What do you think?
Rate this book
Swing
Debut author/illustrator Audrey Meeker playfully explores complicated friendships, gender norms, and navigating other people's expectations in this charming middle grade graphic novel.
Marcus McCalister wants to fit in. So much so that he’s still playing on a soccer team with his childhood friend Ted, despite not liking soccer―or Ted―all that much.
Izzy Briggs wants to stand out. Being labeled the “weird kid” for her bold fashion choices is the price an aspiring designer must pay for a life of greatness―but being confident isn't always easy.
So when Izzy and Marcus are paired together to perform a swing dance routine for a gym project, it’s no surprise that everything goes up in flames, including their grade in the class. Until their gym teacher proposes a deal: if the pair performs the swing routine in the upcoming talent show, they’ll receive extra credit and a passing grade. They accept. . . but Izzy has her own proposal for Marcus: this time, she gets to be the lead.
Marcus McCalister wants to fit in. So much so that he’s still playing on a soccer team with his childhood friend Ted, despite not liking soccer―or Ted―all that much.
Izzy Briggs wants to stand out. Being labeled the “weird kid” for her bold fashion choices is the price an aspiring designer must pay for a life of greatness―but being confident isn't always easy.
So when Izzy and Marcus are paired together to perform a swing dance routine for a gym project, it’s no surprise that everything goes up in flames, including their grade in the class. Until their gym teacher proposes a deal: if the pair performs the swing routine in the upcoming talent show, they’ll receive extra credit and a passing grade. They accept. . . but Izzy has her own proposal for Marcus: this time, she gets to be the lead.
256 pages, Hardcover
First published October 22, 2024
3 people are currently reading
355 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
January 15, 2025
Oh man, my students are going to love this book. So nice to have a story that focuses on the friendship between a boy and a girl and doesn't push it to be anything more. Also love that it explores the pressures that their parents can sometimes unwittingly put on their kids to perform well academically or be involved in sports that they do not necessarily love, something that my students will definitely be able to relate to.
March 18, 2024
I received an ARC from Macmillan Children's Publishing Group via NetGalley. This middle grade graphic novel follows two 8th graders. Marcus doesn’t want to follow in the footsteps of his big brothers soccer stardom. Izzy just wants to do theatre set designs and be herself. They are paired together in gym for a session in dance. Now Marcus and Izzy have to learn how to work as a team to present Swing dance for a final grade. This was another good addition to the trials of middle school bullying, sports, friendship, family expectations and fitting in. It’s an easy recommendation with a good ending.
July 21, 2025
A debut MG graphic novel.
💃🏻
Marcus doesn’t want to play soccer anymore, but pressure from his teammates and family has him caving and attending tryouts as his last year of middle school begins. Izzy hates most of school, but when it comes to Theater Club, she’s all in. Izzy and Marcus are paired together for a gym dance assignment and get swing dancing, but Marcus can’t lead, which forces them to fail the assignment. Hoping to get extra credit so they can both pass, they agree to the coach’s offer to enter the talent show. Will Marcus’s fear of what others think keep him from partnering with Izzy?
🕺🏽
This was such an adorable book It’s popular in my middle school library so I only just now got around to reading it, but I loved how it addressed bullying and fighting against gender norms and stereotypes. I can’t wait to see what the author does next.
CW: bullying, physical assault, blood, toxic friendship, injury, peer pressure, emotional abuse
💃🏻
Marcus doesn’t want to play soccer anymore, but pressure from his teammates and family has him caving and attending tryouts as his last year of middle school begins. Izzy hates most of school, but when it comes to Theater Club, she’s all in. Izzy and Marcus are paired together for a gym dance assignment and get swing dancing, but Marcus can’t lead, which forces them to fail the assignment. Hoping to get extra credit so they can both pass, they agree to the coach’s offer to enter the talent show. Will Marcus’s fear of what others think keep him from partnering with Izzy?
🕺🏽
This was such an adorable book It’s popular in my middle school library so I only just now got around to reading it, but I loved how it addressed bullying and fighting against gender norms and stereotypes. I can’t wait to see what the author does next.
CW: bullying, physical assault, blood, toxic friendship, injury, peer pressure, emotional abuse
June 18, 2024
DEFINITELY NOT BIASED BUT SOOOOO GOOD
August 5, 2025
Two kids who are weighed down by their families' expectations for them are thrown together by an extra credit assignment. Burgeoning friendship vs. peer pressure. Getting the people we care about to listen to us. Overturning gender expectations in fun ways.
March 20, 2025
Too cute, too real
March 4, 2025
While I liked the book subverted some tropes (like not having the characters end up as a couple), it still fit the usual 'main character disparages true friend for fake friend/people who don't care for them until the last minute.'
Again, tropes are fine, but Marcus was so spineless at times it didn't make a fun journey, but I understand middle schoolers wanting to fit in with the status quo. Not too mention Izzy was overly prickly.
Toxic masculinity and gender roles are a big theme here aside from parental expectations and playing a role. Marcus gets bullied about doing a "girly" activity such as (swing) dancing; While it felt unrealistic there was growth on his part.
Pretty good!
2.5
Again, tropes are fine, but Marcus was so spineless at times it didn't make a fun journey, but I understand middle schoolers wanting to fit in with the status quo. Not too mention Izzy was overly prickly.
Toxic masculinity and gender roles are a big theme here aside from parental expectations and playing a role. Marcus gets bullied about doing a "girly" activity such as (swing) dancing; While it felt unrealistic there was growth on his part.
Pretty good!
2.5
February 10, 2025
Absolutely freaking adorable! Love the bending of gender norms, standing up to bullies (and friends and parents!), and making new friends while being true to yourself. Lots of great support from family and friends (eventually). So sweet!
September 8, 2024
Hi everyone,
We are somehow nearly halfway through September and I honestly have no idea where the time has gone. So last week I wanted to take some time to read some more upcoming graphic novels. There are always so many new ones coming out and graphic novels are amazing. Recently I received an E-ARC of Swing, an upcoming graphic novel (thank you so much to the publisher for the E-ARC in exchange for my honest opinions). So I went ahead and downloaded it and dove in!
SPOILERS AHEAD
Marcus is about to start another school year in middle school. His older brother is in high school and a soccer legend, so his parents kind of expect the same from him. Marcus does play soccer and he plays it really well however, he does not really like it. It’s just not his thing but he does not want to let his parents down. On the first day of school in gym class, the students are given an assignment, they will be working in partners and have one week to learn a dance style, that they draw from a hat. Marcus is paired with Izzy, Izzy is kind of the outcast of the grade level but she is a nice person deep down, it’s just she is bullied a lot for how she dresses. Now Marcus and Izzy have a week to learn swing dancing and on top of that Marcus still has soccer practice. On the day the pair are due to swing dance, they absolutely fail and now the teacher is saying the only way to pass the class for the year is to spend time practicing the dance and perform it in the talent show. Neither Izzy nor Marcus are happy about it but they do not want to fail so now they are forced to practice together outside of school.
I absolutely loved this story. Marcus and Izzy were both such interesting characters as well as their families. Each had very different home lives and experiences and it was nice to see how they learned to work together and help each other even outside of the project. The art in the graphic novel was very vivid and bright (which I absolutely love)! This graphic novel hits shelves on October 22nd. I highly recommend picking it up and giving it a try!
Goodreads Rating: 5 Stars
***Thank you so much to the publisher for the E-ARC in exchange for my honest opinions.
We are somehow nearly halfway through September and I honestly have no idea where the time has gone. So last week I wanted to take some time to read some more upcoming graphic novels. There are always so many new ones coming out and graphic novels are amazing. Recently I received an E-ARC of Swing, an upcoming graphic novel (thank you so much to the publisher for the E-ARC in exchange for my honest opinions). So I went ahead and downloaded it and dove in!
SPOILERS AHEAD
Marcus is about to start another school year in middle school. His older brother is in high school and a soccer legend, so his parents kind of expect the same from him. Marcus does play soccer and he plays it really well however, he does not really like it. It’s just not his thing but he does not want to let his parents down. On the first day of school in gym class, the students are given an assignment, they will be working in partners and have one week to learn a dance style, that they draw from a hat. Marcus is paired with Izzy, Izzy is kind of the outcast of the grade level but she is a nice person deep down, it’s just she is bullied a lot for how she dresses. Now Marcus and Izzy have a week to learn swing dancing and on top of that Marcus still has soccer practice. On the day the pair are due to swing dance, they absolutely fail and now the teacher is saying the only way to pass the class for the year is to spend time practicing the dance and perform it in the talent show. Neither Izzy nor Marcus are happy about it but they do not want to fail so now they are forced to practice together outside of school.
I absolutely loved this story. Marcus and Izzy were both such interesting characters as well as their families. Each had very different home lives and experiences and it was nice to see how they learned to work together and help each other even outside of the project. The art in the graphic novel was very vivid and bright (which I absolutely love)! This graphic novel hits shelves on October 22nd. I highly recommend picking it up and giving it a try!
Goodreads Rating: 5 Stars
***Thank you so much to the publisher for the E-ARC in exchange for my honest opinions.
September 4, 2024
E-ARC from NetGalley
In the same vein as the Prince and the Dressmaker and Smile, Swing is a middle grade graphic novel is a love story to the weird kids and the kids who don’t fit in. Two opposite 8th graders are forced to do a class project…perform a swing dance routine. Marcus, a reluctant soccer player, struggles to fit in, while Izzy, the artsy “weird girl,” wants to lie low.
Marcus and Izzy are the odd couple. But the class project creates a new friendship and helps both grow and realize what they want to be. I can see this being incredibly popular with 8th graders, especially those who love Raina Telgemeir
In the same vein as the Prince and the Dressmaker and Smile, Swing is a middle grade graphic novel is a love story to the weird kids and the kids who don’t fit in. Two opposite 8th graders are forced to do a class project…perform a swing dance routine. Marcus, a reluctant soccer player, struggles to fit in, while Izzy, the artsy “weird girl,” wants to lie low.
Marcus and Izzy are the odd couple. But the class project creates a new friendship and helps both grow and realize what they want to be. I can see this being incredibly popular with 8th graders, especially those who love Raina Telgemeir
January 31, 2025
4.5 star rating; but I rounded it up to 5! I dropped it half a star because I really didn't like Ted at all. He was a little brat.
I honestly loved everybody else in the story. Marcus and Izzy were both great. I also love Marcus' older brother. I wish Marcus could have been honest with his parents from the beginning. Max understood him at the end. I wish this happened a little earlier.
I also loved Izzy. She really wanted to be her own person. Her mother was honestly too controlling, but she also got better at the end. I love that she was also able to make the outfits for the theater club like she wanted.
I honestly loved everybody else in the story. Marcus and Izzy were both great. I also love Marcus' older brother. I wish Marcus could have been honest with his parents from the beginning. Max understood him at the end. I wish this happened a little earlier.
I also loved Izzy. She really wanted to be her own person. Her mother was honestly too controlling, but she also got better at the end. I love that she was also able to make the outfits for the theater club like she wanted.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 25, 2025
Absolutely ADORED this! It’s such a good focus on allowing the expectations of others to dictate who you are and what you stand for and now you come out of that to be your own person. It’s a look at friendship and the pressure of who has come before you.
I felt like the ending was a little quick, but I still enjoyed it!
I felt like the ending was a little quick, but I still enjoyed it!
February 1, 2025
Swing
Overall Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ .5 (3.5/5) or 7.28/10 overall
Characters - 7
Atmosphere - 8
Writing - 7
Plot - 7
Intrigue - 7
Logic - 7
Enjoyment - 8
Overall Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ .5 (3.5/5) or 7.28/10 overall
Characters - 7
Atmosphere - 8
Writing - 7
Plot - 7
Intrigue - 7
Logic - 7
Enjoyment - 8
April 18, 2025
Cute with a basic predictable plot.
May 25, 2025
it was a really fun book, my daughter also loved it! she has been reading it repeatedly!! lol
July 2, 2024
What I liked:
Marcus’s need to fit in conflicting with his desire to stop playing soccer felt very realistic and sympathetic, as did his changing relationship with Ted. Overall, the school dynamics felt familiar, if a tad too much so at times, and the scenes in gym class were some of the most relatable I’ve encountered often in middle-grade books.
What I struggled with:
I had a hard time connecting with the actual art style of this book—it’s very blocky and straightforward, without much nuance either in the depictions of characters/settings or in the way the panels are organized. I feel the need to preface my other thoughts with that because I think that, since the art is literally the medium through which the story is conveyed, I do believe it colored other opinions I have on the book as a whole. Perhaps because of that, many of the characters felt less well-rounded than they perhaps should have, and I struggled to connect with Izzy in particular.
This is perhaps a bit more opinion-based, but I also chafed slightly at the depiction of Izzy leading the dance being such a huge twist. In the context of the story, Izzy is the obvious choice for the position given her greater skill and interest. Although I understand the backlash that Marcus faced due to this decision, he takes what feels like a much larger step outside of traditional gender norms with his outfit at the talent show itself without much thought, which made this not ring altogether true. Additionally, since gender norms/stereotypes feel otherwise upheld in Izzy and Marcus’s friendship, this plotline felt like something of a letdown.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an eARC for review purposes in exchange for an honest review! All opinions expressed here are my own.
Marcus’s need to fit in conflicting with his desire to stop playing soccer felt very realistic and sympathetic, as did his changing relationship with Ted. Overall, the school dynamics felt familiar, if a tad too much so at times, and the scenes in gym class were some of the most relatable I’ve encountered often in middle-grade books.
What I struggled with:
I had a hard time connecting with the actual art style of this book—it’s very blocky and straightforward, without much nuance either in the depictions of characters/settings or in the way the panels are organized. I feel the need to preface my other thoughts with that because I think that, since the art is literally the medium through which the story is conveyed, I do believe it colored other opinions I have on the book as a whole. Perhaps because of that, many of the characters felt less well-rounded than they perhaps should have, and I struggled to connect with Izzy in particular.
This is perhaps a bit more opinion-based, but I also chafed slightly at the depiction of Izzy leading the dance being such a huge twist. In the context of the story, Izzy is the obvious choice for the position given her greater skill and interest. Although I understand the backlash that Marcus faced due to this decision, he takes what feels like a much larger step outside of traditional gender norms with his outfit at the talent show itself without much thought, which made this not ring altogether true. Additionally, since gender norms/stereotypes feel otherwise upheld in Izzy and Marcus’s friendship, this plotline felt like something of a letdown.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an eARC for review purposes in exchange for an honest review! All opinions expressed here are my own.
January 26, 2025
This can be a very frustrating read, because the protagonist is very frustrating. He's super wishy washy and passive through almost the entire book.
October 13, 2024
This is a beautiful graphic novel, not only artistically but message wise. There is so much pressure as a teen trying to figure out where you fit. Trying to fulfill everyone expectations can be exhausting, especially when you are not doing things that fill you with joy. Sometimes though it feels like your joy has to take a back seat if you are going to make your parents or peers happy. I love that both Marcus and Izzy are both on their own journeys one to fit in and the other to stand out. I think that the progression of this story is perfection and one that will resonate with kids. That Marcus realizes that standing out is not always bad by the end of the book is just everything. So many times boys really get pigeon holed and Marcus breaks that mold and I appreciate that he does it with such grace. Thank you so much to Macmillan Children's Publishing Group, Feiwel & Friends, and Netgalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this title.
August 11, 2024
I really loved this graphic novel. Besides the engaging illustrations, I adored the multi-layered story which covers bullying, friendships, relationships with parents and teachers, and first crushes to name a few. The layout Meade this graphic novel very easy to navigate and I’m confident my students who are partial to text and those who respond more to images will enjoy. I look forward to seeing more from Meeker.
March 7, 2025
Entertaining. Two good main characters with their own issues with school and home forming a reluctant friendship. Fans of Raina Telgemeier books will enjoy this one. Similar style, art and storyline but doesn't seem like a copy of her work. Stands alone.
June 26, 2024
E ARC provided by Netgalley
School projects can make for strange companions, and in this graphic novel Marcus, a reluctant soccer player, and Izzy, an aspiring fashion designer, are thrown together in a dance project for physical education class. Starting 8th grade is hard for Marcus, who is not as interested in soccer as his older brother is, especially since his former best friend and teammate, Ted, is a jerk. Ted, who also has an older brother, demands that Marcus show up for soccer practice so that the two can beat their brothers' team record, but Marcus wants to distance himself both from the sport and from Ted. Izzy, who often rocks a quirky quasi-Goth style, is on the recieving end of lots of negative comments from classmates, and is also under a lot of pressure from her mother to get good grades. Marcus and Izzy have to do a swing dance for class, which leads Ted to make fun of them, especially when they also end up sitting together in advanced language arts class... for the whole year! Marcus does go to team tryouts but is increasingly bothered by Ted's actions, even though he isn't brave enough to stand up to him. Izzy, meanwhile, finds a welcoming place in the theater group, where Ramona is excited to have her on board for talent show planning and costumes. Marcus and Izzy practice, and do a decent job, although Marcus has trouble leading. When the two do their dance for a grade, Marcus is distracted by Ted's comments, and it ends in disaster. Mr. Walsh, their gym teacher (and retired dancer!) says that their poor grade is enough that they might have to retake the class... unless they do a swing dance for the talent show. Izzy is NOT going to have her grades affected so that her mother has an excuse to pull her out of theater, so the two work on their dance. They actually enjoy being together, and may even have a little crush on each other, if we believe the many flushed cheeks in the pictures. They even hang out, eating popsicles on the driveway, and talk about the pressures they face at school. Of course, Ted isn't happy with Marcus' relationship, especially when he gets put on the silver team instead of the gold one, ruining their chances of beating their brothers. He even spies on the two and posts negative pictures of them on social media. Marcus finds out, and tells Ted that it's not like he's REALLY friends with Izzy--imagine the sorts of things tweens would say to try to save face. Of course, Izzy overhears and asks Mr. Walsh if she can dance solo in the show. Since Izzy's mother had to get the principal involved when Ted bullied Izzy in 7th grade, this is allowed, and Marcus ends up cleaning gym equipment. When Ted is mean about how Marcus plays during a big game, Marcus has had enough, and goes to Izzy's house with a box of soccer treat popsicles to apologize and ask to be able to dance with her. Izzy agrees, as long as Marcus will wear whatever costume she suggests. Marcus ends up in a silly shirt and pants, which rip as they are getting on the stage. Throwing caution to the wind, he dons a skirt, and the two do a great dance. They win second place, Izzy's mom apologizes for trying to deny Izzy the opportunity to do theater, and both Marcus and Ted have heart-to-hearts with their brothers.
Strengths: This is middle school bullying. It's calling people "clown show" when they're at their locker and teachers can't hear. It's Ted giving Marcus a hard time about not playing soccer and hanging out with Izzy. It's a thousand tiny paper cuts of social pressure and judgement. The sibling rivalry is also very true; I have to admit to motivating cross country runners to best their older sibling's time by reminding them that they would have bragging rights at Thanksgiving forever! Marcus' desire to drop out of soccer but he inability to do so is quite common, and it was good to see that Izzy did find a place where she was happy. The constant embarassment and discomfort pretty much defines middle school for many people. It's good to see a happy ending and emotional growth, because that gives readers struggling with their own issues hope that there may be a happy ending for them as well.
Weaknesses: This is not how grades work. Had Mr. Walsh failed the two, Izzy's mom would have thrown a fit with the principal and gotten Mr. Walsh in trouble. It's much more likely that Mr. Walsh would have taken pity on them and let them redo the dance at lunch, and one project is rarely enough to torpedo grades in any classes in today's academic climate. Pretty sure that if Marcus and Izzy showed up for class every day and tried, they would have gotten at least a B. The skirt seemed over the top to me, but since I have a lot of boys who wear eyeliner and nail polish, I don't think today's tweens will think it's as scandalous as Ted seems to.
What I really think: Definitely purchasing, and this will be a popular title with fans of books with plenty of friend drama. Looking forward to seeing more titles from this author.
School projects can make for strange companions, and in this graphic novel Marcus, a reluctant soccer player, and Izzy, an aspiring fashion designer, are thrown together in a dance project for physical education class. Starting 8th grade is hard for Marcus, who is not as interested in soccer as his older brother is, especially since his former best friend and teammate, Ted, is a jerk. Ted, who also has an older brother, demands that Marcus show up for soccer practice so that the two can beat their brothers' team record, but Marcus wants to distance himself both from the sport and from Ted. Izzy, who often rocks a quirky quasi-Goth style, is on the recieving end of lots of negative comments from classmates, and is also under a lot of pressure from her mother to get good grades. Marcus and Izzy have to do a swing dance for class, which leads Ted to make fun of them, especially when they also end up sitting together in advanced language arts class... for the whole year! Marcus does go to team tryouts but is increasingly bothered by Ted's actions, even though he isn't brave enough to stand up to him. Izzy, meanwhile, finds a welcoming place in the theater group, where Ramona is excited to have her on board for talent show planning and costumes. Marcus and Izzy practice, and do a decent job, although Marcus has trouble leading. When the two do their dance for a grade, Marcus is distracted by Ted's comments, and it ends in disaster. Mr. Walsh, their gym teacher (and retired dancer!) says that their poor grade is enough that they might have to retake the class... unless they do a swing dance for the talent show. Izzy is NOT going to have her grades affected so that her mother has an excuse to pull her out of theater, so the two work on their dance. They actually enjoy being together, and may even have a little crush on each other, if we believe the many flushed cheeks in the pictures. They even hang out, eating popsicles on the driveway, and talk about the pressures they face at school. Of course, Ted isn't happy with Marcus' relationship, especially when he gets put on the silver team instead of the gold one, ruining their chances of beating their brothers. He even spies on the two and posts negative pictures of them on social media. Marcus finds out, and tells Ted that it's not like he's REALLY friends with Izzy--imagine the sorts of things tweens would say to try to save face. Of course, Izzy overhears and asks Mr. Walsh if she can dance solo in the show. Since Izzy's mother had to get the principal involved when Ted bullied Izzy in 7th grade, this is allowed, and Marcus ends up cleaning gym equipment. When Ted is mean about how Marcus plays during a big game, Marcus has had enough, and goes to Izzy's house with a box of soccer treat popsicles to apologize and ask to be able to dance with her. Izzy agrees, as long as Marcus will wear whatever costume she suggests. Marcus ends up in a silly shirt and pants, which rip as they are getting on the stage. Throwing caution to the wind, he dons a skirt, and the two do a great dance. They win second place, Izzy's mom apologizes for trying to deny Izzy the opportunity to do theater, and both Marcus and Ted have heart-to-hearts with their brothers.
Strengths: This is middle school bullying. It's calling people "clown show" when they're at their locker and teachers can't hear. It's Ted giving Marcus a hard time about not playing soccer and hanging out with Izzy. It's a thousand tiny paper cuts of social pressure and judgement. The sibling rivalry is also very true; I have to admit to motivating cross country runners to best their older sibling's time by reminding them that they would have bragging rights at Thanksgiving forever! Marcus' desire to drop out of soccer but he inability to do so is quite common, and it was good to see that Izzy did find a place where she was happy. The constant embarassment and discomfort pretty much defines middle school for many people. It's good to see a happy ending and emotional growth, because that gives readers struggling with their own issues hope that there may be a happy ending for them as well.
Weaknesses: This is not how grades work. Had Mr. Walsh failed the two, Izzy's mom would have thrown a fit with the principal and gotten Mr. Walsh in trouble. It's much more likely that Mr. Walsh would have taken pity on them and let them redo the dance at lunch, and one project is rarely enough to torpedo grades in any classes in today's academic climate. Pretty sure that if Marcus and Izzy showed up for class every day and tried, they would have gotten at least a B. The skirt seemed over the top to me, but since I have a lot of boys who wear eyeliner and nail polish, I don't think today's tweens will think it's as scandalous as Ted seems to.
What I really think: Definitely purchasing, and this will be a popular title with fans of books with plenty of friend drama. Looking forward to seeing more titles from this author.
September 12, 2024
A contemporary story about two eighth graders with very different temperments who are forced to work together on a dance project. Marcus is defined mainly by what he doesn't like. He doesn't enjoy playing soccer anymore, even though he's good at it, and he doesn't enjoy spending time with his "friend," Ted. For kids going through middle school, having a character who is mostly coasting through life and tolerating things they don't enjoy, Marcus is realistically portrayed. However, it creates more work to make him an interesting character. Meanwhile, Izzy is the more identifiable and dynamic protagonist. A girl with pink hair and punk/alt-rock influenced clothes, who wants to be a costume designer and has a visible nervous tick of pulling at her wrist bands when she's nervous.
The two are paired up for a P.E. project where they are expected to practice a style of dance. Since neither of them have any friends willing to partner with them, they're stuck together learning swing. The swing dance sections seem fun, although the focus is less on embracing this new activity and more dealing with the personality issues of their partner. It feels like a lot of rom-coms, where misunderstandings and clumsy introductions sour each other's first impression. In some ways the conflicts feel almost too much, where their mutual awkwardness could have sufficed to make their partnership difficult. Another extreme conflict catalyst is the inclusion of Ted, who is not just an old friend Marcus grew apart from, but an active bully who harasses Izzy and stalks Marcus to blackmail him into focusing on soccer.
While some of the plot progresses with a heavier hand, the development of Izzy and Marcus into reluctant friends is the strongest part of the book. There is no loud confession or emotional revelation, they just realize after the initial bickering that they have learned to get along. There is a real charm to the exchange "you doing alright?"/"shut up" while they practice holding onto each other that perfectly moves their relationship from one of arguments to friendly banter. The blushing does suggest there may be an element to their relationship that's partially a crush, which is neither confirmed or denied in the story. It's nice to have that ambiguity, although the teasing that of course a boy and girl would have to be interested in each other romantically to spend time together is part of why they are mocked by Ted and his crew.
Some worldbuilding storytelling elements aren't as strong, such as the P.E. coach giving a giant chunk of their grade to something that only takes a week's preparation. Or how a photo of Marcus doing swing dancing at Izzy's house would be used for his soccer coach to cut him from the team for "being distracted." This also includes how his soccer team decides to punish Marcus by fouling him repeatedly, but the coach neither notices nor comments on it. But overall these are minor issues that you can see are left in the story in order to facilitate Marcus and Izzy coming together.
"Swing" is a solid contemporary graphic novel that focuses on interpersonal relationships, a good addition to collections where socialization meets extracurricular activities such as "Freestyle" by Gale Galligan or "The Tryout" by Christina Soontornvat.
I recieved a free copy of this book from Netgalley.
The two are paired up for a P.E. project where they are expected to practice a style of dance. Since neither of them have any friends willing to partner with them, they're stuck together learning swing. The swing dance sections seem fun, although the focus is less on embracing this new activity and more dealing with the personality issues of their partner. It feels like a lot of rom-coms, where misunderstandings and clumsy introductions sour each other's first impression. In some ways the conflicts feel almost too much, where their mutual awkwardness could have sufficed to make their partnership difficult. Another extreme conflict catalyst is the inclusion of Ted, who is not just an old friend Marcus grew apart from, but an active bully who harasses Izzy and stalks Marcus to blackmail him into focusing on soccer.
While some of the plot progresses with a heavier hand, the development of Izzy and Marcus into reluctant friends is the strongest part of the book. There is no loud confession or emotional revelation, they just realize after the initial bickering that they have learned to get along. There is a real charm to the exchange "you doing alright?"/"shut up" while they practice holding onto each other that perfectly moves their relationship from one of arguments to friendly banter. The blushing does suggest there may be an element to their relationship that's partially a crush, which is neither confirmed or denied in the story. It's nice to have that ambiguity, although the teasing that of course a boy and girl would have to be interested in each other romantically to spend time together is part of why they are mocked by Ted and his crew.
Some worldbuilding storytelling elements aren't as strong, such as the P.E. coach giving a giant chunk of their grade to something that only takes a week's preparation. Or how a photo of Marcus doing swing dancing at Izzy's house would be used for his soccer coach to cut him from the team for "being distracted." This also includes how his soccer team decides to punish Marcus by fouling him repeatedly, but the coach neither notices nor comments on it. But overall these are minor issues that you can see are left in the story in order to facilitate Marcus and Izzy coming together.
"Swing" is a solid contemporary graphic novel that focuses on interpersonal relationships, a good addition to collections where socialization meets extracurricular activities such as "Freestyle" by Gale Galligan or "The Tryout" by Christina Soontornvat.
I recieved a free copy of this book from Netgalley.
August 28, 2024
Swing
Audrey Meeker, Sarah Dividson
This is a hilarious middle school graphic novel.
In Swing we meet two eighth graders: Marcus and Izzy.
Marcus’ big brothers were soccer champs. He plays soccer but doesn’t like it. He’s not all that crazy about his best friend and teammate, Ted who is a bully and a jerk. Ted’s behavior bothers Marcus, but he hesitates to say anything.
Izzy is often the object of jokes. Her schoolmates make fun of her because of how she dresses. She wants to be a designer and dresses sort of goth. Her clothing stands out in a crowd. She is determined to show everyone she is confident but deep down inside she isn’t. Her mother demands good grades. Izzy joins a theater group and feels right at home but her mother is hesitant to allow her to participate.
In physical education class Marcus and Izzy are paired up to swing dance together. Ted makes fun of them, he spies on them, takes photos and posts negative things about them. Things don’t go well, and their grade proves it. Their teacher offers them a second chance; he will give them extra credit if they do the swing dance at the school’s talent show. Izzy and Marcus really enjoy each other’s company, but Ted gives Marcus such a hard time that he denies their friendship. Of course, Izzy overhears the conversation and is so hurt she asks to be allowed to dance alone at the talent show. This isn’t the first time Ted has bullied Izzy. Finally, Marcus has had enough and apologizes to Izzy and asks her to allow him to dance with her. Izzy has some requests of her own.
This tale demonstrates middle school bullying. Kids face this every day in our schools. There is also sibling rivalry. Without meaning too often older siblings or their parents push kids to excel at sports “just like your brother.”
This is a fantastic book for all middle school students. I hope parents and teachers will encourage kids to read it.
Thank you NetGalley for the review copy.
Audrey Meeker, Sarah Dividson
This is a hilarious middle school graphic novel.
In Swing we meet two eighth graders: Marcus and Izzy.
Marcus’ big brothers were soccer champs. He plays soccer but doesn’t like it. He’s not all that crazy about his best friend and teammate, Ted who is a bully and a jerk. Ted’s behavior bothers Marcus, but he hesitates to say anything.
Izzy is often the object of jokes. Her schoolmates make fun of her because of how she dresses. She wants to be a designer and dresses sort of goth. Her clothing stands out in a crowd. She is determined to show everyone she is confident but deep down inside she isn’t. Her mother demands good grades. Izzy joins a theater group and feels right at home but her mother is hesitant to allow her to participate.
In physical education class Marcus and Izzy are paired up to swing dance together. Ted makes fun of them, he spies on them, takes photos and posts negative things about them. Things don’t go well, and their grade proves it. Their teacher offers them a second chance; he will give them extra credit if they do the swing dance at the school’s talent show. Izzy and Marcus really enjoy each other’s company, but Ted gives Marcus such a hard time that he denies their friendship. Of course, Izzy overhears the conversation and is so hurt she asks to be allowed to dance alone at the talent show. This isn’t the first time Ted has bullied Izzy. Finally, Marcus has had enough and apologizes to Izzy and asks her to allow him to dance with her. Izzy has some requests of her own.
This tale demonstrates middle school bullying. Kids face this every day in our schools. There is also sibling rivalry. Without meaning too often older siblings or their parents push kids to excel at sports “just like your brother.”
This is a fantastic book for all middle school students. I hope parents and teachers will encourage kids to read it.
Thank you NetGalley for the review copy.
February 17, 2025
Marcus and Izzy both have trouble fitting in at school and meeting family expectations. When their gym teacher pairs them together on a project about swing dancing these common points do not, unfortunately, lead them to bond together. After their dance demo falls apart, their gym teacher gives them a chance to make up their grade, by performing a swing dance at the school talent show.
This was a straight-up fun book with its heart in the right place. Marcus and Izzy were very believable and true to life, acting like the average kid who wanted to do the right thing, but also struggled to be part of the in-group, and not disappoint friends and family. It's not overly heavy or depressing, but it does a really good job demonstrating the the importance of standing up for oneself, finding one's values in life, and being a good friend.
So, I know this is a stand-alone book and aimed at a younger audience, but after being an interesting read with some challenging issues, the ending was much too easy. Everyone sees Marcus and Izzy like dancing, and so they stop pressuring them to do stuff. Boom, problem solved. And the big bully at school is caught bullying them, his big brother chews him out, other problem solved! I was a little disappointed that it was all so easy. Also, Marcus's big brother just telling him to quit soccer and go on with swing dancing disappointed me too - Marcus didn't dislike soccer, he disliked how obsessively competitive it'd become, and that he was on the team with the aforementioned bullying jerk. I wish Marcus's brother had said, 'hey, maybe you could do both?'
A really good read for any age IMO, the ending might feel a little spoon-feeding to an older reader, but the good examples given make it spot on for the target audience.
This was a straight-up fun book with its heart in the right place. Marcus and Izzy were very believable and true to life, acting like the average kid who wanted to do the right thing, but also struggled to be part of the in-group, and not disappoint friends and family. It's not overly heavy or depressing, but it does a really good job demonstrating the the importance of standing up for oneself, finding one's values in life, and being a good friend.
So, I know this is a stand-alone book and aimed at a younger audience, but after being an interesting read with some challenging issues, the ending was much too easy. Everyone sees Marcus and Izzy like dancing, and so they stop pressuring them to do stuff. Boom, problem solved. And the big bully at school is caught bullying them, his big brother chews him out, other problem solved! I was a little disappointed that it was all so easy. Also, Marcus's big brother just telling him to quit soccer and go on with swing dancing disappointed me too - Marcus didn't dislike soccer, he disliked how obsessively competitive it'd become, and that he was on the team with the aforementioned bullying jerk. I wish Marcus's brother had said, 'hey, maybe you could do both?'
A really good read for any age IMO, the ending might feel a little spoon-feeding to an older reader, but the good examples given make it spot on for the target audience.
October 22, 2024
Review from my little sister Laly (12):
To fit in, Marcus plays soccer with his rude friend Ted, even though he dislikes the sport. However, when he is paired with Izzy—a girl known for her bold fashion choices—for a gym assignment on dance, their lack of trust leads them to fail the assignment completely. To pass gym class, they must perform their dance routine during the talent show. Throughout this experience, Marcus learns the importance of being true to himself and discovering his passions.
I absolutely adored this book to the point that I couldn't put it down and finished it in a single sitting. The protagonist, Marcus, comes across as an everyday guy, yearning for genuine friendships and striving to blend in with the crowd. In stark contrast stands Izzy, who exudes boldness and is determined to make her mark. While Marcus's demeanor is quite unremarkable, Izzy’s personality is a whirlwind of energy, often bordering on being a control freak. Their opposing traits create a delightful tension that enriches the narrative.
However, I must admit I found Ted rather off-putting. His rudeness and air of superiority made it hard to warm up to him. On a brighter note, the artwork throughout the book bursts with vivid colors, perfectly mirroring the lighthearted tone of the story. Every page had me chuckling, leaving me in high spirits.
Overall, I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone in search of a charming and heartfelt friendship tale.
Happy Reading, Laly ❤️ 📚
Thank you, @netgalley for the complimentary ARC, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
To fit in, Marcus plays soccer with his rude friend Ted, even though he dislikes the sport. However, when he is paired with Izzy—a girl known for her bold fashion choices—for a gym assignment on dance, their lack of trust leads them to fail the assignment completely. To pass gym class, they must perform their dance routine during the talent show. Throughout this experience, Marcus learns the importance of being true to himself and discovering his passions.
I absolutely adored this book to the point that I couldn't put it down and finished it in a single sitting. The protagonist, Marcus, comes across as an everyday guy, yearning for genuine friendships and striving to blend in with the crowd. In stark contrast stands Izzy, who exudes boldness and is determined to make her mark. While Marcus's demeanor is quite unremarkable, Izzy’s personality is a whirlwind of energy, often bordering on being a control freak. Their opposing traits create a delightful tension that enriches the narrative.
However, I must admit I found Ted rather off-putting. His rudeness and air of superiority made it hard to warm up to him. On a brighter note, the artwork throughout the book bursts with vivid colors, perfectly mirroring the lighthearted tone of the story. Every page had me chuckling, leaving me in high spirits.
Overall, I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone in search of a charming and heartfelt friendship tale.
Happy Reading, Laly ❤️ 📚
Thank you, @netgalley for the complimentary ARC, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 28, 2024
What must you do to fit in? Do you have to pretend to like something you loath? Or do you say, screw this, and do what you want to do, even if it means being ostracized by all your peers?
This is what faces Marcus, who plays soccer though he hates it, and Izzy, who loves designing clothes, and has decided that she doesn’t give a flying rats patootie if anyone likes what she wears or not.
The two are thrown together because they are not doing well in P.E., and to keep their grades up they must learn a swing dance, and do it for the talent show, and place. If they can do that, they can bring their grades back up.
It isn’t that Marcus doesn’t enjoy dancing, he does. He just doens’t want his “friends” to know. And Izzy doens’t understand why he keeps trying to dis her, and avoid her, when he is around his ‘friends”.
It is a classic case of bullying. You can see it the first time you meet Ted.
I don’t hurt for Izzy as much as I do for Marcus. At least Izzy knows what she wants, and follows her heart. It is Marcus that you are screaming at, to dump Ted, and just go with his heart.
Very enjoyable, if slightly painful, telling of life in Middle School.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review. This book is coming out the 22nd of October 2024.
This is what faces Marcus, who plays soccer though he hates it, and Izzy, who loves designing clothes, and has decided that she doesn’t give a flying rats patootie if anyone likes what she wears or not.
The two are thrown together because they are not doing well in P.E., and to keep their grades up they must learn a swing dance, and do it for the talent show, and place. If they can do that, they can bring their grades back up.
It isn’t that Marcus doesn’t enjoy dancing, he does. He just doens’t want his “friends” to know. And Izzy doens’t understand why he keeps trying to dis her, and avoid her, when he is around his ‘friends”.
It is a classic case of bullying. You can see it the first time you meet Ted.
I don’t hurt for Izzy as much as I do for Marcus. At least Izzy knows what she wants, and follows her heart. It is Marcus that you are screaming at, to dump Ted, and just go with his heart.
Very enjoyable, if slightly painful, telling of life in Middle School.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review. This book is coming out the 22nd of October 2024.
June 26, 2025
I really enjoyed this one! Swing is a graphic novel with a fun premise and two great main characters, Marcus, who’s trying to blend in, and Izzy, who’s determined to stand out. Their dynamic is messy in all the right ways, and I was fully on board for the awkward partnership, the unexpected friendship, and the challenge of pulling off a swing dance routine neither of them asked for.
The story had a solid arc, and the art style worked well with the emotional beats and humor throughout. Izzy, especially, was such a standout. Her confidence and creativity were infectious, and Marcus’s journey to figuring himself out had a lot of heart. Their decision to flip the usual dance roles with Izzy leading added a great layer of depth to the story, too.
That said, I really wish there had been a bit more resolution at the end. There were some behaviors (especially around friendship and self-worth) that felt like they were building toward something, but then the story kind of wrapped up without fully unpacking them. I liked what was there, but I wanted a little more from the character development to feel truly satisfied.
Still, this is a fun, heartfelt read that hits a lot of the right notes. Definitely recommend it for fans of contemporary middle grade graphic novels with quirky characters, school drama, and big feelings.
The story had a solid arc, and the art style worked well with the emotional beats and humor throughout. Izzy, especially, was such a standout. Her confidence and creativity were infectious, and Marcus’s journey to figuring himself out had a lot of heart. Their decision to flip the usual dance roles with Izzy leading added a great layer of depth to the story, too.
That said, I really wish there had been a bit more resolution at the end. There were some behaviors (especially around friendship and self-worth) that felt like they were building toward something, but then the story kind of wrapped up without fully unpacking them. I liked what was there, but I wanted a little more from the character development to feel truly satisfied.
Still, this is a fun, heartfelt read that hits a lot of the right notes. Definitely recommend it for fans of contemporary middle grade graphic novels with quirky characters, school drama, and big feelings.
May 20, 2024
This middle-grade graphic novel follows the journey of two 8th graders, Marcus and Izzy, who are navigating the trials of middle school. Marcus is struggling with the pressure to follow in his older brother’s soccer stardom, despite his lack of interest in the sport, and his desire to fit in makes him vulnerable to peer pressure. On the other hand, Izzy is a bold and unique individual who loves theatre set design and strives to be herself, but finds it challenging to remain true to her identity amidst bullying and labeling.
Their paths cross when they are paired together in gym class for a session in dance, and they must learn to work as a team to present a swing dance for a final grade. Their initial attempt ends in failure, but the gym teacher gives them a second chance to redeem themselves by performing at the school talent show for extra credit. This process not only teaches them the intricate steps of swing dance, which are beautifully illustrated in the novel for readers to follow along, but also helps them build a meaningful friendship. This graphic novel captures the themes of bullying, sports, friendship, family expectations, and the struggle to fit in. It provides a heartfelt and relatable narrative that resonates with the challenges of being a middle schooler.
Their paths cross when they are paired together in gym class for a session in dance, and they must learn to work as a team to present a swing dance for a final grade. Their initial attempt ends in failure, but the gym teacher gives them a second chance to redeem themselves by performing at the school talent show for extra credit. This process not only teaches them the intricate steps of swing dance, which are beautifully illustrated in the novel for readers to follow along, but also helps them build a meaningful friendship. This graphic novel captures the themes of bullying, sports, friendship, family expectations, and the struggle to fit in. It provides a heartfelt and relatable narrative that resonates with the challenges of being a middle schooler.
September 19, 2024
In Swing Marcus comes from a soccer loving family and is expected to fill the shoes of his super star brother... but he doesn't really care for soccer himself. Izzy is the weird girl that gets bullied for her fashion choices who just wants to do costumes for the drama department. They get paired together in gym class and are expected to perform a swing dance. When they can't seem to get along for the dance they find that the only chance to bring their grade up is to perform their dance for the talent show.
The artwork for Swing was well done, the characters were differentiated and the colors were nice. Facial expressions and motion lines did a good job of conveying the feelings and actions. The story was okay. I didn't feel like the story flowed as well as it should have and I don't know how well I really connected with either of the characters. Some of the elements were needed to move the story forward, but I felt could have been portrayed differently. I also feel like Marcus' complete turn around on how he was feeling with the dancing may not have been believable.
With that being said, I do think that Swing will do well with the target audience, so I still plan on buying it for our library.
The artwork for Swing was well done, the characters were differentiated and the colors were nice. Facial expressions and motion lines did a good job of conveying the feelings and actions. The story was okay. I didn't feel like the story flowed as well as it should have and I don't know how well I really connected with either of the characters. Some of the elements were needed to move the story forward, but I felt could have been portrayed differently. I also feel like Marcus' complete turn around on how he was feeling with the dancing may not have been believable.
With that being said, I do think that Swing will do well with the target audience, so I still plan on buying it for our library.
October 9, 2024
Marcus wants to fit in so much that he’s still playing soccer and hanging out with his friend Ted, despite not liking either very much. Izzy wants to be a designer some day and takes pride in demonstrating her own style, but that means that she stands out, and not always in a good way. When Marcus and Izzy are paired up for a dance project in gym class, it is a disaster, so they have to perform in the school talent show as extra credit to save their grades and avoid taking gym all over again.
I had a hard time buying into this book because some of the plot points were so heavy handed, like a major gym project, the school talent show, and the rivalry soccer game all taking place in the first month of school, not to mention a make-or-break class project based on students teaching themselves how to dance. Also, some of the main characters were caricatures, like the bully Ted or the spineless Marcus, lacking nuance to make them truly compelling characters. Despite my complaints, it is a sweet story with a good message, and I expect students who are experiencing slightly more realistic versions of this story will enjoy it.
I had a hard time buying into this book because some of the plot points were so heavy handed, like a major gym project, the school talent show, and the rivalry soccer game all taking place in the first month of school, not to mention a make-or-break class project based on students teaching themselves how to dance. Also, some of the main characters were caricatures, like the bully Ted or the spineless Marcus, lacking nuance to make them truly compelling characters. Despite my complaints, it is a sweet story with a good message, and I expect students who are experiencing slightly more realistic versions of this story will enjoy it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews