What do you think?
Rate this book
A Shanahan Match #1
Calling on the Matchmaker
This large print edition features an easy-to-read larger type size while preserving the complete text of the original edition.
Haunted by the death of her sister, Finola Shanahan has resolved that she's not worthy of a family of her own and commits to spending her days caring for immigrants in the slums. When Finola sabotages yet another unwanted relationship her parents arranged for her, her father calls upon the local Irish matchmaker, who pairs her with successful wagonmaker Riley Rafferty. Finola quickly realizes her usual tricks won't work on him, however, as she cannot outsmart or outwit the dashing, determined, and daring man.
A candidate in the St. Louis mayoral election, Riley is confident a union with the wealthy Shanahan family will help solidify his chances of winning--and even more assured he and Finola can make a difference together. When a cholera outbreak begins to take St. Louis by storm, they must navigate a burgeoning attraction and growing danger testing all they know about love and sacrifice.
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Haunted by the death of her sister, Finola Shanahan has resolved that she's not worthy of a family of her own and commits to spending her days caring for immigrants in the slums. When Finola sabotages yet another unwanted relationship her parents arranged for her, her father calls upon the local Irish matchmaker, who pairs her with successful wagonmaker Riley Rafferty. Finola quickly realizes her usual tricks won't work on him, however, as she cannot outsmart or outwit the dashing, determined, and daring man.
A candidate in the St. Louis mayoral election, Riley is confident a union with the wealthy Shanahan family will help solidify his chances of winning--and even more assured he and Finola can make a difference together. When a cholera outbreak begins to take St. Louis by storm, they must navigate a burgeoning attraction and growing danger testing all they know about love and sacrifice.
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
463 pages, Library Binding
First published December 12, 2023
About the author
Jody Hedlund
158 books4,922 followersJody Hedlund is the best-selling author of over fifty books and is the winner of numerous awards. She writes sweet historical romances with plenty of sizzle. Find out more at jodyhedlund.com.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 761 reviews
December 23, 2023
Ehh… DNF. How is this Christian fiction?? In the first chapter we get a line like this:
“This time she was breathless because the heroic Rylie Rafferty saved her life. Her body awoke to the realization that his full length was covering her, a broad chest, muscular torso, thick arms, and long legs. She knew from watching his dripping wet body emerge from the river that he was a strong man with muscles in every conceivable place. He was the kind of man that could make a nun blush.” 🤮😬
And the second chapter features this:
"He needed to tear his gaze away from her, but he was a starving man at a feast. He'd denied himself womanly pleasures for so long that this glimpse was awakening hunger in him." 🤦♀️
I had like 12 weeks left on this hold at my library, but apparently a ton of other people DNFed it too because I got it way sooner than expected.
And per other of my GoodReads friends, it doesn’t get any better as the book goes on and they say this was a disappointment for this author. It was my first one by this author and will be my last. I went in wary, and the opening scene turned me off.
Apparently no one can drive safely in this book, and the hero is sex-driven and makes sure we know it. 😬
That’s not romantic! I don’t want a man to mainly be into me for my sex appeal! And same goes for the female lead—that’s a horrible reason to fall for a man!
How is this Christian fiction??
The only redeeming quality is that gorgeous cover. 1.5⭐️
“This time she was breathless because the heroic Rylie Rafferty saved her life. Her body awoke to the realization that his full length was covering her, a broad chest, muscular torso, thick arms, and long legs. She knew from watching his dripping wet body emerge from the river that he was a strong man with muscles in every conceivable place. He was the kind of man that could make a nun blush.” 🤮😬
And the second chapter features this:
"He needed to tear his gaze away from her, but he was a starving man at a feast. He'd denied himself womanly pleasures for so long that this glimpse was awakening hunger in him." 🤦♀️
I had like 12 weeks left on this hold at my library, but apparently a ton of other people DNFed it too because I got it way sooner than expected.
And per other of my GoodReads friends, it doesn’t get any better as the book goes on and they say this was a disappointment for this author. It was my first one by this author and will be my last. I went in wary, and the opening scene turned me off.
Apparently no one can drive safely in this book, and the hero is sex-driven and makes sure we know it. 😬
That’s not romantic! I don’t want a man to mainly be into me for my sex appeal! And same goes for the female lead—that’s a horrible reason to fall for a man!
How is this Christian fiction??
The only redeeming quality is that gorgeous cover. 1.5⭐️
August 19, 2023
SOOO CRAZY GOOD!!!
Absolutely loved this book - one of my new favorites from this author!
Finola is determined to never marry. She has her heart set on being a nun and so purposefully drives away every suitor that she is paired with by the matchmaker.
Riley is hesitant at first to use a matchmaker but when he is paired with Finola he decides he is all in, and not just because it will help his business and his run for mayor...
Finola's determination to NOT fall for Riley falters the more she spends time with him but their growing feelings may not be enough to overcome pride, guilt, and a deadly outbreak of cholera.
What to expect:
1840s St. Louis
Dual POV
Matchmaker trope
He falls first, and he falls harder
Main characters with wounded pasts
Memorable meet-cute
Sooo much chemistry!!
The "List"
Ice skating
Caretaking scene
The ring
That first kiss!!
The Shanahan siblings
The grand gesture
Light themes of redemption and forgiveness
THE LAST CHAPTER!!!!
Oh my, does Jody Hedlund know how to write a swoony romance or what?! So much tension between Riley and Finola from the beginning and I loved the push and pull of their relationship as they both learned to let go of the past. There was a lot of physical attraction but I loved that they loved each other for so many other reasons too!
Love the unique setting and the many wonderful themes woven throughout the story about family and loss and love and forgiveness. I am hoping based on the series name that we will get stories for the other Shanahan siblings and I cannot wait!
I received a complimentary copy but a positive review was not required.
TW: Loss of family members, infant death
Absolutely loved this book - one of my new favorites from this author!
Finola is determined to never marry. She has her heart set on being a nun and so purposefully drives away every suitor that she is paired with by the matchmaker.
Riley is hesitant at first to use a matchmaker but when he is paired with Finola he decides he is all in, and not just because it will help his business and his run for mayor...
Finola's determination to NOT fall for Riley falters the more she spends time with him but their growing feelings may not be enough to overcome pride, guilt, and a deadly outbreak of cholera.
What to expect:
1840s St. Louis
Dual POV
Matchmaker trope
He falls first, and he falls harder
Main characters with wounded pasts
Memorable meet-cute
Sooo much chemistry!!
The "List"
Ice skating
Caretaking scene
The ring
That first kiss!!
The Shanahan siblings
The grand gesture
Light themes of redemption and forgiveness
THE LAST CHAPTER!!!!
Oh my, does Jody Hedlund know how to write a swoony romance or what?! So much tension between Riley and Finola from the beginning and I loved the push and pull of their relationship as they both learned to let go of the past. There was a lot of physical attraction but I loved that they loved each other for so many other reasons too!
Love the unique setting and the many wonderful themes woven throughout the story about family and loss and love and forgiveness. I am hoping based on the series name that we will get stories for the other Shanahan siblings and I cannot wait!
I received a complimentary copy but a positive review was not required.
TW: Loss of family members, infant death
January 14, 2024
“Some journeys take longer than others. Some need a little more help to get to the right destination. But in the end, a good matchmaker knows how to make it all happen just so.”
This was an extraordinary journey back to 1849 St. Louis, Missouri. I enjoyed my time with the Irish immigrant families Hedlund so masterfully created and I truly did not want to leave.
Twenty-three-year-old Finola Shanahan has no intentions of getting married. None. Not since that fateful afternoon so many years ago. She has a lifetime of penance ahead of her. In fact, she’s dedicated herself to the Sisters of Charity convent and plans on joining them as soon as she can.
Nobody can convince her otherwise. Not even Bellamy McKenna the Irish matchmaker who’s called in to form advantageous matches with the oldest of the six Shanahan children.
That is, until she finds someone who’s just as good at playing her game as she is!
I’ll be honest with you - I didn’t plan on liking this one as much as I did. This leprechaun thought she’d find holes in the ‘Irish’ story and be able to tell you that it wasn’t an immersive experience. That I wasn’t engaged. I wanted to be able to tell you that it felt reminiscent of Brad Pitt’s accent in Snatch. But I can’t. This felt truly typical and authentic. I LOVED THIS STORY. That’s something coming from someone who doesn’t normally read in this genre. This story is worth all the stars. All.
Bellamy was a hoot. When he spoke, I heard him as Michael O’Sullivan in Waking Ned Devine. I hope we see more of him in book 2.
Riley Rafferty was a studmuffin. I’m not partial to male blondes, so he had dark hair in my mind. I loved how he gave Finola space to come to her own decisions and deal with her forgiveness on her own terms.
This book is centered around forgiveness; both main characters are struggling to forgive themselves and need forgiveness from others. This book is also about:
☘️family dynamics/love
☘️making choices
☘️learning to advocate for oneself; finding one’s voice
☘️dealing with doubt and fear in connection with making mistakes
☘️feeling worthy
☘️running away from problems
☘️feeling the need to prove oneself
☘️learning to relinquish control over every aspect of our life
“Sometimes we mistake our own inability to forgive ourselves as God’s inability.”
You’ll discover a lump in your throat, water at the corner of your eyes and before you know it, you’ll wish there were more pages to the story.
I can’t wait for book two to find out about Enya Shanahan’s story…and, hopefully, more of Finola’s.
I was graciously gifted this copy post-publication by Bethany House Publishers and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
This was an extraordinary journey back to 1849 St. Louis, Missouri. I enjoyed my time with the Irish immigrant families Hedlund so masterfully created and I truly did not want to leave.
Twenty-three-year-old Finola Shanahan has no intentions of getting married. None. Not since that fateful afternoon so many years ago. She has a lifetime of penance ahead of her. In fact, she’s dedicated herself to the Sisters of Charity convent and plans on joining them as soon as she can.
Nobody can convince her otherwise. Not even Bellamy McKenna the Irish matchmaker who’s called in to form advantageous matches with the oldest of the six Shanahan children.
That is, until she finds someone who’s just as good at playing her game as she is!
I’ll be honest with you - I didn’t plan on liking this one as much as I did. This leprechaun thought she’d find holes in the ‘Irish’ story and be able to tell you that it wasn’t an immersive experience. That I wasn’t engaged. I wanted to be able to tell you that it felt reminiscent of Brad Pitt’s accent in Snatch. But I can’t. This felt truly typical and authentic. I LOVED THIS STORY. That’s something coming from someone who doesn’t normally read in this genre. This story is worth all the stars. All.
Bellamy was a hoot. When he spoke, I heard him as Michael O’Sullivan in Waking Ned Devine. I hope we see more of him in book 2.
Riley Rafferty was a studmuffin. I’m not partial to male blondes, so he had dark hair in my mind. I loved how he gave Finola space to come to her own decisions and deal with her forgiveness on her own terms.
This book is centered around forgiveness; both main characters are struggling to forgive themselves and need forgiveness from others. This book is also about:
☘️family dynamics/love
☘️making choices
☘️learning to advocate for oneself; finding one’s voice
☘️dealing with doubt and fear in connection with making mistakes
☘️feeling worthy
☘️running away from problems
☘️feeling the need to prove oneself
☘️learning to relinquish control over every aspect of our life
“Sometimes we mistake our own inability to forgive ourselves as God’s inability.”
You’ll discover a lump in your throat, water at the corner of your eyes and before you know it, you’ll wish there were more pages to the story.
I can’t wait for book two to find out about Enya Shanahan’s story…and, hopefully, more of Finola’s.
I was graciously gifted this copy post-publication by Bethany House Publishers and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
December 15, 2023
First thing’s first: this book is hilarious. Bellamy was such a great character with so many tricks up his sleeve. I hope we get a chance to see him meet his match.
However, this is not a five-star read for me. I got super tired of Finola’s hot/cold mindset. It just dragged for too long.
3.5 Stars
However, this is not a five-star read for me. I got super tired of Finola’s hot/cold mindset. It just dragged for too long.
3.5 Stars
December 16, 2023
DNF at 80%
I've enjoyed books by this author in the past, and there were times when her old style would show through, but sadly I liked very little about this book. My review is in the minority so take my thoughts with a grain of salt.
Let's talk about what I liked.
The historical information and integration were well done, and I liked learning about Irish immigrants to Illinois in 1849. Jody always does a wonderful job researching her times in history.
The Matchmaker character was fun and entertaining. Some of the family members were interesting and charming as well.
THOUGHTS:
The male main character was.... how do I put this... a cocky, and sex deprived Irish Superman.
Let me explain.
This dude is always saving people. In fact, that's how he and Finola met. He saves her. He's known as "the hero" always saving people from drowning etc. He even saves another person, randomly from a run-away coach. Apparently, no one in this town can drive.
He's also quite full of himself at times, but I guess that's what comes with a man who's going into politics.
Riley, (Irish Superman) is so hot and bothered for this girl it grated on my nerves. Now, normally I love a guy who is desperate for his woman, but they JUST met, AND hadn't said more than a few sentences to each other, when this happened.... "He needed to tear his gaze away from her, but he was a starving man at a feast. He'd denied himself womanly pleasures for so long that this glimpse was awakening hunger in him." .... This was just chapter 2.
Unfortunately, this continues throughout. Each chapter had some moment of ridiculous, fluffy and embarrassing attraction, with no foundation.
The moment that solidified I'd be DNFing soon was when Finola decided that in order to "push him away" (cause she want's to be a nun) she needs to be physical and "forward" to scare him away. Because THAT'S what makes a man walk away from a beautiful woman. When she is willingly getting handsy.
OVERALL:
I think I've spent enough time on this review. I wanted to like this book and like I said, I've had success with this author before, so this feels very deflating. I'm happy for those people who loved this.
I've enjoyed books by this author in the past, and there were times when her old style would show through, but sadly I liked very little about this book. My review is in the minority so take my thoughts with a grain of salt.
Let's talk about what I liked.
The historical information and integration were well done, and I liked learning about Irish immigrants to Illinois in 1849. Jody always does a wonderful job researching her times in history.
The Matchmaker character was fun and entertaining. Some of the family members were interesting and charming as well.
THOUGHTS:
The male main character was.... how do I put this... a cocky, and sex deprived Irish Superman.
Let me explain.
This dude is always saving people. In fact, that's how he and Finola met. He saves her. He's known as "the hero" always saving people from drowning etc. He even saves another person, randomly from a run-away coach. Apparently, no one in this town can drive.
He's also quite full of himself at times, but I guess that's what comes with a man who's going into politics.
Riley, (Irish Superman) is so hot and bothered for this girl it grated on my nerves. Now, normally I love a guy who is desperate for his woman, but they JUST met, AND hadn't said more than a few sentences to each other, when this happened.... "He needed to tear his gaze away from her, but he was a starving man at a feast. He'd denied himself womanly pleasures for so long that this glimpse was awakening hunger in him." .... This was just chapter 2.
Unfortunately, this continues throughout. Each chapter had some moment of ridiculous, fluffy and embarrassing attraction, with no foundation.
The moment that solidified I'd be DNFing soon was when Finola decided that in order to "push him away" (cause she want's to be a nun) she needs to be physical and "forward" to scare him away. Because THAT'S what makes a man walk away from a beautiful woman. When she is willingly getting handsy.
OVERALL:
I think I've spent enough time on this review. I wanted to like this book and like I said, I've had success with this author before, so this feels very deflating. I'm happy for those people who loved this.
December 12, 2023
It's great to see a historical fiction book based on immigrants from Ireland. Yes, there are others but the ones I have seen had the characters coming over and settling in New York so one where the characters are settled in St. Louis is new and exciting to me. The way the author describes the slum area is so realistic but tragic. To give everything to move to a new country, leaving behind family and friends, never to be seen again. They had such hope to see their family prosper but in many cases that never came about. The Irish were discriminated against and had such a hard time finding work. My ancestors came over from Galway and settled in Pennsylvania in the 1800's.
There is a lot going on in this book which makes it interesting. A young woman, Finola Shanahan who blames herself for the death of her baby sister feels unworthy of marrying and having children. When she is almost trampled by horses, she is saved by wagonmaker Riley Rafferty.
When her parents realize that she is not interested in any of the matches they've made for her they enlist the help of a local Irish matchmaker. Now this is where the fun comes in as she's paired with none other than Riley Rafferty, a man she already feels attracted to with her senses on high alert when he's around. Convinced she's doing the right thing; she knows she must become a nun and not marry. If only the sparks didn't fly when the two are together.
Touching on a lot of important historical topics I found the book to be relevant and interesting. I love the sense of humor the author injects into her books making the characters fun and realistic.
I greatly look forward to reading more books in this series.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from Interviews and Reviews through Bethany House Books.
November 13, 2023
This book!!! It was WONDERFUL! Full review coming soon
December 11, 2023
Jody Hedlund has wowed me again! Did I hum “Matchmaker, matchmaker make me a match. Find me a find. Catch me a catch” while I was reading? Yes, yes I did. Let me tell you, the matchmaker in this book is a young, mischievous man who has more tricks up his sleeve than Yenta. I was blown away by the unique storyline, the passionate yet clean love story, and the heartfelt drama as two endearing Irish young people with messy pasts deal with an arranged marriage. Set in St. Louis, Missouri in the 1840’s when the question of slavery was building to a fervor and cholera posed a deadly threat, the author completely captures the sights, smells, and history that made me feel like I was there. It’s a story that was so difficult to put down and I can’t wait for more!
Finola Shanahan is determined not to marry, especially after the tragic death of her sister. She wants to become a nun and continue helping those living in the Irish slums. Her family has other plans for her. Though she’s managed to reject one suitor after another, she’s finally met her literal match in Riley Rafferty. Their hilarious meet-cute leads to them becoming the latest match orchestrated by the matchmaker, Bellamy. Despite Finola’s tricks to get out of the betrothal, Riley sees through it all. As they become closer, Finola’s in danger of losing her heart, but her determination to remain single may threaten her chance for real happiness.
The charming Riley fell hard for Finola after he rescued her. He wants to become the town’s next mayor, but is pressured to take another wife after his previous wife died. Their marriage was complicated and Riley’s not interested in marrying again. But, a deathbed promise makes him seek out the matchmaker and when he’s matched with Finola, he’s not disappointed one bit. Can he convince her to give him a chance?
I loved Finola and Riley! The sizzling chemistry between them was off the charts. Their attraction was palpable and there were a few scenes where I needed a fan. Yet, the author keeps things very much closed door. I loved that while there was strong physical attraction, their friendship and bond was strong as well. They respected and challenged each other to be better. Both suffered from mistakes and hurt in the past and I enjoyed how they helped one another see through their problems. I also enjoyed the side characters, especially Bellamy. He’s a charming if sneaky matchmaker and I can’t wait to find out what happens in the next book with the captain.
I found the historical aspects so interesting. Most of the books I’ve read involving Irish immigrants are set in railroad communities or New York. It was a refreshing change to read about how the Irish fared in places like St. Louis. I also appreciated the issues Riley faced while running for mayor, especially slavery. The cholera epidemic was so sad, especially looking at it from a modern perspective where the solution is easily found in proper sanitation.
This must read story is the beginning of a new series and I’m already anxiously anticipating the next book. Highly recommend to historical romance fans. There are elements of faith brilliantly woven into the story, but they’re subtle and expressed in a natural way. If you only want a chaste kiss or two in your romance, this may not be the book for you, but if you like a little sizzle while keeping things firmly closed door, I highly recommend this! I received an advanced complimentary copy from the author and publisher. All opinions are my own and voluntarily provided.
Finola Shanahan is determined not to marry, especially after the tragic death of her sister. She wants to become a nun and continue helping those living in the Irish slums. Her family has other plans for her. Though she’s managed to reject one suitor after another, she’s finally met her literal match in Riley Rafferty. Their hilarious meet-cute leads to them becoming the latest match orchestrated by the matchmaker, Bellamy. Despite Finola’s tricks to get out of the betrothal, Riley sees through it all. As they become closer, Finola’s in danger of losing her heart, but her determination to remain single may threaten her chance for real happiness.
The charming Riley fell hard for Finola after he rescued her. He wants to become the town’s next mayor, but is pressured to take another wife after his previous wife died. Their marriage was complicated and Riley’s not interested in marrying again. But, a deathbed promise makes him seek out the matchmaker and when he’s matched with Finola, he’s not disappointed one bit. Can he convince her to give him a chance?
I loved Finola and Riley! The sizzling chemistry between them was off the charts. Their attraction was palpable and there were a few scenes where I needed a fan. Yet, the author keeps things very much closed door. I loved that while there was strong physical attraction, their friendship and bond was strong as well. They respected and challenged each other to be better. Both suffered from mistakes and hurt in the past and I enjoyed how they helped one another see through their problems. I also enjoyed the side characters, especially Bellamy. He’s a charming if sneaky matchmaker and I can’t wait to find out what happens in the next book with the captain.
I found the historical aspects so interesting. Most of the books I’ve read involving Irish immigrants are set in railroad communities or New York. It was a refreshing change to read about how the Irish fared in places like St. Louis. I also appreciated the issues Riley faced while running for mayor, especially slavery. The cholera epidemic was so sad, especially looking at it from a modern perspective where the solution is easily found in proper sanitation.
This must read story is the beginning of a new series and I’m already anxiously anticipating the next book. Highly recommend to historical romance fans. There are elements of faith brilliantly woven into the story, but they’re subtle and expressed in a natural way. If you only want a chaste kiss or two in your romance, this may not be the book for you, but if you like a little sizzle while keeping things firmly closed door, I highly recommend this! I received an advanced complimentary copy from the author and publisher. All opinions are my own and voluntarily provided.
December 21, 2023
Oh my goodness, y’all. Calling on the Matchmaker is SO FUN! I’ve been woefully behind on my Jody Hedlund reading so I couldn’t wait to dive into this new series from the very beginning. And what a treat it is! (I’ve also started the Bride Ships series this week – finally – and am LOVING it as well. Determined to get caught up!)
Fiona Shanahan is such a delightful heroine and had me laughing on more than one occasion with her courtship-avoidance antics, especially when they backfired so deliciously on her with Riley. (Still swooning over a couple of those scenes!) She has definitely met her match in Riley Rafferty, a local hero who is running for mayor. And both of them have met their match in Bellamy, the town matchmaker’s son who takes on the tough job of arranging a marriage for them both. He. Is. Hilarious! I loved him so much, and he perfectly steals the scenes he’s in with his wily tactics. Based on the last paragraphs in this story, I CANNOT WAIT for book two to see what ‘risky-but-ends-up-working-out-beautifully’ havoc he wreaks on his next clients.
I loved so many things about Calling on the Matchmaker, in addition to Bellamy’s trickery and the tangible (read: smoking hot) chemistry between Riley & Fiona. One of my favorite elements to this book is how they each deal with the tragedies in their respective backstories because it feels so authentic and relatable. We may not have experienced the same trauma as Riley or Fiona have, but we all know what it is to take on guilt and blame that’s not ours to carry and we’ve all experienced how grief indelibly shapes us. The reminder that our Heavenly Father forgives us as far as the east is from the west – and that His forgiveness sets us free – is sweetly woven through the plot in ways that feel natural to the characters and organic to the story. I also loved that, even though Fiona comes from a wealthy family, we still get to spend time with the immigrants who are living in tenements, giving us an important historical perspective that we didn’t often learn about in school.
Bottom Line: What’s a professional matchmaker to do when his clients aren’t being cooperative? Well, if you’re Bellamy McKenna, you decide that if you can’t beat them at their games you join them with some of your own. What follows is a supremely entertaining battle of wits that will delight your sense of humor – and a sizzling (but wholesome) romance that will have you reaching for your fan. Calling on the Matchmaker by Jody Hedlund is charming and absorbing, fully captivating you in the story from the death-defying opening scene to the breath-stealing romantic tension a few pages later… and all the way to the ‘just-perfect’ grand finale, complete with a compelling teaser. I’m eagerly looking forward to the second book, and I’m tempted to read this one again in the meantime because it made my whole heart smile!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
Fiona Shanahan is such a delightful heroine and had me laughing on more than one occasion with her courtship-avoidance antics, especially when they backfired so deliciously on her with Riley. (Still swooning over a couple of those scenes!) She has definitely met her match in Riley Rafferty, a local hero who is running for mayor. And both of them have met their match in Bellamy, the town matchmaker’s son who takes on the tough job of arranging a marriage for them both. He. Is. Hilarious! I loved him so much, and he perfectly steals the scenes he’s in with his wily tactics. Based on the last paragraphs in this story, I CANNOT WAIT for book two to see what ‘risky-but-ends-up-working-out-beautifully’ havoc he wreaks on his next clients.
I loved so many things about Calling on the Matchmaker, in addition to Bellamy’s trickery and the tangible (read: smoking hot) chemistry between Riley & Fiona. One of my favorite elements to this book is how they each deal with the tragedies in their respective backstories because it feels so authentic and relatable. We may not have experienced the same trauma as Riley or Fiona have, but we all know what it is to take on guilt and blame that’s not ours to carry and we’ve all experienced how grief indelibly shapes us. The reminder that our Heavenly Father forgives us as far as the east is from the west – and that His forgiveness sets us free – is sweetly woven through the plot in ways that feel natural to the characters and organic to the story. I also loved that, even though Fiona comes from a wealthy family, we still get to spend time with the immigrants who are living in tenements, giving us an important historical perspective that we didn’t often learn about in school.
Bottom Line: What’s a professional matchmaker to do when his clients aren’t being cooperative? Well, if you’re Bellamy McKenna, you decide that if you can’t beat them at their games you join them with some of your own. What follows is a supremely entertaining battle of wits that will delight your sense of humor – and a sizzling (but wholesome) romance that will have you reaching for your fan. Calling on the Matchmaker by Jody Hedlund is charming and absorbing, fully captivating you in the story from the death-defying opening scene to the breath-stealing romantic tension a few pages later… and all the way to the ‘just-perfect’ grand finale, complete with a compelling teaser. I’m eagerly looking forward to the second book, and I’m tempted to read this one again in the meantime because it made my whole heart smile!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
March 29, 2024
I reallyyyy liked the beginning of this, but quickly lost interest in the story: I've never been a fan of when side character's drama overtakes the main romance in a book- which was sort of the case for this. I also wasn't a fan of the constant will they won't they with the romance. It just made it feel pretty one-sided and rushed towards the end imo.
Both the characters and the romance just fell a little flat to me 🤷♀️.
Both the characters and the romance just fell a little flat to me 🤷♀️.
April 17, 2026
ST. Louis, Missouri. January, 1849. This book is about how Irish immigrants continue to use a matchmaker for marriages. Irish matchmaking is a centuries-old tradition where local matchmakers, often male, arranged marriages based on family compatibility, land, and dowries, rather than just love. The parties would meet in a bar or pub to work out the arrangements. The potential mates were typically supervised by chaperones until they were married.
FMC Finola Shanahan, 23 years old has just been saved from being run over in the middle of a muddy road in a poor tenement neighborhood by MMC Riley Rafferty. She’s dressed as a nun so she can help the underprivileged with the Sisters of Charity. Due to a tragedy that occurred when she was 16, Finola doesn’t believe she deserves to be married and feels her only absolution is to join the convent and do good work. Her parents disagree. They're wealthy and they’ve attempted about 12 times to match her with someone using Oscar McKenna as the matchmaker. But once she knows what her potential suitor doesn’t like, she sets about doing those things to sabotage the union. The candidate becomes discouraged and calls off courting her.
Riley’s nickname is Saint Riley because he never fails to aid someone in dangerous situations. He’s 26 and runs the Rafferty Wagon Company with his father. Business is brisk as many people heading west for the California gold rush need wagons for the long trip. He’s also running for mayor because he wants to help the downtrodden Irish immigrants have better living conditions. Being married once before, Riley has been in no hurry to marry again. When his father becomes ill with a heart attack, he makes Riley promise him that he will get married again.
Since Oscar McKenna had not been successful with the previous dozen proposed matches for Finola, he allows his son, Bellamy to provide a 13th suitor for her. Bellamy is observant and sees things his father misses, so this will be the first match put into Bellamy’s hands. And of course, he presents Riley with a match to Finola. The financial arrangement Riley makes with Mr. Shanahan is that he will purchase ironworks needed for his wagon business from Mr. Shanahan and in return, Mr. Shanahan will help financially promote Riley’s bid for mayor.
Throughout the main body of the book, Finola learns more about Riley and vice versa. He’s a good man and handsome to boot. But Finola doesn’t think she’s worthy due to her history. Riley has his own personal relationship mishap and has vowed to himself he will not push Finola into a marriage she’s not ready for.
This is a good book that shows the author did her research on the St. Louis impoverished Irish immigrants and related gangs, the discrimination that existed against the Irish in America, the cholera epidemic, and how St. Louis citizens felt about the slavery issue. The author took what was really going on historically with Ireland and St. Louis, Missouri in 1849 and built a series of four books around that time. Ms. Hedlund uses the last chapter of each book to introduce what the sequel will entail. (Yes, I'm already reading book three.)
While I enjoyed the story, Finola’s repetitious inner thoughts gave me whiplash. I liked Riley's character and my heart went out to him. He was an honorable man and what he did toward the end not only made Finola cry, but me as well.
After finishing this book, I was so tempted to watch the movie “The Quiet Man” featuring the late Barry Fitzgerald – an accomplished Irish actor. Since I enjoy this author and plan to read the remaining books in the series, my rating for this book is 3 stars.
FMC Finola Shanahan, 23 years old has just been saved from being run over in the middle of a muddy road in a poor tenement neighborhood by MMC Riley Rafferty. She’s dressed as a nun so she can help the underprivileged with the Sisters of Charity. Due to a tragedy that occurred when she was 16, Finola doesn’t believe she deserves to be married and feels her only absolution is to join the convent and do good work. Her parents disagree. They're wealthy and they’ve attempted about 12 times to match her with someone using Oscar McKenna as the matchmaker. But once she knows what her potential suitor doesn’t like, she sets about doing those things to sabotage the union. The candidate becomes discouraged and calls off courting her.
Riley’s nickname is Saint Riley because he never fails to aid someone in dangerous situations. He’s 26 and runs the Rafferty Wagon Company with his father. Business is brisk as many people heading west for the California gold rush need wagons for the long trip. He’s also running for mayor because he wants to help the downtrodden Irish immigrants have better living conditions. Being married once before, Riley has been in no hurry to marry again. When his father becomes ill with a heart attack, he makes Riley promise him that he will get married again.
Since Oscar McKenna had not been successful with the previous dozen proposed matches for Finola, he allows his son, Bellamy to provide a 13th suitor for her. Bellamy is observant and sees things his father misses, so this will be the first match put into Bellamy’s hands. And of course, he presents Riley with a match to Finola. The financial arrangement Riley makes with Mr. Shanahan is that he will purchase ironworks needed for his wagon business from Mr. Shanahan and in return, Mr. Shanahan will help financially promote Riley’s bid for mayor.
Throughout the main body of the book, Finola learns more about Riley and vice versa. He’s a good man and handsome to boot. But Finola doesn’t think she’s worthy due to her history. Riley has his own personal relationship mishap and has vowed to himself he will not push Finola into a marriage she’s not ready for.
This is a good book that shows the author did her research on the St. Louis impoverished Irish immigrants and related gangs, the discrimination that existed against the Irish in America, the cholera epidemic, and how St. Louis citizens felt about the slavery issue. The author took what was really going on historically with Ireland and St. Louis, Missouri in 1849 and built a series of four books around that time. Ms. Hedlund uses the last chapter of each book to introduce what the sequel will entail. (Yes, I'm already reading book three.)
While I enjoyed the story, Finola’s repetitious inner thoughts gave me whiplash. I liked Riley's character and my heart went out to him. He was an honorable man and what he did toward the end not only made Finola cry, but me as well.
After finishing this book, I was so tempted to watch the movie “The Quiet Man” featuring the late Barry Fitzgerald – an accomplished Irish actor. Since I enjoy this author and plan to read the remaining books in the series, my rating for this book is 3 stars.
May 24, 2024
Oh my gosh I wanted this book to be over so fast. It would have been good as a comedy, but not a romance.
This was just bad. I feel so rude saying that, but it’s true. The story was unrealistic, the characters were unbelievable, and the general writing style was not it. There were too many cringey moments to count, beginning with how the male protagonist is known by the community as “Saint Riley”. Give me a break.
What really got me was when Riley got cholera. We skipped over his actual struggle with the disease and jump into when he’s getting better, which Finola doesn’t realize, but she STILL CLIMBS INTO BED WITH HIM TO KEEP WARM AND THEN KISSES HIM. She kisses a man with a deadly disease?? Are you serious?? No. No way. I’d already tapped out at that point, but that was the final straw.
Additionally, the backstory of the characters felt like the author was trying to throw them a pity party. Finola wants to be a nun because she isn’t worthy enough to have a husband and kids because her baby sister fell down the stairs and died on her watch. I get that there’s trauma there, but her conclusion made no sense. Riley, too, had a random tragic backstory - his dad saved only him when his family (mom, dad, and two sisters) had to jump into the river to escape their boat catching on fire. Like…damn. Why all the tragedy in the background? It just felt too forced and random.
Finola’s sister eloping was another poorly developed plot point. We get very little of Enya throughout the story, and then all of a sudden she’s a rebel who runs off with her boyfriend (Lydia Bennett, anyone?) and then everyone just kind of forgets about her until she shows up again out of nowhere and tells Finola she’s pregnant. Huh???
And when I learned it was Christian fiction?? What?? No. It was not. Real Christian fiction wouldn’t have so much lust in it. I never would’ve guessed that it fell into that genre. Riley was CONSTANTLY fighting his “desire” for Finola, wishing he could “kiss every freckle on her body.” Within two chapters, Finola is changing clothes in a barn (which of course happens to be where Riley works) and he sees her half naked. Does he turn away? No. Does he leave? No. He spends the rest of the book trying not to remember what she looked like with only her “unmentionables” on. Ew. Yuck. No. Goodbye.
Not worth the read, sadly. The way this book was “sold” to me on Instagram was that the man realizes the woman is trying to scare him off, so he gives her a fake list of what he doesn’t like. The plot is supposed to be about how she does things on this list that she thinks he doesn’t like but he actually DOES like. It takes one scene for that plot to go bye-bye. She hugs him and runs her hand up his back, he kisses her, and boom that’s it. He reveals that he knew her plan after she tried two things on the list. I wish that idea had been played out more.
And yeah the cholera makeout (which was orchestrated by the matchmaker, who 1) spilled water on Finola, 2) stole the coal for the fire, and 3) removed all blankets from the house so that she’d need to either crawl in bed with a sick man or freeze to death) just really pushed me over the edge. Not over it.
This was just bad. I feel so rude saying that, but it’s true. The story was unrealistic, the characters were unbelievable, and the general writing style was not it. There were too many cringey moments to count, beginning with how the male protagonist is known by the community as “Saint Riley”. Give me a break.
What really got me was when Riley got cholera. We skipped over his actual struggle with the disease and jump into when he’s getting better, which Finola doesn’t realize, but she STILL CLIMBS INTO BED WITH HIM TO KEEP WARM AND THEN KISSES HIM. She kisses a man with a deadly disease?? Are you serious?? No. No way. I’d already tapped out at that point, but that was the final straw.
Additionally, the backstory of the characters felt like the author was trying to throw them a pity party. Finola wants to be a nun because she isn’t worthy enough to have a husband and kids because her baby sister fell down the stairs and died on her watch. I get that there’s trauma there, but her conclusion made no sense. Riley, too, had a random tragic backstory - his dad saved only him when his family (mom, dad, and two sisters) had to jump into the river to escape their boat catching on fire. Like…damn. Why all the tragedy in the background? It just felt too forced and random.
Finola’s sister eloping was another poorly developed plot point. We get very little of Enya throughout the story, and then all of a sudden she’s a rebel who runs off with her boyfriend (Lydia Bennett, anyone?) and then everyone just kind of forgets about her until she shows up again out of nowhere and tells Finola she’s pregnant. Huh???
And when I learned it was Christian fiction?? What?? No. It was not. Real Christian fiction wouldn’t have so much lust in it. I never would’ve guessed that it fell into that genre. Riley was CONSTANTLY fighting his “desire” for Finola, wishing he could “kiss every freckle on her body.” Within two chapters, Finola is changing clothes in a barn (which of course happens to be where Riley works) and he sees her half naked. Does he turn away? No. Does he leave? No. He spends the rest of the book trying not to remember what she looked like with only her “unmentionables” on. Ew. Yuck. No. Goodbye.
Not worth the read, sadly. The way this book was “sold” to me on Instagram was that the man realizes the woman is trying to scare him off, so he gives her a fake list of what he doesn’t like. The plot is supposed to be about how she does things on this list that she thinks he doesn’t like but he actually DOES like. It takes one scene for that plot to go bye-bye. She hugs him and runs her hand up his back, he kisses her, and boom that’s it. He reveals that he knew her plan after she tried two things on the list. I wish that idea had been played out more.
And yeah the cholera makeout (which was orchestrated by the matchmaker, who 1) spilled water on Finola, 2) stole the coal for the fire, and 3) removed all blankets from the house so that she’d need to either crawl in bed with a sick man or freeze to death) just really pushed me over the edge. Not over it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 27, 2023
1849 St Louis
Charming! What a lovely start to a new series.
Due to a childhood tragedy Finola Shanahan has decided to become a nun rather than pursue marriage and a family. Finola has become quite the expert at driving away potential suitors.
Riley Rafferty has no interest in marriage after his first one was a failure. However, can a son deny his father's deathbed wish?
And enter matchmaker Bellamy McKenna. I adored Bellamy with his confidence despite Finola and Riley being his first attempt at matchmaking.
Lots of history. Lots of Irish brogue.
My gratitude to publisher Bethany House for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Charming! What a lovely start to a new series.
Due to a childhood tragedy Finola Shanahan has decided to become a nun rather than pursue marriage and a family. Finola has become quite the expert at driving away potential suitors.
Riley Rafferty has no interest in marriage after his first one was a failure. However, can a son deny his father's deathbed wish?
And enter matchmaker Bellamy McKenna. I adored Bellamy with his confidence despite Finola and Riley being his first attempt at matchmaking.
Lots of history. Lots of Irish brogue.
My gratitude to publisher Bethany House for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
June 26, 2023
From the opening rescue scene covered in mud, through the slow-burn love story and the trials and disappointments of life in the mid-1800s, to that wonderful promise of HEA, Calling on the Matchmaker is an historical romance reader’s delight. Treat yourself! Jody Hedlund does not disappoint.
January 23, 2024
This book had so much potential. However, Finola’s resistance was just too much. Her reason for avoiding marriage, her reason for wanting to enter the convent, and for never talking to her family about what troubled her.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 20, 2023
My first introduction to Jody Hedlund, I didn't really connect with the characters too much but I enjoyed the story and I especially loved the matchmaker. I loved the antics the matchmaker went through to get the pair together.
I can't wait for the second book, as at the end of this story there was a hint to the next one and I have a feeling I know who the next couple will be.
*thank you to Baker Publishing for a copy of this book to read and review, all thoughts are my own.
I can't wait for the second book, as at the end of this story there was a hint to the next one and I have a feeling I know who the next couple will be.
*thank you to Baker Publishing for a copy of this book to read and review, all thoughts are my own.
January 6, 2024
I am quite upset with myself for not DNF'ing this book. Note for self: if something pisses you off every couple of pages, don't try to power through. Just leave it be.
So what are my issues with this book? There are at least four that I can think of at this moment.
1. Riley comes across as a sex-deprived man thirsting after Finola. The one star I have given to this book is because there are some good moments between Riley and Finola, where he tries to bond with her emotionally, gets her to open up, and respects her opinions. But him lusting after her, recalling her in her underthings repeatedly after only the first/second meeting, and being hung up on making out with her no matter the situation or place far outweighs the moments of emotional bonding. I guess, it's because of the imbalance between the physical and emotional aspects of their relationship and the terms used by the author to describe his ardour for her is why he seemed more in lust with her than in love.
2. The matchmaker is an arrogant, dishonourable and manipulative A-hole whose despicable actions are glorified and applauded. He literally creates a scandal, with no regard and respect for our heroine's feelings or reputation, to force her into a marriage with the hero. And this despicable man is presented as this gifted matchmaker who we, the readers, as well as the characters ought to be in awe of. Yeah, right!
3. Riley's tendency to air his dirty laundry in public. He sees Finola in her undergarments, he blurts that out to the matchmaker and to his father. Who does that? He gets rejected by Finola, he announces it to the entire pub and has elaborate discussion with everyone about it. Again, who does that? It was so annoying to see anybody and everybody in the town be a part of a relationship that was nobody's business except for the ones who are in the relationship.
4. This issue may seem tiny to others, but it annoyed me to no end. So, Finola gets her brother, Madigan, to find out all the things that her prospective suitors hate and then does all those to chase them away. Naturally, when it's Riley's turn, she follows the same strategy. But you know what Madigan does? He goes to collect information about Riley from Riley's family members while the guy is at home. For someone who regularly conducts subterfuge like this, you would think he would be more cautious and covert about it. But no! He can't even bother to check if Riley is at home or not. For a book that threw the word 'clever' around a couple of times, none of the character were above average smart.
This was my first book by Jody Hedlund. I had shelved a few books by her to read...but I am not sure if I want to anymore. I am definitely not reading any more books from this series. I absolutely can't tolerate the matchmaker.
I am just very disappointed that my first read of this year has been such a dud, and that also a book that had such a promising set up.
So what are my issues with this book? There are at least four that I can think of at this moment.
1. Riley comes across as a sex-deprived man thirsting after Finola. The one star I have given to this book is because there are some good moments between Riley and Finola, where he tries to bond with her emotionally, gets her to open up, and respects her opinions. But him lusting after her, recalling her in her underthings repeatedly after only the first/second meeting, and being hung up on making out with her no matter the situation or place far outweighs the moments of emotional bonding. I guess, it's because of the imbalance between the physical and emotional aspects of their relationship and the terms used by the author to describe his ardour for her is why he seemed more in lust with her than in love.
2. The matchmaker is an arrogant, dishonourable and manipulative A-hole whose despicable actions are glorified and applauded. He literally creates a scandal, with no regard and respect for our heroine's feelings or reputation, to force her into a marriage with the hero. And this despicable man is presented as this gifted matchmaker who we, the readers, as well as the characters ought to be in awe of. Yeah, right!
3. Riley's tendency to air his dirty laundry in public. He sees Finola in her undergarments, he blurts that out to the matchmaker and to his father. Who does that? He gets rejected by Finola, he announces it to the entire pub and has elaborate discussion with everyone about it. Again, who does that? It was so annoying to see anybody and everybody in the town be a part of a relationship that was nobody's business except for the ones who are in the relationship.
4. This issue may seem tiny to others, but it annoyed me to no end. So, Finola gets her brother, Madigan, to find out all the things that her prospective suitors hate and then does all those to chase them away. Naturally, when it's Riley's turn, she follows the same strategy. But you know what Madigan does? He goes to collect information about Riley from Riley's family members while the guy is at home. For someone who regularly conducts subterfuge like this, you would think he would be more cautious and covert about it. But no! He can't even bother to check if Riley is at home or not. For a book that threw the word 'clever' around a couple of times, none of the character were above average smart.
This was my first book by Jody Hedlund. I had shelved a few books by her to read...but I am not sure if I want to anymore. I am definitely not reading any more books from this series. I absolutely can't tolerate the matchmaker.
I am just very disappointed that my first read of this year has been such a dud, and that also a book that had such a promising set up.
January 9, 2024
Календарът показва 9 януари. Зимен ден в началото на 2024 - та година.
Calling on the Matchmaker ме среща с Райли и Финола - наследници на емигранти от Ирландия. Те продължават традицията на родителите си да се грижат за бедните и новопристигналите в Америка свои сънародници. Всеки по свой начин дава своя принос за доброто на общността. Но когато стане дума за желанието на близките им да ги видят обвързани с любим човек, тогава на дневен ред излизат хитрости, увъртания, криене и всякакъв вид опит за измъкване от примката.
Любимият ирландски грог в тембъра на героите, симпатични личности, остроумни ситуации и съвсем честно описание на привличането, което един човек може да изпитва към друг. Действието се развива през януари 1849 година в Сент Луис. Там е студена зима и аз мога да се потопя в атмосферата на книгата.
Calling on the Matchmaker ме среща с Райли и Финола - наследници на емигранти от Ирландия. Те продължават традицията на родителите си да се грижат за бедните и новопристигналите в Америка свои сънародници. Всеки по свой начин дава своя принос за доброто на общността. Но когато стане дума за желанието на близките им да ги видят обвързани с любим човек, тогава на дневен ред излизат хитрости, увъртания, криене и всякакъв вид опит за измъкване от примката.
Любимият ирландски грог в тембъра на героите, симпатични личности, остроумни ситуации и съвсем честно описание на привличането, което един човек може да изпитва към друг. Действието се развива през януари 1849 година в Сент Луис. Там е студена зима и аз мога да се потопя в атмосферата на книгата.
March 25, 2024
God that book was awful. These people need to be lobotomized.
November 26, 2023
I was expecting a lot from the description of this book, as I've always liked the author's previous books. However, Calling on the Matchmaker by Jody Hedlund left me with mixed emotions.
The story has a great premise. Finola Shanahan is determined to thwart the suitors her parents have been shoving at her. She feels a need to punish herself because of her sister's death. Frustrated, her father hires a matchmaker to get his daughter married once and for all. Enter Riley Rafferty (or Saint Riley, as he is known). When his father is on his deathbed, he makes Riley promise to get married. Not wanting to disappoint his father, he agrees to meet the matchmaker, not knowing that Finola is determined to do everything in her power to make him dislike her in order to call off the match.
While this book has its moments of amusement and seriousness, it takes on a decidedly "unchristian" feel when almost page after page talks about how badly Riley (and then Finola) lusted for each other. The descriptions are very visual, and I was surprised to find them in a book marketed for Christians. The lack of Christian content was also disheartening and instead leaned toward Catholicism.
I did enjoy the story and was happy to see both characters grow, but in the end, I am not sure I could recommend this book to anyone because of the visually descriptive sexual thoughts of the characters. I give it three stars.
I received a complimentary review copy courtesy of Bethany House through NetGalley for my honest opinion.
The story has a great premise. Finola Shanahan is determined to thwart the suitors her parents have been shoving at her. She feels a need to punish herself because of her sister's death. Frustrated, her father hires a matchmaker to get his daughter married once and for all. Enter Riley Rafferty (or Saint Riley, as he is known). When his father is on his deathbed, he makes Riley promise to get married. Not wanting to disappoint his father, he agrees to meet the matchmaker, not knowing that Finola is determined to do everything in her power to make him dislike her in order to call off the match.
While this book has its moments of amusement and seriousness, it takes on a decidedly "unchristian" feel when almost page after page talks about how badly Riley (and then Finola) lusted for each other. The descriptions are very visual, and I was surprised to find them in a book marketed for Christians. The lack of Christian content was also disheartening and instead leaned toward Catholicism.
I did enjoy the story and was happy to see both characters grow, but in the end, I am not sure I could recommend this book to anyone because of the visually descriptive sexual thoughts of the characters. I give it three stars.
I received a complimentary review copy courtesy of Bethany House through NetGalley for my honest opinion.
November 24, 2023
I have always loved Jody Hedlund’s books and so when I got a chance to read this one as an ARC I just couldn't say no! This book definitely fulfilled my expectations and I loved it so much!
I love that in it we get to see the main theme of forgiveness. Not only forgiveness of others but most importantly forgiving ourselves. I also love that Jody always shows readers what it is like historically in the books she writes and this one is no different. She writes descriptions of living in Missouri in the mid 1800s in a way that I could easily picture the harsh realities of life then, especially for the poorer Irish immigrants.
I love that we get to see the FMC Finola’s journey of not only finding her true love, but also confronting her past so she can have a joyful future. I love that she serves others that are going through hardships and she hasn't let the difference in station make her proud or too high and mighty to do her part to help. I love that we get to see why she keeps her suitors from falling for her and that Riley is finally the man to break down the walls around her heart.
I love that Riley is just an all around great guy. I love that he thinks of others, serves others, and doesn't even think twice before running into danger. I love that he falls for Finola first and falls hard! But at the same time he doesn't rush Finola and just wants to be loved for being himself.
I love the scheming matchmaker Bellamy and that this entire series will be about him and the matches he can create. He is such a quirky guy who you can't help but love too.
If you are looking for a wonderful historical romance with sizzle, heart, and an all around amazing story definitely give this one a go!
Physical Intimacy Lvl 3 (Descriptive making out)
Zero Swearing
Triggers: Infant and Family member deaths
Dual POV
One Bed
Takes care of Riley when he is sick
Irish MCs
Christian aspects
Opposites Attract
He Falls First
I love that in it we get to see the main theme of forgiveness. Not only forgiveness of others but most importantly forgiving ourselves. I also love that Jody always shows readers what it is like historically in the books she writes and this one is no different. She writes descriptions of living in Missouri in the mid 1800s in a way that I could easily picture the harsh realities of life then, especially for the poorer Irish immigrants.
I love that we get to see the FMC Finola’s journey of not only finding her true love, but also confronting her past so she can have a joyful future. I love that she serves others that are going through hardships and she hasn't let the difference in station make her proud or too high and mighty to do her part to help. I love that we get to see why she keeps her suitors from falling for her and that Riley is finally the man to break down the walls around her heart.
I love that Riley is just an all around great guy. I love that he thinks of others, serves others, and doesn't even think twice before running into danger. I love that he falls for Finola first and falls hard! But at the same time he doesn't rush Finola and just wants to be loved for being himself.
I love the scheming matchmaker Bellamy and that this entire series will be about him and the matches he can create. He is such a quirky guy who you can't help but love too.
If you are looking for a wonderful historical romance with sizzle, heart, and an all around amazing story definitely give this one a go!
Physical Intimacy Lvl 3 (Descriptive making out)
Zero Swearing
Triggers: Infant and Family member deaths
Dual POV
One Bed
Takes care of Riley when he is sick
Irish MCs
Christian aspects
Opposites Attract
He Falls First
December 12, 2023
I simply adored this novel and am so happy that it is the start of a new series! These two main characters, Riley and Finola, were so drawn to each other, even when at the very beginning, neither one really had a desire to be married. However, Riley soon realized that he cared more for Finola than he had ever cared for anyone before. He fell fast and he fell hard!
Yet, Finola was not an easy win. Even though she agreed to marry him and outwardly appeared to work with the matchmaker to appease her family, this woman carried an enormous weight of guilt that blanketed her every thought and action. There were a few times when her heart slipped through and she connected with Riley, but she felt so undeserving, she quickly tried to shut those feelings down.
I loved this story from start to finish. Riley and Finola were so perfect for each other. The unique and fascinating setting, with Irish immigrants and main characters who wanted to make the world a better place for those who were struggling, and the wonderful romantic tension between Riley and Finola has me truly eager to read the next in the series, which looks to be an absolutely captivating tale.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
Yet, Finola was not an easy win. Even though she agreed to marry him and outwardly appeared to work with the matchmaker to appease her family, this woman carried an enormous weight of guilt that blanketed her every thought and action. There were a few times when her heart slipped through and she connected with Riley, but she felt so undeserving, she quickly tried to shut those feelings down.
I loved this story from start to finish. Riley and Finola were so perfect for each other. The unique and fascinating setting, with Irish immigrants and main characters who wanted to make the world a better place for those who were struggling, and the wonderful romantic tension between Riley and Finola has me truly eager to read the next in the series, which looks to be an absolutely captivating tale.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
February 11, 2024
This one is hard to review. To preface, I usually enjoy Jody Hedlund’s books. Her novel, Never Forget, was a 5-Star read for me last month. If Calling on the Matchmaker had been a secular romance, rather than Christian Fiction, it would have been a solid 4 stars. The storyline was great, the main characters had wonderful chemistry, and it was well written. I blazed through it in less than two days. But, as a Christian Fiction novel, there were 3 areas I had trouble with, hence only 3 stars:
1. The level of attention placed on physical attraction was higher than I thought appropriate. Although not explicit, there is a lot of discussion around Riley’s internal sexual thoughts and both characters’ arousal. There is also a wedding scene where the couple starts making out after the vows and the priest just keeps saying Mass over them. No way that’s happening.
2. There was minimal talk about faith. It was included, but not enough to stand out as a “Christian” novel.
3. All of the characters were Catholic, but it was clear that a Catholic had not reviewed the book. As a Catholic myself, I noticed many inaccuracies, with a few significant enough to find jolting. There were several Protestant items that were just relabeled as applying to Catholicism, when the story would have benefited more from just making the characters Protestants.
1. The level of attention placed on physical attraction was higher than I thought appropriate. Although not explicit, there is a lot of discussion around Riley’s internal sexual thoughts and both characters’ arousal. There is also a wedding scene where the couple starts making out after the vows and the priest just keeps saying Mass over them. No way that’s happening.
2. There was minimal talk about faith. It was included, but not enough to stand out as a “Christian” novel.
3. All of the characters were Catholic, but it was clear that a Catholic had not reviewed the book. As a Catholic myself, I noticed many inaccuracies, with a few significant enough to find jolting. There were several Protestant items that were just relabeled as applying to Catholicism, when the story would have benefited more from just making the characters Protestants.
December 11, 2023
A brand new series focuses on matchmaking in the Irish community in St Louis in 1849.
Ms. Hedlund has written a complex hero who aspires to be the mayor of a growing St Louis. Riley Rafferty has a heart for immigrants and wants to improve conditions. A widower who has no desire to marry again, he is convinced that a good match would further his chances of winning the election. He calls on matchmaker Bellamy for help. The candidate is Finole Shanahan who has put off twelve suitors and wants to become a nun. This stems from guilt concerning an incident in her past. As she tries to thwart advances by Riley, things backfire instead.
The narrative puts you right in the story. The premise was funny and the characters showed growth throughout the book. They looked past their physical attraction into their deeper motivations of helping people. The sizzle level made me a little uncomfortable, although the story was well paced and interesting and gave hints of what book two will bring.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House on behalf of the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
Ms. Hedlund has written a complex hero who aspires to be the mayor of a growing St Louis. Riley Rafferty has a heart for immigrants and wants to improve conditions. A widower who has no desire to marry again, he is convinced that a good match would further his chances of winning the election. He calls on matchmaker Bellamy for help. The candidate is Finole Shanahan who has put off twelve suitors and wants to become a nun. This stems from guilt concerning an incident in her past. As she tries to thwart advances by Riley, things backfire instead.
The narrative puts you right in the story. The premise was funny and the characters showed growth throughout the book. They looked past their physical attraction into their deeper motivations of helping people. The sizzle level made me a little uncomfortable, although the story was well paced and interesting and gave hints of what book two will bring.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House on behalf of the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
December 6, 2023
As soon as this popped up on NetGalley I requested it to review and was tickled when it was granted earlier this week! I quickly moved it up the line and dove into this new novel from Jody Hedlund.
I had to laugh because this book involved an Irish matchmaker--something I just read about in the soon to be released book The Irish Matchmaker by Jennifer Deibel. Because of Jennifer Deibel's book, I knew what many of the terms were in Jody Hedlund's book. I love it when that happens!
Now let's get to my thoughts on the book.
As the synopsis shares, this book is about Finola and Riley. Two very strong characters with childhood trauma that defines their actions today. Finola blames herelf for the death of her baby sister vowing to live a life serving God as a nun rather than as a wife or mother. For how could she trust herself as a mother when she let her baby sister die?
Riley aka Saint Riley is a strapping young man who grabs life by the horns and is known for rushing in to help and save anyone and everyone without through of the risk to himself. He's a widow with no room for any woman. He's determined to run for mayor so he can help his town and immigrant brothers and sisters who struggle to survive.
Finola and Riely get thrown together when Finola's father hires the local matchmaker to find his daughter a husband. Not long afterwards, Riley promises his dying father he will get married again and seeks out the matchmaker. the matchmaker brings the two together sure they will be perfect for each other...
and that's when the fun begins. I love how Finola schemes to make herself undesirable to any man to avoid marriage. and how that backfires when Riley figures out her tricks and sabatoges her plans.
The book follows the ups and downs of their courtship--as Finola keeps deciding to wait a little longer before ending the match--and Riley decides he absolutely wants to marry Finola.
One thing you will notice right from the get go---as has been the case with the latest of Jody's books---the characters have serious sexual tension. and I mean--serious. you don't get far into the book before Riley is lusting over Finola. and eventually finola herself gets heated up. This goes to the point of--well, about ready to ravish each other.
it honestly is getting to be too much in her books lately. Their heated glances and thoughts distract from so much of the plot.
Plot itself--it was a good plot. I enjoyed the story line. I also like how the last chapter prepares you for book #2. And I have a feeling that we will be seeing Finola's sister Enya again.
4 stars. it was interesting, but I didn't love it.
**I was given a copy of this ARC from the publisher and Net Galley. i wasn't required to write a positive review and all opinions shared are my own.
I had to laugh because this book involved an Irish matchmaker--something I just read about in the soon to be released book The Irish Matchmaker by Jennifer Deibel. Because of Jennifer Deibel's book, I knew what many of the terms were in Jody Hedlund's book. I love it when that happens!
Now let's get to my thoughts on the book.
As the synopsis shares, this book is about Finola and Riley. Two very strong characters with childhood trauma that defines their actions today. Finola blames herelf for the death of her baby sister vowing to live a life serving God as a nun rather than as a wife or mother. For how could she trust herself as a mother when she let her baby sister die?
Riley aka Saint Riley is a strapping young man who grabs life by the horns and is known for rushing in to help and save anyone and everyone without through of the risk to himself. He's a widow with no room for any woman. He's determined to run for mayor so he can help his town and immigrant brothers and sisters who struggle to survive.
Finola and Riely get thrown together when Finola's father hires the local matchmaker to find his daughter a husband. Not long afterwards, Riley promises his dying father he will get married again and seeks out the matchmaker. the matchmaker brings the two together sure they will be perfect for each other...
and that's when the fun begins. I love how Finola schemes to make herself undesirable to any man to avoid marriage. and how that backfires when Riley figures out her tricks and sabatoges her plans.
The book follows the ups and downs of their courtship--as Finola keeps deciding to wait a little longer before ending the match--and Riley decides he absolutely wants to marry Finola.
One thing you will notice right from the get go---as has been the case with the latest of Jody's books---the characters have serious sexual tension. and I mean--serious. you don't get far into the book before Riley is lusting over Finola. and eventually finola herself gets heated up. This goes to the point of--well, about ready to ravish each other.
it honestly is getting to be too much in her books lately. Their heated glances and thoughts distract from so much of the plot.
Plot itself--it was a good plot. I enjoyed the story line. I also like how the last chapter prepares you for book #2. And I have a feeling that we will be seeing Finola's sister Enya again.
4 stars. it was interesting, but I didn't love it.
**I was given a copy of this ARC from the publisher and Net Galley. i wasn't required to write a positive review and all opinions shared are my own.
December 30, 2023
This was WILD but in a pretty fun way! Finila was kind of frustrating but I LOOOVE Riley Rafferty and the family/community aspects were strong. Bellamy the Matchmaker is actually a diamond and I kind of hope he gets a book too. Added some much-needed comic relief with all his scheming- I mean, matchmaking.
December 10, 2023
“From the moment he’d rescued Finola Shanahan that day in the mud, it was almost as if she’d taken his heart captive. And now it was hers. He didn’t want it back. But he wanted hers in return.”
It’s always a joy to read Jody Hedlund’s stories, and this new series starter was an absolute delight! I loved it!
After a a childhood tragedy that Finola Shanahan blames herself for, she decides to become a nun to pay her penance, rather than getting married and having a family. After driving away several suitors, Finola’s parents call in the help of an Irish matchmaker.
Riley Rafferty was married before, and blames himself for its failure. He has no interest in getting married again, but he can’t say no to his father's deathbed request that he remarry.
When he learns the matchmaker has picked Finola as his intended, Riley is elated and he’s prepared for Finola to thwart his efforts at winning her heart.
Jody is a wonderful storyteller and always does a masterful job in creating colorful and relatable characters. The chemistry and the push and pull between these two was intense and so enjoyable. I loved the blend of humor, a bit of heartache, and the clean but sizzling romance.
The setting of St. Louis, Missouri in 1849 was obviously well researched and vividly portrayed, as was the life of the Irish immigrants that lived in the area.
A highlight of the book was Bellamy McKenna, the matchmaker. I adored him! He knew these two were right for each other, and was not above scheming to help them come together. I look forward to seeing more of him in the next book.
I loved this sweet and heartwarming story, with its themes of unconditional love and the importance of forgiveness, especially the forgiveness of oneself. I’m really excited for the next book in the series!
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book by NetGalley, Bethany House Publishers, and Austenprose PR. All opinions expressed are my own.
It’s always a joy to read Jody Hedlund’s stories, and this new series starter was an absolute delight! I loved it!
After a a childhood tragedy that Finola Shanahan blames herself for, she decides to become a nun to pay her penance, rather than getting married and having a family. After driving away several suitors, Finola’s parents call in the help of an Irish matchmaker.
Riley Rafferty was married before, and blames himself for its failure. He has no interest in getting married again, but he can’t say no to his father's deathbed request that he remarry.
When he learns the matchmaker has picked Finola as his intended, Riley is elated and he’s prepared for Finola to thwart his efforts at winning her heart.
Jody is a wonderful storyteller and always does a masterful job in creating colorful and relatable characters. The chemistry and the push and pull between these two was intense and so enjoyable. I loved the blend of humor, a bit of heartache, and the clean but sizzling romance.
The setting of St. Louis, Missouri in 1849 was obviously well researched and vividly portrayed, as was the life of the Irish immigrants that lived in the area.
A highlight of the book was Bellamy McKenna, the matchmaker. I adored him! He knew these two were right for each other, and was not above scheming to help them come together. I look forward to seeing more of him in the next book.
I loved this sweet and heartwarming story, with its themes of unconditional love and the importance of forgiveness, especially the forgiveness of oneself. I’m really excited for the next book in the series!
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book by NetGalley, Bethany House Publishers, and Austenprose PR. All opinions expressed are my own.
December 15, 2023
2.5
First I should say that this book toed the line of "clean" romance; it's very physical. Riley sees Finola nearly naked (undergarments) at the beginning and fixates on it throughout the rest of the book. That might be realistic, but then I'd rather not be in his head at those times. Better yet, not at all. I'm advocating, as always, for ONE POV. And it's not limited to that one instance; both characters obsess on each others' looks and sex appeal for the whole. entire. book.
Then they play the same back and forth games: I shall push him away! I will win her over! rinse, repeat.
It got old quickly and there just was not much substance here, despite throwing in Cholera, racism/discrimination, bonding over loss/trauma, volunteer work, etc.
And I was not at all a fan of the way the Matchmaker chose to bring them together - particularly trying to force their hands with a set up and public exposure/humiliation. Ugh.
However I have loved Ms. Hedlund's books in the past, so I would give the second one a shot before deciding whether to continue on with this series or not. Especially since the premise sounds interesting - has a Beauty and the Beast tone to it.
First I should say that this book toed the line of "clean" romance; it's very physical. Riley sees Finola nearly naked (undergarments) at the beginning and fixates on it throughout the rest of the book. That might be realistic, but then I'd rather not be in his head at those times. Better yet, not at all. I'm advocating, as always, for ONE POV. And it's not limited to that one instance; both characters obsess on each others' looks and sex appeal for the whole. entire. book.
Then they play the same back and forth games: I shall push him away! I will win her over! rinse, repeat.
It got old quickly and there just was not much substance here, despite throwing in Cholera, racism/discrimination, bonding over loss/trauma, volunteer work, etc.
And I was not at all a fan of the way the Matchmaker chose to bring them together - particularly trying to force their hands with a set up and public exposure/humiliation. Ugh.
However I have loved Ms. Hedlund's books in the past, so I would give the second one a shot before deciding whether to continue on with this series or not. Especially since the premise sounds interesting - has a Beauty and the Beast tone to it.
December 14, 2023
Determined to never marry and dedicate her life to the church, Finola Shanahan, is willing to do whatever it takes to ruin the match between herself and the dashing Riley Rafferty.
A riveting romance, sparkling with flirtation, that was nearly impossible to put down. I loved getting to know the Shanahan family, and I'm definitely looking forward to seeing more of Bellamy the matchmaker in the future! Riley is a likable man of action, always ready to come to the aid of those around him, with a natural gift for leadership.
This was such a fun read, and over far too quickly, I loved the strong themes of faith and family throughout, as well as the flirty humor that had me grinning. A wonderful read from beginning to end, with a rich Irish culture and historical setting. I can't wait to read the next book in the series!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
A riveting romance, sparkling with flirtation, that was nearly impossible to put down. I loved getting to know the Shanahan family, and I'm definitely looking forward to seeing more of Bellamy the matchmaker in the future! Riley is a likable man of action, always ready to come to the aid of those around him, with a natural gift for leadership.
This was such a fun read, and over far too quickly, I loved the strong themes of faith and family throughout, as well as the flirty humor that had me grinning. A wonderful read from beginning to end, with a rich Irish culture and historical setting. I can't wait to read the next book in the series!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Did Not Finish
March 25, 2024First two chapters were enough for me. Way too much backstory dumping, a forced meet-cute followed by a scene in which the hero follows the heroine into a stable and proceeds to ogle her in her wet undergarments? PASS.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 761 reviews