What do you think?
Rate this book
A Lady
Mary André, sister to a prominent British officer, flees a despairing argument with her brother and loses her way, ending up in the enemy camp just as the American Revolution takes hold. Now Mary must make a powerful decision – to become a member of George Washington’s ring of spies or risk being discovered as the enemy.
Mary’s choice will affect the outcome of the war, as well as unleash a series of consequences in her own life that she can’t escape: Will she risk her own brother’s life to save thousands of revolutionary soldiers? Could she turn the course of the war in the revolution’s favor? Will she be able to face the consequences of falling in love?
Mary’s choice will affect the outcome of the war, as well as unleash a series of consequences in her own life that she can’t escape: Will she risk her own brother’s life to save thousands of revolutionary soldiers? Could she turn the course of the war in the revolution’s favor? Will she be able to face the consequences of falling in love?
Unknown Binding
Published July 4, 2024
3 people are currently reading
110 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
July 5, 2024
Hands down, this is one of the best pieces of historical fiction I've ever read. If you like historical fiction as a genre even a little, you must read this.
The story itself is gripping and is woven seamlessly into real events to bring the colonial and Revolutionary time period in America into bright technicolor.
The story itself is gripping and is woven seamlessly into real events to bring the colonial and Revolutionary time period in America into bright technicolor.
July 6, 2025
This brought me back to my teen years when almost everything I read was historical fiction/romance. And I loved it!!! I loved the intrigue, the romance, the history, the clothes, everything!
July 3, 2025
This was an interesting take on the American Revolution. I liked all the cameos of real historical figures. The story was clearly well-researched and thoughtfully written, though I found the pacing a little inconsistent. But still a pleasant read for history fiction lovers. 3.5 ⭐️
September 10, 2024
As someone obsessed with the American Revolution and the show Turn, I'm beyond giddy and grateful that this book exists.
The author did a great job capturing even the smallest likeness of the characters.
If, like me, you've been dying for a book like this, you'll forego a few things. Does Tallmadge apparently never have to lead his men and spend most of his time at Mary's side? YES. Is Mary's reason for switching teams flimsy? Also, yes. But, is this book a fun historic romance? Yes.
I would have liked a little more spice in the romantic and flirtatious encounters. Things got vanilla after a while. Some more detail and interiority might have remedied that.
In any case, can't even wait for the sequel!
The author did a great job capturing even the smallest likeness of the characters.
If, like me, you've been dying for a book like this, you'll forego a few things. Does Tallmadge apparently never have to lead his men and spend most of his time at Mary's side? YES. Is Mary's reason for switching teams flimsy? Also, yes. But, is this book a fun historic romance? Yes.
I would have liked a little more spice in the romantic and flirtatious encounters. Things got vanilla after a while. Some more detail and interiority might have remedied that.
In any case, can't even wait for the sequel!
June 30, 2024
A great debut. Full review to come
July 21, 2024
If you enjoy learning about the Revolutionary War or enjoying a sweet romance, this is the book for you!
July 27, 2024
As a massive fan of TURN and AmRev history in general, I really, truly wanted to love this book. I was SO excited about it and could barely wait to tear into it. However, I regret to say I was very much left wanting.
The prose is nice, and the author has a good grasp of Ben and Caleb (or at least, they sound very much like the TURN interpretations), but Mary, herself, isn't very interesting. I feel like maybe the author was expecting people to already know these historical figures beforehand, because the narrative makes mention of Mary having sisters and a mother, but we never learn WHY Mary ended up in America with Andre, while the rest of their family stayed behind (presumably -- it's never stated WHERE they are, specifically). She also has no real personality beyond wanting to be "more than a lady." I wanted to know more about her. I know absolutely nothing other than her physical appearance and her restless stir to serve.
That brings me to the next issue: her allegiance to the American Cause is equally weak. The beginning mentions how the rebellion "thrills" Mary, but it's never really stated why. Briefly, she witnesses some redcoats beating a man in front of her, but that hardly seems like a logical reason for Mary to turn away from her brother's side. A considerable ways into the book, we learn her TRUE reason is because Mary wants to feel useful and make a difference (and to be more than a pretty face). To me, that is STILL a weak reason to spy for the Continentals, because she could just as easily be useful to her brother's side, ESPECIALLY since she ended up in the Continental encampment. She could've posed as a double agent. As a fan of slowburn (and realistic plotlines), I would've much preferred if Mary accidentally stumbled upon the camp, had an, "OH, SH&T!" moment, and then once they ask her to spy, she realizes she can help her brother if she agrees. She would've consented, and then tried sneaking out intelligence to Andre. However, after zero successful attempts and a growing bond between Ben, Caleb and herself, she comes to the startling realization that she not only has fallen for Ben, but has found herself in support of their cause. THAT would've been way more compelling than just, "Hey, I'm restless and want a purpose. Hey, I'm in a Continental encampment. Hey, I guess I'm going to turn on my brother and do this because it'll give me a purpose, cuz I SUPPORT FREEDOM!!!" It made Mary seem wishy-washy and selfish at best.
Mary also constantly remarks on how beautiful she is (which, of course, is a sentiment echoed by Ben, Lafayette, Caleb, Simcoe, and pretty much every dang man she encounters). The book started off with her and Simcoe flirting, yet he was pretty much forgotten about once she met Ben. And yes, I get it: Ben/Seth has beautiful blue eyes, but we don't need to be reminded of this every time he looks at her. Lafayette and Caleb also flirt with her, so even though Ben is the clear "winner" in her eyes (she dubbed her alias as "Mary Floyd," so we all know where THAT is going), she's the constant center of attention with varying men. As if that isn't irksome enough, Ben and Mary have ZERO chemistry. Tbh, I feel like Mary and Caleb have the most spark, but that's probably because Caleb's charisma makes her seem more charming by proxy. Throughout the entire first 100+ pages, all Ben and Mary truly do is make small talk and give accusations (I was starting to get whiplash from how many times Ben was kind to her, only to suddenly pull her aside and ask, "ArE YoU a SpY?" because he had yet to trust her due to her being British). Then out of nowhere, Ben confesses to being in love with her and kisses her, and as a fan of slowburn (or just ANY tension at all), I was left wanting. Admittedly, I DID like their next shared scene where Mary, Ben and Caleb sing "Soldier, Will You Marry Me?" while celebrating the French alliance. This was the FIRST time Ben and Mary had any tension/spark, so I feel like THIS scene should've come before their first kiss, and not after.
Thankfully, the second half of the book was a little better. I enjoyed the battle sequence at Monmouth, even if I found it unrealistic that Mary would be able to kill two soldiers and wound Simcoe, and all after ONE afternoon of learning how to shoot/throw axes. I mean, yes, some people are naturally gifted, but since Mary is a LITERAL Mary Sue, I was skeptical and kind of rolling my eyes about it. Because of COURSE this "beautiful, perfect, flawless woman who everyone loves" can also take out MULTIPLE men with the reload time of a trained soldier. As a side note, WHY did this not give Mary any PTSD, or bother her beyond that day in battle? I would think she'd be a bit more shaken about killing and injuring multiple men! But nah, she just got a bath and literally washed away the trauma, because she never reflected on that moment again. It would've been the PERFECT topic to bring up to Ben, because they could commiserate, and maybe even finally have a modicum of chemistry. (EDIT: I forgot Mary killed that defector in the beginning of the novel -- not a good sign, seeing how it was yet ANOTHER monumental event that ended up being nothing more than a blip. The man tried to take advantage of her too, and was the reason she got injured in the first place, so you'd think he would've left a more lasting effect on both Mary and the reader.)
In step with all the Mary Sue adoration, upon her return, she is immediately swept up again by Simcoe and some lord I've forgotten the name of (he was literally just there to show how desirable Mary is. He never made another appearance beyond that ONE scene of him grabbing her).
Although I like Peggy, I found most of the second half pretty dull. The spying bits were also a little disjointed and unclear, so it helps to have prior knowledge of the Culper Spy Ring. Things picked up again when Ben returned, but that's probably just because it's Ben and I missed him (then again, I don't think I'd even love THIS version of Ben if it weren't for my prior knowledge of him, because we get very little about HIM as a person). He and Mary shared some more painfully passionless love scenes, though I did enjoy the cross-examination between Martha Washington and Mary. She's such a kind person, so it was interesting how her sincerity was what came closest to giving Mary away.
Abe and Townsend were introduced in this section, as well, but the ending didn't really give any reason to continue -- or rather, there was no cliffhanger/need for resolution in my eyes, so I'm content to just be told about the next installments rather than reading them.
In terms of what I DO like: the author's prose is well-written (except for all the punctuation errors/occasional typos), and I like her ability to capture the voice of the canon TURN characters, for the most part. I also enjoyed her attention to detail with the camp life. I bought a book on camp followers earlier this year, because I wanted to learn more about them. Their lives aren't celebrated/appreciated nearly enough, so I enjoyed seeing Mary commanded to serve as a camp follower (though I do think her adapting to that lifestyle was a bit fast, given her cushy upbringing). I also really love the cover. It's gorgeous, so kudos to Emilie Haney, the talented designer!
Overall, I know in my heart that I'm only being so harsh because this is essentially fanfiction, and I have read WAY better Ben/OC fics on AO3 that are NOT published. My expectations for this were considerably higher since this author is being PAID for this series.
I would've given this a 3 because of the solid writing style, but I had to dock a star because of the constant incorrect punctuation. Here's an example:
"Hello." Caleb said.
^That is incorrect. "Caleb said" is not a complete sentence. It should have read:
"Hello," Caleb said.
Another instance is as follows:
Ben smiled, "Yes, I'd say so."
^You can't smile dialogue, so it should've either been:
Ben smiled. "Yes, I'd say so."
OR
Ben said, "Yes, I'd say so."
I'm sorry for the uppity grammar lesson, but this drove me absolutely BONKERS, and kept taking me out of the story. If that weren't bad enough, sometimes the punctuation would be correct; the inconsistency bothered me more than the actual mistakes. Where the heck were the editors for this project?
The prose is nice, and the author has a good grasp of Ben and Caleb (or at least, they sound very much like the TURN interpretations), but Mary, herself, isn't very interesting. I feel like maybe the author was expecting people to already know these historical figures beforehand, because the narrative makes mention of Mary having sisters and a mother, but we never learn WHY Mary ended up in America with Andre, while the rest of their family stayed behind (presumably -- it's never stated WHERE they are, specifically). She also has no real personality beyond wanting to be "more than a lady." I wanted to know more about her. I know absolutely nothing other than her physical appearance and her restless stir to serve.
That brings me to the next issue: her allegiance to the American Cause is equally weak. The beginning mentions how the rebellion "thrills" Mary, but it's never really stated why. Briefly, she witnesses some redcoats beating a man in front of her, but that hardly seems like a logical reason for Mary to turn away from her brother's side. A considerable ways into the book, we learn her TRUE reason is because Mary wants to feel useful and make a difference (and to be more than a pretty face). To me, that is STILL a weak reason to spy for the Continentals, because she could just as easily be useful to her brother's side, ESPECIALLY since she ended up in the Continental encampment. She could've posed as a double agent. As a fan of slowburn (and realistic plotlines), I would've much preferred if Mary accidentally stumbled upon the camp, had an, "OH, SH&T!" moment, and then once they ask her to spy, she realizes she can help her brother if she agrees. She would've consented, and then tried sneaking out intelligence to Andre. However, after zero successful attempts and a growing bond between Ben, Caleb and herself, she comes to the startling realization that she not only has fallen for Ben, but has found herself in support of their cause. THAT would've been way more compelling than just, "Hey, I'm restless and want a purpose. Hey, I'm in a Continental encampment. Hey, I guess I'm going to turn on my brother and do this because it'll give me a purpose, cuz I SUPPORT FREEDOM!!!" It made Mary seem wishy-washy and selfish at best.
Mary also constantly remarks on how beautiful she is (which, of course, is a sentiment echoed by Ben, Lafayette, Caleb, Simcoe, and pretty much every dang man she encounters). The book started off with her and Simcoe flirting, yet he was pretty much forgotten about once she met Ben. And yes, I get it: Ben/Seth has beautiful blue eyes, but we don't need to be reminded of this every time he looks at her. Lafayette and Caleb also flirt with her, so even though Ben is the clear "winner" in her eyes (she dubbed her alias as "Mary Floyd," so we all know where THAT is going), she's the constant center of attention with varying men. As if that isn't irksome enough, Ben and Mary have ZERO chemistry. Tbh, I feel like Mary and Caleb have the most spark, but that's probably because Caleb's charisma makes her seem more charming by proxy. Throughout the entire first 100+ pages, all Ben and Mary truly do is make small talk and give accusations (I was starting to get whiplash from how many times Ben was kind to her, only to suddenly pull her aside and ask, "ArE YoU a SpY?" because he had yet to trust her due to her being British). Then out of nowhere, Ben confesses to being in love with her and kisses her, and as a fan of slowburn (or just ANY tension at all), I was left wanting. Admittedly, I DID like their next shared scene where Mary, Ben and Caleb sing "Soldier, Will You Marry Me?" while celebrating the French alliance. This was the FIRST time Ben and Mary had any tension/spark, so I feel like THIS scene should've come before their first kiss, and not after.
Thankfully, the second half of the book was a little better. I enjoyed the battle sequence at Monmouth, even if I found it unrealistic that Mary would be able to kill two soldiers and wound Simcoe, and all after ONE afternoon of learning how to shoot/throw axes. I mean, yes, some people are naturally gifted, but since Mary is a LITERAL Mary Sue, I was skeptical and kind of rolling my eyes about it. Because of COURSE this "beautiful, perfect, flawless woman who everyone loves" can also take out MULTIPLE men with the reload time of a trained soldier. As a side note, WHY did this not give Mary any PTSD, or bother her beyond that day in battle? I would think she'd be a bit more shaken about killing and injuring multiple men! But nah, she just got a bath and literally washed away the trauma, because she never reflected on that moment again. It would've been the PERFECT topic to bring up to Ben, because they could commiserate, and maybe even finally have a modicum of chemistry. (EDIT: I forgot Mary killed that defector in the beginning of the novel -- not a good sign, seeing how it was yet ANOTHER monumental event that ended up being nothing more than a blip. The man tried to take advantage of her too, and was the reason she got injured in the first place, so you'd think he would've left a more lasting effect on both Mary and the reader.)
In step with all the Mary Sue adoration, upon her return, she is immediately swept up again by Simcoe and some lord I've forgotten the name of (he was literally just there to show how desirable Mary is. He never made another appearance beyond that ONE scene of him grabbing her).
Although I like Peggy, I found most of the second half pretty dull. The spying bits were also a little disjointed and unclear, so it helps to have prior knowledge of the Culper Spy Ring. Things picked up again when Ben returned, but that's probably just because it's Ben and I missed him (then again, I don't think I'd even love THIS version of Ben if it weren't for my prior knowledge of him, because we get very little about HIM as a person). He and Mary shared some more painfully passionless love scenes, though I did enjoy the cross-examination between Martha Washington and Mary. She's such a kind person, so it was interesting how her sincerity was what came closest to giving Mary away.
Abe and Townsend were introduced in this section, as well, but the ending didn't really give any reason to continue -- or rather, there was no cliffhanger/need for resolution in my eyes, so I'm content to just be told about the next installments rather than reading them.
In terms of what I DO like: the author's prose is well-written (except for all the punctuation errors/occasional typos), and I like her ability to capture the voice of the canon TURN characters, for the most part. I also enjoyed her attention to detail with the camp life. I bought a book on camp followers earlier this year, because I wanted to learn more about them. Their lives aren't celebrated/appreciated nearly enough, so I enjoyed seeing Mary commanded to serve as a camp follower (though I do think her adapting to that lifestyle was a bit fast, given her cushy upbringing). I also really love the cover. It's gorgeous, so kudos to Emilie Haney, the talented designer!
Overall, I know in my heart that I'm only being so harsh because this is essentially fanfiction, and I have read WAY better Ben/OC fics on AO3 that are NOT published. My expectations for this were considerably higher since this author is being PAID for this series.
I would've given this a 3 because of the solid writing style, but I had to dock a star because of the constant incorrect punctuation. Here's an example:
"Hello." Caleb said.
^That is incorrect. "Caleb said" is not a complete sentence. It should have read:
"Hello," Caleb said.
Another instance is as follows:
Ben smiled, "Yes, I'd say so."
^You can't smile dialogue, so it should've either been:
Ben smiled. "Yes, I'd say so."
OR
Ben said, "Yes, I'd say so."
I'm sorry for the uppity grammar lesson, but this drove me absolutely BONKERS, and kept taking me out of the story. If that weren't bad enough, sometimes the punctuation would be correct; the inconsistency bothered me more than the actual mistakes. Where the heck were the editors for this project?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 13, 2024
I met the author of this novel in a historical fiction writers group, and I was inspired to find someone with such a vivacious love of the written word and the revolutionary period. It was fun to learn that I was not the only one weaving a storyline involving Major John Andre, everyone's favorite Ren Faire hosting, play producing, party-loving, silhouette snipping, sketchpad touting, poem writing, ditty warbling, hymn memorizing intelligence officer artiste for the King. He’s long been one of my go-to historical characters that I relish researching, since he was such a Renaissance man who had not only ambition to rise in his chosen career as the son of Huguenot refugees who had sought sanctuary in Britain but also as someone with a warm personality and good heart that endeared him to most people he met.
Caught up in Benedict Arnold's defection to the British, and refused mercy by a legalistic and retributive tribunal, his life was snuffed out all too soon, though he maintained his honor as a British officer and gentleman to the bitter end, even as the empire he and his comrades fought so hard to preserve was coming apart at the seams. He was mourned deeply by his family, with whom he had a loving and tight-knit relationship. As the eldest brother, he was extremely protective over his siblings, particularly his sisters. The real Mary Andre, who is fictionally depicted as a rebel spy in this novel, remained a loyal subject of King George, a grateful sovereign who honored her brother's sacrifice.
But this novel explores a number of imaginative “what ifs” involving a split within the Andre family which might fit this book most properly within an alternate history subgenre. It explores the ramifications of a civil war which did split many families who found themselves facing off against each as the conflict intensified. It also deals with the consequences that taking opposite stands might entail. The theme of loyalty to causes versus loyalty to individuals is brought to the fore as the story progresses and the moral ambiguities of spywork become increasingly apparent. If you enjoy “Turn”, you will probably appreciate this work, which has a similar thematic focus and depiction of various historically-inspired characters. There are also similarities in general vibe with “Outlander”, “Hamilton”, “Sons of Liberty”, and “The Patriot.”
I congratulate the author on the completion and publication of her debut novel, and hope that the release of her sequel novel later this year will also be a cause for celebration. I have particularly enjoyed watching her launch videos, in which she is clad in period costume, and have smiled broadly to think of cosplay-obsessed Major Andre's ghost enjoying every second of it.
Caught up in Benedict Arnold's defection to the British, and refused mercy by a legalistic and retributive tribunal, his life was snuffed out all too soon, though he maintained his honor as a British officer and gentleman to the bitter end, even as the empire he and his comrades fought so hard to preserve was coming apart at the seams. He was mourned deeply by his family, with whom he had a loving and tight-knit relationship. As the eldest brother, he was extremely protective over his siblings, particularly his sisters. The real Mary Andre, who is fictionally depicted as a rebel spy in this novel, remained a loyal subject of King George, a grateful sovereign who honored her brother's sacrifice.
But this novel explores a number of imaginative “what ifs” involving a split within the Andre family which might fit this book most properly within an alternate history subgenre. It explores the ramifications of a civil war which did split many families who found themselves facing off against each as the conflict intensified. It also deals with the consequences that taking opposite stands might entail. The theme of loyalty to causes versus loyalty to individuals is brought to the fore as the story progresses and the moral ambiguities of spywork become increasingly apparent. If you enjoy “Turn”, you will probably appreciate this work, which has a similar thematic focus and depiction of various historically-inspired characters. There are also similarities in general vibe with “Outlander”, “Hamilton”, “Sons of Liberty”, and “The Patriot.”
I congratulate the author on the completion and publication of her debut novel, and hope that the release of her sequel novel later this year will also be a cause for celebration. I have particularly enjoyed watching her launch videos, in which she is clad in period costume, and have smiled broadly to think of cosplay-obsessed Major Andre's ghost enjoying every second of it.
July 3, 2024
Times perfectly with the 4th of July and one of the most impactful American History events, let me introduce you to A Lady. Mary Andre is the main character in this story and she is the sister of a British soldier stationed in Philadelphia during the year 1777. As Mary is entertaining her brother and his fellow soldiers, she begins to observe behaviors from the men that have her questioning exactly why the British are here and how dark their behaviors really run.
Because of this, she finds herself questioning what her future is. She doesn't really want to continue being around the dangerous British soldiers and she envisions a future for herself where she can contribute more than just being another woman amongst many. As she flees her countrymen in search of her calling, she finds herself in the midst of the Continental Army. After spending time amongst them, she quickly realizes this is where she belongs and offers her access to the British soldiers and information in exchange for being one of them. She is now a spy for the Continental Army.
A gripping historical retelling of the Revolutionary War and the spy network that played such a pivotal role in it all. Based on numerous historical facts and a few added embellishments for entertainment purposes, this was a gripping novel about the realities of war, the dangers we put ourselves in for the ones we love most, and how the spirit and determination of a people can change the outcome of history.
Along with the historical elements of the plot, there is also a wonderful romance that develops between Mary and her Continental savior, Benjamin. In an enemies to lovers situation, Ben fights his desire for Mary because she is the enemy and he struggles to trust her. But after months of time spent together in the Continental Camp, his walls finally dissolve and he lets her in. But this blossoming romance with Ben puts Mary in even further danger as they can never truly be together. Not until the war is over.
It's an emotional pull throughout the entire story from the family dynamics of Mary, to her desire for Ben, but until the war is won - no one is safe.
Because of this, she finds herself questioning what her future is. She doesn't really want to continue being around the dangerous British soldiers and she envisions a future for herself where she can contribute more than just being another woman amongst many. As she flees her countrymen in search of her calling, she finds herself in the midst of the Continental Army. After spending time amongst them, she quickly realizes this is where she belongs and offers her access to the British soldiers and information in exchange for being one of them. She is now a spy for the Continental Army.
A gripping historical retelling of the Revolutionary War and the spy network that played such a pivotal role in it all. Based on numerous historical facts and a few added embellishments for entertainment purposes, this was a gripping novel about the realities of war, the dangers we put ourselves in for the ones we love most, and how the spirit and determination of a people can change the outcome of history.
Along with the historical elements of the plot, there is also a wonderful romance that develops between Mary and her Continental savior, Benjamin. In an enemies to lovers situation, Ben fights his desire for Mary because she is the enemy and he struggles to trust her. But after months of time spent together in the Continental Camp, his walls finally dissolve and he lets her in. But this blossoming romance with Ben puts Mary in even further danger as they can never truly be together. Not until the war is over.
It's an emotional pull throughout the entire story from the family dynamics of Mary, to her desire for Ben, but until the war is won - no one is safe.
July 6, 2024
As a history buff and a lover of the series Turn, I knew that I needed to read this book the moment I saw it. I did thoroughly enjoy it but there were a few things that took me out of the narrative a few times. Thankfully, the final third of this novel really grabbed me and has me excited for the sequel.
The pacing of this book, while never boring, was quite quick. The first few chapters had time jumps of weeks and that felt a bit jarring for me. I understand that it was setting up a lot in those pivotal intro chapters but since the book is pretty short I would have enjoyed getting to know characters more deeply before the start of the main plot.
At times, language choices by the author as well as coincidences or character decisions also took me out of the novel. Because we did not get to know Mary much before she had to make big decisions, some things were a bit unbelievable and I feel as though we never really are given answers as to why she makes the choices she does.
However, the moment we meet Ben I was hooked. As a Tallmadge girlie from day one I knew this romance element would have me in shambles. Throw in that Simcoe triangle and I am eating out of the palm of your hand. I do think this novel would have benefited from the pov of Benjamin, it could have elongated the narrative and also helped tie together some missing pieces and loose ends when it comes to the espionage element. Again, we do not know Ben all that well so it's hard to believe some of his decisions.
Along with the romance elements, I especially liked the descriptions of the action sequences/battles and the clothing. I loved googling these terms and learning more.
I was also under the impression that this was a standalone, and while I'm not mad that there will be another book, I do feel a bit unfulfilled. I am guessing I will feel a whole lot better when the next installment releases. I can't wait to see this build up pay off.
3.5 stars rounded up. Ecstatic for part 2!
The pacing of this book, while never boring, was quite quick. The first few chapters had time jumps of weeks and that felt a bit jarring for me. I understand that it was setting up a lot in those pivotal intro chapters but since the book is pretty short I would have enjoyed getting to know characters more deeply before the start of the main plot.
At times, language choices by the author as well as coincidences or character decisions also took me out of the novel. Because we did not get to know Mary much before she had to make big decisions, some things were a bit unbelievable and I feel as though we never really are given answers as to why she makes the choices she does.
However, the moment we meet Ben I was hooked. As a Tallmadge girlie from day one I knew this romance element would have me in shambles. Throw in that Simcoe triangle and I am eating out of the palm of your hand. I do think this novel would have benefited from the pov of Benjamin, it could have elongated the narrative and also helped tie together some missing pieces and loose ends when it comes to the espionage element. Again, we do not know Ben all that well so it's hard to believe some of his decisions.
Along with the romance elements, I especially liked the descriptions of the action sequences/battles and the clothing. I loved googling these terms and learning more.
I was also under the impression that this was a standalone, and while I'm not mad that there will be another book, I do feel a bit unfulfilled. I am guessing I will feel a whole lot better when the next installment releases. I can't wait to see this build up pay off.
3.5 stars rounded up. Ecstatic for part 2!
May 22, 2024
I adored this book. Something I love about historical fiction is watching history come alive. How fun to vicariously interact with the likes of George Washington, Martha Washington, and other members of our history.
We follow Mary as she goes from a British officer’s sister to living in a winter camp of American Revolutionary soldiers. Mary proves to be intelligent, determined, and full of grit. Her journey from lady of leisure to an injured not-quite prisoner to spy is fascinating and full of bravery.
Then there is Major Tallmage. A swoony hero who is tough on the outside, but all heart on the inside.
Mary is the kind of woman many of us aspire to be. Intelligent, discerning, brave, and determined to do the right thing. And the major is the kind of hero we love. Strong, stoic, yet tender, and a stand-up kind of guy. Full of grit, history, heartbreak, and true heroics, this book will have you flipping pages and writing the author to ask when the next book will be ready.
Something else I loved: The author really brings to light the significant struggles the Revolutionary soldiers endured and the hard-working women that did so much work behind the scenes. I was very moved and filled with a gratefulness for the freedoms we have thanks to people who sacrificed so much.
I’d highly recommend this book. With its swoon, but no spice, it is a safe book for meters of many ages.
** I received an early copy of this manuscript in exchange for a fair and impartial review.
We follow Mary as she goes from a British officer’s sister to living in a winter camp of American Revolutionary soldiers. Mary proves to be intelligent, determined, and full of grit. Her journey from lady of leisure to an injured not-quite prisoner to spy is fascinating and full of bravery.
Then there is Major Tallmage. A swoony hero who is tough on the outside, but all heart on the inside.
Mary is the kind of woman many of us aspire to be. Intelligent, discerning, brave, and determined to do the right thing. And the major is the kind of hero we love. Strong, stoic, yet tender, and a stand-up kind of guy. Full of grit, history, heartbreak, and true heroics, this book will have you flipping pages and writing the author to ask when the next book will be ready.
Something else I loved: The author really brings to light the significant struggles the Revolutionary soldiers endured and the hard-working women that did so much work behind the scenes. I was very moved and filled with a gratefulness for the freedoms we have thanks to people who sacrificed so much.
I’d highly recommend this book. With its swoon, but no spice, it is a safe book for meters of many ages.
** I received an early copy of this manuscript in exchange for a fair and impartial review.
July 3, 2024
A wonderful debut novel by Hannah Honegger!!
I'll start my review by explaining that historical what-if fiction usually isn't my thing. I'm one of those don't-mess-with-history-because-people-will-take-it-as-fact kind of nerd, lol. With that being said, it's high praise when I say I am so glad I picked up A Lady by Hannah Honegger! If you have read about or studied the War of Independence and stumbled across the Culper Ring and became intrigued by the mystery surrounding it, even to this day, then I highly recommend A Lady. Hannah Honegger weaves together fact and fiction so seamlessly that it melds together. Thus, why I recommend learning a bit first! The years of work and research Hannah Honegger placed in this book are made evident by the history brought to life. Benjamin Tallmadge and the others portrayed in A Lady were so accurately written as the honorable and noble gentlemen and ladies they were and deepened my appreciation and respect for those men and women that founded our country. I look forward to A Lady's sequel and how Hannah Honegger might tie some things together!
I recommend you pick up this book, read it, and decide for yourself what you think about A Lady! It is the perfect summer read, and I love that it releases on July 4th.
I received a copy of this book from the author, and was not required to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I'll start my review by explaining that historical what-if fiction usually isn't my thing. I'm one of those don't-mess-with-history-because-people-will-take-it-as-fact kind of nerd, lol. With that being said, it's high praise when I say I am so glad I picked up A Lady by Hannah Honegger! If you have read about or studied the War of Independence and stumbled across the Culper Ring and became intrigued by the mystery surrounding it, even to this day, then I highly recommend A Lady. Hannah Honegger weaves together fact and fiction so seamlessly that it melds together. Thus, why I recommend learning a bit first! The years of work and research Hannah Honegger placed in this book are made evident by the history brought to life. Benjamin Tallmadge and the others portrayed in A Lady were so accurately written as the honorable and noble gentlemen and ladies they were and deepened my appreciation and respect for those men and women that founded our country. I look forward to A Lady's sequel and how Hannah Honegger might tie some things together!
I recommend you pick up this book, read it, and decide for yourself what you think about A Lady! It is the perfect summer read, and I love that it releases on July 4th.
I received a copy of this book from the author, and was not required to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 17, 2024
A Lady is a wonderful historical fiction, teeming with intrigue, deception, gallantry, and delightful tidbits of romance. Set during the American Revolution we join Mary André, sister of the infamous British Major John André, in her quest to find more meaning to her life than just the social duties of being an English lady. Mary soon finds herself thrust–quite literally–into life as a “camp follower” for the Continental Army, where the threat of her real name looms over every decision and friendship made.
Her allegiance is tested when she returns to her brother’s keeping, along with the task of spying for the Continental Army. Caught between loyalties to her brother, and what she feels is right in her heart, Mary is faced with several choices that will affect not only her life, but those of the war also. She must tread carefully in order to not reveal herself–which at many times kept this reader on her toes–and find those she can truly trust, even if it means going against family and friends alike.
If you are a history buff, like myself, you will thoroughly enjoy how well Hannah transports us to such a vital time in our country’s history. And for you romantics out there, myself included, this story is wonderfully peppered with a well drawn romance between our Mary and a Major that begins to see Mary as more than just A Lady.
I highly recommend this one for your lists!
Her allegiance is tested when she returns to her brother’s keeping, along with the task of spying for the Continental Army. Caught between loyalties to her brother, and what she feels is right in her heart, Mary is faced with several choices that will affect not only her life, but those of the war also. She must tread carefully in order to not reveal herself–which at many times kept this reader on her toes–and find those she can truly trust, even if it means going against family and friends alike.
If you are a history buff, like myself, you will thoroughly enjoy how well Hannah transports us to such a vital time in our country’s history. And for you romantics out there, myself included, this story is wonderfully peppered with a well drawn romance between our Mary and a Major that begins to see Mary as more than just A Lady.
I highly recommend this one for your lists!
June 28, 2024
This debut novel is fantastic. A Lady is a well written story set during the Revolutionary War. I was captivated from the beginning. The writing just draws you in and makes you feel apart of the story. There was so much historical accuracy woven throughout the story, but it was done in such a way that leaves the reader wanting more. (I am not a history buff at all and often find myself getting bored with historical romances that throw in too many historical facts. That was not the case with A Lady.)
The action was done very well. The battle scenes were really vivid. I loved the romance between Mary and Ben. Ben was definitely hesitant to pursue a relationship, but in the end he couldn’t resist Mary…or her kisses.
All the side characters added to the story in their own ways. I enjoyed them all immensely…except a certain Major.
I was really sad when I got to the end of the book. It could have gone on and I would have been quite happy. I cannot wait for the next book in the Cipher 355 series. If you love non-explicit historical romances, you need to read A Lady by Hannah Honegger.
**I was sent a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.
December 22, 2024
You can probably get equally good Benjamin Tallmadge/OFC Turn fanfic on AO3 for free, maybe even with André and Simcoe cameos. And I'm being very generous giving it two stars because wtf was that ending. (To be fair, I think it's supposed to be the first book in a series, but I have absolutely no desire to pay money for the next book, so for me it's just a very unsatisfying ending of a standalone book.)
Having Peggy Shippen be the sweet and supportive BFF of the main character is an unexpected (and probably unintentional) throwback to 19th century professional André fanfic like A Great Treason or Pemberton. André isn't paired with her in either of them, though. (It's actually not clear to me that John André and Peggy Shippen were commonly thought of as romantically involved before the early-mid 20th century, except among some of Peggy's descendants, which is why I tend to lend some credence to the Phipps family claiming he was her suitor - I think they may be repeating a family tradition that's uninfluenced by external mythology. I don't think it was a serious relationship, though. For the record.)
Having Peggy Shippen be the sweet and supportive BFF of the main character is an unexpected (and probably unintentional) throwback to 19th century professional André fanfic like A Great Treason or Pemberton. André isn't paired with her in either of them, though. (It's actually not clear to me that John André and Peggy Shippen were commonly thought of as romantically involved before the early-mid 20th century, except among some of Peggy's descendants, which is why I tend to lend some credence to the Phipps family claiming he was her suitor - I think they may be repeating a family tradition that's uninfluenced by external mythology. I don't think it was a serious relationship, though. For the record.)
June 18, 2024
🤍 Thank you so much @hannah_honegger for the lovely copy of your debut novel!🤍
Set in the 1700’s, The Lady follows the sister of a British soldier, Mary, as she navigates love, family, and the war.
I am always sold on stories about women doing daring things and fighting for what they believe in, and this was no different. Mary’s journey was full of the uncertainty, fear, hope, and bravery of the time and I loved her character!
I cannot wait to see what Hannah Honegger does with this story next!
If you love:
• Revolutionary War
• slow burn romance
• strong heroine
• bravery and sacrifice during war times
Then check out this novel coming out July 4th 🇺🇸
My one critique (which does not keep me from recommending this one nor reading this author again) is the page breaks. There were often so many per chapter that it
felt jarring to the flow and progression of the story.
3.75 stars
Set in the 1700’s, The Lady follows the sister of a British soldier, Mary, as she navigates love, family, and the war.
I am always sold on stories about women doing daring things and fighting for what they believe in, and this was no different. Mary’s journey was full of the uncertainty, fear, hope, and bravery of the time and I loved her character!
I cannot wait to see what Hannah Honegger does with this story next!
If you love:
• Revolutionary War
• slow burn romance
• strong heroine
• bravery and sacrifice during war times
Then check out this novel coming out July 4th 🇺🇸
My one critique (which does not keep me from recommending this one nor reading this author again) is the page breaks. There were often so many per chapter that it
felt jarring to the flow and progression of the story.
3.75 stars
October 2, 2024
This was a page-turner for me and it ended too quickly!I love historical fiction & historical romance from this time period. Mary and Benjamin’s romance is so sweet and tender!
I wish there had been more transitional details between the important moments and events - it’s not that it didn’t flow, but I felt like we would skip ahead to the next thing and could have benefited from knowing how we got there. I think there could also have been more of a build-up to Mary’s confrontation with her brother and subsequent leaving, which spurs the action of the plot, as well as more elaboration on Mary’s curiosity about the Patriots & sympathizing with their cause. More inner turmoil about her divided loyalties to family and friends vs Benjamin and the Patriots could have added more drama and intensity as well.
All that being said, this was an engaging, suspenseful read that made me curious to learn more about Washington’s spies during the Revolution.
I wish there had been more transitional details between the important moments and events - it’s not that it didn’t flow, but I felt like we would skip ahead to the next thing and could have benefited from knowing how we got there. I think there could also have been more of a build-up to Mary’s confrontation with her brother and subsequent leaving, which spurs the action of the plot, as well as more elaboration on Mary’s curiosity about the Patriots & sympathizing with their cause. More inner turmoil about her divided loyalties to family and friends vs Benjamin and the Patriots could have added more drama and intensity as well.
All that being said, this was an engaging, suspenseful read that made me curious to learn more about Washington’s spies during the Revolution.
July 2, 2024
I wanted to read this book when I saw the cover it is so stunning. now that I read it I want to read it again and read book 2...... this was a wonderful historical fiction debut book. I love the love story entwined in this story of the revolution, the author did a great job of a what if situation. I love the character of Mary, she is brave and passionate. she has no problem proving herself to the world and doing what she feels is right. I didn't know going into this that this was a duology but I am super excited where this book will take me...... for sure I will be rereading this book when book 2 comes out and preordering book 2. if you loved turn, Washington spies and if you love the history surrounding Hamelton .... this would be a great book to check out. Perfect read for 4th of July when it releases!!!!
#bookreview #bookreviewer #arcreader
July 24, 2024
I could tell the author researched the period well and built very real events for her fictional characters. It felt real and it took me there, made me feel the pain, the danger, the sacrifice, all in the name of standing up for what’s right.
I feel like I learned about the revolutionary war, more than I learned in school. And it is just such a great story. The vulnerability, both physical and emotional, of Mary just pulled me in. It felt as if I were there, with her, making all these gut-wrenching choices that she knew would leave someone in pain or worse.
This book broke my heart and left me bawling like a baby, but it’s one of the best revolutionary war books I’ve ever read. I cannot recommend it enough.
June 1, 2024
A good and clean easy read!
Honnegar paints a good picture without overcomplicating it! The characters are lovely and I felt a connection to them very quickly. I do with there was a bit more spy-work but I imagine the sequel will have a lot more of that. All in all, Mary and Benjamin are great characters and their love is true, but I'm so glad that it wasn't the only interesting thing about the story. I am rooting for them to make it work in book two!
Honnegar paints a good picture without overcomplicating it! The characters are lovely and I felt a connection to them very quickly. I do with there was a bit more spy-work but I imagine the sequel will have a lot more of that. All in all, Mary and Benjamin are great characters and their love is true, but I'm so glad that it wasn't the only interesting thing about the story. I am rooting for them to make it work in book two!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 4, 2025
It's easy to read time period novels and get caught up and irritated in the details that aren't time period accurate. It is clear that this author has done her research creating a capturing story teleporting any true patriot into a time that is the very reason America is Amarica. If you have any interest in period novels, and romantic tales look no further this is your next read. Can't wait for book two to release 😍
April 21, 2024
I was given a free copy of "Lady" by Hannah Honegger via Librarything. This was an interesting book. I love history and this book was written about the Revolutionay War. It has great characters and character interaction. I would recommend this book if you like historical fiction. It is an interesting book.
July 15, 2024
Historical fiction is my very favorite genre and I love it even more when the story is based on actual events. The Revolutionary War is the time period I am most drawn to, I love the progression of our country’s founding. About ten years ago, I stumbled upon a new series, Turn, based on the book Washington’s Spies, a story of the spy ring that helped to win the war against England. I was immediately obsessed!
A Lady takes those events and presents them from a fictionalized point of view of a real life character, Mary André, the sister of British officer John André. This story was filled with lots of factual events and famous players in the war. I quickly recognized names, places, and battles. There is danger, intrigue, and battles. Friendship, both old and new, tested and tried. And the added forbidden romance was the perfect touch.
I feel that the pacing, historical detail, and story length are similar to that of Sian Ann Bessey. For anyone wanting to know a comparable author. I enjoyed this story immensely. My only complaint was there wasn’t enough. It ended too abruptly. But after reading the author notes, I discovered that another story is coming.
A Lady takes those events and presents them from a fictionalized point of view of a real life character, Mary André, the sister of British officer John André. This story was filled with lots of factual events and famous players in the war. I quickly recognized names, places, and battles. There is danger, intrigue, and battles. Friendship, both old and new, tested and tried. And the added forbidden romance was the perfect touch.
I feel that the pacing, historical detail, and story length are similar to that of Sian Ann Bessey. For anyone wanting to know a comparable author. I enjoyed this story immensely. My only complaint was there wasn’t enough. It ended too abruptly. But after reading the author notes, I discovered that another story is coming.
July 8, 2024
As a fan of Turn, I really enjoyed this book! I loved Benjamin Tallmadge in the show and loved him even more here. I really enjoyed seeing favorite and not so favorite characters in this one as well. I thought the story was well written, but the ending was very abrupt. I can’t wait for a sequel!
June 22, 2024
The perfect rainy day reading for all lovers of historical fiction. Hannah's debut is simply fantastic, and I cannot wait to read whatever she puts out next! 👏
January 3, 2025
ended too soon!
Have read other books about the. Culper Gang but this one was most exciting. I hope there is a Second book. Have to know how this ends for Mary.
Have read other books about the. Culper Gang but this one was most exciting. I hope there is a Second book. Have to know how this ends for Mary.
August 11, 2025
"Mary touched his arm. "We all have fears. Being afraid doesn't make us any less brave or good. It's what you do about your fear that makes the difference. " "
October 16, 2025
Loved this!! Just wish it was longer!
August 1, 2024
I have read a couple books about the Culper Spy Ring during the Revolutionary War and was very excited to read another and one specifically that imagined the identity of the spy “A Lady.” The historical background was intriguing with a mix of familiar names and fictionalized aspects. I am always interested in spy storylines and I loved seeing that in this situation.
There were a couple places (especially in the beginning or as the main character is deciding to switch sides) that I felt could have been fleshed out a little more to give a little more dynamic and depth to the situations. But it picked up as it went on and I was turning pages quickly to see how everything would play out.
This is the first book in a series which I think is important to know going in so you aren’t surprised that it ends before everything is tied up. It was a fun spot to end though! I will definitely be picking up the sequel and am very curious to see how the elements of the book play out against the historical events I know are coming.
Trigger/content warnings: battle related violence and injuries, some unwanted sexual advances, death
There were a couple places (especially in the beginning or as the main character is deciding to switch sides) that I felt could have been fleshed out a little more to give a little more dynamic and depth to the situations. But it picked up as it went on and I was turning pages quickly to see how everything would play out.
This is the first book in a series which I think is important to know going in so you aren’t surprised that it ends before everything is tied up. It was a fun spot to end though! I will definitely be picking up the sequel and am very curious to see how the elements of the book play out against the historical events I know are coming.
Trigger/content warnings: battle related violence and injuries, some unwanted sexual advances, death
September 13, 2024
This was a fast paced, exciting story that kept my interest. Revolutionary War fiction is a new favorite genre of mine. I loved the description of Mary Andre’s time in the Continental Army’s camp. I had a little bit of a hard time believing that the opposing side would trust a British officer’s sister. Still, a good book should keep you turning the pages and I could not wait to see what would happen next. The ending was abrupt but I am very excited for book two.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews