To be a part of Red Sox Nation is to be a hopeful romantic who neither betrays loyalty nor surrenders hope in the direst of circumstances. From Bangor to Back Bay, New Englanders endure in baseball matters. And life. The team’s history has intersected with the history of Boston and well beyond it, through the Curse of the Bambino, the military service of Ted Williams during World War II, and the Boston Marathon bombing. The Fenway Effect chronicles these stories and others that have built the incredible saga of the Boston Red Sox.
How did Cheers depict the passion of Boston’s sports fans? Why is Narragansett beer so important to New England? What’s the architectural impact of The Teammates—the statue of Bobby Doerr, Johnny Pesky, Ted Williams, and Dom DiMaggio outside Fenway Park? What did the Boston press really think about Red Sox owner Harry Frazee selling Babe Ruth to the Yankees? What was the origin of Fenway Park’s predecessor—Huntington Avenue Grounds?
Even Yankees fans will tip their caps to the rich impact of the Red Sox on music, movies, branding, broadcasting, and more. Plus, there’s a chapter focusing on the oral history of Red Sox fans, some of whom share here anecdotes that are funny, insightful, and heartwarming.
The Boston Red Sox have a special place in the hearts of many New Englanders. Even those who don’t follow baseball closely seem to have their emotions tied together with the ups and downs of the area’s baseball team. This book by David Krell explores some of those connections and why the Red Sox are an important part of the fabric of Boston.
The book explores many different aspects of this grip that the team has on the culture of the area. Not only are the important baseball games covered (Game Six of the 1975 World Series, Game Six of the 1986 World Series, the “Boston Strong” game after the Boston Marathon bombing where David Ortiz gave his famous speech) but connections in the community and in other forms of entertainment are discussed as well. For the latter, examples of this is the television show “Cheers” and it’s main character Sam Malone who was a pitcher for the Red Sox before opening his bar and “Fever Pitch”, the romantic comedy with Drew Barrymore and Jimmy Fallon, who plays a die-hard Red Sox fan.
Something that is worth noting is that topics that originated from a source other than the Red Sox are also included and proper credit, when due, is given. The best example is one of my favorite topics in the book, the Jimmy Fund. For those who don’t know about it, it is a very popular fundraiser for research into children’s cancer. It was inspired by a child cancer patient in 1948 and the “Jimmy” name is fictional, although the real name of the child is later revealed. But while this charity is well-connected with the Red Sox and legendary Red Sox player Ted Williams often visited patients without publicity, this was not originally a Red Sox staple. “Jimmy” expressed a desire to see his favorite baseball player, Billy Southworth. At the time, he was the manager of the Boston Braves, so the Jimmy Fund was started by the Braves. There are other connections to the Braves and plenty of mentions of the other professional sports teams in Boston.
The fan experience should also be included in this book and it covers many different areas of the region and various ages. This was my only disappointment with the book, although not because they were included. Indeed, this book would be incomplete without hearing from people on why the Red Sox are so important. But reading them in one chapter as they were organized felt like they were staring to sound the same. Of course, they were not – and for other Red Sox fans, this might resonate more greatly, but for me, they just started to feel like the same story but told in different ways.
That doesn’t take away anything from the book as it is one that I thoroughly enjoyed and it is complete for everything from the Red Sox ballpark before Fenway Park (Huntington Avenue Grounds) to the iconic Citgo sign seen over the Green Monster, this book is one that any baseball fan who understands what the Red Sox mean to the New England region will want to read.
I wish to thank University of Nebraska Press for providing a review copy. The opinions expressed are strictly my own.
This was essentially just a data dump. My partner asked if it was the history of Fenway Park or the neighborhood, but alas that would've been more interesting than this.
If you like reading 1-5 page play-by-plays of baseball games, this book is for you. Krell skips the forest, and the trees, and hones in on the bark. I would have loved to learn more about why the Sox moved from Huntington Avenue Grounds to Fenway in 1912, and a lot less about who committed each play of a series of 5 games in 1967. He also uses the book as a platform to chat about topics of interest to him, like tenuously related movies, or late night talk show hosts, skipping any contextualizing historical accounts in favor of poorly-worded strings of facts. And, the chapters repeat themselves. Two stars not one because I started watching Cheers because of this book, which is good, and the chapters on the Citgo Sign and Yastrzemski were enjoyable.
Audiobook was hard to get through! The narrator (author) could not property pronounce key Bostonian words (i.e. Names of cities in towns in Massachusetts and Red Sox players names.)
Perhaps, the worst book I've ever read about the Red Sox. The problem is the author can't decide if he wants to talk about culture or be a play by play announcer. If the author stayed with topics like the Citgo sign, Narragansett Beer and the Jimmy Fund. this book would have been terrific. But the author kept giving play by play for what he thought were key games. Games any Red Sox fan knows by heart to begin with. Seriously, no one needs to hear Bucky Dent ever again.
For some inexplicale reason, the author loves an analogy. So he would take deep dives into movies and tv shows, which have no bearing on Sox culture.
There were so many things he missed. No mention of the interference in game 3 of the 75 world series. David Hemderson's incredible home run in the ALCS against the angels and Dave Roberts stealing second against the Yankees, just to name a few.
Even more maddening is he went on and on about how Tom Seaver was a Red Sox icon. He also waxed eloquent about Vin Sculley, Seriously? What about the Red Sox Voices. Every kid grew up listening to Ken Coleman. Later it was Ken Harrelson and Dick Stockton. These guys are all red sox broadcaster legends. Even Sherm Feller should get a mention as the stadium announcer.
He missed how during the racial violence in Boston, The Red Sox brought the city together. Again, had this book lived up to the culture title, it would have been covered.
During his list of Boston Sports movies, he missed Celtic Pride. How do you skip a movie that had Larry Bird in it? It's a BOSTON book.
No mention of the fight to save Fenway park which was a big deal in the early 90s.
But the most egregious part of all, is how he mispronounced so many city names in the audiobook: Haverhill, Worcester. Salisbury just to name a few. Heck he even got Lechmere wrong. The book felt like a kids was rushing to finish a termpaper and just started dumping facts from a text book. Even AI could have helped.
Rule one of you are going to write about the Red Sox: Realize many of us have lived through the history and know it well. You have to do better. Heck there is even a book about the Yankees Suck T-Shirt history. And it goes into much better detail.
This is not the book it advertises to be. It's a failure all the way around.
Sometimes I rate a book as a 5 for reasons other than a thoughtful literary criticism (which is not my style). The Fenway Effect evoked many wonderful memories, from childhood through today. If you are a Red Sox fan there is a lot of history included, much I was not aware of. Sure, sometimes I thought it bogged down in a little too much detail that I was not especially interested in learning, but that's ok, you can always skim a little. The author captured quite well how sports can mean more than basic entertainment. I too experienced much of the angst of the decade upon decade of losing and heartbreak, and I am thankful to have been a part of the four recent World Series wins. Our dad took us to Fenway when back in Maine on summer vacations, and I have been blessed to pass the love for the Red Sox on to my kids and grandchildren, perhaps reaching at least for now the high point of going on the field itself with my oldest son just a few years ago. This is a very good read even if you are not a die-hard Sox fan, any fan of America's pastime can enjoy it. A thoughtful Christmas gift from one of our daughters who has caught the bug.
You can also see this review, along with others I have written, at my blog, Mr. Book's Book Reviews.
Thank you University of Nebraska Press for providing this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
Mr. Book just finished The Fenway Effect: A Cultural History Of The Boston Red Sox, by David Krell.
The best chapter of the book was about Cheers, while the chapters on race, the 1975 World Series and the Yankees-Red Sox were also highlights.
But, there were also chapters that couldn’t hold my interest at all, such as the Citgo Sign and music at Fenway. Overall, I’m going to give this one a B. Goodreads and NetGalley require grades on a 1-5 star system. In my personal conversion system, a B equates to 3 stars. (A or A+: 5 stars, B+: 4 stars, B: 3 stars, C: 2 stars, D or F: 1 star).
This review has been posted at NetGalley, Goodreads and my blog, Mr. Book’s Book Reviews
Mr. Book originally finished reading this on July 6, 2024.
First of all, I am a very dedicated baseball fan and deep into baseball history. Second, I am a loyal Red Sox fan. So, I had VERY high expectations in this book that it didn't quite live up to. Some sections were very interesting, like the history of the Royal Rooters, and the significance the Citgo sign that goes way beyond advertising. But Mr Krell goes off the rails with descriptions of games and players that have extremely little to do with the culture of the "Fenway Effect". There are much better books about the history of the Red Sox.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
super fun and i obvi liked it bc im a sox fan <3 minus a couple stars because the author doesn’t know how to pronounce some of these places and names smh
As someone who considers themself a big Red Sox fan this book didn’t do much for me in terms of new information with exception of the chapter on Cheers. If you’re not a fan and want to know more this book covers the basics well and would be worth a read.