What do you think?
Rate this book
A Genealogy Mystery #1
The Desk from Hoboken
In a bid to heal from the grief of a personal loss, forensic genealogist, RaeJean Hunter, takes on a straightforward case -identify human remains found on a nearby college campus, believed to be the 180-year-old remains of Mary Rogers, a woman who died mysteriously in 1841 and was believed to have been buried in the nearby cemetery that had washed away. It should be simple enough, a project to get her back in the game.
Unfortunately, it quickly becomes anything but. In fact, it becomes downright dangerous.
Someone doesn't want RaeJean to investigate the puzzling death of the woman whose death inspired Edgar Allan Poe's "The Mystery of Marie Roget." As she follows clues through four states and discovers living family members who both help and hinder her search, she quickly realizes that the secrets of Mary Rogers' demise were never meant to be exposed.
What lengths will someone go to keep the truth buried in the past? As threats escalate and RaeJean and her family's lives become endangered, she's forced to follow every lead and use every skill she has to find the answers she needs before it's too late. Using DNA from two famous New England families, historical data, modern genealogical techniques, and a little guidance from a seemingly mystical antique desk, RaeJean takes on the cold case despite being given every reason to abandon it.
After all, what truths have been hidden for 180 years that would be worth bribery, kidnapping, and even murder?
RaeJean Hunter is about to find out.
Unfortunately, it quickly becomes anything but. In fact, it becomes downright dangerous.
Someone doesn't want RaeJean to investigate the puzzling death of the woman whose death inspired Edgar Allan Poe's "The Mystery of Marie Roget." As she follows clues through four states and discovers living family members who both help and hinder her search, she quickly realizes that the secrets of Mary Rogers' demise were never meant to be exposed.
What lengths will someone go to keep the truth buried in the past? As threats escalate and RaeJean and her family's lives become endangered, she's forced to follow every lead and use every skill she has to find the answers she needs before it's too late. Using DNA from two famous New England families, historical data, modern genealogical techniques, and a little guidance from a seemingly mystical antique desk, RaeJean takes on the cold case despite being given every reason to abandon it.
After all, what truths have been hidden for 180 years that would be worth bribery, kidnapping, and even murder?
RaeJean Hunter is about to find out.
446 pages, Paperback
First published March 5, 2024
78 people are currently reading
227 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 81 reviews
December 12, 2023
Many thanks to both Harbor Lane Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an early copy of The Desk from Hoboken. The expected publication date is March 5, 2024.
"After all, what truths have been hidden for 180 years that would be worth bribery, kidnapping, and even murder?"
The Desk from Hoboken starts when RaeJean is asked to investigate the puzzling death of the woman whose death inspired Edgar Allan Poe's "The Mystery of Marie Roget." Although I enjoy reading historical, as well as historical-fiction books, I became a wee bit tired of the repetition in this one. I probably would have enjoyed the book more if I had ever done any genealogy searches, myself.
The Desk from Hoboken. has some very likable characters and some intriguing side stories. There was a touch of romance and paranormal, too. As one who knows nothing about genealogy, I still liked this book ... and I wanted to own the desk!!
"After all, what truths have been hidden for 180 years that would be worth bribery, kidnapping, and even murder?"
The Desk from Hoboken starts when RaeJean is asked to investigate the puzzling death of the woman whose death inspired Edgar Allan Poe's "The Mystery of Marie Roget." Although I enjoy reading historical, as well as historical-fiction books, I became a wee bit tired of the repetition in this one. I probably would have enjoyed the book more if I had ever done any genealogy searches, myself.
The Desk from Hoboken. has some very likable characters and some intriguing side stories. There was a touch of romance and paranormal, too. As one who knows nothing about genealogy, I still liked this book ... and I wanted to own the desk!!
August 20, 2024
The Desk from Hoboken is the first book in the Genealogy Mysteries series by American author, ML Condike. After six months prostrate with grief and depression over a lost pregnancy, forensic genealogist RaeJean Hunter feels that proving the identity of an almost-two-hundred-year-old corpse, rather than a live criminal FBI case, will be a less stressful way to ease back into work.
Mary Rogers was buried in 1841, probably exhumed in 19xx, then reburied. Professor Michael Carver at the Anthropology Department of Connecticut xx College in New London believes that the corpse his student uncovered on a nearby isthmus has washed down from a Rogerene cemetery, and is that of Mary Rogers.
But he’s a middleman for an anonymous client, which gives RaeJean pause. The fact that another genealogist (probably her good friend Claire Allen) suddenly quit the case without explanation also has warning bells ringing. But the inclusion of an antique ladies secretary desk in her fee has her ignoring them: as soon as she saw the desk, it called to her, in almost a spiritual way.
So she sets to work learning about Mary’s ancestors and contemporaries, as well as doing a bit of research on the desk. But she soon finds that someone seems to be one step ahead of her in the search for answers, someone who, when she meets them, is not at all willing to share knowledge.
Finding out why her friend excused herself from the case, and the man in the ballcap stalking her, ought to be enough to put her off the search, but RaeJean is determined.
Condike certainly gives the reader insight into what a genealogist does and how they do it; that a lot of travel is involved in tracking down journals and memoirs, keepsake books, letters, family trees, church records and books written about historical figures, not all of which can be found on the internet. Visits to cemeteries, historical societies and museums, libraries and private homes are required; phone calls, emails and letters are done; facial reconstruction and handwriting experts need to be consulted.
All that is very interesting, but the repeated rehash of information discovered does get quite tedious, and keeping track of the multitude of characters is a challenge. And when RaeJean says, as she is analysing what she has learned “Before I delved more deeply into each card, I’d weed out people who didn’t support my hypothesis” the reader must wonder at just how balanced her conclusions will be.
The plot features hidden notes, abductions, blackmail, imprisonment, theft of historical documents, secrets, lies and a good dose of melodrama. Suspension of disbelief is required for RaeJean’s role as bait in a background FBI sting, and the motive a certain nasty character is less than convincing.
A protagonist who knowingly puts herself in danger, several times, without taking basic precautions loses some of the reader’s respect. Parts of the genealogy are convoluted enough to make the reader give up on following the threads: a family tree at the end would be helpful except it would contain spoilers.
The whole thing drags on rather too long, and it is hoped that the continuity issues are sorted out in the final version. This is a mystery that may appeal to genealogy enthusiasts who have the tolerance to sort out the confusing links, but less patient readers won’t be tempted by further books in the series.
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Harbor Lane Book LLC.
Mary Rogers was buried in 1841, probably exhumed in 19xx, then reburied. Professor Michael Carver at the Anthropology Department of Connecticut xx College in New London believes that the corpse his student uncovered on a nearby isthmus has washed down from a Rogerene cemetery, and is that of Mary Rogers.
But he’s a middleman for an anonymous client, which gives RaeJean pause. The fact that another genealogist (probably her good friend Claire Allen) suddenly quit the case without explanation also has warning bells ringing. But the inclusion of an antique ladies secretary desk in her fee has her ignoring them: as soon as she saw the desk, it called to her, in almost a spiritual way.
So she sets to work learning about Mary’s ancestors and contemporaries, as well as doing a bit of research on the desk. But she soon finds that someone seems to be one step ahead of her in the search for answers, someone who, when she meets them, is not at all willing to share knowledge.
Finding out why her friend excused herself from the case, and the man in the ballcap stalking her, ought to be enough to put her off the search, but RaeJean is determined.
Condike certainly gives the reader insight into what a genealogist does and how they do it; that a lot of travel is involved in tracking down journals and memoirs, keepsake books, letters, family trees, church records and books written about historical figures, not all of which can be found on the internet. Visits to cemeteries, historical societies and museums, libraries and private homes are required; phone calls, emails and letters are done; facial reconstruction and handwriting experts need to be consulted.
All that is very interesting, but the repeated rehash of information discovered does get quite tedious, and keeping track of the multitude of characters is a challenge. And when RaeJean says, as she is analysing what she has learned “Before I delved more deeply into each card, I’d weed out people who didn’t support my hypothesis” the reader must wonder at just how balanced her conclusions will be.
The plot features hidden notes, abductions, blackmail, imprisonment, theft of historical documents, secrets, lies and a good dose of melodrama. Suspension of disbelief is required for RaeJean’s role as bait in a background FBI sting, and the motive a certain nasty character is less than convincing.
A protagonist who knowingly puts herself in danger, several times, without taking basic precautions loses some of the reader’s respect. Parts of the genealogy are convoluted enough to make the reader give up on following the threads: a family tree at the end would be helpful except it would contain spoilers.
The whole thing drags on rather too long, and it is hoped that the continuity issues are sorted out in the final version. This is a mystery that may appeal to genealogy enthusiasts who have the tolerance to sort out the confusing links, but less patient readers won’t be tempted by further books in the series.
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Harbor Lane Book LLC.
April 30, 2025
So many exciting take-aways from this read!
The Desk from Hoboken
by ML Condike explores:
* forensic genealogy!
* who Mary Rogers was . . .through her bones, her passion for womens' health in the 1800's
* why Mary died mysteriously. . .but where?
* Edgar Allan Poe wrote about her - SEE The Mystery of Marie Roget, by Himself
* tips and tricks of deep in the past genealogy
* tips and tricks of fancy old furniture, puzzles and why they did all that hiding back in the day
* why 180 years later someone still cares that Mary should stay disappeared. . . .
The author has other books in this series and I'm more than thrilled that there's more to read about Rae Jean Hunter, Forensic Genealogist!!
*A sincere thank you to ML Condike, Harbor Lane Books LLC and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.* #TheDeskfromHoboken #NetGalley
* forensic genealogy!
* who Mary Rogers was . . .through her bones, her passion for womens' health in the 1800's
* why Mary died mysteriously. . .but where?
* Edgar Allan Poe wrote about her - SEE The Mystery of Marie Roget, by Himself
* tips and tricks of deep in the past genealogy
* tips and tricks of fancy old furniture, puzzles and why they did all that hiding back in the day
* why 180 years later someone still cares that Mary should stay disappeared. . . .
The author has other books in this series and I'm more than thrilled that there's more to read about Rae Jean Hunter, Forensic Genealogist!!
*A sincere thank you to ML Condike, Harbor Lane Books LLC and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.* #TheDeskfromHoboken #NetGalley
March 20, 2024
Who knew that genealogy could be so dangerous?
This new cozy series is full of information, so much so that you might need to reference the family tree documents on the author's website! If you have ever been fascinated with genealogy, this is a series you might want to dive into. I really enjoyed watching the process of RaeJean uncovering documents and tying them to the people she is researching. She is one smart woman, but not without issues that sometimes impact her work when she comes across something that reminds her of her loss. The relationship that she has with her husband, Sam, is a loving one. They are supportive of each other, and their chosen careers sometimes intersect. This happens when RaeJean finds a puzzle box in a desk she accepts as part of her fee to research Mary Roberts.
The mystery is very detailed, especially when it comes to the affected family trees. It takes a little time to keep these people straight in my head, but I think I had it by the end of the book. It is quite interesting to see the lengths some people will go to protect their family name. RaeJean runs into this with Lillian, a Mather and self-appointed historian for the family. Turns out, not many in the family like her, which is a good thing when all is revealed in the end. Lillian has some secrets; see if you can figure them out. I know I didn't!
The story flows nicely, and I was never left hanging, wondering what happened in different situations. The answer might come later in the book, but everything is explained.
There are some minor characters that I would love to see more of in future books. Claire is a fellow genealogist and quite brilliant in her own right. She has a minor storyline in this book, but it ties everything together. Caitlin is RaeJean's sister and, I think, a strong supporter of RaeJean. You can see the family bond quite well.
My review would be remiss if I didn't mention Sophie, her corgi. I love dogs in books, and I really enjoyed Sophie and how she didn't let RaeJean get too engrossed in her work. After all, dogs need to be walked and fed.
This book revived my interest in my own family's genealogy. There is a lot that goes into tracking down the correct information. I am still unsure how forensic genealogy can help identify bones, but I can understand tracing the family lineage.
This book was hard to put down, and we give it 5 paws up.
This new cozy series is full of information, so much so that you might need to reference the family tree documents on the author's website! If you have ever been fascinated with genealogy, this is a series you might want to dive into. I really enjoyed watching the process of RaeJean uncovering documents and tying them to the people she is researching. She is one smart woman, but not without issues that sometimes impact her work when she comes across something that reminds her of her loss. The relationship that she has with her husband, Sam, is a loving one. They are supportive of each other, and their chosen careers sometimes intersect. This happens when RaeJean finds a puzzle box in a desk she accepts as part of her fee to research Mary Roberts.
The mystery is very detailed, especially when it comes to the affected family trees. It takes a little time to keep these people straight in my head, but I think I had it by the end of the book. It is quite interesting to see the lengths some people will go to protect their family name. RaeJean runs into this with Lillian, a Mather and self-appointed historian for the family. Turns out, not many in the family like her, which is a good thing when all is revealed in the end. Lillian has some secrets; see if you can figure them out. I know I didn't!
The story flows nicely, and I was never left hanging, wondering what happened in different situations. The answer might come later in the book, but everything is explained.
There are some minor characters that I would love to see more of in future books. Claire is a fellow genealogist and quite brilliant in her own right. She has a minor storyline in this book, but it ties everything together. Caitlin is RaeJean's sister and, I think, a strong supporter of RaeJean. You can see the family bond quite well.
My review would be remiss if I didn't mention Sophie, her corgi. I love dogs in books, and I really enjoyed Sophie and how she didn't let RaeJean get too engrossed in her work. After all, dogs need to be walked and fed.
This book revived my interest in my own family's genealogy. There is a lot that goes into tracking down the correct information. I am still unsure how forensic genealogy can help identify bones, but I can understand tracing the family lineage.
This book was hard to put down, and we give it 5 paws up.
March 24, 2024
I thoroughly enjoyed this novel. Suspense, multiple subplots that merge, forensic genealogy, and a hint of paranormal keeps this read interesting. Anything genealogy related can get convoluted and confusing, but I expected that.
November 21, 2023
I wanted to love this. I love genealogy and everything research and library related. But this book dragged on and on and on and it was so repetitive. The violence was silly and the characters were melodramatic. It was really more about pregnancy than real mysteries.
I thank NetGalley for letting me read an advance copy
I thank NetGalley for letting me read an advance copy
March 20, 2024
The Desk from Hoboken was a very up-and-down ride with plenty of twists, loops, and drops to keep you entertained throughout its run. From the very beginning, I was hooked on this interesting take on a mystery story. The forensic genealogy side to this book is something I haven't read but was completely fascinated by, especially since I'm a big fan of Forensic Files AND literary history. I found myself looking up different things about how genealogy works and got myself into one rabbit hole after another.
With the forensics and the history aspects of this story, there's just a lot of meat on these pages. There was so much to gravitate to and different places to look, such as the whole Chinese puzzle scenario (which was another interesting thing to look into). Although there's a lot of meat, it never feels too overwhelming. Everything goes chapter by chapter, instead of skipping around so you don't get confused. So instead of a mountain of meat, our author gives us piece by piece, thus opening the world but by bit as we are uncovering an over 100-year-old mystery.
The only caveat I have about this book is that you have to pay attention to the characters because there's ALOT. There are quite a few people alive you have to keep track of and then there are the dead people you are investigating along with our main character. I found myself having to go back a few times to remember how one person is related to another, but after a few chapters, it got easier and I just made little mental notes to myself.
Overall, I was engrossed in The Desk from Hoboken. Readers will enjoy finding out how everything, including the desk, connects to the case that our main character is solving. It's a very unique read and if you're interested in mystery crime novels, this is one you need to put on your list.
With the forensics and the history aspects of this story, there's just a lot of meat on these pages. There was so much to gravitate to and different places to look, such as the whole Chinese puzzle scenario (which was another interesting thing to look into). Although there's a lot of meat, it never feels too overwhelming. Everything goes chapter by chapter, instead of skipping around so you don't get confused. So instead of a mountain of meat, our author gives us piece by piece, thus opening the world but by bit as we are uncovering an over 100-year-old mystery.
The only caveat I have about this book is that you have to pay attention to the characters because there's ALOT. There are quite a few people alive you have to keep track of and then there are the dead people you are investigating along with our main character. I found myself having to go back a few times to remember how one person is related to another, but after a few chapters, it got easier and I just made little mental notes to myself.
Overall, I was engrossed in The Desk from Hoboken. Readers will enjoy finding out how everything, including the desk, connects to the case that our main character is solving. It's a very unique read and if you're interested in mystery crime novels, this is one you need to put on your list.
December 8, 2023
This unique book will appeal to people with an interest in genealogy and mystery. The main character is RaeJean Hunter, who is a freelance forensic genealogist. She has suffered a personal loss and has not had the heart to take on new cases.
Then a body washes out of what was part of an old, nearby cemetery dating back to the 1800's. Rumors soon start that the woman could be Mary Rogers, who had died almost 200 years before. She was a member of a notorious family, and Edgar Allen Poe had written a short story believed to be based on her. RaeJean is interested enough to take the case, and soon some disquieting things begin to happen. She can't shake the feeling of being followed, and there is a man she spots too often in her vicinity.
I believe anyone interested in history and genealogy will enjoy this story. Learning about the historical resources, and all the different occupations available to people in the history and genealogy fields was fascinating. I particularly liked the combination of history, genealogy, and STEM used to solve the mystery of Mary. With a little help from a possibly haunted desk.
I received an e-ARC of this book from the publisher Harbor Lane Books LLC via NetGalley, and voluntarily read and reviewed it.
Then a body washes out of what was part of an old, nearby cemetery dating back to the 1800's. Rumors soon start that the woman could be Mary Rogers, who had died almost 200 years before. She was a member of a notorious family, and Edgar Allen Poe had written a short story believed to be based on her. RaeJean is interested enough to take the case, and soon some disquieting things begin to happen. She can't shake the feeling of being followed, and there is a man she spots too often in her vicinity.
I believe anyone interested in history and genealogy will enjoy this story. Learning about the historical resources, and all the different occupations available to people in the history and genealogy fields was fascinating. I particularly liked the combination of history, genealogy, and STEM used to solve the mystery of Mary. With a little help from a possibly haunted desk.
I received an e-ARC of this book from the publisher Harbor Lane Books LLC via NetGalley, and voluntarily read and reviewed it.
March 6, 2024
A well-written, intriguing story filled with dynamic characters. I believe the author approached the topic of abortion in a way that didn’t feel political and overly pushed. There were a couple of great secondary characters that kept the story rolling and allowed for some good laughs. I think the desk sounds amazing! The clearly researched topic of genealogy enabled the story to feel genuine and almost real (not sure if it was all fictitious or not??). 1 star removed due to the overwhelming family trees that while a genealogist may enjoy plotting it all out, it stumped the flow of the power of mystery the story could of had that most mystery readers desire.
Kudos for publishing your 1st novel!! I think more successes are to come from ML Condike!!!
Thank you for an ARC for an honest review.
Kudos for publishing your 1st novel!! I think more successes are to come from ML Condike!!!
Thank you for an ARC for an honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 27, 2024
Author ML Condike knocks it out of the park with The Desk from Hoboken! If anyone accuses this story of being formulaic, it could only be because Condike created a new formula that works. Rarely does a book make me this excited about reading; this one does.
The premise to the story seems simple, perhaps even boring: forensic genealogist RaeJean “Rae” Hunter accepts a case to help confirm the identity of some old bones near a university campus. A student thinks they belong to Mary Rogers, whose nineteenth century death remains a mystery. Even Edgar Allan Poe tried to unravel the mystery in his short story, “The Mystery of Marie Rogêt.”
At first reluctant to accept the case, Rae notices a ladies antique secretary desk in the corner, likely from the 1800s. She liked it so much that she accepted the case in exchange for the desk. Rae had no idea what she was signing up for!
Okay, let me talk about the elephant in the book: genealogy. Unless you are really into exploring your roots, most folks would probably consider genealogy boring. Those same folks would definitely consider a book about genealogy just as boring. But boy, would they be missing out!
I went into this book “like most folks” (see above). The only thing that caught my interest was that the Mary Rogers mystery inspired Poe. I suppose I wanted to know why. But Poe wrote his story only a few years after Mary disappeared in 1841. This story takes place over 175 years after that!
The beginning of this book did not impress nor excite me. However, little did I realize that author ML Condike was shrewdly drawing me in. Why did the first genealogist the university hired up and quit shortly after starting? Was Rae being followed or was it her imagination? Why do the stakes seem so high?
I’m not going to spoil it for you. To answer those questions, you have to read the book. But I’ll warn you - if you read this one, you’ll likely read the next one in this new series as well! I know I will.
Technically, the book is top notch. It is quite well edited. I found absolutely no errors (except for a teeny-tiny one in the Acknowledgments). The pacing is a wee bit slow in the beginning, but once the author puts the story in gear, hang on! I definitely had a hard time putting this one down.
The description is also well done. There are a number of antiques, so the description helped my visuals quite a bit. For example, rather than just saying a pile of diaries fell onto a chair, the author wrote, “A second pile of diaries spilled over the seat of a spiral-twist-legged, Elizabethan-style chaise upholstered in Loro Piana linen.”
One other thing I wanted to mention is that the genealogy data has a lot of moving parts, so to speak. There are many, many names and relations. I heard there was a family tree available on the author’s website to help with that, but I was afraid it might contain a spoiler or two, so I avoided it. But if you think it would be helpful, go for it.
The story did not persuade me to become a forensic genealogist, but it did demonstrate how entertaining and downright exciting a story about one can be! I’m hooked!
The premise to the story seems simple, perhaps even boring: forensic genealogist RaeJean “Rae” Hunter accepts a case to help confirm the identity of some old bones near a university campus. A student thinks they belong to Mary Rogers, whose nineteenth century death remains a mystery. Even Edgar Allan Poe tried to unravel the mystery in his short story, “The Mystery of Marie Rogêt.”
At first reluctant to accept the case, Rae notices a ladies antique secretary desk in the corner, likely from the 1800s. She liked it so much that she accepted the case in exchange for the desk. Rae had no idea what she was signing up for!
Okay, let me talk about the elephant in the book: genealogy. Unless you are really into exploring your roots, most folks would probably consider genealogy boring. Those same folks would definitely consider a book about genealogy just as boring. But boy, would they be missing out!
I went into this book “like most folks” (see above). The only thing that caught my interest was that the Mary Rogers mystery inspired Poe. I suppose I wanted to know why. But Poe wrote his story only a few years after Mary disappeared in 1841. This story takes place over 175 years after that!
The beginning of this book did not impress nor excite me. However, little did I realize that author ML Condike was shrewdly drawing me in. Why did the first genealogist the university hired up and quit shortly after starting? Was Rae being followed or was it her imagination? Why do the stakes seem so high?
I’m not going to spoil it for you. To answer those questions, you have to read the book. But I’ll warn you - if you read this one, you’ll likely read the next one in this new series as well! I know I will.
Technically, the book is top notch. It is quite well edited. I found absolutely no errors (except for a teeny-tiny one in the Acknowledgments). The pacing is a wee bit slow in the beginning, but once the author puts the story in gear, hang on! I definitely had a hard time putting this one down.
The description is also well done. There are a number of antiques, so the description helped my visuals quite a bit. For example, rather than just saying a pile of diaries fell onto a chair, the author wrote, “A second pile of diaries spilled over the seat of a spiral-twist-legged, Elizabethan-style chaise upholstered in Loro Piana linen.”
One other thing I wanted to mention is that the genealogy data has a lot of moving parts, so to speak. There are many, many names and relations. I heard there was a family tree available on the author’s website to help with that, but I was afraid it might contain a spoiler or two, so I avoided it. But if you think it would be helpful, go for it.
The story did not persuade me to become a forensic genealogist, but it did demonstrate how entertaining and downright exciting a story about one can be! I’m hooked!
March 26, 2024
The Desk from Hoboken is fiction, but it has a similar feel to the James Burke show Connections, the one where he connects dots through history from conch shells to the creation of the Internet. The mystery in this first entry into ML Condike's new series also connects dots – from exhumed remains to a Poe short story to backroom abortions in the early 20th century, and, yes, to an antique desk, using forensic genealogy as its main method.
RaeJean Hunter, said genealogist, and her husband Sam, an antiquities appraiser, are the sleuthing team at the heart of the story, and they're a delightful couple. RaeJean is just getting back to work after a miscarriage that triggered severe depression, and she takes the case of identifying said remains thinking it will be easy – strawberries, as she puts it.
What unfolds is a compelling tale of intrigue – family secrets, cover-ups, a mysterious client, and a race to piece together all the clues before an obsessed relative of the deceased has them seized or destroyed. To keep things topical there's also a subplot about human trafficking.
I am not exaggerating when I say I devoured this novel. I loved RaeJean's sensibility and no-nonsense attitude. I shared her love of simple food – a well-cooked burger and a cold beer. I really appreciated the little details author Condike included in the story – RaeJean's original desk is a hollow-core door – I know sooooo many writers and academics who used the same sorts of things for years. (My own desk is a vintage library table – not much fancier.) I also enjoyed following the process of investigation and the need to find three primary sources.
The supporting cast – especially RaeJean's sister Caitlin, her colleague Claire, and her friend Grace who works for the FBI – are all well drawn, and I'm hoping at least two of them show up in future books in this series. Worth mentioning is Sophie the corgi, who lit up the pages she was on.
The character of Lillian Baker, who looks a lot like Betty White, but has a conniving soul, made a brilliant foil and turned the "nice old lady" stereotype on its head.
Overall, I felt that the story was well-paced and the blend of the mystery with RaeJean's emotional state was in balance. Her personal story added to the total experience of the novel, and lent color to the mystery, without ever overpowering it.
If you love a good mystery with undercurrents of real history and strong female characters, The Desk from Hoboken is the book for you.
Goes well with Chinese spareribs and won ton soup.
RaeJean Hunter, said genealogist, and her husband Sam, an antiquities appraiser, are the sleuthing team at the heart of the story, and they're a delightful couple. RaeJean is just getting back to work after a miscarriage that triggered severe depression, and she takes the case of identifying said remains thinking it will be easy – strawberries, as she puts it.
What unfolds is a compelling tale of intrigue – family secrets, cover-ups, a mysterious client, and a race to piece together all the clues before an obsessed relative of the deceased has them seized or destroyed. To keep things topical there's also a subplot about human trafficking.
I am not exaggerating when I say I devoured this novel. I loved RaeJean's sensibility and no-nonsense attitude. I shared her love of simple food – a well-cooked burger and a cold beer. I really appreciated the little details author Condike included in the story – RaeJean's original desk is a hollow-core door – I know sooooo many writers and academics who used the same sorts of things for years. (My own desk is a vintage library table – not much fancier.) I also enjoyed following the process of investigation and the need to find three primary sources.
The supporting cast – especially RaeJean's sister Caitlin, her colleague Claire, and her friend Grace who works for the FBI – are all well drawn, and I'm hoping at least two of them show up in future books in this series. Worth mentioning is Sophie the corgi, who lit up the pages she was on.
The character of Lillian Baker, who looks a lot like Betty White, but has a conniving soul, made a brilliant foil and turned the "nice old lady" stereotype on its head.
Overall, I felt that the story was well-paced and the blend of the mystery with RaeJean's emotional state was in balance. Her personal story added to the total experience of the novel, and lent color to the mystery, without ever overpowering it.
If you love a good mystery with undercurrents of real history and strong female characters, The Desk from Hoboken is the book for you.
Goes well with Chinese spareribs and won ton soup.
June 14, 2024
I received an Advance Reader's Copy (ARC) as a Goodreads giveaway. I was intrigued by the description of mixing genealogy with a mystery with supernatural elements.
I'll start with what I did enjoy about this book: the genealogy information. I found it fascinating learning how genealogists conduct research and make connections. Unfortunately my enjoyment of reading about this was not enough for me to give this book a higher rating. If I did not have an ARC of this book, I would have DNF'd it, but my policy for ARC's is I always give an honest review, and I feel that I can't do that accurately if I don't read the whole book.
I felt myself rolling my eyes many, many times during this book and I can't be too specific as I don't want to write any spoilers about the plot. Let's just say the going back and forth about being in danger, to suddenly feeling safe and not taking any precautions to being back in danger, did not feel realistic. Some parts of the plot also felt like they were being mentioned so many times unnecessarily, and then barely mentioned for the rest of the book. I'm sure there are some that will love this book, but it was just wasn't for me.
I'll start with what I did enjoy about this book: the genealogy information. I found it fascinating learning how genealogists conduct research and make connections. Unfortunately my enjoyment of reading about this was not enough for me to give this book a higher rating. If I did not have an ARC of this book, I would have DNF'd it, but my policy for ARC's is I always give an honest review, and I feel that I can't do that accurately if I don't read the whole book.
I felt myself rolling my eyes many, many times during this book and I can't be too specific as I don't want to write any spoilers about the plot. Let's just say the going back and forth about being in danger, to suddenly feeling safe and not taking any precautions to being back in danger, did not feel realistic. Some parts of the plot also felt like they were being mentioned so many times unnecessarily, and then barely mentioned for the rest of the book. I'm sure there are some that will love this book, but it was just wasn't for me.
March 20, 2024
4.5 Stars
Being a Jersey girl at heart, the author had me at the title. Add in the main character taking multiple trips between New York City, Philadelphia, and bordering states, and I felt right at home. RaeJean may be a petite main character, but she makes up for it with her incredible brain. Taking tiny clues and linking them together, she takes the reading on a wiggling web of details as she works on what she believes will be easy to identify a 180-year-old body. But while the surface is calm, there is a whirlpool of action underneath.
The author skillfully weaves together clues, taking readers on a gripping ride. RaeJean encounters allies and adversaries, each adding layers of complexity to the case; not everyone is as they appear to be.
What sets this novel apart is the ingenious blend of historical data, modern techniques, and a touch of the supernatural. From DNA analysis to mystical guidance from an antique desk, RaeJean employs every tool at her disposal to uncover the truth.
As stakes escalate and lives hang in the balance, RaeJean faces increasingly dangerous obstacles. What lengths will someone go to keep the truth buried?
This book kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end. With clever plot twists and engaging characters, I'd say this is a must-read for mystery lovers everywhere.
Being a Jersey girl at heart, the author had me at the title. Add in the main character taking multiple trips between New York City, Philadelphia, and bordering states, and I felt right at home. RaeJean may be a petite main character, but she makes up for it with her incredible brain. Taking tiny clues and linking them together, she takes the reading on a wiggling web of details as she works on what she believes will be easy to identify a 180-year-old body. But while the surface is calm, there is a whirlpool of action underneath.
The author skillfully weaves together clues, taking readers on a gripping ride. RaeJean encounters allies and adversaries, each adding layers of complexity to the case; not everyone is as they appear to be.
What sets this novel apart is the ingenious blend of historical data, modern techniques, and a touch of the supernatural. From DNA analysis to mystical guidance from an antique desk, RaeJean employs every tool at her disposal to uncover the truth.
As stakes escalate and lives hang in the balance, RaeJean faces increasingly dangerous obstacles. What lengths will someone go to keep the truth buried?
This book kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end. With clever plot twists and engaging characters, I'd say this is a must-read for mystery lovers everywhere.
April 20, 2024
I was given this to book to review and enjoyed the pacy read. The book follows a forensic genealogist search to identify 180 year old skeleton. Gaining of an antique desk, as part payment, and the possibility of solving the mystery of the person's death adds to the alure of taking on the contract. RaeJean the center of the story, hits misdirection and blackmail similar
to the previous investigator who dropped the search, which hardens her resolve to complete the contract.
As the story is dealing with various families and their histories, there are a lot of names to put together, but this soon settles down and becomes easier to follow. I haven't read a story with this theme before and enjoyed it.
to the previous investigator who dropped the search, which hardens her resolve to complete the contract.
As the story is dealing with various families and their histories, there are a lot of names to put together, but this soon settles down and becomes easier to follow. I haven't read a story with this theme before and enjoyed it.
February 6, 2024
This book starts interesting but goes downhill fast. I found it rather tedious with all the information of genealogy, family diaries, and history that seemed to be repeated over and over. Thanks to author ML Condike, Harbor Lane Books, LLC, and NetGalley. I received a complimentary copy of this ebook. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
April 15, 2024
This novel has a reasonable narrative arc but the main character's irrational choices and decision making result in silliness.
June 8, 2024
Not for me. At all.
The byzantine plot moved at a glacial pace. I really struggled to finish this one. I won’t be pursuing this genre.
The byzantine plot moved at a glacial pace. I really struggled to finish this one. I won’t be pursuing this genre.
February 5, 2025
too long and confusing to follow
Unfortunately this book was Too long and confusing to follow plus not believable. This book was a disappointment. Do not recommend
Unfortunately this book was Too long and confusing to follow plus not believable. This book was a disappointment. Do not recommend
March 25, 2024
The Desk From Hoboken by ML Condike
Published: 5 March 2024
Publisher: Harbor Lane Books
Genre: Mystery, Genealogy Mystery
Pages: 426
Series: hopefully!
The Short Story: A deep dive into a genealogy mystery
Forensic genealogist, RaeJean Hunter, recovering from a personal tragedy takes what seems like a straightforward genealogy research case, trying to prove that a young woman, Mary Rogers, who died over 180 years ago, was buried in a particular plot in a cemetery, and that the bones found are hers. I like that the case tied in with the real-life mysterious death of a young woman named Maire Roget and her connection to Edgar Allen Poe.
As a genealogy researcher myself, I was really drawn to this story, and the author takes her readers through a thorough analysis of the Rogers family history. At times, I was overwhelmed by the sheer number of names and family relationships but the mystery kept me reading.
As the story unfolds, we learn that someone does not want RaeJean to continue her research but with the support of her husband, sister and a handy friend in the FBI, she is resolute in her pursuit of the facts. Some readers may find it hard to believe that someone would go to the lengths RaeJean’s mystery foe took, but I can tell you that people take their family history very seriously to the point of kookiness. I know this from experience!
The desk from the title is a character in itself. A marvellous piece of furniture with a whiff of the paranormal and a lot of secrets. It was really well plotted, and I enjoyed the slow reveal.
All in all, a very enjoyable story. Well written and well plotted. I highly recommend this book to readers who enjoy a great mystery.
The Desk From Hoboken by ML Condike
Published: 5 March 2024
Publisher: Harbor Lane Books
Genre: Mystery, Genealogy Mystery
Pages: 426
Series: Unclear
The Short Story: A deep dive into a genealogy mystery
Forensic genealogist, RaeJean Hunter, recovering from a personal tragedy takes what seems like a straightforward genealogy research case, trying to prove that a young woman, Mary Rogers, who died over 180 years ago, was buried in a particular plot in a cemetery, and that the bones found are hers. I like that the case tied in with the real-life mysterious death of a young woman named Maire Roget and her connection to Edgar Allen Poe.
As a genealogy researcher myself, I was really drawn to this story, and the author takes her readers through a thorough analysis of the Rogers family history. At times, I was overwhelmed by the sheer number of names and family relationships but the mystery kept me reading.
As the story unfolds, we learn that someone does not want RaeJean to continue her research but with the support of her husband, sister and a handy friend in the FBI, she is resolute in her pursuit of the facts. Some readers may find it hard to believe that someone would go to the lengths RaeJean’s mystery foe took, but I can tell you that people take their family history very seriously to the point of kookiness. I know this from experience!
The desk from the title is a character in itself. A marvellous piece of furniture with a whiff of the paranormal and a lot of secrets. It was really well plotted, and I enjoyed the slow reveal.
All in all, a very enjoyable story. Well written and well plotted. I highly recommend this book to readers who enjoy a great mystery.
Published: 5 March 2024
Publisher: Harbor Lane Books
Genre: Mystery, Genealogy Mystery
Pages: 426
Series: hopefully!
The Short Story: A deep dive into a genealogy mystery
Forensic genealogist, RaeJean Hunter, recovering from a personal tragedy takes what seems like a straightforward genealogy research case, trying to prove that a young woman, Mary Rogers, who died over 180 years ago, was buried in a particular plot in a cemetery, and that the bones found are hers. I like that the case tied in with the real-life mysterious death of a young woman named Maire Roget and her connection to Edgar Allen Poe.
As a genealogy researcher myself, I was really drawn to this story, and the author takes her readers through a thorough analysis of the Rogers family history. At times, I was overwhelmed by the sheer number of names and family relationships but the mystery kept me reading.
As the story unfolds, we learn that someone does not want RaeJean to continue her research but with the support of her husband, sister and a handy friend in the FBI, she is resolute in her pursuit of the facts. Some readers may find it hard to believe that someone would go to the lengths RaeJean’s mystery foe took, but I can tell you that people take their family history very seriously to the point of kookiness. I know this from experience!
The desk from the title is a character in itself. A marvellous piece of furniture with a whiff of the paranormal and a lot of secrets. It was really well plotted, and I enjoyed the slow reveal.
All in all, a very enjoyable story. Well written and well plotted. I highly recommend this book to readers who enjoy a great mystery.
The Desk From Hoboken by ML Condike
Published: 5 March 2024
Publisher: Harbor Lane Books
Genre: Mystery, Genealogy Mystery
Pages: 426
Series: Unclear
The Short Story: A deep dive into a genealogy mystery
Forensic genealogist, RaeJean Hunter, recovering from a personal tragedy takes what seems like a straightforward genealogy research case, trying to prove that a young woman, Mary Rogers, who died over 180 years ago, was buried in a particular plot in a cemetery, and that the bones found are hers. I like that the case tied in with the real-life mysterious death of a young woman named Maire Roget and her connection to Edgar Allen Poe.
As a genealogy researcher myself, I was really drawn to this story, and the author takes her readers through a thorough analysis of the Rogers family history. At times, I was overwhelmed by the sheer number of names and family relationships but the mystery kept me reading.
As the story unfolds, we learn that someone does not want RaeJean to continue her research but with the support of her husband, sister and a handy friend in the FBI, she is resolute in her pursuit of the facts. Some readers may find it hard to believe that someone would go to the lengths RaeJean’s mystery foe took, but I can tell you that people take their family history very seriously to the point of kookiness. I know this from experience!
The desk from the title is a character in itself. A marvellous piece of furniture with a whiff of the paranormal and a lot of secrets. It was really well plotted, and I enjoyed the slow reveal.
All in all, a very enjoyable story. Well written and well plotted. I highly recommend this book to readers who enjoy a great mystery.
March 23, 2024
RaeJean is a fun, spunky character who also happens to be smart and good at her job which entails searching old documents and interviewing people in an effort to trace lost ancestors. She’s worked with the FBI on cases and has garnered a lot of respect for how she does her job.
In solving the mystery of whether the 180 year old cadaver is Mary Rogers, RaeJeans husband, Sam, supports her efforts, and accompanies her on many trips from Philadelphia to New York. The fact that he deals in antiquities is a nice compliment to her work, and they make a good team for further stories. I look forward to meeting them again.
I’d also enjoy seeing Claire again. She’s RaeJean’s friend and fellow genealogist, who first had the case of the identification of the old body, but was threatened off. The abduction of her daughter, Emma, is one of the elements of suspense in the story that keeps tension high. Claire and Emma, and RaeJean’s sister Caitlin, are all strong characters.
A strong element of this story is the odd behavior of Lillian, a descendent of the Mather family that has hidden family diaries in bank vaults, or with attorneys, and put severe restrictions in place, determining who can have access to them. The reader is kept guessing as to what the woman’s motives are and does she really want to help solve the mystery of Mary Rogers.
For access to some of the documents RaeJean races against the clock as the diaries are scheduled to be destroyed. Another great element of tension that holds reader attention, and how RaeJean handles herself with the deceptive Lillian is a testament to her perseverance and determination to do the job no matter what.
While I enjoyed much in this book, some of the repetition of information about the members of the Mather family got tedious, and there was more telling than showing for my total satisfaction with the read.
That said, there are many things I liked, including the interactions between RaeJean and Sam, and the mutual respect they have for their respective professions, and the very satisfying conclusion to the story. I was surprised at the big reveal of the secret Lillian was hiding, but it makes perfect sense, and is a nice tie in to what might have happened to Mary Rogers those many years ago.
Anyone interested in history and genealogy will thoroughly enjoy this story. What I learned about how a person like RaeJean goes about doing that kind of search for answers was really fascinating, and this was a fun look at the mystery of what happened to Mary Rogers that still perplexes people today.
The addition of the endearing Corgi, Sophie, to the story is a nice touch. The little dog reminding RaeJean to get up from her desk is a lot like my dog barking to let me know it’s time to stand and take a walk. That is a relatable element for anyone who has a faithful dog in their lives. I also loved the old desk and how that helped in the investigation. Is it haunted? The reader is left to believe what she wants.
In solving the mystery of whether the 180 year old cadaver is Mary Rogers, RaeJeans husband, Sam, supports her efforts, and accompanies her on many trips from Philadelphia to New York. The fact that he deals in antiquities is a nice compliment to her work, and they make a good team for further stories. I look forward to meeting them again.
I’d also enjoy seeing Claire again. She’s RaeJean’s friend and fellow genealogist, who first had the case of the identification of the old body, but was threatened off. The abduction of her daughter, Emma, is one of the elements of suspense in the story that keeps tension high. Claire and Emma, and RaeJean’s sister Caitlin, are all strong characters.
A strong element of this story is the odd behavior of Lillian, a descendent of the Mather family that has hidden family diaries in bank vaults, or with attorneys, and put severe restrictions in place, determining who can have access to them. The reader is kept guessing as to what the woman’s motives are and does she really want to help solve the mystery of Mary Rogers.
For access to some of the documents RaeJean races against the clock as the diaries are scheduled to be destroyed. Another great element of tension that holds reader attention, and how RaeJean handles herself with the deceptive Lillian is a testament to her perseverance and determination to do the job no matter what.
While I enjoyed much in this book, some of the repetition of information about the members of the Mather family got tedious, and there was more telling than showing for my total satisfaction with the read.
That said, there are many things I liked, including the interactions between RaeJean and Sam, and the mutual respect they have for their respective professions, and the very satisfying conclusion to the story. I was surprised at the big reveal of the secret Lillian was hiding, but it makes perfect sense, and is a nice tie in to what might have happened to Mary Rogers those many years ago.
Anyone interested in history and genealogy will thoroughly enjoy this story. What I learned about how a person like RaeJean goes about doing that kind of search for answers was really fascinating, and this was a fun look at the mystery of what happened to Mary Rogers that still perplexes people today.
The addition of the endearing Corgi, Sophie, to the story is a nice touch. The little dog reminding RaeJean to get up from her desk is a lot like my dog barking to let me know it’s time to stand and take a walk. That is a relatable element for anyone who has a faithful dog in their lives. I also loved the old desk and how that helped in the investigation. Is it haunted? The reader is left to believe what she wants.
March 27, 2024
RaeJean Hunter is a forensic genealogist who’s been taking a break from her work due to a personal loss. When she’s contacted to verify the identity of 180-year-old remains found on a college campus, she thinks this will be a nice, low-key way to ease back into her work routine. Turns out, it’s anything but.
Trying to determine if the remains are those of Mary Rogers, supposedly a descendant of both the Mather and Rogers families, leads RaeJean all over New England. She digs through records in libraries (it’s said she never could pass up a library – I can relate!), museums, and Mather relatives’ personal collections. Lillian is the pushiest relative she meets, by turns aloof and overly involved in RaeJean’s investigation (and always seemingly a step ahead), and RaeJean can’t quite figure out her motivation. Her quest leads her into unexpected danger, and her friend Claire, who was previously working on the same case, begs her to drop the matter. RaeJean suspects this is about more than just the identity of the remains and whether Mary Rogers died from a botched abortion. No, someone is trying to protect a much bigger secret than that.
ML Condike gives us a beautifully flawed protagonist in RaeJean. She’s working through her own issues, trying to get back to her normal routine. I think we can all relate to that. She and Sam are a good team, and their occupations sometimes intersect, allowing them to work together. But their relationship isn’t picture perfect, and they have to sort through some things in the middle of work and life, just like we all do. Sometimes RaeJean is too focused on her pursuit of answers for her own good, and as the reader looking in, I wanted to holler at her not to do what she was about to do, because it wasn’t going to go well! That made for some tense moments as I read and kept the pages turning.
I loved the inclusion of the titular “desk from Hoboken” in the story. RaeJean saw it in her client’s office and requested it as part of her compensation for her work. It may or may not be haunted (you read and decide for yourself), and it includes a puzzle box that plays a vital role in solving the mystery.
All told, The Desk from Hoboken is an intelligent, well-written, compelling mystery that fans of mystery and history alike will enjoy. And since Mary Rogers is the person on whose story Edgar Allan Poe based his short story The Murder of Marie Rogêt, literary lovers might like it, too. I can’t wait to read more in the series! Five stars from me.
Trying to determine if the remains are those of Mary Rogers, supposedly a descendant of both the Mather and Rogers families, leads RaeJean all over New England. She digs through records in libraries (it’s said she never could pass up a library – I can relate!), museums, and Mather relatives’ personal collections. Lillian is the pushiest relative she meets, by turns aloof and overly involved in RaeJean’s investigation (and always seemingly a step ahead), and RaeJean can’t quite figure out her motivation. Her quest leads her into unexpected danger, and her friend Claire, who was previously working on the same case, begs her to drop the matter. RaeJean suspects this is about more than just the identity of the remains and whether Mary Rogers died from a botched abortion. No, someone is trying to protect a much bigger secret than that.
ML Condike gives us a beautifully flawed protagonist in RaeJean. She’s working through her own issues, trying to get back to her normal routine. I think we can all relate to that. She and Sam are a good team, and their occupations sometimes intersect, allowing them to work together. But their relationship isn’t picture perfect, and they have to sort through some things in the middle of work and life, just like we all do. Sometimes RaeJean is too focused on her pursuit of answers for her own good, and as the reader looking in, I wanted to holler at her not to do what she was about to do, because it wasn’t going to go well! That made for some tense moments as I read and kept the pages turning.
I loved the inclusion of the titular “desk from Hoboken” in the story. RaeJean saw it in her client’s office and requested it as part of her compensation for her work. It may or may not be haunted (you read and decide for yourself), and it includes a puzzle box that plays a vital role in solving the mystery.
All told, The Desk from Hoboken is an intelligent, well-written, compelling mystery that fans of mystery and history alike will enjoy. And since Mary Rogers is the person on whose story Edgar Allan Poe based his short story The Murder of Marie Rogêt, literary lovers might like it, too. I can’t wait to read more in the series! Five stars from me.
May 16, 2024
Book Review: The Desk from Hoboken by M.L. Condike
Rating: 3.5 Stars
As I delved into "The Desk from Hoboken" by M.L. Condike, I found myself immersed in the world of forensic genealogist RaeJean Hunter on a quest to uncover the truth behind the mysterious death of Mary Rogers. Initially drawn to the book to heal from personal grief, RaeJean's straightforward case of identifying human remains takes a perilous turn, leading her on a dangerous journey filled with unexpected twists and turns.
From the start, the narrative captured my attention with its blend of historical facts, modern genealogical techniques, and a hint of mysticism surrounding an antique desk that guides RaeJean in her investigation. The story unfolds across four states, revealing long-buried secrets and escalating threats that put both RaeJean and her family in jeopardy.
While the premise of the Mary Rogers mystery and the forensic genealogy elements were undoubtedly intriguing, I found myself struggling with the pacing of the book as it approached the three-quarter mark. The plot became repetitive and convoluted, detracting from the overall enjoyment of the story. However, despite these drawbacks, the novel still managed to maintain its grip on me, compelling me to see it through to its conclusion.
"The Desk from Hoboken" has the potential to be a standout read with its captivating premise and well-crafted characters. With some refinements to streamline the plot and eliminate unnecessary repetitions, this book could easily elevate its rating. Fans of mystery and genealogy will find this novel a worthwhile read, eagerly anticipating the next installment in the series.
For those intrigued by historical mysteries, suspenseful storytelling, and the intricacies of forensic investigation, "The Desk from Hoboken" offers a compelling narrative that is both engaging and thought-provoking. Despite its flaws, this book sets the stage for a promising series that will likely resonate with fans of the genre.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
Rating: 3.5 Stars
As I delved into "The Desk from Hoboken" by M.L. Condike, I found myself immersed in the world of forensic genealogist RaeJean Hunter on a quest to uncover the truth behind the mysterious death of Mary Rogers. Initially drawn to the book to heal from personal grief, RaeJean's straightforward case of identifying human remains takes a perilous turn, leading her on a dangerous journey filled with unexpected twists and turns.
From the start, the narrative captured my attention with its blend of historical facts, modern genealogical techniques, and a hint of mysticism surrounding an antique desk that guides RaeJean in her investigation. The story unfolds across four states, revealing long-buried secrets and escalating threats that put both RaeJean and her family in jeopardy.
While the premise of the Mary Rogers mystery and the forensic genealogy elements were undoubtedly intriguing, I found myself struggling with the pacing of the book as it approached the three-quarter mark. The plot became repetitive and convoluted, detracting from the overall enjoyment of the story. However, despite these drawbacks, the novel still managed to maintain its grip on me, compelling me to see it through to its conclusion.
"The Desk from Hoboken" has the potential to be a standout read with its captivating premise and well-crafted characters. With some refinements to streamline the plot and eliminate unnecessary repetitions, this book could easily elevate its rating. Fans of mystery and genealogy will find this novel a worthwhile read, eagerly anticipating the next installment in the series.
For those intrigued by historical mysteries, suspenseful storytelling, and the intricacies of forensic investigation, "The Desk from Hoboken" offers a compelling narrative that is both engaging and thought-provoking. Despite its flaws, this book sets the stage for a promising series that will likely resonate with fans of the genre.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
March 20, 2024
The Desk from Hoboken is a quiet mystery with an air of sadness as its protagonist, forensic genealogist RaeJean Hunter is recovering from personal loss. It was a fascinating look into how a forensic genealogist works. There is also a bit of “spooky” thrown in as the lovely desk she takes as part of her payment for the job speaks to her emotionally and feels like it has a purpose to serve. (And how do you not love a story with an adorable corgi?)
What should be a straightforward job, albeit one shrouded in secrecy as the benefactor of the search is nameless (as is the previous forensic genealogist who started, and then abruptly quit the job) turns out to be much more complicated than expected. There’s an interesting cast of characters who add to the drama, including a very unreliable relative who is also allegedly doing research. One minute she seems to be willing to help RaeJean, the next she is either scooping her research or standing in her way.
Coincidences abound (or are they?) as this fascinating story further unfolds and danger ramps up.
This is a quiet, almost cerebral mystery that takes a few jarring turns as RaeJean finds herself in several dangerous situations. Someone does not want her to finish the research, and the why is not apparent until the climax.
I enjoyed the mystery, the history, the look into the life of a forensic genealogist, and the touch of the supernatural RaeJean experiences with the desk. My only (very mild) issue with the story IS its villain, - believable as the bad guy, but their actions feel a bit out of character (or just totally unhinged).
Still, this was a lovely book for a rainy afternoon with a cup of tea, and totally engaging. This is a story about secrets – those we keep from each other, those that are buried to protect, and those that are meant to hide. It’s also a story about healing, and about setting right the past.
I’m giving The Desk From Hoboken four stars.
What should be a straightforward job, albeit one shrouded in secrecy as the benefactor of the search is nameless (as is the previous forensic genealogist who started, and then abruptly quit the job) turns out to be much more complicated than expected. There’s an interesting cast of characters who add to the drama, including a very unreliable relative who is also allegedly doing research. One minute she seems to be willing to help RaeJean, the next she is either scooping her research or standing in her way.
Coincidences abound (or are they?) as this fascinating story further unfolds and danger ramps up.
This is a quiet, almost cerebral mystery that takes a few jarring turns as RaeJean finds herself in several dangerous situations. Someone does not want her to finish the research, and the why is not apparent until the climax.
I enjoyed the mystery, the history, the look into the life of a forensic genealogist, and the touch of the supernatural RaeJean experiences with the desk. My only (very mild) issue with the story IS its villain, - believable as the bad guy, but their actions feel a bit out of character (or just totally unhinged).
Still, this was a lovely book for a rainy afternoon with a cup of tea, and totally engaging. This is a story about secrets – those we keep from each other, those that are buried to protect, and those that are meant to hide. It’s also a story about healing, and about setting right the past.
I’m giving The Desk From Hoboken four stars.
March 21, 2024
Author ML Condike creates a complex genealogy mystery that keeps readers intrigued from the start. The remains of a 180-year-old body, a forensic genealogist, an antique desk, and a host of supporting characters hiding secrets make this a page-turner.
Each character has realistic depth and personality. RaeJean Hunter is overcoming a personal loss but decides to re-engage in life by returning to forensic genealogy work. Her husband Sam is believable and delightfully supportive of Rae and her choices. A professor invites RaeJean to take an easy case to prove the body’s identity. Agreeing to take the case, Rae embarks on an adventure in and around various East Coast cities. She visits libraries, reads diaries, hunts news stories, and interviews family members and descendants of Mary Rogers, hearing the stories passed down. The research angles and scientific process followed, adding delightful edginess to this adventure.
Rae’s travels are revealed with picturesque descriptions that bring life into the scenes, especially in the smaller towns and libraries. One can smell the food, touch the paper of worn pages with faded ink, hear the surrounding noises, and walk the path as the story unfolds. The dialogue aptly delivers the attitudes in the exchanges, revealing underlying character traits. Some surprising relationships RaeJean discovered, as with old man Zeke, developed in unforeseen yet endearing ways while increasing the tension.
The unique storyline meshes a suspenseful mystery with drama, action, unexpected interactions, and multiple leads brought together into the perfect dénouement. Fans of cozy mysteries will enjoy the masterfully executed and highly recommended The Desk from Hoboken. ML Condike delivers an outstanding tale everyone can enjoy
Each character has realistic depth and personality. RaeJean Hunter is overcoming a personal loss but decides to re-engage in life by returning to forensic genealogy work. Her husband Sam is believable and delightfully supportive of Rae and her choices. A professor invites RaeJean to take an easy case to prove the body’s identity. Agreeing to take the case, Rae embarks on an adventure in and around various East Coast cities. She visits libraries, reads diaries, hunts news stories, and interviews family members and descendants of Mary Rogers, hearing the stories passed down. The research angles and scientific process followed, adding delightful edginess to this adventure.
Rae’s travels are revealed with picturesque descriptions that bring life into the scenes, especially in the smaller towns and libraries. One can smell the food, touch the paper of worn pages with faded ink, hear the surrounding noises, and walk the path as the story unfolds. The dialogue aptly delivers the attitudes in the exchanges, revealing underlying character traits. Some surprising relationships RaeJean discovered, as with old man Zeke, developed in unforeseen yet endearing ways while increasing the tension.
The unique storyline meshes a suspenseful mystery with drama, action, unexpected interactions, and multiple leads brought together into the perfect dénouement. Fans of cozy mysteries will enjoy the masterfully executed and highly recommended The Desk from Hoboken. ML Condike delivers an outstanding tale everyone can enjoy
April 1, 2024
One thing I really liked about this book was its perspective. It is told in first-person from RaeJean's POV. I enjoyed her adventure a lot. It had danger, thrills, and plenty of puzzles to piece together. Rae is also unique in that she is a forensic genealogist. When I've read other mysteries I've gotten used to reading from the perspective of official detectives or amateur detectives (bakers, scholars, etc.) and less so from forensic scientist angles. However, forensic genealogy is rather different from the usual forensics, making this a distinct read based on that alone. I love the historical elements added and the trails that can be followed that aren't typical in mysteries.
This book deals with some big topics, some of which may be of concern to some readers. There are discussions of abortion and pregnancy struggles, as well as a fight to find faith after traumatic events from the past. These aspects play a big role in discovering the secrets surrounding Mary Rogers and her fate. While the name may be recognizable to many, I actually wasn't all that familiar with her story before this book. I found this to be a very interesting novel that led me on quite a few research paths to learn more about the facts surrounding the people and events - as far as what is actually known. These are just things to be aware of as some readers may not find them to be their cup of tea.
I really liked the pacing, the relationship dynamic Rae has with Sam, and really, who doesn't love corgis? All in all, I found this to be a highly enjoyable and fresh mystery. I've read several so it's nice to find stories that are different, using different clues, character backgrounds, and alternate occupations from the norm.
This book deals with some big topics, some of which may be of concern to some readers. There are discussions of abortion and pregnancy struggles, as well as a fight to find faith after traumatic events from the past. These aspects play a big role in discovering the secrets surrounding Mary Rogers and her fate. While the name may be recognizable to many, I actually wasn't all that familiar with her story before this book. I found this to be a very interesting novel that led me on quite a few research paths to learn more about the facts surrounding the people and events - as far as what is actually known. These are just things to be aware of as some readers may not find them to be their cup of tea.
I really liked the pacing, the relationship dynamic Rae has with Sam, and really, who doesn't love corgis? All in all, I found this to be a highly enjoyable and fresh mystery. I've read several so it's nice to find stories that are different, using different clues, character backgrounds, and alternate occupations from the norm.
June 24, 2024
I picked up this book as a part of my book club. And I am very happy with the book overall.
To start off, this book is a total mystery book, and there are (kinda) two mystery elements that RaeJean and us are looking for. We are tasked into looking to seeing if the human remains are Mary Rogers and as a bonus, figure out what happened to her. While also looking into the background of the desk that RaeJean gets as compensation for the job.
There were moments that I was doubting her husband, because the author did plant some seeds in our heads. One key moments is when Raejean makes the note that her husband never really was able to grieve over their unborn child. While she was mourning heavily over the loss of their child. I was expecting some kind of involvement of Sam into the history. Especially when Lillian mentioned Sam, and I was like oh shit, here it comes. But nothing came from it. I wasn't really happy over that. Seeds were planted and the plant is dead on arrival.
Regarding the main mystery of Mary Rogers, it was a good mystery overall. But it gets overwhelming with the amount of names to keep track of. Also the amount of travel is also overwhelming. Shes in one place and the next chapter, shes in another. I felt like I needed to buy a whiteboard to keep track of the connections. I feel like a revisit on some connections occasionally would have been great.
Then the connection to the desk. It might seem like it was a reach and kinda a plot bandage, but I really did enjoy the solving of the desk's history and the puzzle. There were times were I was more interested into the desk than the actual mystery itself.
Overall, not bad of a read. I enjoyed the mystery aspect of this whole book, it was nicely done.
To start off, this book is a total mystery book, and there are (kinda) two mystery elements that RaeJean and us are looking for. We are tasked into looking to seeing if the human remains are Mary Rogers and as a bonus, figure out what happened to her. While also looking into the background of the desk that RaeJean gets as compensation for the job.
There were moments that I was doubting her husband, because the author did plant some seeds in our heads. One key moments is when Raejean makes the note that her husband never really was able to grieve over their unborn child. While she was mourning heavily over the loss of their child. I was expecting some kind of involvement of Sam into the history. Especially when Lillian mentioned Sam, and I was like oh shit, here it comes. But nothing came from it. I wasn't really happy over that. Seeds were planted and the plant is dead on arrival.
Regarding the main mystery of Mary Rogers, it was a good mystery overall. But it gets overwhelming with the amount of names to keep track of. Also the amount of travel is also overwhelming. Shes in one place and the next chapter, shes in another. I felt like I needed to buy a whiteboard to keep track of the connections. I feel like a revisit on some connections occasionally would have been great.
Then the connection to the desk. It might seem like it was a reach and kinda a plot bandage, but I really did enjoy the solving of the desk's history and the puzzle. There were times were I was more interested into the desk than the actual mystery itself.
Overall, not bad of a read. I enjoyed the mystery aspect of this whole book, it was nicely done.
October 26, 2023
5 stars
RaeJean Hunter is recovering from a major loss and starting to think about returning to work as a forensic genealogist. She receives a phone call from a professor at the local college. He has the skeletal remains of a woman he suspects is Mary Rogers. Mary was supposed to have died sometime during the 1840’s Rae is intrigued and decides to take the case. It looks to be an easy one. Right?
Rae meets a wide variety of people during her searches. Some of them are simply delightful. Others are not so nice. She finds herself in trouble. The search for Mary is definitely an adventure. The descriptions of the scenery around New York and Connecticut are vivid. I’ve never been to either place, so I was drinking in the scenery as it went by.
While traveling around the East Coast, searching for information about Mary and her family, she comes across an antique ladies’ secretary. She is fascinated by it and must have it. Once she gets it home, she finds that it has some rather unique properties.
This is a delightful and fascinating book. The characters are well fleshed out and believable. I especially liked the relationship between the main protagonist, RaeJean Hunter and her husband Sam. The book is packed with action, twists and surprises. There are evil, selfish people trying to thwart Rae’s investigation.
I want to thank NetGalley and Harbor Lane Books for forwarding to me a copy of this remarkable book for me to read, enjoy and review. The opinions expressed in this review are solely my own.
RaeJean Hunter is recovering from a major loss and starting to think about returning to work as a forensic genealogist. She receives a phone call from a professor at the local college. He has the skeletal remains of a woman he suspects is Mary Rogers. Mary was supposed to have died sometime during the 1840’s Rae is intrigued and decides to take the case. It looks to be an easy one. Right?
Rae meets a wide variety of people during her searches. Some of them are simply delightful. Others are not so nice. She finds herself in trouble. The search for Mary is definitely an adventure. The descriptions of the scenery around New York and Connecticut are vivid. I’ve never been to either place, so I was drinking in the scenery as it went by.
While traveling around the East Coast, searching for information about Mary and her family, she comes across an antique ladies’ secretary. She is fascinated by it and must have it. Once she gets it home, she finds that it has some rather unique properties.
This is a delightful and fascinating book. The characters are well fleshed out and believable. I especially liked the relationship between the main protagonist, RaeJean Hunter and her husband Sam. The book is packed with action, twists and surprises. There are evil, selfish people trying to thwart Rae’s investigation.
I want to thank NetGalley and Harbor Lane Books for forwarding to me a copy of this remarkable book for me to read, enjoy and review. The opinions expressed in this review are solely my own.
November 5, 2023
In theory, I feel like this book should have been boring. After all, what exciting things can happen when researching archives, websites, libraries, and family heirlooms for connections to a 180-year-old body? In practice, it was one of the most interesting books I have read in the recent months, and not only due to the unique viewpoint of a genealogist.
The plot was marvellous, it had mystery, drama, suspense, fascinating leads and exciting twists and turns that you wouldn’t expect at first glance. ReaJean's life was masterfully integrated with the main plotline of the book, and all the characters felt fleshed out and real even if they appeared only a few times. Thankfully, Condike didn’t fall into the frequent bad family relationship trope, and I was glad to see the main character loved and supported throughout the book.
Of course, I must note the hours and hours of research that evidently went into this book. It was evident the author knew what they were talking about regarding the very real case of Mary Rogers and the terminology associated with genealogical field. Unfortunately, at times it was a bit hard to follow from the readers perspective, I feel the book would have greatly benefitted from a family tree in the appendix, or perhaps even throughout the book as RaeJean’s investigation progressed and it filled out.
Overall, I feel this book deserves a 5* rating.
Big thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for letting me read an early access version of The Desk from Hoboken.
The plot was marvellous, it had mystery, drama, suspense, fascinating leads and exciting twists and turns that you wouldn’t expect at first glance. ReaJean's life was masterfully integrated with the main plotline of the book, and all the characters felt fleshed out and real even if they appeared only a few times. Thankfully, Condike didn’t fall into the frequent bad family relationship trope, and I was glad to see the main character loved and supported throughout the book.
Of course, I must note the hours and hours of research that evidently went into this book. It was evident the author knew what they were talking about regarding the very real case of Mary Rogers and the terminology associated with genealogical field. Unfortunately, at times it was a bit hard to follow from the readers perspective, I feel the book would have greatly benefitted from a family tree in the appendix, or perhaps even throughout the book as RaeJean’s investigation progressed and it filled out.
Overall, I feel this book deserves a 5* rating.
Big thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for letting me read an early access version of The Desk from Hoboken.
April 8, 2025
What did I like about this reading?
I liked how RaeJean came to acquire the Hoboken Desk; as part of the fee for finding out the truth and if indeed the skeleton is in fact, Mary Rogers. There’s a ghost or some supernatural entity within the desk but that is not elaborated upon much; perhaps in another story.
I also like RaeJean’s husband Sam who is by her side for all things; he knows when to give her room to mourn and when to travel with her while she researches this most bizarre case. Sam is the most supportive partner a woman could ever want in a man.
I think that the title: The Desk from Hoboken should be changed to: Much Ado About Nothing; even though this title has been used by none other than Shakespeare and he was to have penned a story about Mary Roget; trying to figure out what happened or could have happened to her; this beauty known as the ‘cigar girl’ in some circle.
I say, ‘Much Ado’ because at times the reading seemed like it was going nowhere; all of the traveling to the many historical societies to read the diaries while looking at their margins to see if notes were written on them for clues when in fact the clue was there from day one.
In all; this book reads like art imitating life, when in fact life is lived to make art seem life-like through many generations. Or I have not understood this reading since readers are reminded: although “The Desk from Hoboken” is based on extensive research and numerous field trips to actual locations, it is a work of fiction.
I liked how RaeJean came to acquire the Hoboken Desk; as part of the fee for finding out the truth and if indeed the skeleton is in fact, Mary Rogers. There’s a ghost or some supernatural entity within the desk but that is not elaborated upon much; perhaps in another story.
I also like RaeJean’s husband Sam who is by her side for all things; he knows when to give her room to mourn and when to travel with her while she researches this most bizarre case. Sam is the most supportive partner a woman could ever want in a man.
I think that the title: The Desk from Hoboken should be changed to: Much Ado About Nothing; even though this title has been used by none other than Shakespeare and he was to have penned a story about Mary Roget; trying to figure out what happened or could have happened to her; this beauty known as the ‘cigar girl’ in some circle.
I say, ‘Much Ado’ because at times the reading seemed like it was going nowhere; all of the traveling to the many historical societies to read the diaries while looking at their margins to see if notes were written on them for clues when in fact the clue was there from day one.
In all; this book reads like art imitating life, when in fact life is lived to make art seem life-like through many generations. Or I have not understood this reading since readers are reminded: although “The Desk from Hoboken” is based on extensive research and numerous field trips to actual locations, it is a work of fiction.
November 6, 2023
The Desk From Hoboken from ML Condike combines historical fiction, forensic genealogy, and a cozy mystery into a wonderful story about Mary Rogers. Mary's body was found floating in the Hudson River in 1841. Her death was never explained, yet it influenced Edger Allen Poe to fictionalize her death.
ML Condike also fictionalized her death in The Desk From Hoboken but with a modern twist. Condike uses today's technology to weave a story that would explain Mary's death and her history. The originality of the story sets it apart from other mysteries. Condike combines the action of the investigation with historical information to speculate a tale of intrigue and adventure. It was reminiscent of the movie National Treasure but with a focus on identifying a body, instead of finding a treasure.
Being a novice at genealogy, I was interested in reading this immediately. The intermingling of history and mystery kept me invested in finishing the book and I had great trouble putting it down. I would be thrilled if Condike evolved this into a series, with ReaJean continuing to solve genealogical mysteries. I think Condike could lose the religious references, the paranormal leanings, and tighten up the story as there was some dialogue that seemed repetitive. However, the story thrilled me and I enjoyed every minute of reading it.
Thanks to Netgalley and Harbor Lane Books for the advanced copy of the book. The opinions are my own.
ML Condike also fictionalized her death in The Desk From Hoboken but with a modern twist. Condike uses today's technology to weave a story that would explain Mary's death and her history. The originality of the story sets it apart from other mysteries. Condike combines the action of the investigation with historical information to speculate a tale of intrigue and adventure. It was reminiscent of the movie National Treasure but with a focus on identifying a body, instead of finding a treasure.
Being a novice at genealogy, I was interested in reading this immediately. The intermingling of history and mystery kept me invested in finishing the book and I had great trouble putting it down. I would be thrilled if Condike evolved this into a series, with ReaJean continuing to solve genealogical mysteries. I think Condike could lose the religious references, the paranormal leanings, and tighten up the story as there was some dialogue that seemed repetitive. However, the story thrilled me and I enjoyed every minute of reading it.
Thanks to Netgalley and Harbor Lane Books for the advanced copy of the book. The opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 81 reviews