Since originally the return of Gotrek was confined to two audio books after which they released the rest of the series in book form, I did not get to read the first two books of the series which are now combined in this bundle.
If I am totally honest, it should be two and a half stars for the first half and 1 star for the second half but the problems I have with the second half are already present. Where to start well how about how much is in this book. We encounter, fyreslayers, stormcast eternals, lizardmen, orks, deepkin, skaven, undead, sigmarite humans, tzeentch cultists, plaguebearers and a plague lord, an old dwarf (Grombrindal?), a dark elf and sylvaneth wood spirits including the everqueen herself...... I mean tone it down a bit? Scenery and enemies switch so fast that I can hardly keep up and after two thirds I was not invested anymore. It is coming in the territory of what I don't like about dnd books, namely that to many different races are all heaped on another and it is the most normal thing to just keep encountering new peoples every streetcorner. Its not that I don't like many fantasy races, but by putting them all together so casually it becomes so tedious, uninspiring and plain boring. It becomes namedroppig rather then really thinking what would make sense, or perhaps I just don't get what age of Sigmar is all about, equally possible off course.
Character wise, I mean Gotrek is still fun but I so sorely wish they had mad him the POV rather then stuck to the old formula of a companion talking about Gotrek. Now, the fyreslayer Broddur is not the worst at it and I could find fun in his presence but why, why does Gotrek allow that dark elf Maleneth to stick around? What is the motivation here? With Broddur there was the aspect of him being a dwarf or duardin and his devotion to Gotrek was genuine, but Gotrek has nothing good to say about Maleneth so why tolerate her presence? Minor characters were okish but what really wrinkled me was the return of a certain enemy of Gotrek, I like said character but here he so forced in, he does not get his time to shine. The return of an old friend likewise felt so hollow, like what does it mean that he found him?
Lastly, plot and setting. Similar to the amount of races, the settings are just following up on each other in such a rapid succession that you care very little about any of them. It is also hard to appreciate things as godbeasts when three of them appear in the book and none are even a minor obstacle, why even have them? Now I liked the first setting of the fyreslayer lodge but we leave it so soon and after that we go through at least 4 different realms which begs me the quesion; how easy is it really to travel between these realms even if some of them are linked to said godbeast? It makes it seem so casual and at this point the problem for me became that your making it in a sort of epic fantasy while still writing as if it is the old brutal sword and sorcery setting. It just doesn't gell, Gotrek is not a good character to push into this new world and he would agree as most of his speech is dedicated to pissing on everything what makes the age of Sigmar different to the old world.
In conclusion, especially the second half really was a chore and a bore to read, I did not care anymore and while the first half had something going for it, it too is burnded by choices made for the character, setting and plot that can not redeem it. I have read two of the following books and there they did learn to stop the whole jumping between realms so casually and refocus the books on a singular plot and type of enemy (like the old gotrek books) but that dark elf keeps sticking around... By the fourth they did give time and space for Gotrek to really interact with his surroundings beyond grumbling how shit everything is (which btw what a weird way to support your new world setting for your franchise) but I still feel that Gotrek should have been put to rest with the old world. You were cheated Gotrek, cheated not by Grimnir but a far more powerful entity, the games workshop company.