My review is for To Follow the Star by Courtenay Burden:
The collection is billed as Christmas stories, and there's no more apt description for this short story by Courtenay Burden! Complete with a cold wintry setting, the story is theme-heavy: the carol The First Noel, the star (a Moravian star in particular), and of course the parallels straight from scripture are all strong threads throughout the story.
There is little action to be had, at least on-page. Much of the conflict, tension, and struggles occur as reflections by Stella, and her thoughts about them. The hopeless point and climax, however, do happen as written, but the writing style lends to a more "inside" look—that is, inside Stella's thoughts.
The story establishes the setting of Homewood as it first began, in 1831, and I love the premise, although few specifics of the time period grace the narrative. Still, there are no obvious historical inaccuracies.
I do remember some of the characters, particularly William, from Courtenay's story in A Homewood Christmas, which is quite pleasing. Again, there is a whole gaggle of sisters, and it can be hard to keep track of them, but they all have their simple, distinct character trait. Perfect style for a short story.