcoxson, from whom I received a gift of this wonderful novel as a subscriber to her newsletter. This is my honest opinion.
June 7, 2022
But One Life
Even the title just moves me.
Nathan Hale was a hero of the American revolution. He gave his life for the cause that his country might be free. He had but one life, but if he'd had a thousand lives, he would have given them all.
Samantha Wilcoxson has written about the life of one of America's great patriots. The book is remarkable in that she shows us a fascinating glimpse of a life that was only a mere droplet in the universe, his years being so few, his youth so raw, and yet at only 21, he had given so much of his life to his country. A graduate of Yale, he became a school teacher, a progressive of his time, he allowed girls to attend and although he had to teach them separately, they were taught the same subjects as the boys. Always a patriot, he loved his country, and he loved the freedoms that his people had come to enjoy in the British colony of America. Having neglected the colony, the British arrive to re-establish their overlordship with unwelcome taxes and interference in the colony's affairs. The British were to find that a large establishment of dissenters were against them and when their concerns are not listened to, their only recourse seems to be rebellion. After seeing his country and fellow Americans oppressed by the governing masters, Nathan finally gives in and joins the opposing army. The remarkable thing about this story? Ms Wilcoxson shows us Hale's life through his own eyes, we see and feel his thoughts as though we are seeing the events develop alongside him. He had but one life, but as readers, we share that life too.
Wilcoxson is known for her extraordinary emotive reads. She gets right into the heads of her protagonists adding a deeper dimension to the reading experience. During the read I was often enthralled by the reverent ability of the author to deliver a story so respectful of someone whom we knew little about, and breath taken by the beautiful prose so elegantly written.
'I looked down at my body, slim and sinewy thanks to the privations of war. It was odd to think that I would soon leave it. We are taught that our flesh was no more than clothing for our soul, but at this moment I found it difficult to believe. What would it feel like to be parted from it, to become ethereal and invisible to those I loved.'
Ms. Wilcoxson begins the story with Nathan's birth and then with his brother Enoch on their way to start their education at Yale. The descriptions of school life and the coming of age of the lads in Nathan's life are exquisitely shown to us and I had to smile to myself that the behaviours of these lads were so typical that we could see much of our own young men today. The prose is such that you can visualise the dorms and the rooms in which they lived. The conversations and the sounds of their voices brings the reader to a panoramic view of life in the 18th century.
As a British person I feel more informed after reading this life story of one of America's greatest patriots and the true meaning of patriotism is what I have got from this beautifully written story by one of our greatest writers. Such is the manner in which this book has touched my own soul. Ms Wilcoxson has written this soul wrenching story of a young man who had but one life to give and if he'd had more, he would have given them all. Nathan Hale's name will always be indelibly imprinted on my heart.
Even the title just moves me.
Nathan Hale was a hero of the American revolution. He gave his life for the cause that his country might be free. He had but one life, but if he'd had a thousand lives, he would have given them all.
Samantha Wilcoxson has written about the life of one of America's great patriots. The book is remarkable in that she shows us a fascinating glimpse of a life that was only a mere droplet in the universe, his years being so few, his youth so raw, and yet at only 21, he had given so much of his life to his country. A graduate of Yale, he became a school teacher, a progressive of his time, he allowed girls to attend and although he had to teach them separately, they were taught the same subjects as the boys. Always a patriot, he loved his country, and he loved the freedoms that his people had come to enjoy in the British colony of America. Having neglected the colony, the British arrive to re-establish their overlordship with unwelcome taxes and interference in the colony's affairs. The British were to find that a large establishment of dissenters were against them and when their concerns are not listened to, their only recourse seems to be rebellion. After seeing his country and fellow Americans oppressed by the governing masters, Nathan finally gives in and joins the opposing army. The remarkable thing about this story? Ms Wilcoxson shows us Hale's life through his own eyes, we see and feel his thoughts as though we are seeing the events develop alongside him. He had but one life, but as readers, we share that life too.
Wilcoxson is known for her extraordinary emotive reads. She gets right into the heads of her protagonists adding a deeper dimension to the reading experience. During the read I was often enthralled by the reverent ability of the author to deliver a story so respectful of someone whom we knew little about, and breath taken by the beautiful prose so elegantly written.
'I looked down at my body, slim and sinewy thanks to the privations of war. It was odd to think that I would soon leave it. We are taught that our flesh was no more than clothing for our soul, but at this moment I found it difficult to believe. What would it feel like to be parted from it, to become ethereal and invisible to those I loved.'
Ms. Wilcoxson begins the story with Nathan's birth and then with his brother Enoch on their way to start their education at Yale. The descriptions of school life and the coming of age of the lads in Nathan's life are exquisitely shown to us and I had to smile to myself that the behaviours of these lads were so typical that we could see much of our own young men today. The prose is such that you can visualise the dorms and the rooms in which they lived. The conversations and the sounds of their voices brings the reader to a panoramic view of life in the 18th century.
As a British person I feel more informed after reading this life story of one of America's greatest patriots and the true meaning of patriotism is what I have got from this beautifully written story by one of our greatest writers. Such is the manner in which this book has touched my own soul. Ms Wilcoxson has written this soul wrenching story of a young man who had but one life to give and if he'd had more, he would have given them all. Nathan Hale's name will always be indelibly imprinted on my heart.
May 7, 2024
Nathan Hale (June 6, 1755–September 22, 1776) was an American Patriot, soldier and spy for the Continental Army during the American Revolutionary War.In 1769,Nathan Hale was sent with his brother Enoch,to Yale College.He was a classmate of fellow Patriot spy Benjamin Tallmadge.The Hale brothers belonged to the Linonian Society of Yale,which debated topics in astronomy,mathematics,literature, and the ethics of slavery.Nathan graduated with first-class honors in 1773 and became a teacher, first in East Haddam and later in New London.After the Revolutionary War began in 1775,Hale joined a Connecticut militia unit and was elected first lieutenant within 5 months.His company participated in the Siege of Boston,but Hale remained behind.He was unsure as to whether he wanted to fight,and his his teaching contract in New London did not expire until in July 1775.On July 4, 1775, Hale received a letter from Benjamin Tallmadge, who had gone to Boston to see the siege for himself.Tallmadge's letter convinced Hale so much that he accepted a commission as first lieutenant in the 7th Connecticut Regiment under Colonel Charles Webb of Stamford.Hale was also a part of Knowlton's Rangers, the first US organised intelligence service organization, led by Lt. Thomas Knowlton.In the spring of 1776,the Continental Army moved to Manhattan to defend New York City against the anticipated British attack.General George Washington was desperate to determine the location of the imminent British invasion of Manhattan; so he called for a spy behind enemy lines,and Hale was the only volunteer.He was ferried across the Long Island Sound to Huntington, NY, on Sep 12.Hale planned to disguise himself as a Dutch schoolteacher looking for work,though he didn't use a fake name.Hale was betrayed by someone who pretended to be a Patriot.British General William Howe questioned Hale and found evidence on him.He requested a Bible and clergyman,which were denied.General Howe did permit him to write letters to Enoch and his commanding officer,but the next day,they were torn up in front of him by the provost marshal,Captain Cunningham.Hale was hanged but he eventually became a hero of Connecticut.
May 24, 2024
Summary: But One Life is a work of historical fiction, based on the life of Nathan Hale, an idealistic and patriotic man who was hung as a spy and traitor to the British Empire at the tender age of 21. He is now lionized as a hero of the American Revolution.
Thoughts: This was an interesting read for me, as a Canadian, since I only know the barest outline of the history of the American Revolution. The entire novel is told in first-person from Nathan’s perspective, and sheds light on his life after he journeys from his father’s home to Yale College with his beloved older brother, Enoch. There he becomes a learned young man, debating philosophy and politics with his peers, and eventually graduating at the age of 18. He becomes a teacher and is persuaded to join the cause of the revolution by his classmate and close friend, Benjamin Tallmadge.
What I found interesting was the influence that religious fervour had upon the revolution, and the fact that many of the young men in Hale’s circle were a product of that Great Awakening religious dedication. I had no idea that puritanical religious devotion was intertwined with the ideals of the revolution. The author adds a storyline of a romance with a young woman in New London who was also a pupil, but the romance comes to nothing when Hale joins the revolutionary cause. This, along with his evident love for his family and friends, adds depth and colour to his character and creates interest in what might otherwise be a dry account of his education and brief military career.
Hale’s youth, lack of military experience and naivety led to his capture and death on September 22 by the British forces. To add insult to injury, it may have been his own cousin who betrayed him to the British. I commend Samantha Wilcoxson for bringing history to life and giving a voice to a historical figure that for many is probably just a name or a statue.
Thoughts: This was an interesting read for me, as a Canadian, since I only know the barest outline of the history of the American Revolution. The entire novel is told in first-person from Nathan’s perspective, and sheds light on his life after he journeys from his father’s home to Yale College with his beloved older brother, Enoch. There he becomes a learned young man, debating philosophy and politics with his peers, and eventually graduating at the age of 18. He becomes a teacher and is persuaded to join the cause of the revolution by his classmate and close friend, Benjamin Tallmadge.
What I found interesting was the influence that religious fervour had upon the revolution, and the fact that many of the young men in Hale’s circle were a product of that Great Awakening religious dedication. I had no idea that puritanical religious devotion was intertwined with the ideals of the revolution. The author adds a storyline of a romance with a young woman in New London who was also a pupil, but the romance comes to nothing when Hale joins the revolutionary cause. This, along with his evident love for his family and friends, adds depth and colour to his character and creates interest in what might otherwise be a dry account of his education and brief military career.
Hale’s youth, lack of military experience and naivety led to his capture and death on September 22 by the British forces. To add insult to injury, it may have been his own cousin who betrayed him to the British. I commend Samantha Wilcoxson for bringing history to life and giving a voice to a historical figure that for many is probably just a name or a statue.
June 7, 2024
I'm not American, and I didn't know anything about Nathan Hale before I was offered the chance to review this.
I do enjoy learning about people who have made a mark on society and I wanted to review this because of that, and because I LOVED Samantha Wilcoxson's book Lithium: The Story of a Radium Girl.
I was, therefore, eager to experience another book by her.
But One Life was interesting, and I enjoyed learning about Nathan's life.
Samantha Wilcoxson's easy writing style is highly detailed, but in a good way, as it's a good way to really feel immersed in the book.
Thanks to Samantha Wilcoxson and Coffee and Thorn for my audiobook in exchange for an honest and voluntary review.
4 stars
I do enjoy learning about people who have made a mark on society and I wanted to review this because of that, and because I LOVED Samantha Wilcoxson's book Lithium: The Story of a Radium Girl.
I was, therefore, eager to experience another book by her.
But One Life was interesting, and I enjoyed learning about Nathan's life.
Samantha Wilcoxson's easy writing style is highly detailed, but in a good way, as it's a good way to really feel immersed in the book.
Thanks to Samantha Wilcoxson and Coffee and Thorn for my audiobook in exchange for an honest and voluntary review.
4 stars
July 9, 2022
History,
Although one learns a lot of history through their years at school, The Story of Nathan Hale put a personal side to him that isn’t found in history books. Those times are usually glazed over with no depth to them. I loved learning about Nathan Hale the man and those around him. This is an excellent read! I have enjoyed all of Ms Wilcoxson’s books and her broad diversity in her writing!
Although one learns a lot of history through their years at school, The Story of Nathan Hale put a personal side to him that isn’t found in history books. Those times are usually glazed over with no depth to them. I loved learning about Nathan Hale the man and those around him. This is an excellent read! I have enjoyed all of Ms Wilcoxson’s books and her broad diversity in her writing!
June 5, 2024
But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale by Samantha Wilcoxson
A Book Review by AZ Perez
June 2024
This book is a story of a hero in the American War of Independence.
When this book gives the readers a glimpse of Nathan Hale’s family and his childhood, it’s idyllic and heart touching. His family is close knit and is onto farming and the faith to God is the center of their family life. He has a strong bond with his siblings. They are self-sufficient and content. In his young adulthood he learns things such as what he must value most and his life’s aspiration.
The heartbreaking and inspiring part starts when war arrives and recruits its young and capable men. War becomes a normal thing and choices in life become slim. Nathan Hale, a principled, young lad must heed to the call of times. Even though he is already a teacher doing meaningful things and he has a lady - Betsy who is ready to marry him. However, war is the order of the day and being a soldier and participating in the actual battle befit a necessary, superior profession and life’s calling. Nathan Hale makes his choice and leaves everything behind - the comfort of life his community, family and Betsy- his sweetheart can give.
It’s inspiring to read how selfless Nathan is; and the army and its soldiers in general, offering their lives in battlefields in exchange of the ‘freedom’ for everyone to enjoy. However, it’s heartbreaking as well to know that Nathan together with the other soldiers and their families have to put up a ‘strong self’ no matter how ‘shattered’ or how ‘scared they are within’ in the face of ‘war carnage and suffering’.
Although war as a medium and its inevitability to emerge pacifies some conflicts and in the process produces great men and women such as Nathan Hale tempered by its bloodshed and anguish; it’s no denying that on the other hand, war breeds further monstrosity and alienation among humanity – its actual atrocity is inhumane. It does not spare a meaningful man like Nathan, not counting the innocent children! While on the lighter side, it is also real and true that peace and peace time produces great men and women of different quality. They are hardened by the challenges of what is good, better and best in various aspects concerning life.
In my reflection, even when the world is not yet in the context of (global) war (again), many are experiencing hunger, suffering, anguish and misery caused by diverse factors. How much more if the world (again) is at war (aggravated by the context of high-end technology and military warfare)? It takes a lifetime and more to expunge a war’s sorrowful and monstrous memories. It saddens me contemplating these things.
War is destructive by nature and I still wish and pray that one day, its circumstance and its presence, will disappear. And we will have more of Nathan Hale born, raised and becoming the hero of peace time and not just in war.
A very relevant book to read!
A Book Review by AZ Perez
June 2024
This book is a story of a hero in the American War of Independence.
When this book gives the readers a glimpse of Nathan Hale’s family and his childhood, it’s idyllic and heart touching. His family is close knit and is onto farming and the faith to God is the center of their family life. He has a strong bond with his siblings. They are self-sufficient and content. In his young adulthood he learns things such as what he must value most and his life’s aspiration.
The heartbreaking and inspiring part starts when war arrives and recruits its young and capable men. War becomes a normal thing and choices in life become slim. Nathan Hale, a principled, young lad must heed to the call of times. Even though he is already a teacher doing meaningful things and he has a lady - Betsy who is ready to marry him. However, war is the order of the day and being a soldier and participating in the actual battle befit a necessary, superior profession and life’s calling. Nathan Hale makes his choice and leaves everything behind - the comfort of life his community, family and Betsy- his sweetheart can give.
It’s inspiring to read how selfless Nathan is; and the army and its soldiers in general, offering their lives in battlefields in exchange of the ‘freedom’ for everyone to enjoy. However, it’s heartbreaking as well to know that Nathan together with the other soldiers and their families have to put up a ‘strong self’ no matter how ‘shattered’ or how ‘scared they are within’ in the face of ‘war carnage and suffering’.
Although war as a medium and its inevitability to emerge pacifies some conflicts and in the process produces great men and women such as Nathan Hale tempered by its bloodshed and anguish; it’s no denying that on the other hand, war breeds further monstrosity and alienation among humanity – its actual atrocity is inhumane. It does not spare a meaningful man like Nathan, not counting the innocent children! While on the lighter side, it is also real and true that peace and peace time produces great men and women of different quality. They are hardened by the challenges of what is good, better and best in various aspects concerning life.
In my reflection, even when the world is not yet in the context of (global) war (again), many are experiencing hunger, suffering, anguish and misery caused by diverse factors. How much more if the world (again) is at war (aggravated by the context of high-end technology and military warfare)? It takes a lifetime and more to expunge a war’s sorrowful and monstrous memories. It saddens me contemplating these things.
War is destructive by nature and I still wish and pray that one day, its circumstance and its presence, will disappear. And we will have more of Nathan Hale born, raised and becoming the hero of peace time and not just in war.
A very relevant book to read!
June 9, 2024
A compelling fictionalised account of the life of Nathan Hale. Hale was a patriot, soldier and spy and well known as a hero of the American Revolutionary War. I
admit this is an area of history that I don’t know much about and enjoyed learning more about it and Hale.
This is the second book I’ve read by Samantha and I love the way she brings history to life. Her comprehensive research makes you feel like you’ve travelled back in time and the characters are all so engaging and you feel like you’re getting to know the real person behind the story. Whilst Nathan is known for his sacrifice, it was his relationship with his brother and time as a teacher that I enjoyed getting to know about. He was very progressive and allowed females to access education which wasn’t done at the time. I look forward to discovering more new bit of history from Samantha.
admit this is an area of history that I don’t know much about and enjoyed learning more about it and Hale.
This is the second book I’ve read by Samantha and I love the way she brings history to life. Her comprehensive research makes you feel like you’ve travelled back in time and the characters are all so engaging and you feel like you’re getting to know the real person behind the story. Whilst Nathan is known for his sacrifice, it was his relationship with his brother and time as a teacher that I enjoyed getting to know about. He was very progressive and allowed females to access education which wasn’t done at the time. I look forward to discovering more new bit of history from Samantha.
September 1, 2023
I've always had a soft spot for historical characters who meet tragic ends and die in dramatic fashions. Nathan Hale definitely fits into this category, so I am glad that an author took the time to offer a glimpse into his brief life and developing character of this idealistic young man in the years leading up to his embrace of the revolutionary cause and his death in its service. I appreciated the inclusion of his Christian faith as an integral part of his identity, which ties in perfectly with his finally request, spitefully denied him, to have a Bible. The way the author had Hale ponder his own impending death, which he clearly sees as the separation of the soul from the body, was moving, particularly his hope of being reunited with his mother. I must say I was surprised by the chapter featuring my history crush, the sequence-studded Major John Andre, who will forever gain loves of love and sparkles from the artistic community due to his arts, crafts, poetry, and theme parties that basically turned into the first RenFaire events in Philly, jousts and all. Nathan's college bro Ben morbidly unimpressed, however, and cultivated the rather strong urge to punch him in the face and lock him in a cellar for his trouble. Unfortunately, we did not get the chance to touch upon his own religious epiphany upon the eve of his demise which tapped into his own deeply Christian upbringing from which he had, at times, strayed. But you know, can't steal the show each time, even if he's just the type to manage it. *Casts sparkles upon the waters in his memory*
June 13, 2022
As an author of the American Revolution myself this was a story I was extremely familiar with, but Samantha Wilcoxson drew the reader in to hear and feel the heartbeat of Nathan Hale like no other author of this young patriot's life has done.
June 8, 2024
Title: But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale
Author: Samantha Wilcoxson
Genre: Historical Fiction
Format: ebook
Series: NA
Star Rating: 3.5 stars
A special thank you goes to Coffee and Thorn for providing me with a copy of this book. Please know that this does not influence my rating or thoughts on the book itself.
tw: parental death, underage drinking (by today’s standard), vandalism, illness, death, war, misogyny, suicide, gun violence, hanging
So, as I have mentioned in previous reviews, I don’t know much about American history. It’s a time period that I don’t reach for often. I’ve read a lot of Clara Barton because when I was younger, I became pretty hyper-fixated on her. I was an odd kid. But when Coffee and Thorn offered this book, I decided to give this book a shot. I have read another book by this author and I enjoyed it so I knew I would enjoy this book too. And I did. I learned quite a bit too. Which is always a plus when you are reading.
When I started this book, I truly thought Nathan Hale was an author. I have a feeling I was getting him confused with another person. But I quickly realized that was not the case. Confusion aside, I truly enjoyed Nathan. It was so much fun watching Nathan grow up from a child to a brave young man. One of my favorite things about him was how he was for women being educated. That is such a rare thing for men of his time. I wanted to shout with joy! He immediately became my favorite. Another one of my favorite things about this book was the relationship between Nathan and his brother, Enoch. The bond they had with each other was so amazing. They weren’t afraid to get emotional with each other. They truly were each other's best friends. And it reminded me of my relationship with my sister. She is my best friend in the whole world. One way to get me to love a book is to give it sibling relationships as I have with my sister and like Nathan had with Enoch and I will be obsessed with it.
I enjoyed the pacing of the book. It wasn’t too fast but it also wasn’t too slow. It took its time, letting you get to know Nathan and his struggles with patriotism and doing what his heart wants. I truly felt his pain and there were a couple of times I found myself tearing up. I can’t imagine what it would be like to be a young man, with your whole future ahead of you, trying to decide if you want to serve your country and follow your heart. The author lets us sit with the emotions Nathan felt. I appreciated that quite a bit.
Overall, I was kind of surprised that I liked this book considering the time it takes place. Like I mentioned before, I don’t read a lot of American history but this one got me interested in the espionage side of the American Revolution. I have always been interested in spying and espionage so it’ll be interesting to read more about how it was used in the American Revolution since I know so much about espionage during World War II and I feel like it’s time for a change of scenery. Overall, though, if you enjoy learning about the American Revolution or just enjoy American history in general, this is the book for you!
Author: Samantha Wilcoxson
Genre: Historical Fiction
Format: ebook
Series: NA
Star Rating: 3.5 stars
A special thank you goes to Coffee and Thorn for providing me with a copy of this book. Please know that this does not influence my rating or thoughts on the book itself.
tw: parental death, underage drinking (by today’s standard), vandalism, illness, death, war, misogyny, suicide, gun violence, hanging
So, as I have mentioned in previous reviews, I don’t know much about American history. It’s a time period that I don’t reach for often. I’ve read a lot of Clara Barton because when I was younger, I became pretty hyper-fixated on her. I was an odd kid. But when Coffee and Thorn offered this book, I decided to give this book a shot. I have read another book by this author and I enjoyed it so I knew I would enjoy this book too. And I did. I learned quite a bit too. Which is always a plus when you are reading.
When I started this book, I truly thought Nathan Hale was an author. I have a feeling I was getting him confused with another person. But I quickly realized that was not the case. Confusion aside, I truly enjoyed Nathan. It was so much fun watching Nathan grow up from a child to a brave young man. One of my favorite things about him was how he was for women being educated. That is such a rare thing for men of his time. I wanted to shout with joy! He immediately became my favorite. Another one of my favorite things about this book was the relationship between Nathan and his brother, Enoch. The bond they had with each other was so amazing. They weren’t afraid to get emotional with each other. They truly were each other's best friends. And it reminded me of my relationship with my sister. She is my best friend in the whole world. One way to get me to love a book is to give it sibling relationships as I have with my sister and like Nathan had with Enoch and I will be obsessed with it.
I enjoyed the pacing of the book. It wasn’t too fast but it also wasn’t too slow. It took its time, letting you get to know Nathan and his struggles with patriotism and doing what his heart wants. I truly felt his pain and there were a couple of times I found myself tearing up. I can’t imagine what it would be like to be a young man, with your whole future ahead of you, trying to decide if you want to serve your country and follow your heart. The author lets us sit with the emotions Nathan felt. I appreciated that quite a bit.
Overall, I was kind of surprised that I liked this book considering the time it takes place. Like I mentioned before, I don’t read a lot of American history but this one got me interested in the espionage side of the American Revolution. I have always been interested in spying and espionage so it’ll be interesting to read more about how it was used in the American Revolution since I know so much about espionage during World War II and I feel like it’s time for a change of scenery. Overall, though, if you enjoy learning about the American Revolution or just enjoy American history in general, this is the book for you!
November 18, 2023
Nathan Hale was only a shadowy figure to me until I read this novel. We see an idealistic, honest young man off to Yale with his brother and away from home for the first time. He’s a fast learner with a pretty good grip of human nature. Everyone is taken with war fever, which only escalates as the situation in Boston heats up. After graduation, brother Enoch prepares for the ministry, while Nathan begins his career as a school teacher. His daily routine reads as a pretty mundane existence until he finally feels obliged to sign up and fight for his country:
“We have always governed ourselves. We always mean to. They don’t mean that we should.”
I needed no further convincing, but I stood up straighter and agreed, “The British shall not rule us as second-class citizens.”
He grasped me by the shoulder. “Not when we have honorable men willing to fight for liberty.”
I was not ready to proclaim yet, as Patrick Henry had, ‘Give me liberty or give me death,’ but I had taken a step closer.
Prophetic words, indeed. Forced to choose between the woman he loved and his country, he chose the latter, although the reality of fighting in the militia was discouraging and wretched. He finally saw the opportunity to make a difference and volunteered for an assignment he was ill suited for. This is a sad story about a brave man who followed his principles all the way until the end.
“We have always governed ourselves. We always mean to. They don’t mean that we should.”
I needed no further convincing, but I stood up straighter and agreed, “The British shall not rule us as second-class citizens.”
He grasped me by the shoulder. “Not when we have honorable men willing to fight for liberty.”
I was not ready to proclaim yet, as Patrick Henry had, ‘Give me liberty or give me death,’ but I had taken a step closer.
Prophetic words, indeed. Forced to choose between the woman he loved and his country, he chose the latter, although the reality of fighting in the militia was discouraging and wretched. He finally saw the opportunity to make a difference and volunteered for an assignment he was ill suited for. This is a sad story about a brave man who followed his principles all the way until the end.
June 14, 2024
Spoilers: Probably if it wasn't for Nathan Hale’s final words, we probably wouldn't know much about him at all. Nathan Hale (1755-1776) was a school teacher who took up arms during the American Revolutionary War. He volunteered for an intelligence gathering mission in New York City but was caught, exposed, and eventually executed. His final words were, “I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country.” These words proved to be an inspiration to many of the Patriots fighting for American independence and are still remembered as one of the most important quotes in American history.
Just as she did with her previous work, Luminous: The Story of a Radium Girl, Samantha Wilcoxson brings to life a historical figure who lived during important times. They are written as regular normal people that are caught in dramatic and tragic events that are beyond their scope. They heed the call, rise to the occasion, and make their mark during their time and for the future.
Wilcoxson never loses sight of Hale’s ordinariness. In fact, that is a key part of this book. Most of the plot focuses on his university years and his teaching career. The Revolutionary War does not even kick off until halfway through the book. His time as a spy only features in the last two or three chapters (more on that later). In fact during University, Hale is seen as a tag along kid brother following his elder sibling Enoch around. This earns him the nickname “Secondus” (Second) to Enoch’s “Primus.”
Hale is someone who stumbles upon the world at large rather than charging headlong into it. At Yale, he and his classmates which include future spymaster, Benjamin Tallmadge are aware of events like the Boston Massacre and the Boston Tea Party but are not involved in them. Mostly they study and debate whether taxation without representation is unjust and whether they are really considered British or American citizens. Like many college students before and since, Hale and his friends become aware of a larger world around them and discover their political and social identities, emphasizing and sometimes annoying everyone else with them. Their early contributions to American independence consist of knowing that such a thing is possible and identifying as Americans. They probably never thought that the road to independence would become so bloody and violent.
Hale’s post-University but pre-Revolution career is a series of ups and downs, some of it affected by the changing world and some of it from his own difficulties. His first teaching job in Haddan Landing is such a disaster that he resigns before Christmas and accepts a much better position in New London. His courtship with Betsey Adams is troubled by contrasting ideals and differing future plans. He even becomes more involved with the concepts of liberty and independence instead of just talking about it. He has the radical notion of educating girls as well as boys so they can embrace the enlightened values of freedom and education. He speaks out in support of the Suffolk Resolves, a declaration that rejected the Massachusetts Government Act and resulted in the boycott of imported goods because of the Intolerable Acts. When the shot is heard around the world at the Battle of Lexington and Concord, Hale officially enlists. This decision becomes a deal breaker for Betsey who ends their relationship but it leads Hale directly towards his inevitable destiny.
Hale’s military service is rich in details about the hardships that soldiers and civilians endured during war time. From the freezing conditions, to frequent illnesses, changing orders, disgruntled enlistees, and of course the threat of violence and death in battle, this approach takes out the mindless propaganda and leaves the realism that is involved in warfare. Hale’s hopes boil down to staying alive and hoping that this fight will be worth it in the end. Maybe his country will have its independence and Hale might gain some significance. It’s only towards the end that both goals come to fruition but not without Hale making the ultimate sacrifice.
While the book does a great job of humanizing Hale’s journey and making him a real person, it also confused me at first. I read most of it wondering when we were going to read about Hale becoming a spy. Why was the most important historical fact about Hale pushed so far towards the back of the book? After all other books like 355: The Women of Washington’s Spy Ring by Kit Sergeant put espionage front and center and Wilcoxson only devotes the final third to Hale’s missions. I was curious until I read the chapters that covered Hale’s spying. It turns out that he wasn’t really that good at it.
In Wilcoxson’s laudable effort to humanize Hale and the other early American patriots, she makes the Reader aware of their flaws. While Hale was a dedicated Patriot, an excellent soldier, and probably a terrific forward thinking teacher, he was not so adept at the spy game. In his first and only assignment, he manages to gather some intelligence but his cover is easily blown and he is very quickly discovered. It’s kind of humorous especially compared to Sergeant’s work where Meg Moncrieff Coughlin, Elizabeth Burgin, and Sally Townsend have much more successful multiple missions as members of the Culper Spy Ring and one may have even been the notorious “Agent 355,” one of Washington’s most successful female spies and who still to this day has remained unidentified. I was disappointed when I came upon Hale’s chapters and preferred the rest of the book, but after much thought I realized that was the point.
Nathan Hale was not some super spy secret agent. He was just an ordinary guy thrust into an extraordinary situation. One that in some ways he was unprepared for, but rose to the occasion anyway. He was someone who was proud to be one of the many who fought and died for his country and ultimately summarized those feelings with the right words.
Just as she did with her previous work, Luminous: The Story of a Radium Girl, Samantha Wilcoxson brings to life a historical figure who lived during important times. They are written as regular normal people that are caught in dramatic and tragic events that are beyond their scope. They heed the call, rise to the occasion, and make their mark during their time and for the future.
Wilcoxson never loses sight of Hale’s ordinariness. In fact, that is a key part of this book. Most of the plot focuses on his university years and his teaching career. The Revolutionary War does not even kick off until halfway through the book. His time as a spy only features in the last two or three chapters (more on that later). In fact during University, Hale is seen as a tag along kid brother following his elder sibling Enoch around. This earns him the nickname “Secondus” (Second) to Enoch’s “Primus.”
Hale is someone who stumbles upon the world at large rather than charging headlong into it. At Yale, he and his classmates which include future spymaster, Benjamin Tallmadge are aware of events like the Boston Massacre and the Boston Tea Party but are not involved in them. Mostly they study and debate whether taxation without representation is unjust and whether they are really considered British or American citizens. Like many college students before and since, Hale and his friends become aware of a larger world around them and discover their political and social identities, emphasizing and sometimes annoying everyone else with them. Their early contributions to American independence consist of knowing that such a thing is possible and identifying as Americans. They probably never thought that the road to independence would become so bloody and violent.
Hale’s post-University but pre-Revolution career is a series of ups and downs, some of it affected by the changing world and some of it from his own difficulties. His first teaching job in Haddan Landing is such a disaster that he resigns before Christmas and accepts a much better position in New London. His courtship with Betsey Adams is troubled by contrasting ideals and differing future plans. He even becomes more involved with the concepts of liberty and independence instead of just talking about it. He has the radical notion of educating girls as well as boys so they can embrace the enlightened values of freedom and education. He speaks out in support of the Suffolk Resolves, a declaration that rejected the Massachusetts Government Act and resulted in the boycott of imported goods because of the Intolerable Acts. When the shot is heard around the world at the Battle of Lexington and Concord, Hale officially enlists. This decision becomes a deal breaker for Betsey who ends their relationship but it leads Hale directly towards his inevitable destiny.
Hale’s military service is rich in details about the hardships that soldiers and civilians endured during war time. From the freezing conditions, to frequent illnesses, changing orders, disgruntled enlistees, and of course the threat of violence and death in battle, this approach takes out the mindless propaganda and leaves the realism that is involved in warfare. Hale’s hopes boil down to staying alive and hoping that this fight will be worth it in the end. Maybe his country will have its independence and Hale might gain some significance. It’s only towards the end that both goals come to fruition but not without Hale making the ultimate sacrifice.
While the book does a great job of humanizing Hale’s journey and making him a real person, it also confused me at first. I read most of it wondering when we were going to read about Hale becoming a spy. Why was the most important historical fact about Hale pushed so far towards the back of the book? After all other books like 355: The Women of Washington’s Spy Ring by Kit Sergeant put espionage front and center and Wilcoxson only devotes the final third to Hale’s missions. I was curious until I read the chapters that covered Hale’s spying. It turns out that he wasn’t really that good at it.
In Wilcoxson’s laudable effort to humanize Hale and the other early American patriots, she makes the Reader aware of their flaws. While Hale was a dedicated Patriot, an excellent soldier, and probably a terrific forward thinking teacher, he was not so adept at the spy game. In his first and only assignment, he manages to gather some intelligence but his cover is easily blown and he is very quickly discovered. It’s kind of humorous especially compared to Sergeant’s work where Meg Moncrieff Coughlin, Elizabeth Burgin, and Sally Townsend have much more successful multiple missions as members of the Culper Spy Ring and one may have even been the notorious “Agent 355,” one of Washington’s most successful female spies and who still to this day has remained unidentified. I was disappointed when I came upon Hale’s chapters and preferred the rest of the book, but after much thought I realized that was the point.
Nathan Hale was not some super spy secret agent. He was just an ordinary guy thrust into an extraordinary situation. One that in some ways he was unprepared for, but rose to the occasion anyway. He was someone who was proud to be one of the many who fought and died for his country and ultimately summarized those feelings with the right words.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 25, 2024
But One Life by Samantha Wilcoxson
Reviewed By: Sara Hailstone
“But One Life” by Samantha Wilcoxson is a narrative tapestry of the imagined life of an American hero, young Nathan Hale. An American Patriot, Hale is remembered as a soldier and spy for the Continental Army during the American Revolutionary War. “But One Life,” the title of the novel plays on final words that historical storytelling has projected he uttered right before his hanging. Wilcoxson imagines Hale taking in the crowds at his hanging and reflecting when asked if there are any last words. He responds, “I only regret that I have but one life to give for my country.” A man who had sacrificed love, career and family for country, the pull of his life story and masthead of a tragic figure had captivated the author. Weaving fact and fiction together to braid a captivating story, Wilcoxson accepts that “there is no way to be certain at this point if he said all or none of them.”
Samantha Wilcoxson has become prominent as an author of biographical fiction. Her writing humanizes and gives voice to those at the throes of larger historical processes and events. She writes non-fiction for Pen & Sword History. She has written “Women of the American Revolution,” which depicts and navigates the lives of 18th century women. Coming soon is her biography of James Alexander Hamilton, “Son of the American Revolution,” published by Pen & Sword History.
Wilcoxson could be found here:
• Website: https://samanthawilcoxson.blogspot.com/
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/samantha_wi...
• Twitter: https://twitter.com/carpe_librum
Wilcoxson writes the story of Nathan Hale from birth, through childhood with his brother Enoch and into their adulthood as students at Yale University. The reader connects with the plotline and the stakes of a man who sacrificed his life with a coming-of-age story. As the reader journeys through the unfolding of political and military timelines of this figure, there is always understanding that this narrative is based on a real story. Nathan Hale was a living and breathing man acting within the 18th century. Ultimately, he is remembered as a hero.
At 21 and a graduate from Yale, Hale took on a teaching contract and was devoted to this work first in East Haddam and later in New London. He let women attend separately in the early hours, a revolutionary and heroic act in its own right. Hale’s teaching career would be interrupted with the onslaught of military and political revolution. The Revolutionary War began in 1775 and Hale joined a Connecticut militia unit. Elected as first lieutenant within 5 months, Hale was persuaded in a letter by Benjamin Tallmadge to accept a commission as first lieutenant in the 7th Connecticut Regiment. Further, Hale joined the first US organised intelligence service organization. With steady progression his lifeline shifts when the Continental Army moved into Manhattan to defend New York City against the British. At this point, Hale was the only volunteer to act as a spy in Manhattan, Hale set out to camouflage himself as a Dutch schoolteacher. He was betrayed. He was questioned by British General William Howe and was prosecuted by hanging.
I was invested in what was denied to Hale during his execution and how Wilcoxson offered us an intimate view of this denial from Hale’s own perspective. He requested a Bible, his final request. He was denied this request. He was allowed to write letters as well that were torn up before him. Also, he had chosen to fight for his country instead of living a life loving a woman. Wilcoxson herself identifies that the quote by Betsy at the beginning of Chapter 39 is authentic. “No species of deception had any lurking place in his frank, open, meek and pious mind; his soul disdained disguise, however imperious circumstances of personal safety might demand a resort to duplicity & ambiguity. On the whole, I then thought him one of the most perfect human characters recorded in history or exemplified in any age or nation.” Betsy had written these words decades after Hale’s death. Yet, Wilcoxson articulates that “Betsy’s ultimatum is a figment of my imagination.” And in imagining this ultimatum, the reader feels the extent of what Hale had sacrificed at such a young age. “She was gone in a swirl of skirts and cries that left me utterly devastated.”
Wilcoxson wrote about Hale because he is a tragic hero, his unrealized potential during his time. I like that she articulated in her “Afterward” that she wanted to write a novel that appealed to both male and female readers. His life story is essentially tragic, but the progression of the events and more importantly the choices that this young man made, connect with all of us. Although, I feel his story propels us to further contemplate what we would truly sacrifice and fight for if we found ourselves in the same circumstances. My final contemplation of this text lies in the reality that Wilcoxson voiced that Hale has monuments dedicated to him but “no contemporary image of him exists.” I like to think that “But One Life” functions as a textual monument for him, a space we can stop long enough before, to reflect, to contemplate, to rise ourselves to the adversity and challenges we face in our own lives each day.
Thank you to Samantha Wilcoxson and Coffee & Thorn for the complimentary copy in request for an honest review!
Reviewed By: Sara Hailstone
“But One Life” by Samantha Wilcoxson is a narrative tapestry of the imagined life of an American hero, young Nathan Hale. An American Patriot, Hale is remembered as a soldier and spy for the Continental Army during the American Revolutionary War. “But One Life,” the title of the novel plays on final words that historical storytelling has projected he uttered right before his hanging. Wilcoxson imagines Hale taking in the crowds at his hanging and reflecting when asked if there are any last words. He responds, “I only regret that I have but one life to give for my country.” A man who had sacrificed love, career and family for country, the pull of his life story and masthead of a tragic figure had captivated the author. Weaving fact and fiction together to braid a captivating story, Wilcoxson accepts that “there is no way to be certain at this point if he said all or none of them.”
Samantha Wilcoxson has become prominent as an author of biographical fiction. Her writing humanizes and gives voice to those at the throes of larger historical processes and events. She writes non-fiction for Pen & Sword History. She has written “Women of the American Revolution,” which depicts and navigates the lives of 18th century women. Coming soon is her biography of James Alexander Hamilton, “Son of the American Revolution,” published by Pen & Sword History.
Wilcoxson could be found here:
• Website: https://samanthawilcoxson.blogspot.com/
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/samantha_wi...
• Twitter: https://twitter.com/carpe_librum
Wilcoxson writes the story of Nathan Hale from birth, through childhood with his brother Enoch and into their adulthood as students at Yale University. The reader connects with the plotline and the stakes of a man who sacrificed his life with a coming-of-age story. As the reader journeys through the unfolding of political and military timelines of this figure, there is always understanding that this narrative is based on a real story. Nathan Hale was a living and breathing man acting within the 18th century. Ultimately, he is remembered as a hero.
At 21 and a graduate from Yale, Hale took on a teaching contract and was devoted to this work first in East Haddam and later in New London. He let women attend separately in the early hours, a revolutionary and heroic act in its own right. Hale’s teaching career would be interrupted with the onslaught of military and political revolution. The Revolutionary War began in 1775 and Hale joined a Connecticut militia unit. Elected as first lieutenant within 5 months, Hale was persuaded in a letter by Benjamin Tallmadge to accept a commission as first lieutenant in the 7th Connecticut Regiment. Further, Hale joined the first US organised intelligence service organization. With steady progression his lifeline shifts when the Continental Army moved into Manhattan to defend New York City against the British. At this point, Hale was the only volunteer to act as a spy in Manhattan, Hale set out to camouflage himself as a Dutch schoolteacher. He was betrayed. He was questioned by British General William Howe and was prosecuted by hanging.
I was invested in what was denied to Hale during his execution and how Wilcoxson offered us an intimate view of this denial from Hale’s own perspective. He requested a Bible, his final request. He was denied this request. He was allowed to write letters as well that were torn up before him. Also, he had chosen to fight for his country instead of living a life loving a woman. Wilcoxson herself identifies that the quote by Betsy at the beginning of Chapter 39 is authentic. “No species of deception had any lurking place in his frank, open, meek and pious mind; his soul disdained disguise, however imperious circumstances of personal safety might demand a resort to duplicity & ambiguity. On the whole, I then thought him one of the most perfect human characters recorded in history or exemplified in any age or nation.” Betsy had written these words decades after Hale’s death. Yet, Wilcoxson articulates that “Betsy’s ultimatum is a figment of my imagination.” And in imagining this ultimatum, the reader feels the extent of what Hale had sacrificed at such a young age. “She was gone in a swirl of skirts and cries that left me utterly devastated.”
Wilcoxson wrote about Hale because he is a tragic hero, his unrealized potential during his time. I like that she articulated in her “Afterward” that she wanted to write a novel that appealed to both male and female readers. His life story is essentially tragic, but the progression of the events and more importantly the choices that this young man made, connect with all of us. Although, I feel his story propels us to further contemplate what we would truly sacrifice and fight for if we found ourselves in the same circumstances. My final contemplation of this text lies in the reality that Wilcoxson voiced that Hale has monuments dedicated to him but “no contemporary image of him exists.” I like to think that “But One Life” functions as a textual monument for him, a space we can stop long enough before, to reflect, to contemplate, to rise ourselves to the adversity and challenges we face in our own lives each day.
Thank you to Samantha Wilcoxson and Coffee & Thorn for the complimentary copy in request for an honest review!
December 29, 2023
Stirring tale of patriotism
Wilcoxson accurately describes the story of Nathan Hale, American patriot. Hales’s human side and weaknesses are on full display along with his strengths. The pacing occasionally lags a bit, but overall a very enjoyable read.
Wilcoxson accurately describes the story of Nathan Hale, American patriot. Hales’s human side and weaknesses are on full display along with his strengths. The pacing occasionally lags a bit, but overall a very enjoyable read.
June 9, 2024
I think this book would have read differently if I had been taught at school – as perhaps American children are – about Nathan Hale, hero of the American War of Independence, martyred by his dedication to the independence of his emerging nation. (Oh how nations love their dead heroes!)
I read it “blind”. I didn’t know who the characters were, or where the story was going, and for a while (mea culpa, I must have missed the subtitle...) I didn’t realise that Nathan, the person from whose perspective is told, would end up as the hero of the story. He seemed such a mild character, a younger son, bookish and kind, well suited to the life of a schoolteacher, his attention and admiration fixed on others, particularly Benjamin Tallmadge, who seemed to be cut from more heroic cloth.
I hugely enjoyed the quiet narrative of his time at Yale – in an era when boys went to college at 14 and graduated at 18 – and his growing engagement with the political ideas and turmoil of the time. I was completely absorbed by his life as a teacher and his warm and loving relationships with his family, particularly his brother Enoch, and his blossoming romance with his sweetheart. These episodes are told gently, and beautifully convey the mindset of the time.
But then War. Young and idealistic, like so many young men in so many wars, he joins up to fight for his country against British oppression.
The story as it then unfolded appalled me. Here he was, such a young man, so inexperienced in life, with zero training and almost zero guidance, persuaded to volunteer for the dangerous and disparaged role of “spy”. The author does not press the point, but equally she leaves it quite clear that the objective of his mission was unclear from the start, his means of achieving it an almost complete blank, and his preparation for it non-existent. In taking on this role, his idealism is powerful but his naivety is greater
Of course, before he achieves anything of any value, he is detected and captured. And of course, he is then executed – not before his final requests, for a bible and a priest, are denied by the British and his final letters to his loved ones are torn up in front of him. A pointlessly cruel death. The British are the villains here, but what of those senior officers who signed him up for this mission? Did they think for one moment of Nathan Hale’s one life, before they sent him to this rather certain death?
By all accounts he faced his death bravely and died with dignity. But oh, what a waste.
The book is written without unnecessary flourishes, without jingoism and with clear eyes. Retrospectively, I admire this in it. The narrative has a bright, crystal quality, but also an honesty that is unusual in books about heroes. Its rather flat tone leaves the reader to read between the lines and supply the emotional depth. If I were American, and knew the story from my school days, perhaps I would have felt a certain pride from the start and added a hurrah even if I allowed myself the sentimentality of a tear. As it was, I was left thinking bleakly of the tragedy of all wars. So much waste of so many lives. It doesn’t matter to the generals that each of their men has but one life to lay down. They have thousands of lives at their disposal and without much thought might lay down every one. (Except, on the whole, their own.)
I read it “blind”. I didn’t know who the characters were, or where the story was going, and for a while (mea culpa, I must have missed the subtitle...) I didn’t realise that Nathan, the person from whose perspective is told, would end up as the hero of the story. He seemed such a mild character, a younger son, bookish and kind, well suited to the life of a schoolteacher, his attention and admiration fixed on others, particularly Benjamin Tallmadge, who seemed to be cut from more heroic cloth.
I hugely enjoyed the quiet narrative of his time at Yale – in an era when boys went to college at 14 and graduated at 18 – and his growing engagement with the political ideas and turmoil of the time. I was completely absorbed by his life as a teacher and his warm and loving relationships with his family, particularly his brother Enoch, and his blossoming romance with his sweetheart. These episodes are told gently, and beautifully convey the mindset of the time.
But then War. Young and idealistic, like so many young men in so many wars, he joins up to fight for his country against British oppression.
The story as it then unfolded appalled me. Here he was, such a young man, so inexperienced in life, with zero training and almost zero guidance, persuaded to volunteer for the dangerous and disparaged role of “spy”. The author does not press the point, but equally she leaves it quite clear that the objective of his mission was unclear from the start, his means of achieving it an almost complete blank, and his preparation for it non-existent. In taking on this role, his idealism is powerful but his naivety is greater
Of course, before he achieves anything of any value, he is detected and captured. And of course, he is then executed – not before his final requests, for a bible and a priest, are denied by the British and his final letters to his loved ones are torn up in front of him. A pointlessly cruel death. The British are the villains here, but what of those senior officers who signed him up for this mission? Did they think for one moment of Nathan Hale’s one life, before they sent him to this rather certain death?
By all accounts he faced his death bravely and died with dignity. But oh, what a waste.
The book is written without unnecessary flourishes, without jingoism and with clear eyes. Retrospectively, I admire this in it. The narrative has a bright, crystal quality, but also an honesty that is unusual in books about heroes. Its rather flat tone leaves the reader to read between the lines and supply the emotional depth. If I were American, and knew the story from my school days, perhaps I would have felt a certain pride from the start and added a hurrah even if I allowed myself the sentimentality of a tear. As it was, I was left thinking bleakly of the tragedy of all wars. So much waste of so many lives. It doesn’t matter to the generals that each of their men has but one life to lay down. They have thousands of lives at their disposal and without much thought might lay down every one. (Except, on the whole, their own.)
June 10, 2024
Samantha Wilcoxson’s But One Life, a biographical novel of Nathan Hale, is thoroughly and deeply researched, immersing the reader in a convincing, detailed recreation of late 18th century colonial life in the United States. The influences on Hale’s life are clearly delineated: faith, bolstered by his brother Enoch’s even deeper religious conviction; classical thought (translated through a popular play of the time, Joseph Addison’s Cato), and the beliefs fostered and developed through debate and discussion during his years at Yale, especially in the Linonian Society.
Hale is a hero to many citizens of the United States, for his actions and his attributed last words: I only regret that I have but one life to give to my country – but he is also a tragic figure, a young man who allowed his impatient desire to contribute to the colonists’ War of Independence against Great Britain to be his downfall. Unsuited for the role he takes on, untrained and working against his friends’ advice, his bold gesture of patriotism results in his death by hanging. Wilcoxson does not shy away from this interpretation, showing Hale’s actions in his last days as they were: naïve and bound to fail.
Wilcoxson’s novel fleshes out Hale’s life with a writer’s imagination, although only a failed romance strays far from the established facts. Hale’s life may have been one lived in a limited geography, but the ideas of thinkers and statesmen travelled to his world, as did news of the clashes between colonists and British troops even as early as his years at Yale. Here lies my only quibble with But One Life: other than reports of two uprisings involving violence, very little background into the causes of the growing frustration of the colonists with Britain is given: the Stamp and Townsend acts, resulting in taxation without representation; the Port Act, and the insistence by the British parliament that they had political control of the colonies. The discussions at Yale, especially in the Linonian Society, could have provided an ideal vehicle for background, which, while it may be familiar to readers educated in schools in the United States, may not be to readers from other countries.
Nonetheless, But One Life is a solid, well written biographical novel of a man seen by many as an American hero. Recommended.
Hale is a hero to many citizens of the United States, for his actions and his attributed last words: I only regret that I have but one life to give to my country – but he is also a tragic figure, a young man who allowed his impatient desire to contribute to the colonists’ War of Independence against Great Britain to be his downfall. Unsuited for the role he takes on, untrained and working against his friends’ advice, his bold gesture of patriotism results in his death by hanging. Wilcoxson does not shy away from this interpretation, showing Hale’s actions in his last days as they were: naïve and bound to fail.
Wilcoxson’s novel fleshes out Hale’s life with a writer’s imagination, although only a failed romance strays far from the established facts. Hale’s life may have been one lived in a limited geography, but the ideas of thinkers and statesmen travelled to his world, as did news of the clashes between colonists and British troops even as early as his years at Yale. Here lies my only quibble with But One Life: other than reports of two uprisings involving violence, very little background into the causes of the growing frustration of the colonists with Britain is given: the Stamp and Townsend acts, resulting in taxation without representation; the Port Act, and the insistence by the British parliament that they had political control of the colonies. The discussions at Yale, especially in the Linonian Society, could have provided an ideal vehicle for background, which, while it may be familiar to readers educated in schools in the United States, may not be to readers from other countries.
Nonetheless, But One Life is a solid, well written biographical novel of a man seen by many as an American hero. Recommended.
June 12, 2024
I started this book with a lot of misgivings. I don’t like books about war heroes. I am not a fan of the United States. And in recent years, thanks to Trump, the term “American Patriot” has become very ugly. So although the book was warmly recommended to me, I was ready to put it down at the first sign of jingoism, and if, for a moment it glorified war, I was ready to write a harsh review.
It won me over. As well as being a meticulously researched historical biography - with a dash of fiction to fill in the gaps - it’s an exploration of how a hero might be made, about how a young mind might turn to patriotic sacrifice, how individual happiness is lost in the machinery of war. Much of the book is a simple and sympathetic telling of a young lad’s life: friendships, family, adventures at college, idealism, doubt, romance. The characters have a solidity that defies political generalisation: they aren’t cardboard cutouts representing political ideas, they are just people: people who really lived, who happened to be there, at that time. That ground is established in painstaking detail, very slowly – if one wanted a story about a war hero, the slowness of the first half of the book might have made one put it down, whereas for me it kept me reading and took a hold on me that wouldn’t let go even when we got to the war bit...
Actually, the “war bit” is deftly done. Nothing is glorified. The politics are crisply dealt with but without jingoism. As an officer responsible for hungry, unpaid men, hungry himself, losing heart, watching as his men grow sick, he remains compelling. As a volunteer for an unwelcome and desperately dangerous role, he is driven equally by his own idealism and the readiness of others to exploit this for their own amitions. This is, actually, what war is like.
And as for the heroism, the author cuts no corners. The British are in the wrong, but they are not cookie-cutter bad guys, just people fighting the same war, by accident on the other side, some decent enough, others not. As the story rolls to its sacrificial conclusion, it holds the line: managing to be deeply moving without sentimentality. At the end, yes, he cuts a heroic figure, but against the background of all that the author has already told us, this is psychologically grounded, comprehensible. Tosh free. And yes, despite everything, one has to admire heroism.
It won me over. As well as being a meticulously researched historical biography - with a dash of fiction to fill in the gaps - it’s an exploration of how a hero might be made, about how a young mind might turn to patriotic sacrifice, how individual happiness is lost in the machinery of war. Much of the book is a simple and sympathetic telling of a young lad’s life: friendships, family, adventures at college, idealism, doubt, romance. The characters have a solidity that defies political generalisation: they aren’t cardboard cutouts representing political ideas, they are just people: people who really lived, who happened to be there, at that time. That ground is established in painstaking detail, very slowly – if one wanted a story about a war hero, the slowness of the first half of the book might have made one put it down, whereas for me it kept me reading and took a hold on me that wouldn’t let go even when we got to the war bit...
Actually, the “war bit” is deftly done. Nothing is glorified. The politics are crisply dealt with but without jingoism. As an officer responsible for hungry, unpaid men, hungry himself, losing heart, watching as his men grow sick, he remains compelling. As a volunteer for an unwelcome and desperately dangerous role, he is driven equally by his own idealism and the readiness of others to exploit this for their own amitions. This is, actually, what war is like.
And as for the heroism, the author cuts no corners. The British are in the wrong, but they are not cookie-cutter bad guys, just people fighting the same war, by accident on the other side, some decent enough, others not. As the story rolls to its sacrificial conclusion, it holds the line: managing to be deeply moving without sentimentality. At the end, yes, he cuts a heroic figure, but against the background of all that the author has already told us, this is psychologically grounded, comprehensible. Tosh free. And yes, despite everything, one has to admire heroism.
June 7, 2024
Unveiling Nathan Hale: A Riveting Dive into Patriotism and Betrayal
Diving into Samantha Wilcoxson's "But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale" was like unearthing a hidden gem in American historical fiction. Wilcoxson masterfully breathes life into the enigmatic figure of Nathan Hale, whisking readers through the tumultuous era of the American Revolution with gripping prose and meticulous attention to detail.
From Hale's formative years at Harvard to his fateful decision to serve as a spy, Wilcoxson captures the essence of a young man grappling with the weight of his convictions in the face of betrayal. Through her vivid portrayal, Hale emerges not just as a historical figure, but as a relatable and complex character torn between faith, idealism, and duty.
What sets Wilcoxson's narrative apart is her ability to seamlessly blend fact with fiction, offering readers a rich tapestry of historical context while weaving a compelling story that keeps them hooked from start to finish. As someone with a personal connection to the Revolutionary War, I found myself utterly captivated by Wilcoxson's portrayal of this pivotal period in American history.
Moreover, Wilcoxson's inclusion of a comprehensive list of references is a testament to her dedication to authenticity and scholarship. It's clear that she has done her homework, and her passion for her subject shines through on every page.
In conclusion, "But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale" is a must-read for anyone interested in delving deeper into the life and legacy of this remarkable figure. Wilcoxson's gripping narrative will leave you craving more, prompting further exploration into the fascinating story of Nathan Hale.
Diving into Samantha Wilcoxson's "But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale" was like unearthing a hidden gem in American historical fiction. Wilcoxson masterfully breathes life into the enigmatic figure of Nathan Hale, whisking readers through the tumultuous era of the American Revolution with gripping prose and meticulous attention to detail.
From Hale's formative years at Harvard to his fateful decision to serve as a spy, Wilcoxson captures the essence of a young man grappling with the weight of his convictions in the face of betrayal. Through her vivid portrayal, Hale emerges not just as a historical figure, but as a relatable and complex character torn between faith, idealism, and duty.
What sets Wilcoxson's narrative apart is her ability to seamlessly blend fact with fiction, offering readers a rich tapestry of historical context while weaving a compelling story that keeps them hooked from start to finish. As someone with a personal connection to the Revolutionary War, I found myself utterly captivated by Wilcoxson's portrayal of this pivotal period in American history.
Moreover, Wilcoxson's inclusion of a comprehensive list of references is a testament to her dedication to authenticity and scholarship. It's clear that she has done her homework, and her passion for her subject shines through on every page.
In conclusion, "But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale" is a must-read for anyone interested in delving deeper into the life and legacy of this remarkable figure. Wilcoxson's gripping narrative will leave you craving more, prompting further exploration into the fascinating story of Nathan Hale.
June 8, 2024
Check out all my reviews at: https://www.avonnalovesgenres.com
BUT ONE LIFE: The Story of Nathan Hale by Samantha Wilcoxson is a biographical historical fiction about the short life of American revolutionary idealist and patriot, Nathan Hale. This story is told in the first person which lends itself to the addition of personal religious beliefs as well as his belief in the revolutionary cause.
This tale begins when Nathan goes off to study at Yale College with his closest older brother, Enoch. While in college, Soon Nathan begins to form and stand up for his own beliefs through political and philosophical debates. At a time of revolutionary fervor, many tenants of religious beliefs tie in with the cause, also. Feeling the British oppression and with the convincing of one of his best friends from Yale, Nathan joins the revolutionary cause, but is soon captured and considered a spy. The British sentence for captured spies is to be hung.
This story covers Nathan Hale’s life from approximately 14 years of age to his execution at 21 years of age. I found the beginning of the story, recounting his years at Yale, to be interesting but slow paced and it also took me awhile to become accustomed to the prose which is written as if the reader is in 1700’s. As the story got into revolutionary politics and Nathan’s part in the war the pace picked up dramatically and I was more invested. In school, we were taught Hale was a symbol of patriotism and self-sacrifice and this story brings the young idealistic and religious man to life instead of a myth.
RATING: 3.5 out of 5 (Rounded Up)
BUT ONE LIFE: The Story of Nathan Hale by Samantha Wilcoxson is a biographical historical fiction about the short life of American revolutionary idealist and patriot, Nathan Hale. This story is told in the first person which lends itself to the addition of personal religious beliefs as well as his belief in the revolutionary cause.
This tale begins when Nathan goes off to study at Yale College with his closest older brother, Enoch. While in college, Soon Nathan begins to form and stand up for his own beliefs through political and philosophical debates. At a time of revolutionary fervor, many tenants of religious beliefs tie in with the cause, also. Feeling the British oppression and with the convincing of one of his best friends from Yale, Nathan joins the revolutionary cause, but is soon captured and considered a spy. The British sentence for captured spies is to be hung.
This story covers Nathan Hale’s life from approximately 14 years of age to his execution at 21 years of age. I found the beginning of the story, recounting his years at Yale, to be interesting but slow paced and it also took me awhile to become accustomed to the prose which is written as if the reader is in 1700’s. As the story got into revolutionary politics and Nathan’s part in the war the pace picked up dramatically and I was more invested. In school, we were taught Hale was a symbol of patriotism and self-sacrifice and this story brings the young idealistic and religious man to life instead of a myth.
RATING: 3.5 out of 5 (Rounded Up)
June 8, 2024
An intriguing read, particularly suited for those who are interested in, or want to know more about American history -- and the birth of a nation. I know the British view, what started the War of Independence (basically the British stopping the smuggling trade at Rhode Island and a greed for taxes) and some of the early American nautical history but that is about my limit.
Nathan Hale was an American patriot, someone, I suspect, that many of us British readers have never heard of, which is where historical fiction nicely fills that empty gap of course.
Samantha Wilcoxson portrays Hale's character well, his strengths and weaknesses, his beliefs and his determination, but like most stories of war and conflict this is rather a tragic and sad story about a man who follows his principles to the bitter end.
As I know nothing of Hale, I cannot say whether the book is accurate regarding research etc. I think I would have enjoyed the read more, had I been more aware of the characters involved, and indeed known more about the American view of this bitter era of history -- not the author's fault that I don't!
The pacing of the narrative does slow a little in places which is a shame, and I felt the ending was a tad rushed, but all the same, a most interesting read particularly for American history enthusiasts.
Nathan Hale was an American patriot, someone, I suspect, that many of us British readers have never heard of, which is where historical fiction nicely fills that empty gap of course.
Samantha Wilcoxson portrays Hale's character well, his strengths and weaknesses, his beliefs and his determination, but like most stories of war and conflict this is rather a tragic and sad story about a man who follows his principles to the bitter end.
As I know nothing of Hale, I cannot say whether the book is accurate regarding research etc. I think I would have enjoyed the read more, had I been more aware of the characters involved, and indeed known more about the American view of this bitter era of history -- not the author's fault that I don't!
The pacing of the narrative does slow a little in places which is a shame, and I felt the ending was a tad rushed, but all the same, a most interesting read particularly for American history enthusiasts.
June 10, 2024
Samantha Wilcoxson writes an interesting book about Nathan Hale
Nathan Hale is a very interesting book and topic for this author to pick. Nathan Hale was a patriot in the American Revolutionary War. He was also a spy for the Continental Army and a hero, for going to enemy lines to gain valuable information of the British and to relay this to his own army. This is the first book I have read from this author. Unfortunately, Hale was killed, hanged as a spy by the British. He was indeed a hero, and I like how Samantha Wilcoxson tells his story. This is one of those books that grabs you from the start and pulls you in. If you like historical biographies, you will enjoy this book, especially if you're a Revolutionary war era history buff. This read is more than just words on a page. What I like about this story is that it doesn't read like a textbook, which some historical books and biographies can sometimes do. Many remember Nathan Hales famous quote before his dead, 'I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country.' But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale is a definite recommendation by Amy's Bookshelf Reviews. I read this book to give my unbiased and honest review. Amy's Bookshelf Reviews recommends that anyone who reads this book to also write a review.
Nathan Hale is a very interesting book and topic for this author to pick. Nathan Hale was a patriot in the American Revolutionary War. He was also a spy for the Continental Army and a hero, for going to enemy lines to gain valuable information of the British and to relay this to his own army. This is the first book I have read from this author. Unfortunately, Hale was killed, hanged as a spy by the British. He was indeed a hero, and I like how Samantha Wilcoxson tells his story. This is one of those books that grabs you from the start and pulls you in. If you like historical biographies, you will enjoy this book, especially if you're a Revolutionary war era history buff. This read is more than just words on a page. What I like about this story is that it doesn't read like a textbook, which some historical books and biographies can sometimes do. Many remember Nathan Hales famous quote before his dead, 'I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country.' But One Life: The Story of Nathan Hale is a definite recommendation by Amy's Bookshelf Reviews. I read this book to give my unbiased and honest review. Amy's Bookshelf Reviews recommends that anyone who reads this book to also write a review.
June 7, 2024
I received a copy of this for free, to review for a tour with Coffee and Thorn.
“But One Life” follows Nathan Hale, a student at Yale university in the 1770s. When I started reading, it didn't take me long to warm to him as a narrator. He seemed an intelligent, warm character, and I loved his enthusiasm. He seemed like someone who would see the good in everything, and appreciate everything. I wondered, what was it like to be a student in the 1770s? I was keen to read more of Nathan's story.
Attending a college or university is an exciting and important time, a time of growth and discovery, when a person may make major decisions about their future. As I read more of Nathan's story, I tried to have faith and believe that the choices he made would be the best ones for him.
I came to see him not only as the protagonist, but also the hero of the story. I became quite invested and emotional, particularly towards the end. Nathan's story speaks to friendship, bravery, and to the importance of always being true to yourself. It was uplifting to read.
Thank you to Coffee and Thorn, and to the author, for the opportunity to read and review this.
“But One Life” follows Nathan Hale, a student at Yale university in the 1770s. When I started reading, it didn't take me long to warm to him as a narrator. He seemed an intelligent, warm character, and I loved his enthusiasm. He seemed like someone who would see the good in everything, and appreciate everything. I wondered, what was it like to be a student in the 1770s? I was keen to read more of Nathan's story.
Attending a college or university is an exciting and important time, a time of growth and discovery, when a person may make major decisions about their future. As I read more of Nathan's story, I tried to have faith and believe that the choices he made would be the best ones for him.
I came to see him not only as the protagonist, but also the hero of the story. I became quite invested and emotional, particularly towards the end. Nathan's story speaks to friendship, bravery, and to the importance of always being true to yourself. It was uplifting to read.
Thank you to Coffee and Thorn, and to the author, for the opportunity to read and review this.
June 8, 2024
Richly Imagined Retelling of Nathan Hale’s Life
Before reading this fictionalized biography of Nathan Hale, the only thing I knew about him was his famous quote: “I regret that I have but one life to give for my country.”
The author draws you into the world of young Nathan Hale with the elegant language and fine manners of the time. I quickly became immersed in the story of young Nathan studying at Yale at the age of fourteen with his beloved brother, Enoch. The unfolding of Hale’s path from schoolteacher to joining the militia and leaving behind a woman he loved was well-told.
This very personal reimagining of this young man’s life touched me deeply. As I neared the end of the novel, I hesitated to read the last chapter, knowing his fate. I highly recommend this story of an American patriot who sacrificed everything for his country.
Before reading this fictionalized biography of Nathan Hale, the only thing I knew about him was his famous quote: “I regret that I have but one life to give for my country.”
The author draws you into the world of young Nathan Hale with the elegant language and fine manners of the time. I quickly became immersed in the story of young Nathan studying at Yale at the age of fourteen with his beloved brother, Enoch. The unfolding of Hale’s path from schoolteacher to joining the militia and leaving behind a woman he loved was well-told.
This very personal reimagining of this young man’s life touched me deeply. As I neared the end of the novel, I hesitated to read the last chapter, knowing his fate. I highly recommend this story of an American patriot who sacrificed everything for his country.
March 25, 2024
The author penned an impressive account of the epic Revolutionary War figure, Nathan Hale. Everything in life begins with family, and he had a large one. Of all his siblings, it was Enoch that was the closest to him. He was the only one for whom he could confide his deepest and darkest secrets. In short, they were inseparable. However, when it came time after from graduation from Yale University, they went their separate ways, a blow to younger brother, Nathan. I gathered from the theme of the book, if his brother had been with him all along Nathan's ending might not have ended so tragically.
March 23, 2024
great book
What a great book! It was difficult to put down. You feel as if you are part of the American Revolution and a part of Nathan’s life!
I would highly recommend this book! Very well written!
What a great book! It was difficult to put down. You feel as if you are part of the American Revolution and a part of Nathan’s life!
I would highly recommend this book! Very well written!
June 23, 2022
Overall satisfied with this read.
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews