What do you think?
Rate this book


208 pages, Paperback
Published September 3, 2024
Full disclosure I received an Early Reviewer copy of this book through LibraryThing which means that I did request a copy of this book but I did not pay for it. I say that only because paying for this book may have changed my rating some.
Ever since my college days I have been very interested in the way feminism and the idea of what being female means interact especially in literature and the real world. And I think it is very important to keep an open mind in this area as humans are ever evolving which means that feminism and the idea of female needs to evolve also. And this is where this book started to go wrong for me. But let me provide some details of what I mean.
The author, Lisa Bevere, opens the book with the description of a dream involving dragons. In keeping with the accepted meaning of dragons in the Bible, these dragons are harbingers of something terrible and Bevere struggles with why the women in her dream would be nurturing baby dragons which obviously are agents of evil; this lays the ground work for the entire book. I believe she had this dream and I believe that her interpretation of the dream upholds her belief that the way to reclaim the "divine identity" of woman that seems to have fallen by the wayside is to return to the Bible and to follow it religiously (no sarcasm or judgment of this belief intended). After all, religious freedom means being allowed to practice religion as one chooses.
But, having been raised in a Christian church where women were not given enough credit for protecting their families and where evangelism was preached but only if it was to like-minded people, I struggle with any direction to return to a previous time. After all, adapting is what keeps all of us moving forward, whereas digging in ones heels and refusing to move forward only causes you to get run over. And maybe if the author had stuck to religion this may have been a worthy argument.
However, and this is the crux of my issue with this book, there are arguments against the evolution of language and some blatant Bible shopping to back up the points made. There are many Bible "quotations" that do not include the appropriate references which is unfortunate when part of the argument is to return to the Word and study it. In addition, Bevere uses several different translations of the Bible without providing a clear argument for choosing one translation over another especially when the difference in the translations may contradict each other. This takes me back to the original reference to dragons, which may or may not be the result of an evolution of language. Seemingly, there is some debate over whether "dragon" is the appropriate translation of the word "tannin" in the original Hebrew. (While this is an interesting debate, I would not begin to argue one side or the other but it is important to note.)
Finally, this book does a fair amount of glossing over some of the issues that are actually making it hard to maintain a traditional view of femininity. A lot of the argument in this book revolves around insulating oneself from the world while at the same time creating new connections with people. In one instance, someone asks how to talk with a friend who is dealing with gender disphoria and the answer is to tell them to just wait for the next life when all will be well. In another instance a shooting in a Christian school by a trans-male is referenced but there is no context as to what this shooting has to do with the purpose of the book; in fact, I had to hunt down the referenced newspaper article to even find what that shooting was about and was disappointed to not get an answer there either. And probably the biggest issue in the book comes in Chapter 9. In this chapter, Bevere quotes from 1 Timothy where Paul talks about how worship should be performed. This verse specifies men but the author takes it upon herself to assure us that Paul meant to include women when he wrote this. This is an awful lot of conjecture based on very little evidence.
I gave this book 3 stars because I think that it could make an interesting basis for a Bible study that also includes opinions from Bible scholars. But ultimately the book did not give me much hope for "reclaiming our divine identity" because I am not sure that there has ever been a clear understanding of what exactly the Christian idea of femininity is beyond being subservient to men in home and church.