I absolutely adored Curse of the Specter Queen and was so excited to read Rise of the Snake Goddess, but … it just didn’t deliver in the same way that the first book did.
I can succinctly identify the problem I had with Rise of the Snake Queen: Samantha freaking Knox.
In book one, Sam’s character felt so well rounded. She struggled with being stuck in her small town and the semi-estrangement from Jo. We saw her really come to life as the mystery unfolded and she continued to prove her intellect and sharp analytical skills over and over again.
Despite the character building in book one, book two immediately starts with Sam being a pain in the butt. Sam is bitter, reckless, obsessed with proving her by making a world famous discovery, and selfish. She doesn’t ever really stop to think any plan through or even how it might impact Jo and Bennet. She has a chip on her shoulder and all she really cares about is proving that she is the smart and the best at everything. The rekindled friendship with Jo and the relationship with Bennet are soured by Sam’s resentment towards the siblings for their upbringing and wealth, even though Sam has obviously benefited greatly from their father’s generosity towards her. Despite Sam not even being Mr. Steeling’s own child he has paid for so many things for Sam and has even pulled strings to ensure she is granted access to opportunities she would not have had access to on her own. Poor Bennet gets punished repeatedly by Sam for trying to be levelheaded, responsible, and safety minded, simply because she thinks he “doesn’t understand her” while she is once again being reckless and obsessive over earning archaeological fame. I understand Sam’s behavior gets worked into the plot, but it was just so unpleasant to read for the entire book. The whole “woe is me, no one understands me or my genius” trope is obnoxious and tired at this point.
My smaller gripe with book two is that the riddle solving, code breaking, and overall discovery which helped book one to shine were just not present in this installment. The plot was kind of 1. Discover something of archaeological significance (and find it a bit too easily, at that), 2. Sam is reckless and fights with Jo and Bennet nonstop for about 60% of the book, 3. Mystical things happen and Sam only discovers the pattern/answer/solution because the things have happened and not because she worked them out from the clues she has found (probably bc there were no clues this time around). The actual mystery was not as well formulated or tied together this time, which was really disappointing.
I rated Curse of the Specter Queen 4 stars when I read it last year, but I remember thinking it was a solid 4-4.5 star read for me. Rise of the Snake Goddess is 3-3.5 stars (I’m sad it’s so low bc I genuinely really like this series). Even though this series definitely suffers with the dreaded book two curse, I’ll be excited to continue reading the series as it comes out.