a 3-point-five-ish stars, my lord
first, to be clear: i am an atheist. i would almost certainly never have read this unprompted after seeing all the 'god stuff' in the description and cover reviews. i get very uncomfortable very quickly by ostentatiously-religious books and people; it feels like im entertaining a cultist, and i have a *really* difficult time with that.
my mum had this book and told me she loved it and learnt a lot from it (of that ive seen scant evidence, but i'll get to that in a bit). she said it 'was a little religious, but not that much' (she's Catholic, but really only at Easter) and i didn't bother to read the book blurbs prior to cracking this open. my mum was so effusive about how much she enjoyed it and wanted me to read it, practically shoving it in my hands; i welcomed the chance to learn some new things – and read a book, of course.
this book was clearly intended for women. the pink cover with the painted lips might've tipped you off, but it wasn't until i got into the book itself that it was clear to me; i just figured the author chose a cover that reflected the author's own personality, not something emblematic of gendered stereotypes (pseudo-spoiler alert: the latter was, in fact, her goal).
and speaking of, Ms Ehman propagates the fallacious claim that women talk more than men*, and throws in some pretty nasty commentary to boot: the 'Utterly Untameable' is a 'beast'(!) behind a curtain, revealed to be a woman chatting on her mobile; frequent references to 'women flapping their jaws' and 'yakking' with the obvious implication of nothing meaningful being said; implications that women speaking is a rightful annoyance, especially to men.
much of this was straight from the first, ergh; it thankfully got a little better through the book, but that plus the scripture at the starting line didn't set my expectations high at all (my eyes rolled much faster). tact was certainly lacking in parts, too, and it felt more than a few times as though i was reading the words of an '80s-era motivational speaker.
and my mum misspoke: this was VERY religious. very, very, VERY.
i.e., picture Buzz Lightyear: 'god-stuff! god-stuff everywhere!'
still, i ended up enjoying the book considerably more than id expected (i assumed id ultimately give it one star). though scripture is not my thing, the author chose verses that at least suited the point, and her beliefs were surprisingly consistent. she exhibited a level of fairness toward other beliefs and lifestyles that surprised me, and she seemed to genuinely want to both help others -and- herself. there's a level of humility present that is generally atypical in my experiences with theists; i will always respect someone who admits that they don't have all the answers or behaviours down pat but are nevertheless trying to do their best to learn and grow.
some of the advice is really sound for everyone, not just women or 'believers', and i did have a lot to reflect on whilst making my way through the book - including how much of the work ive already done, which was a surprising realisation (and confidence boost). scripture and religion aside, there are tips even heathens like me can use – and so much the better for those who do believe, as i think the 'god stuff' helps support her points rather than diminish or negate them.
(also, i do not recall any verses or mention of women being relegated to Servants for Men®, or of being told that women need to shut it when a Man® is talking; there were no admonitions to 'Be a good, subservient little housewife and STFU' – and thank god for that...as they say. this would be a very angry, infinitely less favourable review otherwise, haha.)
of course, as effusive as my mum was about how much she gained from it, i am sincerely hoping she reads it again as soon as i return it to her. i keep my distance because it's healthier for both of us, but even my being as kind and patient communicative and 'lovingly honest' for years (and, im now aware, as the book likewise instructs) has not yet done a thing to improve her treatment of me.
maybe revisiting this book knowing ive now read it will help her follow through...well, at least i know im on the right track, and it's got me one book closer to my reading goal this year.
PS this is a much longer review than id intended, or than many ive written, so i obviously still have work to do. 😉
_________________
*the claim has long been debunked. further, a review of 56 studies, conducted by a linguistics researcher and a social psychologist, found that only two supported the claim.
of the remaining 54...
34(!) studies found men did more of the talking; 16 showed the same amount for both; and four had no clear pattern at all.
in actuality, status - not gender - is the clearest determining factor of word count. the person perceived to be of higher status tends to have the bulk of the floor (though men often talk over and interrupt women regardless of their position).