It’s been a while since we were in the company of Casey Wray and the Hampstead County PD, but if you think that, after solving a string of heinous murders and unmasking corruption in some of the highest positions on the force, Casey would be in a much better place, personally and professionally, you’d be very, very, wrong. She may have been deemed innocent of any involvement in what happened, but it hasn’t made her any more popular around the office. Looked over for promotion, she now has to contend with a new boss who does not trust her, and a double homicide for which there is no clear motive, and no real clue as to which of the victims was the intended target. Was this a domestic turned bad, or something far worse?
Rod Reynolds has done a brilliant job of drawing readers into this new novel, diving straight into the action, a scene packed with jeopardy where the words ‘officer down’ really had me glued to the page, wanting to understand the what, why and wherefore of it all. But for that I had to wait because, after successfully baiting us with this explosive opener, he takes us back a short way in time to the inciting incident – the reason why Casey found herself under fire in the first place.
It’s a style that works well in this particular novel, a kind of count down that allows us to get to grips with the new characters, the potential suspects and motives, and to draw our own conclusions about why they might have been targeted. It also builds and maintains the tension as we know what is coming and when, just not quite how we got there. I found that is helped with the pace of the story too, and I felt compelled to keep reading long after my brain told me I should be asleep, as it had that one more chapter feel about it, each new revelation providing a reason to keep reading onward.
I like Casey as a character although at times I did have to wonder why she didn’t just accept the offer of alternative employment, a lifeline thrown by the least likely of people from her past. In terms of her wider team, given what happened in Black Reed Bay it’s safe to say that there are plenty of new faces to get to know. She has a new partner in Billy, a guy who I quite liked even if there were element of his personality that were a touch questionable. However, when it comes to the other women on her team, Casey comes under quite a bit of pressure, especially from her new Lieutenant, whose very clear agenda is to remove Casey from the team.
This is perhaps the one element which niggled a touch. Just personal preference, but I’d prefer to see women teaming up against the male dominated hierarchy, rather than seeking each other out to it, but there is a sense of authenticity in this approach, and it does fit with the story so other readers might feel differently. That said, this whole case is wrapped up in political wrangling, and it gives it all that edginess and sense of conflict that keeps the tension high, and the focus completely on the page as I was hoping to see some of them face their just deserts.
If I had my time again, I’d have maybe read Black Reed Bay again before tucking into this latest case. It can be read as a standalone, and there is enough of a recap in the book to prompt memories of before without spoiling it for others who are coming to this second book first. I just think it would have helped cement some of the older names and situations in my mind before I picked them back up here. Again, a very personal thing and whilst I’d advocate reading the books in order (and why not read both – that’s what series were designed for and you’d be rightly supporting the author in doing so), it’s not absolutely necessary as this is a standalone case. Sort of. I guess when it comes to a police force plagued by corruption, nothing can ever truly stand alone.
A thrilling, pacey, high stakes investigation that held my attention from start to finish. The author has captured that authentic feel of the American justice system, and backed it up with brilliant characters, both main and supporting, and a cunning killer who really takes some pinning down. Definitely recommended and if you enjoyed BRB, you are going to love this. The series just seems to be getting stronger and I’m intrigued to see what is next for Casey.