“Westport” is James Comey’s follow-up to his first novel “Central Park West”, and much like its predecessor, carries many accolades and fanfare. It has received a whole lot of critical acclaim and strong word of mouth recommendations, including Publishers Weekly, Booklist, and several renowned bestselling authors. Not a bad way to start oof your writing career.
James Comey brings a strong background of experience to his first crime novel. He has been a prosecutor, defense lawyer, general counsel, and served as Director of the FBI. If that doesn’t help give you an inside edge of knowledge and understanding of the criminal, judicial, and political world, I don’t know what does.
But can he write a good novel? The good news is yes. Not only can he write a very good one, but he has now proven that he can do it again for a second time.
“Westport” is a worthy, and in some ways stronger, follow-up to “Central Park West”.
The book begins two years later with the same protagonist, Nora Carleton, now living in Westport, Connecticut, with her daughter, Sophie, and mother, Teresa. Nora left her job at the U.S. Attorney’s office in New York City to become the lead counsel at Saugatuck Associates, the world’s largest hedge fund. She was recommended for the position by her daughter’s father’s father-in-law, who also pays for Sophie to attend an excellent private school to make things easy for co-parenting and living close together. Nora is fine with the arrangement and with a few exceptions likes the people she works with at Saugatuck’s.
That is until things go bad one evening when a well-dressed woman is found dead in an abandoned red canoe with her throat slit.
The deceased woman is Helen Carmichael, Nora’s boss, and it was Nora’s canoe that she was found dead in. When the investigating detective, Demi Kofatos, interviews Nora, blood is also found on her car which adds to appearance of Nora’s involvement in murder.
Things unravel fast for Nora as she becomes the primary lead in the investigation. She realizes that someone’s trying to frame her, but why? Has she made an enemy at the company? She knows of at least one person who wants her job, but would he kill for it? Then there’s the secret investigation that she and Helen were working on to find out who was possibly stealing from the company’s hedge funds. Could someone have discovered what they were doing? Were they getting close to finding the guilty party?
Nora realizes that if she gets arrested and charged with murder, it will have a severe impact on her daughter that will not be able to be erased. It’s time to protect herself and call for help. Before she knows it, her old colleagues from the U.S. Attorney’s office arrive - Benny Dugan, her old partner and investigator, and Carmen Garcia, her previous boss and lawyer. Their goal is to keep Nora out of jail while finding the real killer and bringing that person to justice.
It’s up to them to stay a step ahead of the police investigation, which includes a police chief who wants to see Nora charged in a rush for judgment as well as an old conflict with Benny from when they worked together in the past. They also have to stay ahead of killer who is helping make the case against Nora tight and impossible to prove her way out of. It looks like Nora’s days are numbered…
There’s more I could share with the synopsis, but I really don’t want to give too much away regarding the plot so that you can have the pleasure of finding out for yourself. Self-discovery makes this book even better.
As I mentioned with my previous review of Comey’s first novel, he again masterfully combined characters, plotting, setting, with his law enforcement and legal background to create a savory and breathless reading experience. I enjoyed this one quite a bit, even more than his first for two reasons.
First, because of the awesome characters. He introduced them in the first book and I grew to admire, respect, and love them. Then, in the second book, he puts them in dire circumstances and forces them to work together to save their own. It makes for an emotional focus that only gets stronger as he peels the mystery one layer at a time.
Second, the mystery is much more personal than the first novel. I loved the parallel plotting of the two court cases in the prior novel and it really worked. Comey created a complex focus around the courtroom legal proceedings and the mob culture. At the same time, he carefully started revealing his primary character backgrounds and family relationships. Those histories and conflicts created empathy for them that Comey brilliantly builds on and amplifies even more in the second book. The investment in the first book pays off in the second because Nora’s freedom is at risk and the villain she most likely knows and works with rather than an outside influence. You needed the first book to set-up the second to create a successful one two punch.
Comey’s pacing and delivery were absolutely gripping throughout, and there were several surprising twists and turns along the way. This was a great read for those who love the mystery / crime genre with a real sense of authenticity and addictive storytelling. This book was so good that I read it in 24 hours. Not that I recommend that approach; I just wanted to share what an amazing read it was for me.
As I mentioned in my review of his first book, Comey knows his stuff and he spins a marvelous crime novel that combines elements of Michael Connelly (investigation), David Baldacci (suspense), and John Grisham (storytelling). I kid you not. Those three are my personal favorite mystery/suspense writers and I have no problems standing behind that. However, what I really enjoyed most about Comey’s first novel is not that he was able to bring in aspects of three of the best gold standard writers in this genre, but that he was able to do it in his own way. His own voice. His own plotting. His own pacing. And his own unique and colorful characters. He took what the greats have done and added his own twist. His own unique voice. He brings a freshness to law enforcement investigations and legal courtroom activities, as well as mixing in small-city politics.
Not only did I enjoy his complex storylines and pacing, I was also drawn to his characters and relationships which were layered with depth, history, and quality. Besides being drawn wholeheartedly to Nora, I continued to be enamored with Benny Dugan, her FBI partner, and Teresa, her mother. Benny was the good guy who does bad things on the job and trying to rebuild his family from mistakes he made in the past. Teresa gives the best advice, love, and support, that any mother or family member can give. And I absolutely (careful of spoilers), without a doubt, loved the developing relationship between these two characters. I didn’t see it coming, but Comey made it seem like a natural fit.
I also appreciated how Helen’s backstory was peeled away, one layer at a time, during the investigation process. It revealed a very complex, intelligent, and analytical character that was multi-dimensional, as well as providing the mystery a bigger impact. I would also be remiss if I didn’t throw a shout to police detective Demi Kofatos, who played a key role in this one, trying to perform an independent investigation while having to hold-off her biased captain hell bent on railroading Nora with the charges. Demi kept a cool head with a focus on doing what was right. She was also hinted at as being more, even a potential love interest, and I hope to see more of her again.
Overall, this novel involved a multitude of characters, several connecting storylines, and a lot of moving parts. Just the kind of novel I enjoy; one in which you peel the onion one layer at a time like a challenging Sudoku or Connections puzzle. Everything from the very first page to the end was a thrilling roller coaster ride, with several dramatic emotional outcomes along the way.
This is an absolutely strong 4.5 out of 5 stars rating. A more than worthy read. I cannot recommend it enough and even though it’s very early in the year, I have a strong feeling that this will end up on my top ten favorite reads list for 2025. Yes, it’s that dang good!