Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Hell Riders: The True Story of the Charge of the Light Brigade

Rate this book
On the 150th anniversary of the world's most famous cavalry charge comes a revisionist retelling of the battle based on firsthand accounts from the soldiers who fought there

In October 1854, with the Crimean War just under way and British and French troops pushing the tsar's forces back from the Black Sea, seven hundred intrepid English horsemen charged a mile and a half into the most heavily fortified Russian position. In the seven minutes it took the cavalry to cross this distance, more than five hundred of them were killed. Celebrated in poetry and legend, the charge of the Light Brigade has stood for a century and a half as a pure example of military dash and daring. Until now, historical accounts of this cavalry charge have relied upon politically motivated press reports and diaries kept by the aristocratic British generals who commanded the action.

In Hell Riders, noted historian and Crimean War expert Terry Brighton looks, for the first time, to the journals recorded by survivors-the soldiers who did the fighting. His riveting firsthand narrative reveals the tragically inept leadership on the part of the British commander in chief, Lord Raglan, whose orders for the charge were poorly communicated and misinterpreted, and an unfathomable indifference on the part of British officers to the men who survived the battle and were left to tend their wounds and bury the dead in the freezing cold. While the charge overran the Russians, it gained nothing and the war continued for another two years. In finally capturing the truth behind the charge of the Light Brigade, Brighton offers a stirring portrait of incredible bravery in the service of a misguided endeavor.

431 pages, Kindle Edition

Published December 10, 2013

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Terry Brighton

10 books10 followers
Terry Brighton is a British military historian and writer. His work is published in the U.K., the U.S., and in translation around the world.

In his controversial extended essay, The MAGA Offensive, published by Hard Corps Essays in September 2020, he argues that "the re-election of President Donald Trump is crucial for the survival of the real USA and the core values of Western culture."

He is best known for his research on the Charge of the Light Brigade, published in “Hell Riders: The True Story of the Charge of the Light Brigade.” But according to Publishers Weekly it was his work on three Second World War generals, “Patton, Montgomery, Rommel: Masters of War” that moved him “into the top rank of general audience military writers.”

His first novel, “Hell's Mile,” was published in 2020. According to the author, this makes good a promise he made to Richard Madeley on the British TV chat show Richard & Judy that he would “write the novel” of the Charge of the Light Brigade. “Hell’s Mile” is based on survivors’ graphic accounts and is not for the faint-hearted.

Terry Brighton has been an Anglican priest, chaplain to the SAS [British Special Forces], and curator of The Queen's Royal Lancers Regimental Museum. He lives in England with his wife, Linda, and their dog, Belle.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
92 (44%)
4 stars
90 (43%)
3 stars
25 (12%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews
Profile Image for Jill H..
1,693 reviews100 followers
June 21, 2011
Into the valley of death rode the 600 and into the imagination of the public for over 150 years. The ill-fated Charge of the Light Brigade has resounded through poetry and film and has been romanticized in the process. This book is, in my opinion, one of the two best accounts of the Charge ever written...the other being The Reason Why: The Story of the Fatal Charge of the Light Brigade by Cecil Woodham-Smith.

The story is told through accounts by survivors, observers, and military leaders. The author has done meticulous research and challenges the reader to decide why the Charge occurred and who was responsible.....was it Lords Cardigan, Lucan, or Raglan......or was it just a miscommunication of orders that sent so many men to their deaths?

Even if you are not a reader of history or are uninterested in the Crimean War, this book, which so vividly describes every aspect of the Charge, will still hold your interest. Its an amazing history and beautifully written.

A rather ironic aside is that Alfred, Lord Tennyson, who wrote his world famous poem within a week of the Charge, was disconcerted to discover that the number of men involved was closer to 700 than 600....but it was too late to modify the poem as it had been published. He was happy to realize that "700" didn't scan in the poem's meter and into history rode the "600", right or wrong.'

I highly recommend this insightful history of a mistake that became glorious in its telling.
Profile Image for Betsy.
1,205 reviews143 followers
September 14, 2026
Rounded up from 3.5. Interestingly enough the most the first part of the book about the Alma, the 'thin red line', the Charge of the Heavy Brigade, and even the Charge of the Light Brigade are not as interesting as I have seen in other books. They're almost perfunctory although the author does go into detail about the Light Brigade of course. Part of the problem may be the plethora of quotes by the participants as they make their way against the guns and back again. It tends to break up the action, and also there are no maps to help the reader visualize what is being described.

The author really saves the best part for the after action comments on such topics as Forence Nightingale and Mary Seacole, the two men whose trumpet calls sent the Light Brigade down the Valley, the various officers involved and whose fault was it? Most important of all the Charge was not the debacle that Tennyson's poem would have you believe, but it should never have happened as it it did.

If you know anything about the battle on October 25, 1854, you know about the controversies. The author's conclusions are nothing new, but he does a fine job in analyzing what did happen.
Profile Image for Christopher Saunders.
1,091 reviews995 followers
October 11, 2012
Terry Brighton's Hell Riders offers a detailed reconstruction of the Charge of the Light Brigade, the Crimean War's most notorious military catastrophe. Brighton approaches this well-covered topic with energy and verve, doing a nice job combining the command-level view of the Charge (the bumbling Lord Raglan, boorish Lord Lucan and obscene Lord Cardigan) with eyewitness reports extrapolated from soldier's memoirs, reports and interviews conducted after the fact. Thus the book manages an immediacy in its accounts of military catastrophe that many other histories lack, showing how horrifying it would actually have been to ride through the "Valley of Death," painfully aware of the catastrophe unfolding but powerless to stop it. Much of the book is devoted to a moment-by-moment reconstruction of the Charge, and its here that Brighton's strengths as a narrative historian come into play, allowing the participants to speak to themselves, registering each shot, shell, wound, felled horse and anguished cry as if in a demented sports play-by-play. Brighton also shows the Light Brigade's sorry fate after the Charge; ill-treated by their commanding officers, they suffered from privation with the rest of the British Army through the fall of Sevastopol, then returned to a hero's welcome only to be forgotten and ignored after the war concluded. The book sags in its back third with a series of essays on the Charge's historiography, some interesting, others trivial and redundant, that are best-consumed by devoted military buffs. Even so, it's a bracing read for most of its length, an energetic recreation of a blunder many have heard about, but few understand.
Profile Image for Olethros.
2,722 reviews555 followers
May 12, 2016
-Cuando el historiador es casi un detective los resultados suelen ser llamativos.-

Género. Historia.

Lo que nos cuenta. Análisis de lo ocurrido en Balaclava el 25 de octubre de 1854 durante la Guerra de Crimea, cuando dos regimientos de dragones ligeros, dos de húsares y uno de lanceros (más dos perros), que constituían la Brigada ligera de caballería británica, cargan por razones que hoy siguen siendo objeto de debate contra una batería de cañones rusos al fondo de un valle estrecho de kilómetro y medio de longitud protegido en ambos lados por unos veinte batallones de infantería, varios de caballería y más piezas de artillería, desarrollándose así un episodio bélico que genera admiración y horror a partes iguales.

¿Quiere saber más de este libro, sin spoilers? Visite:

http://librosdeolethros.blogspot.com....
Profile Image for SoulSurvivor.
818 reviews
May 13, 2022
This was the second Crimean War book I read in a 30-day period. The first was too detailed in the presentation of all segments of the War, from events leading up to it to how it changed the future of Europe to come. This book breezed through those elements but concentrated on the infamous
'Charge of the Light Brigade'.I've read the Tennyson poem a number of times, but this account made me appreciate it.
Profile Image for Stuart Bobb.
217 reviews3 followers
November 15, 2026
What:
====
This book is a history of the famous 1854 charge of the light brigade at Balaklava in the Crimean War. The attack itself being only seven minutes or so long, you might wonder what would fill up the rest of the book. The author includes a lot of the back story for both the conflict and key characters and provides a large dose of “in their own words” quoting from the survivors written record as well as commentary from the Russian historical documents. (Fun fact: Leo Tolstoy was present as an artillery officer at the siege of Sevastopol)

The book gives us insight into how the British military operated, how senior officers were selected (buying their commissions) and a deep post mortem analysis of the larger conflict and the charge.

The charge itself is remembered because Tennyson did a marvelous job of passing along the glory of cavalry making an attack straight into the face of an artillery position while also being fired upon from both flanks by artillery and infantry. The officers did not expect much of the brigade would survive.

Spoiler: The suffering didn’t end when the remainder of the light brigade made it back to British lines.

This is a book that will appeal to those who want to see how historians grapple with contradictory testimony and evidence.

You will encounter some interesting ways to think about a set of historical facts. There are some unkind remarks about Florence Nightingale handed out as part of the revisionist story told here.

Some High Points and Reasons to Read:
==============
How many men were in the famous charge? Seems like a simple question that would have a single agreed upon answer. In fact, the number is still a point of argument. Men were in the attack that did not belong to that brigade and there were men that belong to that brigade that were not in the attack. It was most likely not lower than 660 and not likely higher than 674. Tennyson was working from early dispatches which were quite inaccurate; there were certainly more than 600.

How many died? Again you would have to determine whether you will count only those who died of their wounds on the field or in the hospital. How about those that died later, as prisoners of war in the care of the Russians?

If you enjoy watching a measurement puzzle like this taken apart and analyzed (lots of reasons for differing counts!) you'll like this book.

Though it goes on a bit long, the question of who actually blew the bugle for the final charge was also disputed - and this matters when a bugle claiming that notoriety goes up for auction decades later! Complicating the discussion is the fact that there are many different bugle calls that get sounded at various stages. Consider that the call to “mount up” was blown far earlier (and possibly by a different trumpeter) than the calls for “trot” for “gallop” and of course, maximum speed, the “charge” and you have room for much doubt and argument.

The actual “charge” (the last portion before a knee to knee wall of horses and sabers crashes into its objective) is almost always less than 100 yards and it was at Balaklava as well, though of course the whole attack was over 1.25 miles.

Analyzing who could hear what and how mistakes were so long lived (including those that testified to the end of their lives that no bugle call for charge was ever sounded) is the sort of detail that gets worked through.

Other points of argument are heavily dissected as well. Who is to blame for what was ultimately a pointless loss of horses and men? Four officers from Lord Raglan down to Captain Nolan each get an in-depth prosecution/defense treatment by the author.

Did the senior light brigade commander, Cardigan, (yes, him of the sweater) retreat early or did he fight Cossacks beyond the guns? Testimony for both incompatible facts exists.

The analysis of success or failure is well done. From a larger military objective (keep the Russians from breaking the British/French siege of Sevastopol) the charge was pointless. The Heavy Brigade had already repulsed an earlier Russian attack. The military campaign objective was to take Sevastopol and destroy the Russian Black Seas Fleet. Nothing about this charge contributed to that objective and frankly, the loss of horses endangered that objective.

The wrong guns were charged. From a “did you do the mission senior leadership intended you to do”, it is an abject failure. No British guns from the heights were recaptured by this pointless attack.

From the perspective of what Cardigan thought he was tasked to do (a suicidal attack directly into an artillery position in front of him more than a mile away) it was an overwhelming success! The remainder of the brigade made it to the guns and they hacked down any artillery personnel that were available. More ever, they made a credible effort of driving back a much larger (5x in size!) Russian cavalry group that was beyond the guns.

The utter insanity of this charge also shocked the Russian cavalry to its core. Russian morale for any future cavalry encounters with the British in this campaign was greatly reduced. They were in shock and fear of a force that was so reckless with its life and would attack with such unstoppable ferocity while taking horrible losses. British prisoners were interrogated as to what their officers had given them to drink before the charge. (answer: nothing).

If you are looking for a story of bravery in an impossible situation, here it is.

If you are looking for a story of gross military incompetence, absurd levels of leadership stupidity and the shocking cost of poor officer communications, here it is in the same story.

How did this military create an empire on which the sun did not set? The incompetence of their foes must have been of glue-eating scale.


Weaknesses, Reasons to Skip
==============
I’m often leery of “in their own words” writing in any military history I read. Most participants in combat are not good writers. I think the author chose good examples and limited the length of quotes appropriately, but if you don’t like reading these journal snippets, you won’t likely enjoy large parts of this book.

Horse lovers might want to give this book a pass. The horses suffered far more than the men and the men suffered greatly. The horses suffer getting to Crimea and the horses are killed (or euthanized after) at an appalling rate in the attack, The suffering of those still fit goes to new heights in the aftermath. (How do you feed horses during wartime in a Crimean winter when they are too far from the port? Hint: You largely don’t, even as you work them to death… )

A direct frontal attack on artillery by a cavalry brigade results in gruesome levels of carnage. Shot, canister and exploding shells do unspeakable damage to human and horse flesh. This book is not gratuitous but it is clear just how appalling the butchery was. The fact that it was basically pointless makes it all the more tragic.

All the classic tropes of British military leadership’s pigheadedness and incompetence are on display. The awful fruit of having leaders that bought their positions while having no merit, talent or skill is on full display. You might be tired of seeing the Victorian military hierarchy held up as such a blundering incompetent set of fools - but they were and they get no mercy in this book. Some of Lord Lucan and Lord Cardigan’s behaviors are so infuriating you wonder how much more of it you can read about.

This book was written in 2004 - (Lined up well with the 150th anniversary, I would guess). Scholarship may have moved further, I didn’t check. While there are almost no footnotes, the author does provide a bibliography and some detail as to where his claims come from.
Profile Image for Eric.
17 reviews2 followers
March 10, 2017
Any fan of Western history or literature has no doubt heard of the Charge of the Light Brigade, the ill-fated British cavalry charge in the Crimean war immortalized by Tennyson's poem. Brighton's book uses a variety of primary sources to reveal the truth behind the charge, as told by the soldiers (and others) who were there. An excellent read that captures both the drama and horror of the 1-mile charge across open ground under heavy fire, it also describes the aftermath for the survivors, and offers a fascinating final section that goes into detail about some of the lesser-known aspects and historical debates about the charge. The first quarter of the book is a fascinating look at the personalities behind the charge, including the commanders Lords Raglan (army), Lucan (cavalry) and Cardigan (brigade). The middle half is a white-knuckle description of the charge itself. And the final quarter offers a series of short case studies that range from descriptions of what happened to some of the men to debating some of the historical issues surrounding the charge, such as who actually "blunder'd" in sending the men into the mouths of the guns. A must-read for any military history fan.
53 reviews
September 2, 2022
Not much new here if you’re familiar with the story (or even the movie). A number of other controversial issues thrown in to fill up the book. Author works to assign blame for the infamous charge and does a pretty solid job of laying out the arguments and evidence. Overall an easy and entertaining read.
282 reviews2 followers
April 12, 2026
This book is highly recommended in academic circles. It contains 20 chapters, index, bibliography, introduction, two appendices and a few other sundry publisher requirements for a total of 431 pages. There are approximately 415 reading pages if you begin the count at the cover page.
For the student of warfare, in some respects, one will find that officers had wide latitude and that mission command type orders were issued – that officers were expected to act on the commander's intent.
The truth of war is not found in the official despatches and is mostly missing from the written history. We all know the quip: history is written by the victorious. Most military history is centered around the tactical, operational and strategic analysis – the lessons learned as interpretated by the author. Additionally, may historians use the survey method to write their own versions and when they do the perpetuate myths because they relied on secondary sources and unverified information. This is not to say that those lessons are unimportant. For the student of warfare they are, for the soldier they are a frame of reference and offer insights in lieu of actual combat experience.
The real history of war is written in the diaries, letters and observations of the participants. Is there room for error and embellishment? Yes. But the stories are closer to the mark than the original staff reports. The numerous individual actions that constitute great battles, or any battle, carry the reader into the deeper and darker recesses of the execution of brute force of the continuation of policy and politics by other means.
This story is told as the survivors – the twenty or o men who wrote down their experiences.
The charge down the valley was not what Lord Raglan, Commander in Chief of the British Army in the Crimea had intended. The written order had been carried by an aide-de-camp to Lord Lucan who commanded the Cavalry Division. Lord Lucan in turn gave the order orally to Lord Cardigan, commanding the Light Brigade. Somewhere between Lord Raglan and Lord Cardigan the meaning and intent of the order was misunderstood.
This book explicitly covers the entire aspects of the story of the key players, the lessor known and each phase – preparation for war, the ruling class, the trial of deployment, the invasion, the intelligence that could have saved the Light Brigade; and then moves in the Part two – The Charge.
What makes this book fascinating is the articulate detail, with a full chapter devoted to the twenty minutes from receipt of the order to the survivors fight to return. All in all, two chapters cover, in detail what took place inside of one hour. Part three of the book, three chapters, covers fact and fiction. Part four of the book covers the investigation, scandals, Florence Nightengale, the Bugle controversy and finding faults. Lastly, the conclusion wraps it up. The book is exceptionally readable history that drives the reader deep into the culture, the army, personalities and the outcomes.
I read this book about the time it was first published in 2004. I deployed to Afghanistan in 2006; I subsequently di 5 tours. April of 2026, I decided to reread this book as I refocus my interests to the late 18th and 19th centuries. After 5 tours in Afghanistan, I have a different perspective. No spoilers – you will need to read the book – I highly recommend it,
Profile Image for Erin Shaffer.
2 reviews3 followers
February 19, 2022
Fascinating and extremely well written. I didn’t love the analysis chapters at the end, and didn’t find them necessary honestly. He gave us enough throughout the story to draw our own conclusions.
576 reviews1 follower
December 30, 2023
Too much description of the charge details (minute by minute and from several perspectives) for my liking but I really enjoyed his analysis of who to blame for what.
58 reviews
April 17, 2024
A revelation of politics and military history and amazingly brutal but stupid courage. Brilliant
Profile Image for Simon Whitelaw.
16 reviews
June 24, 2024
Excellent read. What awful characters were Lucas and Cardigan. Such pompous and incompetent twats! Such that such brave men had these men as leaders.
Profile Image for Jack Abernethy.
38 reviews1 follower
May 27, 2025
Who is to be pitied more, the man or the horse?

Not often I read military history in my downtime, but this was perfect, comprehensive and engaging.
11 reviews
January 1, 2026
One of my favourite history books i've read. Brilliantly put together and tells a clear and impartial story of the causes, conduct and outcomes of The Charge of the Light Brigade.
Profile Image for Peter.
718 reviews2 followers
July 3, 2026
Excellent and detailed analysis of the Charge of the Light Brigade and assessment of the various controversies.
2 reviews
September 20, 2026
A very good book.

Well written and well researched. The lack of real military lesdershipn was, in my mind, the cause of this magnificent blunder.
Profile Image for James Hatton.
294 reviews5 followers
November 19, 2014
October 25, 1854. The Battle of Balaclava. The Crimean War. The Great Game is played, another inning. In this history of the Charge of the Light Brigade, Brighton interleaves the lines Tennyson's famous poem with the lines of men who fought and died in this famous battle. A myth is obliterated. Fool's folly revealed. Bravery and courage made obvious. Tragedy shown true.

The Charge of the Light Brigade

Half a league, half a league,
Half a league onward,
All in the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.
"Forward, the Light Brigade!
"Charge for the guns!" he said:
Into the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.

"Forward, the Light Brigade!"
Was there a man dismay'd?
Not tho' the soldier knew
Someone had blunder'd:
Theirs not to make reply,
Theirs not to reason why,
Theirs but to do and die:
Into the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.

Cannon to right of them,
Cannon to left of them,
Cannon in front of them
Volley'd and thunder'd;
Storm'd at with shot and shell,
Boldly they rode and well,
Into the jaws of Death,
Into the mouth of Hell
Rode the six hundred.

Flash'd all their sabres bare,
Flash'd as they turn'd in air,
Sabring the gunners there,
Charging an army, while
All the world wonder'd:
Plunged in the battery-smoke
Right thro' the line they broke;
Cossack and Russian
Reel'd from the sabre stroke
Shatter'd and sunder'd.
Then they rode back, but not
Not the six hundred.

Cannon to right of them,
Cannon to left of them,
Cannon behind them
Volley'd and thunder'd;
Storm'd at with shot and shell,
While horse and hero fell,
They that had fought so well
Came thro' the jaws of Death
Back from the mouth of Hell,
All that was left of them,
Left of six hundred.

When can their glory fade?
O the wild charge they made!
All the world wondered.
Honour the charge they made,
Honour the Light Brigade,
Noble six hundred.

-Tennyson
Profile Image for Rebecca.
15 reviews
March 12, 2016
A detailed yet entertaining account of the British cavalry's most famous blunder, Brighton discusses each and every aspect of the light cavalry at the time. As well as covering the charge he also goes into detail about the hardships the light brigade faced before and after Balaclava.
The author gives a fair judgement of who was to blame for the disaster, going into detail about the four prime suspects and considering their life and motivations before the charge. He is also not afraid to challenge the views of other historians. For a while the mainstream belief was that Captain Nolan was somehow wholly responsible, but Brighton gives a convincing case that the majority of the responsibility actually fell upon Lucan.
To conclude, I think everyone who is a British military history enthusiast, or is just interested in the concept of Victorian heroism should definitely have this book on their shelves.
Profile Image for Liberty.
94 reviews
March 13, 2014
Just one of the best books I've ever read on military history. Equally ranking (if not more) Cecil Woodham Smith's book The Reason Why (you will pardon me Madam. Smith I hope). Frightfully accurate, he displaces a good deal of myths and inaccuracies that have sprung up over the last 160 years. One of the best elements of the book is how he uses the soldiers and eyewitness of the charge to recreate a minute by minute account of the daring charge. C'est magnifique personnifié!
Profile Image for Nathan.
595 reviews11 followers
January 20, 2012
Popular (read amateur) history about the titular charge, with a centrepiece being a minute by minute (!) account of the ride down the Valley of Death, using first hand accounts wherever possible. Pretty rousing stuff all round, what! Only quibble: not enough use made of Russian sources looking at it from the other side. But still a superior volume of its type. 3.5/5
Profile Image for Rich Taylor.
187 reviews15 followers
March 14, 2015
A well told tale of a too little known war and battle. Amazing, in so many ways, being the charge itself.

I personally didn't need quite so much analysis of who blew the bugle or how a pair of veterans died in mysterious circumstances years later etc, but that may appeal to others more than I.
9 reviews
August 18, 2008
Very readable account of the Charge of the Light Brigade. Honestly, I thought the poem was a fictitous account and this text fills in a lot of the details from the ground.
Profile Image for Tom.
19 reviews2 followers
August 4, 2011
very good evocation of a dramatic mistake in military history. a story of incompetence ...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews