I’m sure there is some truth behind the contents in this book for instance, babies have feelings and being close to a parent allows them to release those feelings, I don’t think anyone is contesting that. The rest of it I can’t help but feel is total and utter tripe.
In a nutshell, the method described here is essentially cry-it-out with a twist. It’s cry-it-out with you present holding your baby pretending like it’s ok because they’re reliving their traumatic birth or some other nonsense so don’t bother soothing them that’ll only distract them from this emotional breakthrough. Some might find this idea reassuring, if nothing else works to soothe your baby maybe it is easier to believe this than just accepting that some babies cry. For the rest of us, like we don’t have enough to worry about without this author claiming attempts to soothe your baby suppresses their feelings. Even going as far to say that babies sucking their hands is a dissociative behaviour, rather than a perfectly normal, healthy soothing skill and necessary developmental practice prior to transitioning onto solid foods.
I have no doubt that some experiences babies find overstimulating, but referring to necessary activities parents need to undertake, like going to the mall, as traumatic is reaching. Again, can we not fear monger new parents into never leaving the house by making such exaggerated claims.
I’m not familiar with “Aware Parenting” but if this book represent its teachings, it’s not for me.