I don't think I've ever disagreed more on the reviews of a book than I do on this one. Only a smattering of Goodreads reviews, many 1 and 2 star ratings. Just proves again that my taste is very different from the general public's. I LOVED this book. 6 stars. Devoured it on vacation. Evocative, charged, suspenseful, unique, breathtaking prose. The plot is deftly handled, keeps you guessing till the last page, and I wasn't disappointed. I kept wondering how Spalding would get herself out of the plot she had built so carefully to a point where it almost implodes, then she gently reels it back in and ends on a perfect note (don't want to give it away). Not many writers can do that. I had read her Daughters of Captain Cook years ago and loved the writing, but this is a novel I will read again and again for the settings, the characters, and the heart wrenching story. Spalding's an acrobat on paper.