For fans of Radium Girls and history and WWII buffs, The Girls Who Stepped Out of Line takes you inside the lives and experiences of 15 unknown women heroes from the Greatest Generation, the women who served, fought, struggled, and made things happen during WWII - in and out of uniform, for theirs is a legacy destined to embolden generations of women to come.
The Girls Who Stepped Out of Line are the heroes of the Greatest Generation that you hardly ever hear about. These women who did extraordinary things didn’t expect thanks and shied away from medals and recognition. Despite their amazing accomplishments, they’ve gone mostly unheralded and unrewarded. No longer. These are the women of World War II who served, fought, struggled, and made things happen - in and out of uniform.
Liane B. Russell fled Austria with nothing and later became a renowned US scientist whose research on the effects of radiation on embryos made a difference to thousands of lives. Gena Turgel was a prisoner who worked in the hospital at Bergen-Belsen and cared for the young Anne Frank, who was dying of typhus. Gena survived and went on to write a memoir and spent her life educating children about the Holocaust. Ida and Louise Cook were British sisters who repeatedly smuggled out jewelry and furs and served as sponsors for refugees, and they also established temporary housing for immigrant families in London.
Retired US Army Major General Mari K. Eder wrote this book because she knew their stories needed to be told - and the sooner the better. For theirs is a legacy destined to embolden generations of women to come.
Mari K. Eder, retired U.S. Army Major General, is a renowned speaker and author, and a thought leader on strategic communication and leadership. General Eder has served as Director of Public Affairs at the George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies and as an adjunct professor and lecturer in communications and public diplomacy at the NATO School and Sweden’s International Training Command. She served in a number of senior positions in the Pentagon, on the Army Staff, as Deputy Chief of Public Affairs and Deputy Chief of the Army Reserve, and with DoD’s Reserve Forces Policy Board. General Eder speaks and writes frequently on communication, ethics, and security topics in universities and for international audiences and consults on communications issues. When not writing, lecturing, or traveling, she works with rescue groups and fosters rescued Schnauzers.
Great up until the last chapter in which she lists modern females who are supposedly stepping out of line and being firsts of some kind. She also makes a statement about such women being known by their humility and humanity ….. after listing Greta Thunberg, Nancy Pelosi, and Ilhan Omar as such women. If those are the types of women who are supposed to be our role models these days, females are doomed. What an absolute joke.
All of the women from WW2 were exceptional and I greatly enjoyed hearing their stories. Some I had heard before, whereas others were new and fascinating. They were extraordinary women living in extraordinary times.
This was an interesting book but some of the stories were drawn out. The last section of the book, authors overview, was repetitive of the information already presented in the book. It took all of my will power to finish it.
My husband works in the medical field and had a patient reading this book. He wrote down the title to share with me. I’d never heard of it.
I started listening to it and wouldn’t stop talking about it so it became our road trip listen.
This book is comprised of chapters focusing on various women that made contributions during WWII. I’d never heard of these women and their stories were fascinating!!! The stories also brought light to facets of WWII I didn’t know about, which I love. There was such a variety as well. There were women living in the U.S., multiple countries in Europe and in Asia as well.
There were spies, escapees, refugees, cartographers, prisoners of war, journalists, etc.
Some of the stories were soo exciting!
Some of the stories were not quite as exciting, but I am still glad they were included.
This book was a tremendous research effort and I am very glad we listened to it.
Neither of us liked the ending chapters as much, but I’d still highly recommend this one to any history enthusiasts.
This was a really in depth look at several women who are otherwise unknown. With the exception of Virginia Hall whom I had read a book about in 2020, none of these names were familiar. I am glad the author chose to dig into these people's stories and share them, especially as they have all since passed away and therefore cannot share their own stories any longer. It is important to recognize that winning the war was a collective effort not undertaken solely by white men, but was a national effort. This book celebrates that. I highly recommend it.
This was the book my book club read for Sept and one of the ladies said it best-it read like a history book. All of the stories about the ladies were interesting but I felt like I was reading one story after another about different women. I picked up this book for a while - stopped read two others And came back to it. I’m glad I read it but different than my normal reading.
A great introduction to some very important (and, for most of them, little-known) women who acted out of courage, service, and morality to make a difference during the course of WW II. This would be a great read for someone who's looking into finding out more about the people involved who didn't become "famous" characters after the war.
I really loved learning the stories of women who pioneered in their respective areas and paved the way for all who came behind them. I’m glad their stories are being told.
I very much enjoyed this book. Reading about so many women of “The Greatest Generation”, who were firsts in their military occupations was so interesting and eye opening.
This book sparked interesting conversations with my mother, so I think it’s a necessary book and probably good for an overview history/social studies course related to WWII. It’s fairly long and dry however, and reads a bit like an encyclopedia. My husband is reading the print version and I imagine the book might be better with the photographs he gets to experience. Also, the stories are supposedly “untold,” but as you go along it’s apparent that the majority of the women wrote their own memoirs or had books written about them as far back as 40 years ago, so the stories were definitely told before. The only new information seems to be the women dying circa 2019, which I guess turns the book into an obituary section of the newspaper.
I don’t mean to downplay the fantastic lives and accomplishments of the women listed in the book, but as far as a good read goes, I imagine the separate memoirs are better. I have read fantastic nonfiction historical records that are written in a page-turning style, so it is possible. Still, as a woman born in the 1980s, all of these stories were news to me, so clearly important that my generation make some study of this history, and I suppose a collection like this one makes that study more convenient. Probably some college professors should take note of the title for their students, or AP history teachers. But if you’re reading for pleasure, I’d advise skimming the reference section of this book for the actual memoirs. That’s what I plan to do for any future reading I do on this topic.
This book was amazing to read. All women that were mentioned had courage, determination, motivation, and finished their duties until the very end. I wished I had learned about them when I was in grade school or high school. This book would encourage young girls to find follow their dreams or give them an idea on what they want to do for their future. I just wish that women would have been treated better in the past like they do now.
So I'm trying to read more nonfiction. Unfortunately this one reminded me why I don't read non fiction. It read like my college thesis.My college thesis was not good. ** I'm back a month later to say this book was actually not good after having sat with it for a minute. I get a headache anytime I think about it.
The thing I liked most about this book was that it wasn’t about just one exceptional woman, it was about many exceptional women. These women stepped up to serve during WWII because they felt a call to service in a time when civilization, itself, appeared to be at risk. It wasn’t enough to keep the home fires burning. Women had to step up to support a war effort in ways they had never done before and they did it in numbers and roles that were every bit as varied and heroic as their male counterparts, all the while fighting or circumventing cultural restrictions aimed at keeping them in their place. This book details these contributions of women who stepped up in their communities as volunteers and those who flocked to military service roles that hadn’t existed before, creating their service roles as they challenged the massive resistance of the male-dominated systems they entered, or remaining in their communities, secretly supporting and rescuing those most at risk from fascist forces bent on eliminating entire populations they regarded as subhuman. These women were professional military (but only in support roles), spies, cartographers, medical personnel, teachers, athletes, postal workers, organizers, proto-social workers, even a chicken farmer, but they all found ways to contribute to the war effort.
It was inspiring to read each of the stories. My only real criticism is the poor quality of the photographs that were included. They were dark and blurry. I couldn’t make out their faces or other details, which was unfortunate because I really wanted to look into the faces of these remarkable women. I realize they were old snapshots and camera quality wasn’t what it is now, but there are ways to improve picture quality using modern computer technology that would have immeasurably cleared up the details and brought these women to life on the pages. They deserve that.
Also the final chapters were a little redundant. The author added more detail to the stories of women in the previous chapters but it was difficult to remember who they were without looking back at previous chapters. I’m not good at remembering names so it was hard to find them back in such a lengthy book. And she greatly expanded the list with snippets of additional stories that proved intriguing but inadequate. She also expanded the list of significant role models into current history which really didn’t fit. Maybe she needed another additional volume or sequel. I understand the dilemma. It’s hard to cover the significant contributions of so many women in a single history. Women need more than one book. Look how many books produced by Damien Lewis about male soldiers in WWII. And he’s just one of many historians of this period. There’s a lot more to cover so I hope she and other authors make a priority of writing women’s histories to fill in the gaps and from here on, write inclusive histories that tell more complete stories about human progress and achievement.
I absolutely loved The Girls Who Stepped Out of Line! This was such a fascinating and inspiring collection of stories about real women in history who stepped up, broke barriers, and made a difference.
I especially enjoyed learning about these women because so much of their history was completely new to me. I had no idea that Wonder Woman was inspired by a real person, and I found myself constantly surprised by the stories and contributions of these incredible women.
Although this is a history book, it never felt like I was just reading facts and dates. Mari Eder writes these stories in a way that pulls you in and makes you feel connected to the women behind the history. Their courage, determination, and resilience truly came through on every page.
I love discovering pieces of history that I didn't know before, and this book gave me so many new people to learn about and admire. A must-read for anyone who enjoys history, especially the stories of the remarkable women who helped shape our world.
I thoroughly enjoyed Major General Mari K. Eder's collection of stories about women who "stepped out of line" during WWII to put their talents to use, challenge bigotry and prejudice, and save lives. Her book celebrates women whose accomplishments during the war were swept under the rug due to prejudice. You learn of the courage of Resistance fighters, women who rescued Jews and others persecuted by the Nazis, flyers, cartographers, nurses, spies, and the 6888th Postal Battalion who saved fighting morale - all overcoming impossible odds with courage, discipline, insight, determination, and compassion. Eder's research and sources are reliable and extensive, her writing itself is clear and exciting, while her extensive array of the various roles women played is convincing. An enjoyable and inspirational book.
The Girls Who Stepped Out of Line was an interesting and eye-opening read about the women who served in the military and contributed in ways that are often overlooked in history. I appreciated learning about their experiences, challenges, and the barriers they faced while serving.
That said, I found some parts of the book a little repetitive, and I didn’t connect equally with every story. While the subject matter was important, the pacing made it harder for me to stay fully engaged at times.
Overall, I’m glad I read it and learned more about these women and their contributions. It’s a worthwhile book for anyone interested in military history and the often-overlooked stories of women who served.
From some of these women’s stories it brought tears in my eyes being from mostly the gratitude I feel for them but also because my feminism was screaming in learning they were not getting recognized—until 50 later, having no benefits, having to keep their life a secret, cracking war codes, military status denial. I cannot imagine where our country would be without these women! I gave 4 stars because the writing around the stories was not strong and it made it slow.
Interesting stories of very courageous women in World War II, whose stories need to be shared. However, I found at times that the book was a little dry. It wasn't a book that made me want to keep reading. Fortunately, the chapters were rather short. I forced myself to finish but found the later chapters to be less interesting and, at times, a bit repetitive.
Interesting topic. I had an issue with them calling it the “Palestine problem”, but outside of that it was interesting to learn about the women that changed history. I can only imagine how hard it would have been to do so much for our country during world war 2 only to then have to return to the status quo submissive life of the 1950s for women.
Excellent book and well titled. We’ve read extensively about women résistants, spies, and code breakers in WWII but this has expanded our knowledge of the role of women in military WWII history. The detailed bibliography is providing us future reads.
This one one of the most interesting books about women in the war that I've read. Each chapter is about a different woman so it really was easier to read. I highly recommend this book. I have 3 more books on women in the war to read. A very interesting and great read.
I loved every chapter of this book. I listened to it after solo-hiking the Tanner Trail in Grand Canyon. It was fun to hear all the stories of women much braver than I. And the stories are very entertaining, not boring at all.
“We stand on their shoulders because they stepped out of line.” Amazing stories about women who paved the way for women today. We still have a long way to go but wouldn’t be where we are without these brave heroes! 🫡 💪