Donald Alexander Mackenzie was a Scottish journalist and folklorist and a prolific writer on religion, mythology and anthropology in the early 20th century.
Having nothing whatsoever to compare this book to, I'd say that it is very good and also enjoyable. The illustrations leave a little to be desired, but for a collection of short stories, this book makes a good introduction to Scottish Fairy Tales. I read this book aloud to our kids and everyone enjoyed it.
I almost stopped reading after the first story because of the pedestrian writing style. The other stories kept my attention so I read on. Though I have great interest in Scotland and have been there twice, perhaps I don't have enough Scots blood in my vein to appreciate these stories.
Hope Irvin Marston, author of EYE ON THE IDITAROD: AISLING'S STORY
Not a fan of the Dover Children's Thrift Classics. Low quality. And I mean the stories not the paper and pictures, which are also low quality. Of the ones I bought this one had the better stories, but still not great at all.