Replacement plays with a tried-and true trope, twins who switch places. In this case, Jade needs a place to hide from her unrelenting stalker and his associates. So when her sister Amber unexpectedly reaches out after years of neglect, Jade’s willing to agree to her rather crazy scheme to pretend to be Amber so that Amber can escape a relationship she’s really only in for the money.
Both Jade and William are likable people, but your belief in this story is going to hinge on your acceptance of the switched-twins trope. In this case, I struggled with it. Jade is so different from her twin that she very quickly retreats to the things she loves in life: making jewelry and cooking (which is about all we know about her). Amber is set up to be amazingly superficial, in part to allow Jade to be able to impersonate her, but after a decade apart it’s hard to believe Jade knows enough about Amber to fake being her 24/7.
William didn’t really form as a character in my mind. He’s set up as a workaholic, but that’s it. The Worthing properties that are a focal point of the first book in this series are just a means to his job—we never even find out what work he’ll be doing when he moves to focus on a few businesses. He’s generally sketched, and other than being nice, he isn’t much at all.
Jade’s stalking situation is also pat—somehow her stalker is obsessed with her after a 20-minute conversation, to the point of moving a lot of pieces around to find her over and over. There’s really no reason why, since he’s basically a bogeyman figure.
What’s winning in this book is Adams’ assured writing style. It made the book accessible, particularly as Jade is a truly appealing character. But I felt removed from this couple and their story.