3.75⭐️
There is a sprinkle of spoilers in this review - Thank you to NetGalley for giving me this ARC in return for an honest review.
Maeve Kaminski is a very OCD 24-year-old young lady who just got her heart broken by a boyfriend who used her name to open up a credit card and rack her up in debt. Tragic. While this is happening, Maeve learns that her biological dad (whom she never met) has passed and has given her his pub in a small town in Ireland. Maeve travels to Ireland without letting her family know the situation (I could never). How her mom never asked where she was the whole first 3/4 of the book surprises me (well, she was on a cruise, but still). She discovers in this town, there are only two pubs, and they are rivals. Now, based on this, you can tell what the trope will be—enemies to lovers. You can’t go wrong with that. In my opinion, they aren’t necessarily “enemies,” but they are in a family/pub rivalry that turns into a love story. Briggs (who we find out has the same heart condition as his deceased father) is the owner (after his father passes) of the other pub in town. Long story short, they meet and instantly have crushes on each other. But God forbid you both ruin the rivalry and fall in love.
As the book goes on, Maeve stays longer than anticipated and is debating on selling the pub as she can’t run it because her whole life in Chicago is waiting for her. My job would have fired me if I had been gone that long. In order to sell the pub, her father has made it difficult by creating a checklist (before death) she must complete to get the blessing to sell. She is working with a very annoying man, Eoin O’Connor (a giant piece of work), who is in charge of the will/overseeing the pub falling to Maeve.
About 60% into the book, Maeve and Briggs finally communicate and tell each other how they feel…except Maeve hasn’t told him she plans on selling the pub and moving back home. At this point, you can guess what will most likely happen: he finds out, they stop talking, she goes home, one of them runs to the other and says they can’t live without them, yada yada yada. And if you guessed that, you’re right. There isn’t much of a plot twist in this ending as it would if you were reading another romance novel.
Maeve does learn that one of the items on the list was, in a way, a trick and discovers her dad left her his apartment as well. To me, the list was a distraction and a way for her to know the town more and the people to make her, in the end, want to stay. When she finally learns about the apartment from sweet Barb, she finds a letter he wrote. I will say I did tear up a bit reading the letter. In the beginning, you see the biological dad as a bad guy, but in the end, he’s not so bad and had reasons for never communicating.
Fast forward, we get to them being all lovey-dovey. First of all, this is labeled as a YA book; I wouldn’t categorize it as that at all. There are too many things that make it not YA. Second of all, if a man starts tickling me and blowing raspberries on my stomach, I’m getting up and walking out the door, never to return. Good lord, LOL. I usually cringe a lot during romance novels, but that made me physically ill, haha. He asks her to be his girlfriend, and they hide the relationship for apparent reasons. They go to Cork on a date where the whole town can’t see them and stir up drama. During this time, she meets her grandfather, who she recently learned was still alive. I teared up again. Briggs also tells her he loves her, and she hits him with a “thank you for telling me that” line like it’s The Bachelor. They get back, and everything is fine. At this point, the next chapter throws me off as she determines she’s staying in Ireland, but she is still trying to check off the last item on the list to sell the pub. In my mind, she’d want to keep the pub if she’s staying. After she gets back from this excursion, Briggs is waiting for her, freaking out cause he couldn’t get a hold of her in the storm. Because of this, he goes off on a rant about how he can’t do this anymore blah blah blah, and then proceeds to propose to her which she tells him to wait. By 80% of the book, she still hasn’t told her family about anything (ex-boyfriend/debt included) or told Briggs the whole truth (ex-boyfriend and selling the pub). She gives herself 48 hours to get all the secrets and situations cleared.
And then it all falls apart. Within a couple of pages, that little prick Eoin shows up and ruins a housewarming party and dumps all her secrets about the list and selling the pub to everyone in the room. Briggs is upset and storms out, feeling betrayed. Somehow, Maeve’s text messages haven’t been coming in, and she’s just now getting messages. Turns out her mom knows she’s in Ireland and is livid. Part of it is her best friend’s fault (who she argued with earlier in the book. Not too critical). She’s shocked and doesn’t know what to do. If I could punch Eoin through the book, I would.
The next day, Briggs gets to his senses and runs back to the bar/apartment, but she’s gone back to Chicago. Because of all the running and the stress, the chapter ends with him collapsing from too much push on his heart condition. Maeve has been in Chicago for a couple of weeks now, all depressed and mopey. She finally goes back to her apartment, and guess who shows up? No, not Briggs. The scammy ex-boyfriend to pay her back for the debt. Later, she gets an email from nasty little Eoin with her dad's letter for when she completed the list. It turns out I was wrong, and he did want her to sell it and not feel like she had any regrets. He wants her not to feel trapped like he did and to have her live her life.
Now it's Maeve's turn to come to her senses. She finally realizes she doesn’t want to sell the pub and needs to return to Ireland ASAP. At the airport, she gets a text about something wrong with Briggs. He had the surgery he was putting off and is doing better. He planned on going to Chicago to chase after her, but she beat him to it. They catch up, and she tells him she’s staying and running the pub. The book ends happily, with them together and obviously in love.
In the epilogue, Maeve writes her deceased dad a sweet letter catching him up on the last year. She talks about her and Briggs finally getting engaged, her not selling the pub, and many other things—a perfect way to end the book without it being 600 pages.
Overall, this was a cute book. I didn’t love it, but I liked it.