I attended a launch event and reading of this book when it was first published. I decided not to buy the book on the night but with a vague idea I would buy it later. Which I did. Except when I started reading it I realised I had actually bought Mark Webber's book instead. Oops. I finished Mark's book and then duly purchased this book.
A book written by the drummer is always going to be a deep cut. And this book could certainly have done with a bit more vigorous editing - just silly things like using the same word twice in one sentence and (gasp) a typo in one of the track names. Also Nick's style of cheeky northern chap was probably never going to be a comfortable fit for me as a reader. There were not a lot of laughs for me but a few wry smiles.
Despite all that, this is a competent book that manages to build a bit of excitement even around very well known events. Once I got used to the writing style I was swept along quite merrily.
I did sometimes wonder who Nick thought he was writing for - do any Pulp fans need an explanation of what a working men's club or Glastonbury festival is? Surely anyone too young or not British enough would just look it up online?
The most interesting bit for me was probably reading about how difficult the process was recording This is Hardcore. Due to my age (I was around 15 when this album was released) this is 'my' Pulp album in a way that Different Class isn't. I listened to it while some pretty formative life experiences were going on. So it's weird to hear that the creative process was so stressful and that Nick didn't think some of the tracks were all that great. Certainly I knew that it was less commercially successful than Different Class but when you're 15 that's all the better. I never considered what a let down it might have been for the band to feel the spotlight had moved on.
Unlike Mark's book, which showed quite a bit of resentment and grumpiness around the rest of the band, particularly Jarvis, Nick presents himself as being a very easy going guy. He occasionally disagreed with a decision, wasn't listened to, and said, 'Oh well.' Which is probably the kind of dependable, non dramatic person you need in a band. He does occasionally stoop to slagging off other bands which seems a little petty at this distance.
It did amuse me in the thanks at the end that he mentioned he had consulted Truth and Beauty to check some of the facts, which is a book I have also read. So, bring it on Russell and Candida, I look forward to increasing my collection of books by and about Pulp.