I was really excited about this book when I picked it up. The concept is excellent and so needed in our current cultural climate. Unfortunately, I had a difficult time getting through it. Before I offer my critique, I want to highlight some positives:
GOOD:
• Packed with references to Scripture, it’s clearly rooted in biblical concepts.
• The conversation skills mentioned—listening, asking questions, and finding common ground—are essential for good dialogue with people who disagree. These skills should be shouted from the rooftops (kindly, of course 😉).
• There were some interesting statistics and anecdotes riddled throughout the book.
• Starting in Chapter 10, the content became much more practical and engaging.
CRITIQUE:
• The first 9 chapters felt dragged out. While I appreciated the bridge analogy in Chapter 2, it felt overexplained. Once I understood the concept, I wanted to move on, but there were 40 pages dedicated to bridges. I would’ve preferred to spend that time exploring how to have practical conversations about different worldviews.
• The book often overstated the obvious, and many points felt overexplained. For example, there was a section dedicated to the idea that friendships are important. Another on how to make friends, one on keeping friends, and another on prioritizing friendships. These are all pretty common sense ideas in my opinion. But maybe I just don’t realize how blessed I am to have friends as an adult.
• Some sections felt underdeveloped. For example, the section on New Age beliefs was too brief to be useful The New Age Movement was neither defined beyond being a mashup of various eastern religions nor were its practices clearly explained. It would have been more helpful if she gave specific examples of people practicing New Age beliefs and common red flags that a friend might unknowingly subscribe to New Age beliefs, followed by questions to have a conversation about these beliefs with the friend. She did share an anecdote about how she wrote a blog post on New Age beliefs and then a friend who read it realized she held those beliefs; however, the author didn’t specify what those beliefs were or use that as an opportunity to demonstrate how she connected with her friend using the principles in the book.
Chapter 1 (on prayer) was great, and Chapter 10 was wonderful. The content after Chapter 10 was much more practical, featuring helpful true stories, examples of open-ended questions, clear conversation skills, and ideas for reaching out to people with different worldviews (hospitality, etc.). I wish the practical content started much earlier instead of cramming so many concepts and facts into the first half.
• The book could have been more concise. A lot of content could’ve been explained in fewer words.
Biggest Critique:
The kind of person who would pick up this book is likely already self-aware enough to know many of the common-sense ideas laid out in its pages. What would have been more compelling is if the chapters went deeper into these concepts through transformative stories, practical encouragement for handling nerves, and advice on how to be real with people even when we are nervous to dialogue.
Final Thoughts:
Despite my critiques, the book has value. The author clearly has a gift for reaching people in her own life, and her kindness and compassion shine through. Her constant reminder not to be a jerk (like to Jehovah’s Witnesses or Mormons at your door) was refreshing.
While I wish the book had focused more on practical strategies earlier on, the message is important, and I’m glad someone is writing about this topic. The author seems like someone I’d love to have coffee with, even if we disagreed on everything.