This has to be my biggest disappointment of the year so far, and I couldn't feel sadder about it. With it being Miyazaki's favourite childhood book, possibly the inspiration for the next Studio Ghibli film; a book about a kid who wonders and questions what it means to live, to love, to create connections with others without feeling lonely; what could go wrong? It had all the ingredients for me to adore it.
And yet, here I am trying not to be too negative 🙈
I'll say this first: if this had been told from Copper's perspective only, I probably would have enjoyed it so much more. The uncle's chapters ruined it completely for me.
I praised this book during a reading vlog when I'd just read the first few chapters, saying how much I loved that it was treating kids respectfully - meaning, treating them as the smart, sensible, curious people they are, despite their naivety, which was also embraced, as it should be. Their youth was not being used as an excuse for them to be looked down at or mistreated by adults, which I always appreciate.
While I never felt this book was exactly disrespecting children, soon enough, when we started getting the uncle's responses to Copper's letters, it immediately went downhill for me. Copper asks big questions; questions that either don't have answers and everyone spends their lives trying to figure them out or, when they do, they're not simple, easy answers. I was hoping for the book to touch on that, and to tell Copper that it's okay. The world is a messy, complicated place, and everyone feels lost. All we can do is try to be the best version of ourselves, help others, be empathetic and respectful, and navigate all this mess together.
Instead, what I got were extremely condescending responses from the uncle. Instead of meaningful conversations, they were pretentious. Instead of taking time to slowly try to unfold and discuss complicated topics (school bullying, poverty, racism, classism are all mentioned examples), they were rushed and treated like something simple, and if they were discussing favourite colours. His responses sounded pompous, and dismissed his nephew's intelligence and care when questioning him.
This would have been a lovely opportunity to develop Copper and his uncle's relationship, while leaving subtle hints about the world around them, with all its ups and downs. But unfortunately, it didn't feel meaningful at all.