Moss Manor and Aunt Erica aren't quite what foster teen Beth was expecting, and she becomes even more unsure when she starts hearing sinister whispers from behind locked doors. Also, Beth is overweight, and a lot of people do not approve. So begins some Mean Girls drama at Beth's new high school, and there's also some small town drama, and it's possible that Aunt Erica has been hiding information from Beth for an entire two weeks about whether or not she's been involved in an affair, and also Beth meets a girl who could be her new best friend and the girl's brother, who is kind of cute. But also everyone has mental health disorders. Oh, and eventually there's a dead body, which is pretty spooky, but we can't do anything about that, so maybe we should talk about gypsies, and since that isn't very interesting, let's add some romantic tension and a terrible argument. Did I mention Beth was overweight? No one else has forgotten. And then the whispers are back, and there's something about a secret and some spell books and possibly a demon, and wow, look at this crazy weather.
Don't let my synopsis fool you. While there's certainly commentary on foster care/family relationships/substance abuse/high school drama/small town drama/trust/friendship/young romance/mental health/a murder mystery/romantic drama/family secrets/magic/travelers/demons/supernatural weather/other subplots, this book is mostly about Beth being overweight and trying to decide if she should try to change that.
But, Sirah, this book is only 300 pages; how does all that fit in?
Poorly.
There were a lot of good parts in this book, but they felt disjointed because the book was doing so much that it never managed to fully commit to anything or satisfactorily resolve much. Since this book was marketed to me as a murder mystery, I was expecting a body to show up sooner than 40% through the book. And witches? They aren't even mentioned with any amount of seriousness until 80% of the way through. I can chalk that up to a weird twist of the market, but that still doesn't excuse the writing style, which had to be completely unsubtle to fit everything in, which didn't allow me to get to know the characters organically. That's a bummer, as I think I really would have liked Flora and Heath and even Beth and Erica.