Last summer, I went to BookExpo America in NYC on the children's/YA day. To my excitement, Jason Segel was there, signing pamphlet thingies (which had an excerpt from this book in them) and ... I MET HIM. At the time my hair was dyed dark purple and he was like, "Cool hair! It matches the cover of the book." And I was like, "... um yeah haha thanks bye." I was very awkward, plus the line was moving very quickly, but yeah. AHHHHH. It was still pretty cool. I also got to meet the co-author of the book (aka the person who probably did the actual writing), Kirsten Miller, who seemed very nice––although once again, the line was moving super fast so I only had time to say hi and thanks and that was about it.
Anyway, I didn't actually buy the book until a few months ago, when it was on sale on Amazon. I tend to be a bit skeptical of celebrity-written (or co-written) books, but I decided to give it a try anyway.
It took me kind of a long time to get through the whole thing, but that was mostly because I usually was only reading it in snatches on my Kindle when I couldn't sleep (which is kind of fitting, considering the plot of the book).
The beginning was a little slow-going for me. It takes almost half of the book before the main character, Charlie, goes into the "Netherworld"––the dream world where most of the important part of the story takes place. Before that it's mostly just Charlie being terrible to his stepmother and brother. I get that he's mourning the death of his mother and going through a lot, but sometimes in the beginning I found it hard to sympathize with him––especially when he was calling his stepmother a witch to her face.
But once Charlie finally enters the portal into the Netherworld, that's where the story hit its stride. I really liked the creative world-building of the Netherworld. It's creepy and unique, both funny and scary. It's kind of like Neil Gaiman and Rick Riordan had a baby or something (figuratively, of course).
I became more invested in the story as Charlie encountered his group of friends in the dream world, and helped them conquer their nightmares. I liked the message the book conveys to its readers, that everyone has nightmares/fears, and they're not something to be ashamed of. Sometimes I did feel like the book kind of beat the reader over the head with those messages, but I thought they were important nevertheless.
A few minor things that I also really appreciated:
• I liked that one of Charlie's friends (Paige) is a girl whose best friends are all boys––and she's never described as a "tomboy" or "not like the other gurlz". We need more boy-girl friendships! And girls who are friends with boys without shaming other girls!
• There was a strong implication that Paige's mother suffers from serious depression, and that Paige's greatest fear was becoming depressed like her mother, especially after being told by a doctor that it's hereditary. Dang ... that's some heavy stuff, but I think it's very important for kids to read. Many children have parents with mental illnesses, or suffer from such illnesses themselves. And especially as someone who has had anxiety and panic attacks since I was 11 years old, I appreciate that this was acknowledged in a children's book. Not only that, but that depression is discussed as what it truly is––a medical condition that is chronic and often requires help from doctors. So I really applaud the book for that.
• One of Charlie's other friends, Rocco, is terrified of taking tests––which of course, causes him his nightmares. And Charlie's other friend, Alfie, who does much better in school, tells Rocco something along the lines of: "Tests don't measure how smart you are, they just measure how good you are at taking tests." YES. THANK YOU. Maybe I'm biased because I went to a college that had no tests or grades, but I was really glad to see those words in a kids' book. While I do think tests can help kids learn to a certain degree, for the most part I've always thought they're more about how good you are at memorization than you are at actually learning. And I think it's important for kids to understand that even if you don't always do well on tests, it doesn't mean you're stupid.
The final word:
Although this book was a little slow in the beginning, I liked it well enough in the end. The second half of it had a compelling plot, some fun world-building, and some bold and important messages that I hadn't often seen in children's literature. I didn't think it was amazing, but I liked it enough that I might still try the sequel.