Ode to the Brave
Saul David is a proven historian of great worth. All of the books I have read by him have been excellent. Sky Warriors, his book on the British Airborne Forces in the Second World War is no different. These were brave if also reckless soldiers who may also have been let down by poor leadership. But the legendary Red Devils were among them, who were considered some of the finest combat troops of the war. The parachute regiments were born at the instigation of Winston Churchill in 1940, a body of 500 men. This grew into three divisions of 10,000 men by the end of the war. They played a pivotal part in fighting in every major theatre of the war, from the Far East, North Africa and Europe.
Sky Warriors starts with the formation and training in the early years in and around Manchester. It ends with the climax and disaster at Arnhem where the famous failure to capture the bridges before German forces in the area overwhelmed them. They lost just under 2000 men and had a further 6800 captured. Despite their bravery and determination they were let down by poor intelligence which did not detect Panzer divisions in the area and lack of air support the campaign failed. One of the key features of this book is its focus on personal stories and Saul David effectively balances the broader historical story with the individual stories, bringing to life the stories of bravery, innovation and sacrifices of the men and women involved.
The strength of this book lies in David’s ability to combine military history with the personal stories of the men themselves. He draws on letters, diaries, and interviews to give the paras a voice, and it makes their experiences feel vivid and real. From their beginnings in 1940—when the idea of a British airborne force was still experimental—to their defining roles in North Africa, Sicily, Arnhem, and beyond, David traces not only what the soldiers did, but also what it meant to them. The detail is rich, but the narrative never gets bogged down; it reads quickly and keeps you turning the pages.
A good comparison to this book is Stephen Ambrose’s Band of Brothers, as both capture the camaraderie and the cost of serving in an elite unit. The paratroopers emerge as ordinary young men thrown into extraordinary situations, tested by relentless training, chaotic drops behind enemy lines, and savage combat. However, David doesn’t romanticise their experience in some ways that Ambrose does in Band of Brothers as he shows the exhaustion, the fear, and the staggering losses they faced. Like Ambrose though, David conveys the loyalty and brotherhood that kept them fighting.
That said, I have some criticisms. It is clear that David at times leans heavily on anecdote, which, while powerful, can leave certain larger strategic contexts underexplored. Furthermore, though less of a problem for me is that his admiration for the paras sometimes shades into hero-worship (they did go through an unimaginable experience after all), glossing over darker moments of indiscipline or the controversies that surrounded some operations (soldiers are still men who aren’t perfect). Finally, even though it was their largest engagement, Sky Warriors focuses on Arnhem too much for me. They were deployed one more time in the war to liberate Norway from Nazi occupation in 1945 before the final and ultimate surrender.
Sky Warriors is a must read for anyone interested in WWII or the development of aerial combat. But you can also be the casual reader as the military history is blended with human stories. This book is of the highest standard which is well written all the same and offers an invaluable insight into how WWII massively influenced the evolution of warfare.