What do you think?
Rate this book
Kate Hanson #5
The Coldest Death
Please note this book was previously published as Cold, Cold Heart .
Forensic psychologist Kate Hanson re-examines a brutal ten-year-old murder case in this deliciously twisty crime mystery.
Then.
Famous novelist David Lockman is convicted of murdering Della Harrington. He’s sentenced to life in prison.
Now.
Lockman walks free after ten years in jail. A miscarriage of justice.
But if he didn’t kill Della, who did?
Kate is determined to get justice for Della. But her search for the truth will lead her down a dark path and jeopardize everything she’s ever worked for.
Forensic psychologist Kate Hanson re-examines a brutal ten-year-old murder case in this deliciously twisty crime mystery.
Then.
Famous novelist David Lockman is convicted of murdering Della Harrington. He’s sentenced to life in prison.
Now.
Lockman walks free after ten years in jail. A miscarriage of justice.
But if he didn’t kill Della, who did?
Kate is determined to get justice for Della. But her search for the truth will lead her down a dark path and jeopardize everything she’s ever worked for.
- GenresMysteryProcedural
325 pages, Kindle Edition
First published December 1, 2018
261 people are currently reading
141 people want to read
About the author
A.J. Cross
20 books88 followersA.J. Cross is a forensic psychologist and frequent court-appointed expert witness. She obtained her Masters Degree and PhD at the University of Birmingham, the latter relating to children as witnesses within the criminal court system. Her professional experience has included consultancy work for the Probation Service within its sexual offender unit in her home city. She currently lives in the West Midlands with her musician husband.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
November 4, 2018
AJ Cross writes the fourth in the forensic psychologist, Professor Kate Hanson series set in Birmingham. It is the first book for me, but I found it works perfectly fine as a standalone. It begins with the murder of 30 year old call centre supervisor, Della Harrington in her flat, with her dead body displayed in such a fashion that it suggests that the killer is a sexual predator. A novelist, David Lockman, has served 10 years in prison for Della's murder before the Court of Appeal rules his conviction as unsafe and a miscarriage of justice. With the media focus on the freeing of Lockman, The new police investigation into the murder becomes the responsibility of the Unsolved Crime Unit (UCU) run by DI Bernard Watts, with seconded Boston PD lieutenant, Joseph Carrington. Kate is to be involved on a part time basis whilst she continues with her academic duties. Chief Superintendent Maurice Gander expects results and fast, but it is no easy matter to solve this cold case.
Kate has a 14 year old daughter, Maisie, a whizz at Maths studying part time at the university and a handful. Charlie, Kate's stepfather, has re-entered the family and Kate is keen to keep him close. Her private life is an emotional desert, with Kate determined to protect herself by only getting involved in short term relationships that have no future. The American Corrigan has feelings for her that Kate is keeping at bay. The UCU identify and focus on three possible suspects that might fit their sexual predator killer theory. Steffan Coultard, a member of a operatic performing group with Della, and socially awkward in his relationships with women. Archie Fenton, the maintenance guy with a fondness for pornography, and property management man, Leonard Dobbs, with a penchant for preying on female tenants that are struggling financially. Interspersed in the narrative is the menacing presence of the Watcher, intent on ensuring the murder does not get solved. As Kate begins to question whether the assumptions underlying their profile of the killer are correct, she finds herself in hot water as she insists on investigating in forbidden areas.
This is an enjoyable cold case police procedural despite being occasionally predictable. I did find it hard initially to get a complete handle on Kate as a person, but I did jump into the middle of a series but I got to like her character, her complex family dynamics and personal relationships. The cold case team worked well together, even when a team member is pushed out in the cold. They have the tortuous task of addressing the failings of the original murder inquiry, interview people about decade old events and hone into the identity of the true killer whilst under severe pressure from the police hierarchy and the media. I found this an entertaining and compelling piece of crime fiction. Many thanks to Severn House for an ARC.
Kate has a 14 year old daughter, Maisie, a whizz at Maths studying part time at the university and a handful. Charlie, Kate's stepfather, has re-entered the family and Kate is keen to keep him close. Her private life is an emotional desert, with Kate determined to protect herself by only getting involved in short term relationships that have no future. The American Corrigan has feelings for her that Kate is keeping at bay. The UCU identify and focus on three possible suspects that might fit their sexual predator killer theory. Steffan Coultard, a member of a operatic performing group with Della, and socially awkward in his relationships with women. Archie Fenton, the maintenance guy with a fondness for pornography, and property management man, Leonard Dobbs, with a penchant for preying on female tenants that are struggling financially. Interspersed in the narrative is the menacing presence of the Watcher, intent on ensuring the murder does not get solved. As Kate begins to question whether the assumptions underlying their profile of the killer are correct, she finds herself in hot water as she insists on investigating in forbidden areas.
This is an enjoyable cold case police procedural despite being occasionally predictable. I did find it hard initially to get a complete handle on Kate as a person, but I did jump into the middle of a series but I got to like her character, her complex family dynamics and personal relationships. The cold case team worked well together, even when a team member is pushed out in the cold. They have the tortuous task of addressing the failings of the original murder inquiry, interview people about decade old events and hone into the identity of the true killer whilst under severe pressure from the police hierarchy and the media. I found this an entertaining and compelling piece of crime fiction. Many thanks to Severn House for an ARC.
November 30, 2018
Cold, Cold Heart, the fourth book to feature forensic psychologist Professor Kate Hanson, was an enjoyable but predictable read. A police procedural about a miscarriage of justice, it had the makings of a thrilling story. Unfortunately, it was less compelling than expected, difficult to engage with and the cast of characters aren't particularly well developed. It works perfectly as a standalone as the plot of each book is self-contained although you will miss details on how the recurring characters have evolved.
It was lacking in believability as the Professor collected evidence despite having no background in law enforcement or forensics which was simply ridiculous. As for predictability, I guessed the murderer correctly within the first 30% of the novel which inevitably leads to lack of tension and left me disappointed. I hope when Cross releases the fifth instalment it provides the thrills, shocks and surprises that are necessary for the genre. It certainly isn't the worst book I've read but it's not the best either. Distinctly mediocre.
Many thanks to Severn House Publishers for an ARC.
It was lacking in believability as the Professor collected evidence despite having no background in law enforcement or forensics which was simply ridiculous. As for predictability, I guessed the murderer correctly within the first 30% of the novel which inevitably leads to lack of tension and left me disappointed. I hope when Cross releases the fifth instalment it provides the thrills, shocks and surprises that are necessary for the genre. It certainly isn't the worst book I've read but it's not the best either. Distinctly mediocre.
Many thanks to Severn House Publishers for an ARC.
December 12, 2018
COLD COLD HEART (KATE HANSON, BK 4) by A. J. CROSS
Professor Kate Hanson once again joins with Lt. Joseph Corrigan in the Unsolved Crime Unit.
David Lockman was imprisoned 10 years for the murder of Della Harrington. He's now been released because the evidence used to convict him was unsatisfactory. There are lots of mixed emotions. The original cops stand by their evidence. The Unsolved Crime Unit, with Kate's help, finds a lot of holes that were never attended to.
If Lockman did not kill the young woman, then who did? Who would have wanted her dead? When Kate and Corrigan go back over the original investigation, they find that not everyone told the truth ... or knew way more than they let on.
What Kate ultimately finds will jeopardize her job and her budding relationship with Corrigan.
This is a well-written crime fiction, an absolute page turner, and a credible story line. I like the characters of Kate and Corrigan and how they work together and relate to each other on a different level. As each suspect is questioned, the suspense climbs until the very unexpected ending.
This is the 5th book of the series and COLD COLD HEART is easily read as a stand alone. I recommend starting at the very beginning to understand some of Kate's family dynamics.
Many thanks to the author / Bloodhound Books / Netgalley for the digital copy of this crime fiction. Opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
4.5 Stars
Professor Kate Hanson once again joins with Lt. Joseph Corrigan in the Unsolved Crime Unit.
David Lockman was imprisoned 10 years for the murder of Della Harrington. He's now been released because the evidence used to convict him was unsatisfactory. There are lots of mixed emotions. The original cops stand by their evidence. The Unsolved Crime Unit, with Kate's help, finds a lot of holes that were never attended to.
If Lockman did not kill the young woman, then who did? Who would have wanted her dead? When Kate and Corrigan go back over the original investigation, they find that not everyone told the truth ... or knew way more than they let on.
What Kate ultimately finds will jeopardize her job and her budding relationship with Corrigan.
This is a well-written crime fiction, an absolute page turner, and a credible story line. I like the characters of Kate and Corrigan and how they work together and relate to each other on a different level. As each suspect is questioned, the suspense climbs until the very unexpected ending.
This is the 5th book of the series and COLD COLD HEART is easily read as a stand alone. I recommend starting at the very beginning to understand some of Kate's family dynamics.
Many thanks to the author / Bloodhound Books / Netgalley for the digital copy of this crime fiction. Opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
4.5 Stars
November 14, 2020
3.5 stars. David Lockman spent 10 years in prison for the murder of Delia Harrington and his life sentence has been set aside on appeal. Professor Kate Hanson, forensic psychologist, assists the Unsolved Crime Unit in figuring out who the real killer is.
I notice this is book 5 in a series but it is fine as a standalone. As I read the forensic evidence in chapter 1, I saw holes in the case. I know this is a UK book and doesn't necessarily go by American forensics, but I waited halfway through the book for anyone to mention DNA in the form of semen. There are lots of red herrings in the story but I didn't know who killed Delia until the very end of the book. I like that type of ending.
I notice this is book 5 in a series but it is fine as a standalone. As I read the forensic evidence in chapter 1, I saw holes in the case. I know this is a UK book and doesn't necessarily go by American forensics, but I waited halfway through the book for anyone to mention DNA in the form of semen. There are lots of red herrings in the story but I didn't know who killed Delia until the very end of the book. I like that type of ending.
August 29, 2019
The fifth in the Kate Hanson series is an intriguing hybrid of forensic psychology and police procedure leavened with domestic detail and a soupcon of romance.
October 5, 2018
There are no clear boundaries between crimes of passion and crimes of logic.
Despite his protestations of innocence, the novelist David Lockman was convicted and sentenced to life for the murder of Della Harrington, but after serving 10 years the Court of Appeal deems the original verdict against him to be unsafe, and his conviction is therefore quashed. He has his life back; what’s left of it.
The case is given to the Unsolved Crime Unit as its next case and Detective Inspector Bernard Watts, Lieutenant Joe Corrigan and Dr Kate Hanson, a Forensic Psychologist, are under pressure from the chief to solve the case because of press interest and intrusion. What they must look for is any lead, anything, any possibility that was missed or not followed up once the focus was on Lockman and he became a suspect. Kate is useful because she searches for the psychological angle that the police often do not see. From the crime scene photos, she sees that the killer created a deliberate scene using the victim’s body, a scene suggesting undoubtedly sexual homicide. The killer was an artist and a most cold-hearted bastard.
With this in mind, the team soon have three suspects: Steffan Coultard, uncomfortable with women, Archie Fenton, a pornography aficionado and Leonard Dobbs, a man who pressures young women for payment of another kind when they cannot afford their rent. Each of them has strong connections to the scene of the crime at the time of the murder. But something is troubling Kate – is this really a brutal sexual homicide? All three suspects have been known to have exploitative sexual interests of some kind, but if the Harrington case isn’t a sexual homicide, they don’t fit. The more they know, the less they understand!
I enjoyed reviewing this book, the second one I have reviewed by this author. The characters are portrayed as human beings and not just policemen or specialists in their field. Kate Hanson has a genius teenage daughter and an ex-husband and father who abandoned her causing her to have commitment issues. Bernard Watts has a gruff façade but beneath it is a willingness to listen and an ability to learn and Joe Corrigan, on secondment from the Boston Police Department, is far from home and harbours more than platonic feelings for Kate. Well worth the read!
Saphira
Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review.
Despite his protestations of innocence, the novelist David Lockman was convicted and sentenced to life for the murder of Della Harrington, but after serving 10 years the Court of Appeal deems the original verdict against him to be unsafe, and his conviction is therefore quashed. He has his life back; what’s left of it.
The case is given to the Unsolved Crime Unit as its next case and Detective Inspector Bernard Watts, Lieutenant Joe Corrigan and Dr Kate Hanson, a Forensic Psychologist, are under pressure from the chief to solve the case because of press interest and intrusion. What they must look for is any lead, anything, any possibility that was missed or not followed up once the focus was on Lockman and he became a suspect. Kate is useful because she searches for the psychological angle that the police often do not see. From the crime scene photos, she sees that the killer created a deliberate scene using the victim’s body, a scene suggesting undoubtedly sexual homicide. The killer was an artist and a most cold-hearted bastard.
With this in mind, the team soon have three suspects: Steffan Coultard, uncomfortable with women, Archie Fenton, a pornography aficionado and Leonard Dobbs, a man who pressures young women for payment of another kind when they cannot afford their rent. Each of them has strong connections to the scene of the crime at the time of the murder. But something is troubling Kate – is this really a brutal sexual homicide? All three suspects have been known to have exploitative sexual interests of some kind, but if the Harrington case isn’t a sexual homicide, they don’t fit. The more they know, the less they understand!
I enjoyed reviewing this book, the second one I have reviewed by this author. The characters are portrayed as human beings and not just policemen or specialists in their field. Kate Hanson has a genius teenage daughter and an ex-husband and father who abandoned her causing her to have commitment issues. Bernard Watts has a gruff façade but beneath it is a willingness to listen and an ability to learn and Joe Corrigan, on secondment from the Boston Police Department, is far from home and harbours more than platonic feelings for Kate. Well worth the read!
Saphira
Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review.
November 22, 2018
4.5 stars.
Cold, Cold Heart by A.J. Cross is a clever police procedural that is unique and quite engrossing. This newest installment in the Kate Hanson series can easily be read as a standalone.
When convicted killer David Lockman's conviction is overturned, Dr. Kate Hanson and the rest of the Unsolved Crime Unit are assigned to investigate the ten year older murder of Della Harrington. The original investigation was less than thorough so Detective Bernard Watts and Lt. Joseph Corrigan begin re-interviewing witnesses. Three suspects begin to emerge when they uncover troubling information about Letting Agent Leonard Dobbs, maintenance man Archie Fenton and Della's fellow opera performer, Steffan Coultard. Watts and Corrigan are soon convinced Della's murder might have been sexually motivated, but Kate is less certain. Will her psychological insights lead them to Della's killer? Or will Kate's impulsive decisions leave the UCU scrambling to solve the case without her input?
Kate is a forensic psychologist and university professor who provides invaluable information through her attention to detail and shrewd psychological interpretation of crime scenes and witnesses. She often picks up subtle clues that are overlooked and she is able to accurately assess if witnesses are being honest and forthcoming. Like Watts and Corrigan, Kate believes in Lockman's innocence and they are determined to find justice for Della. However, she is unable to convince Watts that he is on the wrong track so she makes a fateful decision that has far-reaching implications for the case and her professional life.
Cold, Cold Heart is a suspense-laden mystery with a complex storyline and realistically drawn characters. Kate is a flawed yet sympathetic protagonist with a complicated history that continues to affect her choices in the present. Watts is a little brusque and stubborn but he values Kate's contributions to the UCU. Corrigan is an American police officer on special assignment with the UCU whose interest in Kate goes beyond professional. The investigation is fascinating and moves at a brisk yet realistic pace. With several possible suspects and no clear motive for Della's murder, readers will be surprised and delighted when A.J. Cross brings the novel to a very stunning conclusion. Fans of the genre are sure to enjoy this latest addition to the Kate Hanson series.
Cold, Cold Heart by A.J. Cross is a clever police procedural that is unique and quite engrossing. This newest installment in the Kate Hanson series can easily be read as a standalone.
When convicted killer David Lockman's conviction is overturned, Dr. Kate Hanson and the rest of the Unsolved Crime Unit are assigned to investigate the ten year older murder of Della Harrington. The original investigation was less than thorough so Detective Bernard Watts and Lt. Joseph Corrigan begin re-interviewing witnesses. Three suspects begin to emerge when they uncover troubling information about Letting Agent Leonard Dobbs, maintenance man Archie Fenton and Della's fellow opera performer, Steffan Coultard. Watts and Corrigan are soon convinced Della's murder might have been sexually motivated, but Kate is less certain. Will her psychological insights lead them to Della's killer? Or will Kate's impulsive decisions leave the UCU scrambling to solve the case without her input?
Kate is a forensic psychologist and university professor who provides invaluable information through her attention to detail and shrewd psychological interpretation of crime scenes and witnesses. She often picks up subtle clues that are overlooked and she is able to accurately assess if witnesses are being honest and forthcoming. Like Watts and Corrigan, Kate believes in Lockman's innocence and they are determined to find justice for Della. However, she is unable to convince Watts that he is on the wrong track so she makes a fateful decision that has far-reaching implications for the case and her professional life.
Cold, Cold Heart is a suspense-laden mystery with a complex storyline and realistically drawn characters. Kate is a flawed yet sympathetic protagonist with a complicated history that continues to affect her choices in the present. Watts is a little brusque and stubborn but he values Kate's contributions to the UCU. Corrigan is an American police officer on special assignment with the UCU whose interest in Kate goes beyond professional. The investigation is fascinating and moves at a brisk yet realistic pace. With several possible suspects and no clear motive for Della's murder, readers will be surprised and delighted when A.J. Cross brings the novel to a very stunning conclusion. Fans of the genre are sure to enjoy this latest addition to the Kate Hanson series.
October 5, 2018
Thank you to NetGalley and Severn House Publishing for a digital galley of this novel.
Okay, so what we have here are two policemen and a university professor who is a forensic psychologist who tromp all over the laws regarding investigating and gathering evidence in a criminal case. I suppose having the team follow the rules of gathering evidence would have been way too slow so.....jump right in and get it however you can.
This is the fifth book in this series. I found myself talking to the book, and not in a pleasant way, after only several chapters in. The premise sounded good; a successful author had been found guilty ten years previously of a murder but now an appeal has been heard resulting in him being set free. The Birmingham, England, Unsolved Crime Unit is charged with solving this very cold case. The structure of the UCU was sacrificed by the author in favor of letting the three investigators - yes, the professor did her share of investigating on her own even though she is not a member of law enforcement - just get on with it. Clues are uncovered but then ignored. Suppositions are made and counted as fact. I stayed with it all the way to the end because I wanted to see how the author would reveal the person I knew was guilty to be, indeed, the murderer. It's always a disappointment to know so early on who committed the crime.
Okay, so what we have here are two policemen and a university professor who is a forensic psychologist who tromp all over the laws regarding investigating and gathering evidence in a criminal case. I suppose having the team follow the rules of gathering evidence would have been way too slow so.....jump right in and get it however you can.
This is the fifth book in this series. I found myself talking to the book, and not in a pleasant way, after only several chapters in. The premise sounded good; a successful author had been found guilty ten years previously of a murder but now an appeal has been heard resulting in him being set free. The Birmingham, England, Unsolved Crime Unit is charged with solving this very cold case. The structure of the UCU was sacrificed by the author in favor of letting the three investigators - yes, the professor did her share of investigating on her own even though she is not a member of law enforcement - just get on with it. Clues are uncovered but then ignored. Suppositions are made and counted as fact. I stayed with it all the way to the end because I wanted to see how the author would reveal the person I knew was guilty to be, indeed, the murderer. It's always a disappointment to know so early on who committed the crime.
October 16, 2018
Professor Kate Hanson a forensic psychologist is a consultant with the unsolved crimes unit. David Lockwood has been in prison for 10 years, convicted of the murder. He has now been released because a panel of judges decided there wasn’t enough to convict him. Kate is asked to look at the evidence from the crime to try to find a new suspect. Ten years have passed which doesn’t make it easy.
This book is full of suspense. You will be kept guessing who the murderer is. There are plenty of suspects. The ending came completely out of left field for me. I never expected it. If you like police procedurals this is for you. Thank you to net galley for an advanced readers copy.
This book is full of suspense. You will be kept guessing who the murderer is. There are plenty of suspects. The ending came completely out of left field for me. I never expected it. If you like police procedurals this is for you. Thank you to net galley for an advanced readers copy.
October 22, 2018
Cold, Cold Heart by author A.J. Cross is by far a fast paced suspenseful book! Full of character and plot, you won’t want to put this down!
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for an arc copy of Cold, Cold Heart in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for an arc copy of Cold, Cold Heart in exchange for an honest review.
November 15, 2020
Good - not excellent. Definitely had a twist I did not see coming.
June 11, 2024
Another cliched story with characters who are irritating or formula written
November 23, 2023
Urgh! I have to give this book four stars because I really was gripped by the tale throughout most of the book. But I'm tempted to deduct a star for the reasoning given in the big reveal at the end. So annoying.
I will give the author their due: they did get me going off on a completely incorrect tangent. One I hope was intended because of the various crumbs scattered about that made me go wilding off in a mad scramble to make sense of what I was reading. If I was supposed to jump to those conclusions then good for you A. J. Cross.
However I'm still perplexed over one detail that made me originally start to believe it was one person (working with another) because the very thing that cemented my being convinced of it being a certain person, was a detail that somehow also led Kate to figure out whodunit. The detail in question however makes zero sense because we're never told why the killer knew this detail or how they found it out. It's never explained and while I can sort of overlook some loose ends not being tied up at the denouement, THIS one cannot be forgiven, purely because of how much of the crime solving hinged on its discovery. And that really peed me off. It wasn't fair on the reader and it needs to be rectified. I know authors don't read a lot of their reviews but in the vaguest of chances that Cross does ever read this: YOU NEED TO GO BACK AND REWORK HOW THIS DETAIL MAKES ANY SENSE IN THE CASE OF THE KILLER KNOWING IT AND THEN KATE SUDDENLY SOLVING THE CASE ALMOST ENTIRELY BECAUSE OF THIS!
Ahem. Sorry about that. I just feel like after having read what was an intriguing tale for the most part, the author did me dirty in the final chapters.
I'm also not convinced by the reasoning behind the motive. Would someone really kill more than one person, over something so utterly banal, using a scheme dreamed up that didn't work out the way they were hoping it would? It was a stupid motive and I hated it. Such an annoying way to conclude not just a book but a series. I've ploughed through them all over the past two weeks, so I've been well immersed in the setting. Kate seemed cool in the first book, but then went on to become a typical annoying feminist type in subsequent instalments. I dislike her immensely and her daughter is an annoying pain in the hoop too.
Corrigan is a dull character. Set up to be the hero and love interest, he came across with about as much depth as one of those photos you see in a mail order catalogue, where a man who looks like a bland Ken doll is pointing off in the distance while modelling some hideous lounge wear. I'm sure Kate and him will eventually ride off into the sunset as he becomes her life-long simp.
Bernie though has been awesome throughout. I haven't watched television in about four years, but I do remember a guy in one of those antique shows called Philip Serrell; that's what I picture Bernie looking like whenever his character is on the page. I love everything about his old-school, unreconstructed bloke and proper copper vibe. He was so well drawn and balanced in the way he was both a gentleman and a gobshite! My kind of guy.
It did annoy me that the author, throughout this series kept trying to make out like Bernie refused to believe in any of the theory behind criminology and behavioural psychology. I could accept it once in the first book, but in every single one? Get out of here! He's worked with Kate for four years on five cases. All of which her input had helped solve. There's no way a guy who got promoted to chief sergeant (or whatever the new rank was) could have been so blithely stupid in acting like he wasn't on board with the value of pay-off from using behavioural profiling. But the author needed to make a lazy stereotype out of a straight, white make I guess?
All in all I mostly enjoyed this series. It's not without its faults (the author has a habit of leaving a lot of loose ends still not resolved by the denouement - feels like they get a while bunch of ideas for plot strands, starts off excited, but by the end is too frazzled, lazy or confused by the web of their own making, to bother thing things up one way or another) but despite losing its way around book three which lacked the pace of the others, they were far better than I expected them to be. Getting to read them via Kindle Unlimited was a bonus too. I'd definitely read something else by this author in future.
And if especially like at least one Bernie-centric spin off because Watts is a legend! #TeamBernie
I will give the author their due: they did get me going off on a completely incorrect tangent. One I hope was intended because of the various crumbs scattered about that made me go wilding off in a mad scramble to make sense of what I was reading. If I was supposed to jump to those conclusions then good for you A. J. Cross.
However I'm still perplexed over one detail that made me originally start to believe it was one person (working with another) because the very thing that cemented my being convinced of it being a certain person, was a detail that somehow also led Kate to figure out whodunit. The detail in question however makes zero sense because we're never told why the killer knew this detail or how they found it out. It's never explained and while I can sort of overlook some loose ends not being tied up at the denouement, THIS one cannot be forgiven, purely because of how much of the crime solving hinged on its discovery. And that really peed me off. It wasn't fair on the reader and it needs to be rectified. I know authors don't read a lot of their reviews but in the vaguest of chances that Cross does ever read this: YOU NEED TO GO BACK AND REWORK HOW THIS DETAIL MAKES ANY SENSE IN THE CASE OF THE KILLER KNOWING IT AND THEN KATE SUDDENLY SOLVING THE CASE ALMOST ENTIRELY BECAUSE OF THIS!
Ahem. Sorry about that. I just feel like after having read what was an intriguing tale for the most part, the author did me dirty in the final chapters.
I'm also not convinced by the reasoning behind the motive. Would someone really kill more than one person, over something so utterly banal, using a scheme dreamed up that didn't work out the way they were hoping it would? It was a stupid motive and I hated it. Such an annoying way to conclude not just a book but a series. I've ploughed through them all over the past two weeks, so I've been well immersed in the setting. Kate seemed cool in the first book, but then went on to become a typical annoying feminist type in subsequent instalments. I dislike her immensely and her daughter is an annoying pain in the hoop too.
Corrigan is a dull character. Set up to be the hero and love interest, he came across with about as much depth as one of those photos you see in a mail order catalogue, where a man who looks like a bland Ken doll is pointing off in the distance while modelling some hideous lounge wear. I'm sure Kate and him will eventually ride off into the sunset as he becomes her life-long simp.
Bernie though has been awesome throughout. I haven't watched television in about four years, but I do remember a guy in one of those antique shows called Philip Serrell; that's what I picture Bernie looking like whenever his character is on the page. I love everything about his old-school, unreconstructed bloke and proper copper vibe. He was so well drawn and balanced in the way he was both a gentleman and a gobshite! My kind of guy.
It did annoy me that the author, throughout this series kept trying to make out like Bernie refused to believe in any of the theory behind criminology and behavioural psychology. I could accept it once in the first book, but in every single one? Get out of here! He's worked with Kate for four years on five cases. All of which her input had helped solve. There's no way a guy who got promoted to chief sergeant (or whatever the new rank was) could have been so blithely stupid in acting like he wasn't on board with the value of pay-off from using behavioural profiling. But the author needed to make a lazy stereotype out of a straight, white make I guess?
All in all I mostly enjoyed this series. It's not without its faults (the author has a habit of leaving a lot of loose ends still not resolved by the denouement - feels like they get a while bunch of ideas for plot strands, starts off excited, but by the end is too frazzled, lazy or confused by the web of their own making, to bother thing things up one way or another) but despite losing its way around book three which lacked the pace of the others, they were far better than I expected them to be. Getting to read them via Kindle Unlimited was a bonus too. I'd definitely read something else by this author in future.
And if especially like at least one Bernie-centric spin off because Watts is a legend! #TeamBernie
August 28, 2018
I liked the story - solving a cold case and delving into the background of the victim and those around her. I enjoyed the relationships between the different characters and starting to understand how their experiences would be driving their thoughts, feelings and actions. I also thought the ending of the book was good and something I wasn't expecting. However, the thing I enjoyed less about the book was the heavy use of surnames for all the characters as I felt it made it hard to connect with them. I can understand why sometimes this may be useful to use - particularly within a police drama but this was used even when the female psychologist was talking to her daughter - which seemed less relevant.
October 29, 2023
ABSOLUTELY *FANTASTIC*!!!…..
In the Dr. Kate Hanson Mysteries series thus far (*fingers crossed more books forthcoming!…) this one — Book 5, has been my favorite.
With Book 1 in the series being an almost too close to call 2nd.
The Coldest Death features all the best of author A.J. Cross’s writing.
The story is highly creative, extremely well crafted, the plot, twists, & conclusion perfectly executed … a total gripper!
The “villain/s” this time around were each written with incredibly detailed & rich character development. So we not only get to know the main characters more deeply, we are offered the opportunity to learn exactly who the “bad guys” are historically, in the present, & what motivates them from core levels.
That takes some phenomenal character writing chops for sure!
Overall the entire tale is complex, engaging, intriguing, & thrilling, from first page ‘till last.
Additionally, the very real forensic information is such a pleasure to read, as it’s clear the great lengths Cross goes into researching.
Definitely the star book of the series.
I don’t know what to do with myself now after being so immersed in Kate, Corrigan, Watts Julian, Maisie, Charlie, Chong, & company’s world for so long now whilst reading the 5 books back-to-back.
I really cannot wait to see an announcement that Book 6 has been released!
In the meantime — go back to Book 1, & start there if you haven’t already.
The Dr. Kate Hanson Mysteries series is like eating chips (or crisps! Lol ;) … after a couple chapters, you just cannot help yourself. You HAVE TO devour each & every book!
In the Dr. Kate Hanson Mysteries series thus far (*fingers crossed more books forthcoming!…) this one — Book 5, has been my favorite.
With Book 1 in the series being an almost too close to call 2nd.
The Coldest Death features all the best of author A.J. Cross’s writing.
The story is highly creative, extremely well crafted, the plot, twists, & conclusion perfectly executed … a total gripper!
The “villain/s” this time around were each written with incredibly detailed & rich character development. So we not only get to know the main characters more deeply, we are offered the opportunity to learn exactly who the “bad guys” are historically, in the present, & what motivates them from core levels.
That takes some phenomenal character writing chops for sure!
Overall the entire tale is complex, engaging, intriguing, & thrilling, from first page ‘till last.
Additionally, the very real forensic information is such a pleasure to read, as it’s clear the great lengths Cross goes into researching.
Definitely the star book of the series.
I don’t know what to do with myself now after being so immersed in Kate, Corrigan, Watts Julian, Maisie, Charlie, Chong, & company’s world for so long now whilst reading the 5 books back-to-back.
I really cannot wait to see an announcement that Book 6 has been released!
In the meantime — go back to Book 1, & start there if you haven’t already.
The Dr. Kate Hanson Mysteries series is like eating chips (or crisps! Lol ;) … after a couple chapters, you just cannot help yourself. You HAVE TO devour each & every book!
September 23, 2018
Thank you NetGalley and Severn House for a copy of this book in return for my review.
This is the first of A J Cross’s books that I have read and I thought that was a good enjoyable police detective novel underpinned by some interesting forensic psychology.
Professor Kate Hanson, a forensic psychologist, and the team at the Unsolved Crime Unit (UCU) are given a controversial crime to solve. Ten years ago David Lockman, a famous author, was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of Della Harrington. After persistent efforts by his legal team, Lockman has now been set free and the original verdict declared unsafe. The members of the UCU have been tasked with reviewing the original evidence and finding out who the murderer might be if it was not Lockman. They soon find problems with the original evidence and identify three new suspects, but Kate is uncertain that they are heading in the right direction.
This is a very ably plotted mystery novel that smoothly goes through its paces and keeps the reader happily engaged until the surprising outcome. The suspects are nicely sketched and interesting, but I thought that Kate and her colleagues were a little bland and I found it difficult to differentiate between the two police detectives. I also thought that Kate’s actions were a little unlikely at times. Nevertheless, the story was clever and enjoyable, and the author does a good job of keeping the reader guessing as to who the killer is. It would make a good television show.
This is the first of A J Cross’s books that I have read and I thought that was a good enjoyable police detective novel underpinned by some interesting forensic psychology.
Professor Kate Hanson, a forensic psychologist, and the team at the Unsolved Crime Unit (UCU) are given a controversial crime to solve. Ten years ago David Lockman, a famous author, was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of Della Harrington. After persistent efforts by his legal team, Lockman has now been set free and the original verdict declared unsafe. The members of the UCU have been tasked with reviewing the original evidence and finding out who the murderer might be if it was not Lockman. They soon find problems with the original evidence and identify three new suspects, but Kate is uncertain that they are heading in the right direction.
This is a very ably plotted mystery novel that smoothly goes through its paces and keeps the reader happily engaged until the surprising outcome. The suspects are nicely sketched and interesting, but I thought that Kate and her colleagues were a little bland and I found it difficult to differentiate between the two police detectives. I also thought that Kate’s actions were a little unlikely at times. Nevertheless, the story was clever and enjoyable, and the author does a good job of keeping the reader guessing as to who the killer is. It would make a good television show.
January 5, 2025
This is an excellent read. I really do enjoy this series as it’s so different to the normal type of police procedural novels, which makes a big change. I enjoy the psychology aspect to crimes and this author is one of the best at this kind of approach. I genuinely like Kate Hanson, despite her head-strong ways but she is dedicated to getting justice for the victims of the horrible crimes that have been left un-solved for so long. The UCU is made up of an enthusiastic group of hard-working individuals and they make a good team. As usual, we hear a lot about Kate’s personal life – her daughter Maisie who is good fun – and her relationship with her father. I also enjoy the complicated attachment that Kate has with Corrigan as I believe they should be together, and hopefully they will make the decision soon. The plot in this book was intricately woven and very complex with so many suspects and so little evidence. The fact that the UCU were working to try and clear the name of a man who was originally convicted for the murder and spent 10 years in jail, makes it even harder for the team to reach a conclusion. However, the reveal at the end was a huge surprise and something that I certainly didn’t see coming. I get the feeling that this could well be the last in this series, which is a shame, but I am encouraged by the fact that this author has another series out and I am sure it will be every bit as good.
October 8, 2018
Apparently this is the fifth book in the series which has Kate Hanson (a university professor) assisting two policemen (the Unsolved Crime Unit) in the role of a forensic psychologist, investigating a cold case. The action is set in Birmingham. We join the action as the person convicted of a murder is released and the team have to start at the beginning to discover who committed the crime.
As far as it goes, that is all well and good. What is required is the ability to just go with the flow in terms of accepting that Kate would be able to visit, investigate and interrogate witnesses without due respect of procedure (even down to procuring evidence. I have been here before when watching Silent Witness when the coroners are rarely actually in the mortuary but they are out there right next to the police and not only actively involved in the investigation but solving it too.
That said I did quite enjoy it. It was well-written, fast paced and kept me engaged. One thing though – if I am ever falsely imprisoned, I will not care who investigates or solves the crime – just get me out!
Would I recommend it? Yes because in spite of the above comments, I still watch and enjoy Silent Witness and I did enjoy this.
Thank you to the publishers, author and NetGalley for providing an ARC via my Kindle in return for an honest review.
As far as it goes, that is all well and good. What is required is the ability to just go with the flow in terms of accepting that Kate would be able to visit, investigate and interrogate witnesses without due respect of procedure (even down to procuring evidence. I have been here before when watching Silent Witness when the coroners are rarely actually in the mortuary but they are out there right next to the police and not only actively involved in the investigation but solving it too.
That said I did quite enjoy it. It was well-written, fast paced and kept me engaged. One thing though – if I am ever falsely imprisoned, I will not care who investigates or solves the crime – just get me out!
Would I recommend it? Yes because in spite of the above comments, I still watch and enjoy Silent Witness and I did enjoy this.
Thank you to the publishers, author and NetGalley for providing an ARC via my Kindle in return for an honest review.
July 6, 2023
I found some of the "forensic mysteries" in the library, and I am hooked. There are two series, this one and the Will Traynor books. He replaces Hanson after this book. The common characters are Bernard Watts and Connie Chong, the pathologist. Watts starts off somewhere as Sergeant, eventually makes DCI (he's DI in this one), and is getting close to retirement. The weird thing is that the officers still call him Sarge, very unusual in a paramilitary organisation. An efficient and even hard-nosed cop, he also has a softer side in relation to certain junior cops. I wonder if he is the model for what the author would have liked to see when she worked in forensics.
Another unusual feature of the Unsolved Crimes Unit is the presence of an American, Lieutenant Corrigan, firearms expert or something, and love interest for Kate Hanson, which may spell disaster for the team. Hanson is probably the most developed character, although we gradually learn quite a bit about Watts. The rather unbelievable plot point is the use of forensic psychologists, non-police, as investigators. It's a bit of a running scenario, capturing / bopping of the FP or a family member. What happened to Occupational health and Safety rules?
Having said all this, the stories rock along at a good pace, and there's suspense to burn. Just to give a little weight to the above comments, I rate this 3.7.
Another unusual feature of the Unsolved Crimes Unit is the presence of an American, Lieutenant Corrigan, firearms expert or something, and love interest for Kate Hanson, which may spell disaster for the team. Hanson is probably the most developed character, although we gradually learn quite a bit about Watts. The rather unbelievable plot point is the use of forensic psychologists, non-police, as investigators. It's a bit of a running scenario, capturing / bopping of the FP or a family member. What happened to Occupational health and Safety rules?
Having said all this, the stories rock along at a good pace, and there's suspense to burn. Just to give a little weight to the above comments, I rate this 3.7.
December 1, 2018
This is the fifth mystery in the Professor Kate Hanson series by A. J. Cross. Kate, who is a forensic psychologist, is requested to go over the details of the murder of Della Harrington. Della was found murdered, in her home, ten years ago. David Lockman was arrested and sentenced to life for her murder. Now, almost ten years later and another hearing, David is released from his life sentence as the court found issues with the forensic evidence. Kate has assisted the Unsolved Crime Unit before and will dig in to the case hoping for more evidence that will completely clear Mr. Lockman, find new evidence against Mr. Lockman or find another suspect. Lt. Joseph Corrigan, from Boston, will provide a fresh set of “eyes” on the case. Kate and Corrigan will question past witnesses as new clues and evidence will come forth that may break the case. Was the murder staged to deflect the police from the real reason Della was murdered? Will David Lockman be found guilty or will the team come up with another suspect? Ms. Cross is able to weave her mysteries in such a manner that you are always one step behind. I received a free copy of this book and voluntarily chose to give an honest review. (by paytonpuppy)
September 11, 2018
Thank you NetGalley and Severn House Publishing for the eARC.
Professor Kate Hanson and the Unsolved Cases Unit catch a cold case. David Lockman served 10 years of his life sentence for the murder of Stella Harrington, when he's set free mainly because the police investigation 10 years ago was flawed and his lawyers have fought hard all this time to get him his freedom. But if Lockman didn't commit the murder, who did?
Kate and the team end up focusing on 3 suspects, all of them around when the murder occurred, all.of them unsavory characters. But it's a hard slog, because it was a long time ago and anyone they interview either doesn't remember much or refuses to answer their questions.
When Kate goes against the Superintendent's order of not approaching Lockman, she endangers her job at the University as she's kicked out of the USU.
The ending of the book was jawdropping, I did not see that coming!
This was my 2nd book in the series and I'm beginning to really like Kate and her 2 USU colleagues. Can't wait for the next book and highly recommend this excellent series.
Professor Kate Hanson and the Unsolved Cases Unit catch a cold case. David Lockman served 10 years of his life sentence for the murder of Stella Harrington, when he's set free mainly because the police investigation 10 years ago was flawed and his lawyers have fought hard all this time to get him his freedom. But if Lockman didn't commit the murder, who did?
Kate and the team end up focusing on 3 suspects, all of them around when the murder occurred, all.of them unsavory characters. But it's a hard slog, because it was a long time ago and anyone they interview either doesn't remember much or refuses to answer their questions.
When Kate goes against the Superintendent's order of not approaching Lockman, she endangers her job at the University as she's kicked out of the USU.
The ending of the book was jawdropping, I did not see that coming!
This was my 2nd book in the series and I'm beginning to really like Kate and her 2 USU colleagues. Can't wait for the next book and highly recommend this excellent series.
December 6, 2018
Forensic psychologist, Kate Hanson, investigates a cold case - ten years ago David Lockwood was found guilty of the murder of Della Harrington. Now the verdict has been overturned, Kate and her police colleagues try to find the real killer.
I haven't read any of the previous books but didn't feel it was a detriment to reading this one. I did find that it took the characters a long time to realise things which were fairly obvious. There were plenty of suspects and red herrings, and the ending was well done, even though a vital piece of evidence was kept from the reader until the reveal at the end. I enjoyed it enough to add the first 4 books on my TBR list. 3.5 stars
Thanks to NetGalley and publishers, Severn House, for the opportunity to review an ARC.
I haven't read any of the previous books but didn't feel it was a detriment to reading this one. I did find that it took the characters a long time to realise things which were fairly obvious. There were plenty of suspects and red herrings, and the ending was well done, even though a vital piece of evidence was kept from the reader until the reveal at the end. I enjoyed it enough to add the first 4 books on my TBR list. 3.5 stars
Thanks to NetGalley and publishers, Severn House, for the opportunity to review an ARC.
December 29, 2023
I was prepared to give this book 5-stars right up to the conclusion. The book ending left too many holes and the series ending left too many questions. I liked the series overall and was wanting some murder mysteries to break up my Christmas cheesy, but I’m shaking my head in bafflement at how it ended. I will close with two thoughts. 1. I know these books were previously published under other names and it surprises me if they didn’t do well. There are very few reviews even now and this also baffles me as I do think they are good reads. 2. The detectives are likeable characters, but I grew tired of them being helpless and inevitably wrong unless Kate was leading the way. It felt like given their supposed expertise they could have been made out to have some independent success.
February 7, 2024
A brilliant read.
I have just finished reading the fifth book in this series. Great characters and believable plots. The romance was a slow burn but Hanson finally got there. Hopefully she's not so stubborn in the next book. Great reads.
I have just finished reading the fifth book in this series. Great characters and believable plots. The romance was a slow burn but Hanson finally got there. Hopefully she's not so stubborn in the next book. Great reads.
August 27, 2024
Guilty
Lokman was released from prison after 10 years . He had been found guilty of killing a young woman but was granted a reprieve because of witnesses testimony. Dr Hanson, Watts and Corrigan investigated the case but no suspect was found. A surprise ending awaits.
Lokman was released from prison after 10 years . He had been found guilty of killing a young woman but was granted a reprieve because of witnesses testimony. Dr Hanson, Watts and Corrigan investigated the case but no suspect was found. A surprise ending awaits.
December 10, 2018
Interesting plot. Good characters
July 12, 2019
I wanted to like this series (I know I started in the middle) but it seemed so choppy.
October 8, 2020
Very clever novel featuring forensic psychologist Kate Hanson. Great characters and a brilliant twist at the end.
December 20, 2021
Two and a half stars
March 30, 2022
A mystery that takes place in England. One of the investigators is a college psychology professor who specializes in crime. The characters are great and I read it in just a few days.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews