What do you think?
Rate this book
A Day to Remember #3
When Hope Sank
Can Hope Resurface After Evil Tries to Drown It? Introducing a new series of 6 exciting novels featuring historic American disasters that transformed landscapes and multiple lives. Whether by nature or by man, these disasters changed history and were a day to be remembered. The Civil War has taken everything from Lily Livingston—her parents, her twin brother, her home. Now she works at her uncle’s inn and keeps her head down. Speaking up for her beliefs proved too costly in a part of Arkansas split by conflicting loyalties and overrun by spies and bushwhackers. Emaciated in body but resilient in spirit, Lieutenant Cade Palmer is crowded onto the Sultana with other paroled Andersonville and Cahaba POWs for the journey north. But a fiery explosion on April 27, 1886, rends the steamer and empties two thousand men into the frigid Mississippi River. Recovering from wounds that might end his career as a surgeon but clinging to his faith, Cade threatens both Lily’s defenses and her heart. How can she tell him she might’ve prevented the tragedy if only she’d reported a suspected saboteur’s claims? And when the man returns to town and encoded messages pass through the hotel, will Lily follow her convictions to prevent another tragedy?Also available in the A Day to Remember the Waters Came by Candice Sue PattersonWhen the Flames Ravaged by Rhonda Dragomir
259 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 1, 2024
8 people are currently reading
1056 people want to read
About the author
Denise Weimer
29 books402 followersDenise Weimer writes historical and contemporary romance from her home in North Georgia and also serves as a freelance editor and the Acquisitions & Editorial Liaison for Wild Heart Books. A mother of two daughters, she always pauses for coffee, chocolate, and old houses.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 98 reviews
November 30, 2024
This was a satisfying as well as heartbreaking too of course as the storyline was set around the end of the American civil war. It was based around a sinking of a steamboat carrying prisoners of war back home; which I hadn't known about so it was enlightening as several theories made for intriguing and insightful reading! It made perfect sense as explained during the end, as to why one reason was eagerly accepted by one group; became suspicious as such....can't say too much to ruin any surprises!
There were themes of forgiveness and sorrow naturally as I could feel as if there in the midst of the hardships and resentments so speak following a war with the devastation it brought about.
There were plenty of spiritual elements throughout as some characters had a steadfast trust in the Lord despite such tragic losses of life from the war itself and tragedies that also occur unfortunately.
I was pleased with this author and will gladly read others by her as well as she passed my "one chance" test; I don't have as much patience nor inclination I suppose I will call it, to bother a second time if I wasn't gung ho with a first book :)
There were themes of forgiveness and sorrow naturally as I could feel as if there in the midst of the hardships and resentments so speak following a war with the devastation it brought about.
There were plenty of spiritual elements throughout as some characters had a steadfast trust in the Lord despite such tragic losses of life from the war itself and tragedies that also occur unfortunately.
I was pleased with this author and will gladly read others by her as well as she passed my "one chance" test; I don't have as much patience nor inclination I suppose I will call it, to bother a second time if I wasn't gung ho with a first book :)
May 30, 2024
When Hope Sank is a story that draws deeply on a historical event from the Civil War era–the explosion and sinking of the Sultana. But it’s more than that. It’s a story that explores ordinary people caught up in a tragedy beyond their control. When Hope Sank looks at the emotional side of the Sultana’s fall.
Denise did an incredible job in researching the details of this story. One aspect that I especially loved was all the 1860’s medical talk and the battles over which treatments would be best for patients in the long run. The information is fascinating.
Cade and Lily are both loveable characters. More than that, they are characters that come alive in your mind and linger. Their hearts pour into the story, and the climax will steal your breath. Of all the points in the book, that is the spot where Cade and Lily shine brightest.
Content for potential concern: There was one point where a man kidnaps a woman and almost treats her in a wicked way. He doesn’t have his way–but it’s close. Sensitive readers will want to keep this in mind.
When Hope Sank has all the elements of an enduring tale. A unique take on history. Love. Struggle. Sacrifice. It’s a story I highly recommend for anyone who loves Christian fiction with a strong historical theme.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book, but was not required to leave a positive review. My thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
Denise did an incredible job in researching the details of this story. One aspect that I especially loved was all the 1860’s medical talk and the battles over which treatments would be best for patients in the long run. The information is fascinating.
Cade and Lily are both loveable characters. More than that, they are characters that come alive in your mind and linger. Their hearts pour into the story, and the climax will steal your breath. Of all the points in the book, that is the spot where Cade and Lily shine brightest.
Content for potential concern: There was one point where a man kidnaps a woman and almost treats her in a wicked way. He doesn’t have his way–but it’s close. Sensitive readers will want to keep this in mind.
When Hope Sank has all the elements of an enduring tale. A unique take on history. Love. Struggle. Sacrifice. It’s a story I highly recommend for anyone who loves Christian fiction with a strong historical theme.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book, but was not required to leave a positive review. My thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
May 24, 2024
My endorsement for this lovely book:
“Intriguing from page one, ‘When Hope Sank’ pulls you into a world of tragedy, hard decisions, real-to-life emotions, and the tenderest of romances. Weimer sprinkles painful circumstances with the perfect dose of hope. Don’t miss this beautifully-told historical tale.”
“Intriguing from page one, ‘When Hope Sank’ pulls you into a world of tragedy, hard decisions, real-to-life emotions, and the tenderest of romances. Weimer sprinkles painful circumstances with the perfect dose of hope. Don’t miss this beautifully-told historical tale.”
April 24, 2024
Wonderfully written historical story of the sinking of the steamboat Sultana. The historical aspects of the story made it come alive and I was engaged from the beginning. The main characters are well-developed and lead interesting lives filled with hardships. Their struggles tugged at my heart.
The storyline takes place just after the Civil War with countless injured soldiers. There are accounts of espionage, deception, and betrayal, but the story also shows hope and faith in God. It's a good over evil, and sacrifice over selfishness story. You will be thinking about the story long after the last page is turned. An excellent and exciting story.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and voluntarily chose to review it. All opinions are my own.
The storyline takes place just after the Civil War with countless injured soldiers. There are accounts of espionage, deception, and betrayal, but the story also shows hope and faith in God. It's a good over evil, and sacrifice over selfishness story. You will be thinking about the story long after the last page is turned. An excellent and exciting story.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and voluntarily chose to review it. All opinions are my own.
Read
May 1, 2024Yay! It's finally release day for When Hope Sank. How about a sneak peek inside?
Chapter Three
People yelling—inside the inn as well as without—woke Lily. Lights flickered even through her third-story window. She sat up in bed. The curtain partition to her little brother’s nook remained closed, so he must still be asleep. But now the bells of steamboats downriver, across at Memphis, began to clang. Something was very wrong.
Lily padded barefoot across the braided rug and held aside her window’s muslin curtain. Dark figures ran along the streets carrying lanterns, and lights also dotted the flooded Mississippi River as a variety of crafts launched from Mound City. Crafts that had apparently been hidden two days prior when, in an effort to stop guerilla warfare, the Union picket boat Pocahontas had prowled the local waters on a mission to destroy any civilian-owned yawls, rowboats, skiffs, rafts, and canoes. But where were they going?
“Wake up, Jacob. Something’s happened.” Lily called to her brother as she pulled her wrapper over her cotton nightgown. She hurried out of their room onto the narrow landing, then through the door to her right that led onto the small third-floor balcony. There her breath clogged in her throat, and her heart nearly stopped.
About a mile up the river, which was lit for miles in all directions, flames engulfed a steamer. The paddlewheels had fallen away, and the boat turned around. Hundreds of figures crowded the main forward deck, many jumping off—or pushing each other. Bodies and debris darkened the surrounding water. And were those people in the trees? Yes, clinging to the tops of the cottonwoods and willows submerged to the point that they resembled bushes.
“What is it?” Jacob stood in the doorway, rubbing his eyes. His sandy hair stuck up in all directions.
“A boat is on fire. Lots of people in the water.” Without giving him time to gawp at the view, she nudged him back toward their room. “Get dressed.”
“But what can we do? Uncle Thad said the Yankees hacked up our canoe.”
“We’ll ready the inn. The steamers will send out their rowboats, and once they’ve built up steam, they’ll go too. The people they rescue will need places to stay.”
“Lily?” Her uncle’s call up the stairs stopped her at the entrance to her room.
“Yes, Uncle Thad?”
“You and Jacob get dressed and come down. I need your help.”
“We’ll be right there.” She grasped the door and shooed Jacob to his alcove.
Uncle Thad raised his voice once more. “Bring some extra blankets and meet me at the livery.”
The livery? That had nothing to do with cooking breakfast or making up beds. Yet Lily called her consent and hastened to change into her chemise. The many layers of a lady’s clothing never seemed more ridiculous than in an emergency. But she daren’t leave off her stockings, pantalets, corset, under-petticoat, or the corded petticoat she wore to keep her skirts from dragging in lieu of the wider hoops. Not with the strange men who would shortly flood their inn.
She was donning her navy cotton one-piece dress with its practical fitted coat sleeves when Jacob demanded, “Are you ready yet?”
“Yes.” She’d no sooner answered than he snatched the partition aside and marched into her area in his old boots, wool pants, suspenders, and a striped shirt.
Jacob grabbed an armload of quilts from their chest. “Let’s go.”
Lily fumbled with the top two hooks of her bodice as she followed him down the stairs. They met Beth descending from the second story. In the wavering light of the oil lamp mounted on the wall at the landing, her dark braid was disheveled, her face pale.
“Martha is already in the kitchen.” Beth spoke breathlessly. “Father insists we get the rooms ready, although I say, let the Yankees in Memphis take care of their own.”
“Their own?”
“Yes. That steamer was carrying prisoners of war.”
Lily’s steps faltered as the voice of the gloating stranger in the River Rest’s private room came back to her from a couple of weeks before. Hundreds of paroled Yankee prisoners, blown to kingdom come. “Oh no, Beth. No…” Had they really done it? Blown up a Union steamer?
Chapter Three
People yelling—inside the inn as well as without—woke Lily. Lights flickered even through her third-story window. She sat up in bed. The curtain partition to her little brother’s nook remained closed, so he must still be asleep. But now the bells of steamboats downriver, across at Memphis, began to clang. Something was very wrong.
Lily padded barefoot across the braided rug and held aside her window’s muslin curtain. Dark figures ran along the streets carrying lanterns, and lights also dotted the flooded Mississippi River as a variety of crafts launched from Mound City. Crafts that had apparently been hidden two days prior when, in an effort to stop guerilla warfare, the Union picket boat Pocahontas had prowled the local waters on a mission to destroy any civilian-owned yawls, rowboats, skiffs, rafts, and canoes. But where were they going?
“Wake up, Jacob. Something’s happened.” Lily called to her brother as she pulled her wrapper over her cotton nightgown. She hurried out of their room onto the narrow landing, then through the door to her right that led onto the small third-floor balcony. There her breath clogged in her throat, and her heart nearly stopped.
About a mile up the river, which was lit for miles in all directions, flames engulfed a steamer. The paddlewheels had fallen away, and the boat turned around. Hundreds of figures crowded the main forward deck, many jumping off—or pushing each other. Bodies and debris darkened the surrounding water. And were those people in the trees? Yes, clinging to the tops of the cottonwoods and willows submerged to the point that they resembled bushes.
“What is it?” Jacob stood in the doorway, rubbing his eyes. His sandy hair stuck up in all directions.
“A boat is on fire. Lots of people in the water.” Without giving him time to gawp at the view, she nudged him back toward their room. “Get dressed.”
“But what can we do? Uncle Thad said the Yankees hacked up our canoe.”
“We’ll ready the inn. The steamers will send out their rowboats, and once they’ve built up steam, they’ll go too. The people they rescue will need places to stay.”
“Lily?” Her uncle’s call up the stairs stopped her at the entrance to her room.
“Yes, Uncle Thad?”
“You and Jacob get dressed and come down. I need your help.”
“We’ll be right there.” She grasped the door and shooed Jacob to his alcove.
Uncle Thad raised his voice once more. “Bring some extra blankets and meet me at the livery.”
The livery? That had nothing to do with cooking breakfast or making up beds. Yet Lily called her consent and hastened to change into her chemise. The many layers of a lady’s clothing never seemed more ridiculous than in an emergency. But she daren’t leave off her stockings, pantalets, corset, under-petticoat, or the corded petticoat she wore to keep her skirts from dragging in lieu of the wider hoops. Not with the strange men who would shortly flood their inn.
She was donning her navy cotton one-piece dress with its practical fitted coat sleeves when Jacob demanded, “Are you ready yet?”
“Yes.” She’d no sooner answered than he snatched the partition aside and marched into her area in his old boots, wool pants, suspenders, and a striped shirt.
Jacob grabbed an armload of quilts from their chest. “Let’s go.”
Lily fumbled with the top two hooks of her bodice as she followed him down the stairs. They met Beth descending from the second story. In the wavering light of the oil lamp mounted on the wall at the landing, her dark braid was disheveled, her face pale.
“Martha is already in the kitchen.” Beth spoke breathlessly. “Father insists we get the rooms ready, although I say, let the Yankees in Memphis take care of their own.”
“Their own?”
“Yes. That steamer was carrying prisoners of war.”
Lily’s steps faltered as the voice of the gloating stranger in the River Rest’s private room came back to her from a couple of weeks before. Hundreds of paroled Yankee prisoners, blown to kingdom come. “Oh no, Beth. No…” Had they really done it? Blown up a Union steamer?
March 29, 2024
1865 Arkansas
This fictional series based upon U.S. tragedies is fascinating. In this novel. the time period is just after the end of the Civil War and tensions remain high between the north and south. An exploding steamer ends so many lives and leaves a number of injured as well. Soldiers finally leaving Andersonville and heading home find themselves still in the south and at the mercy of the southerners that find them after the explosion.
The two main characters, Cade and Lily, were easy to like.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to write a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
This fictional series based upon U.S. tragedies is fascinating. In this novel. the time period is just after the end of the Civil War and tensions remain high between the north and south. An exploding steamer ends so many lives and leaves a number of injured as well. Soldiers finally leaving Andersonville and heading home find themselves still in the south and at the mercy of the southerners that find them after the explosion.
The two main characters, Cade and Lily, were easy to like.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to write a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
May 24, 2024
This historical fiction novel about the critical time at the end of the Civil War with prisoners of war released from Andersonville flowed easily and Cade and Lily were characters I easily connected with.
Apart from the physical and emotional healing Cade was going through, there was also a danger and mystery thread involving Southern sympathizers who did not want to accept the end of the war.
The author also did a good job of showing different viewpoints of the people involved, those who supported the southern beliefs, those caught in the southern world but was behind what the north fought for, and the slaves caught om the middle.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
Apart from the physical and emotional healing Cade was going through, there was also a danger and mystery thread involving Southern sympathizers who did not want to accept the end of the war.
The author also did a good job of showing different viewpoints of the people involved, those who supported the southern beliefs, those caught in the southern world but was behind what the north fought for, and the slaves caught om the middle.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
October 18, 2024
My favorite genre: historical fiction. One of my favorite time periods: the Civil War era. Based on true events: a huge bonus. When Hope Sank covers them all! Add in Christian faith, and a touch of romance, and this one hits it out of the ballpark!
Since I lived near the Mississippi River for several years, it was easy for me to feel immersed in this story. Being a Northern-born girl myself, who has lived a large portion of my life in the South, I understand the tension (which sometimes still exists today). Lily's story resonates with my heart.
If you enjoy Christian historical fiction, with a touch of romance, be sure to grab your own copy!
I received a complimentary copy. These opinions are my own.
Since I lived near the Mississippi River for several years, it was easy for me to feel immersed in this story. Being a Northern-born girl myself, who has lived a large portion of my life in the South, I understand the tension (which sometimes still exists today). Lily's story resonates with my heart.
If you enjoy Christian historical fiction, with a touch of romance, be sure to grab your own copy!
I received a complimentary copy. These opinions are my own.
March 27, 2024
When Hope Sank is book #3 in the Day to Remember Series. I've been able to read ARC copies of each of the books in this series so far--so was glad to snag this one as well.
When Hope Sank follows the aftermath of the sinking of the Sultana immediately after the Civil War. IT was a ship of Union prisoners from Andersonville who were being sent back home. For a long time no one was sure if it was "terrorist" or faulty mechanics that caused it. And that plays into the story.
Lily is the lead character. A southerner who is a Union supporter but who has lost her parents, twin brother, and home to the war. Now completely dependent on her aunt and uncle for housing and care for she and her younger brother, she works hard to help them run their inn and tavern. Through the course of the story, she rescues a union officer from the water after the explosion and brings him to her uncles inn where she nurses him carefully. As you can imagine nurse and patient start having feelings for each other and in that manner the story progresses as expected.
Also in the story is Lily's guilt for possibly knowing the event of the Sultana was going to happen and doing nothing about it. So she seeks to learn more about the causes and get drawn into a path of danger.
Throughout the story however is excellent scripture based messages of hope for both Lily and Cade (the officer) regarding their future.
4 stars
*I was given a complimentary ARC by the publisher and NetGalley in return for my honest review of the story. I was not obligated to write a positive review and all words are my own.
When Hope Sank follows the aftermath of the sinking of the Sultana immediately after the Civil War. IT was a ship of Union prisoners from Andersonville who were being sent back home. For a long time no one was sure if it was "terrorist" or faulty mechanics that caused it. And that plays into the story.
Lily is the lead character. A southerner who is a Union supporter but who has lost her parents, twin brother, and home to the war. Now completely dependent on her aunt and uncle for housing and care for she and her younger brother, she works hard to help them run their inn and tavern. Through the course of the story, she rescues a union officer from the water after the explosion and brings him to her uncles inn where she nurses him carefully. As you can imagine nurse and patient start having feelings for each other and in that manner the story progresses as expected.
Also in the story is Lily's guilt for possibly knowing the event of the Sultana was going to happen and doing nothing about it. So she seeks to learn more about the causes and get drawn into a path of danger.
Throughout the story however is excellent scripture based messages of hope for both Lily and Cade (the officer) regarding their future.
4 stars
*I was given a complimentary ARC by the publisher and NetGalley in return for my honest review of the story. I was not obligated to write a positive review and all words are my own.
February 8, 2024
Most definitely a 5 star read for me! What a wonderful story that kept me turning the pages. I simply couldn't put Cade and Lily's story down.
Fast paced from the beginning and didn't let go until the end.
I just finished reading this wonderful adventure that is mostly not heard about. In fact, I found myself looking up this event in history that this author has brought to life for us. The steamer called The Sultana. Mystery still surrounds her.
Weimer has done a marvelous job weaving fact with fiction that offers hope in a seemingly hopeless situation. Never give up hope in anything. God is an awesome God!
I loved the way prayer was written in to help Cade and Lily on their journey to solve a mystery.
I highly recommend this novel.
The cover of this book is awesome!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Fast paced from the beginning and didn't let go until the end.
I just finished reading this wonderful adventure that is mostly not heard about. In fact, I found myself looking up this event in history that this author has brought to life for us. The steamer called The Sultana. Mystery still surrounds her.
Weimer has done a marvelous job weaving fact with fiction that offers hope in a seemingly hopeless situation. Never give up hope in anything. God is an awesome God!
I loved the way prayer was written in to help Cade and Lily on their journey to solve a mystery.
I highly recommend this novel.
The cover of this book is awesome!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
June 8, 2024
I’ve always been drawn to stories that take place during or post war. I just love these stories show the strength of the human heart and soul’s ability to overcome tragedies. I’ve read and enjoyed all the books in the A Day to Remember series. Each story is written by a different author and features an American historical disaster.
“When Hope Sank” is a memorable and meaningful redemption story with a Civil War setting. I love how the story opens with action and dialogue instead of dumping me in backstory or superfluous descriptions. I was quickly drawn in by Lily, her personality, and the 1860s era.
I was captivated by the historical elements, wonderfully fleshed out characters, the mystery of what sank the Sultana, romance, and the spiritual thread throughout. Lily was easy to connect with and Cade was interesting, flaws and all.
This story pulled me through my emotions, and I learned so much about the explosion of the Sultana. Don’t miss the author’s note at the end!
First Line: “Free Arkansas.”
Series: A Day to Remember, book 3
Genre: Christian Historical Fiction
Author: Denise Weimer
Page Count: 256
#CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions are 100% mine.
“When Hope Sank” is a memorable and meaningful redemption story with a Civil War setting. I love how the story opens with action and dialogue instead of dumping me in backstory or superfluous descriptions. I was quickly drawn in by Lily, her personality, and the 1860s era.
I was captivated by the historical elements, wonderfully fleshed out characters, the mystery of what sank the Sultana, romance, and the spiritual thread throughout. Lily was easy to connect with and Cade was interesting, flaws and all.
This story pulled me through my emotions, and I learned so much about the explosion of the Sultana. Don’t miss the author’s note at the end!
First Line: “Free Arkansas.”
Series: A Day to Remember, book 3
Genre: Christian Historical Fiction
Author: Denise Weimer
Page Count: 256
#CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions are 100% mine.
June 4, 2024
When Hope Sank: April 27, 1865 (A Day to Remember Book 3) by Denise Weimer is a Christian historical romance based on real events. The Civil War took everything from Lily Livingston, including her parents and twin brother and their home. She and her younger brother live and work at her uncle’s inn. She tries to keep her head down and to stay out of trouble. Engaged, she waits for her twin brother to return to marry her.
Damaged in body but resilient in spirit, Lieutenant Cade Palmer finds himself crowded onto the Sultana with other paroled Andersonville and Cahaba POWs for the journey north, including his best friend. But a fiery explosion on April 27, 1865, rends the steamer and empties two thousand men into the frigid Mississippi River. He finds himself rescued by Lily and her brother.
The author builds a moving story that chronicles Cade’s recovery from the explosion and the development of a relationship with Lily. I found myself unable to put this book down until I finished reading. Like the other books in this series, I loved reading the event’s history while getting to know the characters. With the indication of sabotage, traitors in the midst, danger, intrigue, and more, this book packs a lot into its pages.
So, if you enjoy works of historical fiction centered around real events, check out When Hope Sank: April 27, 1865 (A Day to Remember Book 3) by Denise Weimer. I definitely recommend it, along with the other books in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
Damaged in body but resilient in spirit, Lieutenant Cade Palmer finds himself crowded onto the Sultana with other paroled Andersonville and Cahaba POWs for the journey north, including his best friend. But a fiery explosion on April 27, 1865, rends the steamer and empties two thousand men into the frigid Mississippi River. He finds himself rescued by Lily and her brother.
The author builds a moving story that chronicles Cade’s recovery from the explosion and the development of a relationship with Lily. I found myself unable to put this book down until I finished reading. Like the other books in this series, I loved reading the event’s history while getting to know the characters. With the indication of sabotage, traitors in the midst, danger, intrigue, and more, this book packs a lot into its pages.
So, if you enjoy works of historical fiction centered around real events, check out When Hope Sank: April 27, 1865 (A Day to Remember Book 3) by Denise Weimer. I definitely recommend it, along with the other books in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
June 6, 2024
Tensions throbbed in the South after the Civil War. This novel captures the people and divisions in a small Southern town that takes care of some of the injured Yankee prisoners following the explosion of the boat carrying them north after their release. Lily Livingston is thrown into the middle of this conflict and the intrigue going on at her uncle’s inn. One former soldier, whom she rescued from the river, soon finds his life growing intwined with hers. Danger looms over them both as they try to uncover who is behind the threats and the plans for further harm. The intense tale will hold readers captive as the mystery unfolds and they wonder who can be trusted. The author craftily created a compelling story with believable characters in a twist-filled plot. It keeps you guessing and engaged. I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
October 22, 2024
I enjoy this series because I’ve learned a lot about historical events I’ve never heard of. This one was especially interesting because of the connection to the Civil War. The sunken Sultana ship was the worst maritime disaster in United States history, surpassing the death toll of the Titanic. It was also interesting to learn about how Confederates helped Union soldiers just weeks after they were at war with each other. This huge historic event did not receive as much publicity because of the assassination of President Lincoln just over a week before. The love story was sweet, yet predictable. As a history buff, I went down many rabbit trails with this book and this entire series.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 16, 2024
These historical fiction stories are fascinating to me. I always knew of the more famous ships sinking but had never heard of the Sultana. The story of Cade and Lilly was full of intrigue. The characters cared deeply for their family members and their friends. They were often in difficult situations but tried to follow God's will. The suspense was exciting to read about as the reader sought to figure out how the ship sank.
Thanks so much to Barbour Publishing and netgalley for the arc. The opinions are my own
Thanks so much to Barbour Publishing and netgalley for the arc. The opinions are my own
March 29, 2024
When Hope Sank by Denise Weimer is the 3rd book in the A Day to Remember series by Barbour Publishing. Each book has taken on the true events of a natural or man-made tragedy in the USA. This story is about the explosion of a steamboat, killing many men headed home after the Civil War. This terrible event took place on April 27, 1886. This series is a mix of heart-pounding tragedy and God’s grace through it all. There are to be 6 books total.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions expressed are completely my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions expressed are completely my own.
May 27, 2024
Weimer brings to life the tragedy of the Sultana, which exploded on its journey to return Union soldiers from Andersonville and Cahaba Prison Camps. As the passengers fight for their lives, Lily Livingston and her family help with rescue efforts.
Lt. Cade Palmer is one of those saved from a watery grave and taken to the Livingstons’ home. The search for the cause of the explosion puts Lily in a difficult position even as she and Cade are drawn to each other. Careful research and superb storytelling make this novel an eye-opener to the clandestine elements at work during the war and the conflicting emotions of those caught in the middle.
Lt. Cade Palmer is one of those saved from a watery grave and taken to the Livingstons’ home. The search for the cause of the explosion puts Lily in a difficult position even as she and Cade are drawn to each other. Careful research and superb storytelling make this novel an eye-opener to the clandestine elements at work during the war and the conflicting emotions of those caught in the middle.
April 9, 2024
When Hope Sank is installment 3 in the A Day to Remember historic disaster fiction series. The Sultana, a steamboat transporting Union POWs up north via the Mississippi River, explodes in Arkansas on April 17, 1865, About 2,000 men end up in the Mississippi River.
Lily follows her Uncle Thad to help rescue as many Union men as they can from the river. They bring the men back to Uncle Thad's inn to help them heal, despite the town being known to have Confederate sympathizers. One of those men, Cade Palmer, quickly forms a bond with Lily while she cares for him. Her attitude brings him hope as he struggles with injuries that may end his dream of being a surgeon.
Information surrounding the Sultana's explosion emerges and sabotage is a possible cause. Lily is conflicted with the idea that she might have been able to stop the explosion and save thousands of lives by reporting a conversation she overheard at her uncle's inn day before the explosion. Could she really have changed the outcome? Will her decision to withhold this information affect her and Cade's growing friendship?
Denise Weimer perfectly combines hope, romance, and historical details in When Hope Sank. I appreciated the message of hope and God making good from the bad. While quick, the romance between Cade and Lily is sweet and is based on ideals and faith. I look forward to reading more by Denise Weimer!
A special thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for sending an ARC for consideration. All opinions are my own.
Lily follows her Uncle Thad to help rescue as many Union men as they can from the river. They bring the men back to Uncle Thad's inn to help them heal, despite the town being known to have Confederate sympathizers. One of those men, Cade Palmer, quickly forms a bond with Lily while she cares for him. Her attitude brings him hope as he struggles with injuries that may end his dream of being a surgeon.
Information surrounding the Sultana's explosion emerges and sabotage is a possible cause. Lily is conflicted with the idea that she might have been able to stop the explosion and save thousands of lives by reporting a conversation she overheard at her uncle's inn day before the explosion. Could she really have changed the outcome? Will her decision to withhold this information affect her and Cade's growing friendship?
Denise Weimer perfectly combines hope, romance, and historical details in When Hope Sank. I appreciated the message of hope and God making good from the bad. While quick, the romance between Cade and Lily is sweet and is based on ideals and faith. I look forward to reading more by Denise Weimer!
A special thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for sending an ARC for consideration. All opinions are my own.
March 5, 2025
Great book! Historical fiction about the end of the Civil War. This story also has romance and family drama,.
The Civil War is formally over but peace has not had time to heal all of the hard feelings between the people of America. Becoming united is going to take time. This book gives you a feel for some of the issues that people had to deal with in the south after the war was over. Losing is hard and the Union troops did not let the south forget that they had lost the war. Then on top of all of that, Lincoln was assassinated.
This story is set in 1865 in Arkansas and about the sinking of the steam boat Sultana that was carrying prisoners of war home to the north.. The Sultana disaster remains one the most deadly maritime accidents in U.S. history. The wooden steamboat exploded and caught fire while going up the Mississippi River overloaded with these Civil War Vets. So they had to be rescued and cared for by southern sympathizers after the explosion. So this was a very awkward and difficult situation for all involved. The characters in the book were well developed and engaging. I really enjoyed the love story. The family drama and issues of the southern sympathizers was enlightening.
The Civil War is formally over but peace has not had time to heal all of the hard feelings between the people of America. Becoming united is going to take time. This book gives you a feel for some of the issues that people had to deal with in the south after the war was over. Losing is hard and the Union troops did not let the south forget that they had lost the war. Then on top of all of that, Lincoln was assassinated.
This story is set in 1865 in Arkansas and about the sinking of the steam boat Sultana that was carrying prisoners of war home to the north.. The Sultana disaster remains one the most deadly maritime accidents in U.S. history. The wooden steamboat exploded and caught fire while going up the Mississippi River overloaded with these Civil War Vets. So they had to be rescued and cared for by southern sympathizers after the explosion. So this was a very awkward and difficult situation for all involved. The characters in the book were well developed and engaging. I really enjoyed the love story. The family drama and issues of the southern sympathizers was enlightening.
April 5, 2024
When Hope Sank by Denise Weimer occurs at the end of the Civil War. Times when families turned against each other. When a river boat explodes from possible sabotage and the town rescues the passengers, Lily Livingston jumps in to rescue two caught in a whirlpool. Lieutenant Cade Palmer barely survives. Can he trust Lily and the town to care for him even though the war is over? Between sabotage, sympathizers, and those trying to keep the war alive, what will happen? Who can be trusted? Unexpected twists throughout the story.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
June 13, 2024
I enjoyed reading this book and learning about this little known historical event. I found the book to be well written and easy to read. The biblical faith thread woven through the story and the lessons learned are nice. I look forward to reading more books in this series as well as more books by Denise Weimer.
I got a free copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own and given voluntarily. No compensation was received for my review.
I got a free copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own and given voluntarily. No compensation was received for my review.
July 3, 2024
When Hope Sank: April 27, 1865. The day the steamboat, the Sultana, went down and over 1,100 people died.
The book is the third in the series, A Day to Remember.
Such research went into this book. Like many history buffs (I’m one via my genealogy research and no, I didn’t have anyone on the Sultana.), I’ve read about the Sultana tragedy and wondered if it was an accident, poor judgment, or what we would call today a terrorist act. This is a novel based on a historical event. The Sultana remains the worst maritime disaster in United States history.
The novel, When Hope Sank, is a window into what happened, the survivors and those who cared for them. The Civil War had ended only days before (April 9th). Soldiers were coming home. Those who hated still hated — whether Union or Confederate.
One passenger on board the Sultana was a doctor, Lt. Cade Palmer, who was freed from Andersonville Prison. His best friend, James Caldwell, had also survived and Cade knew he wouldn’t have made it without James. The ship was overcrowded. Massively so. The upper deck had been braced with heavy wooden beams. A blast tore through the boat and Cade stopped worrying about the sick & injured on board. Now it was about getting as many off the ship as he and James could do plus saving themselves. The fires were moving fast and time was of the essence.
Those ashore heard the blasts and ran toward the Mississippi to see what happened. Those who thought a moment came more prepared with wagons and blankets to transport the injured. Lucy Livingston’s Uncle Chad was one of those. Lucy worked at her uncle’s establishment, River Rest, an inn with a private room where meetings were not always ones where what was discussed was meant for anyone outside the room to hear.
Dr. Palmer was taken along with many others including James to River Rest with a badly injured hand, the hand that he needed to continue to do surgery. Lucy became Dr. Palmer’s primary caretaker. Lucy worked at River Rest, but was treated, especially by “aunt” Susanna like a servant, not as a niece. Lucy held her tongue because she had no way to provide for herself and her younger brother, Jacob. Also part of River Rest were Martha and her daughter Mika now freed but nothing had changed about their lives and working conditions.
Before you jump to the conclusion this is a romance …
This story has that element but is far more. There’s the older doctor who is caring for the injured and considers Dr. Palmer an upstart and his insistence about the treatment of his hand to be wrong. Wrong. Wrong. There’s the daughter of Uncle Chad but who is more like her mother Susanna. A girl whose jealousy has her make bad decisions which impact others. The young man who everyone thinks is Lucy’s “intended” returns from the war uninjured in body but is not the same man she knew. And most important, a mystery entwined throughout that could cost Lucy her life.
I highly recommend When Hope Sank. A novel but an educational one. This book is number three in the “A Day to Remember” series. I am now eager to read the previous two books. The series features “historic American disasters that transformed landscapes and multiple lives. Whether by nature or by man, these disasters changed history and were a day to be remembered.“
Barbour Publishing’s mission is “to inspire the world with the life-changing message of the Bible” and this story meets that goal. Faith brings the doctor and Lucy together. You will feel with the doctor his concern about his best friend James, an unbeliever. The words are never hammered at the reader but are gently part of that person’s persona. To this reviewer, the best way to present our Lord’s message.
I received a complimentary DRC (digital review copy) of When Hope Sank via NetGalley from the publisher, Barbour. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Rating: 5 stars
Series: A Day to Remember, #3
Cover: Absolutely perfect!!!!!!!
Pages: 259
Publish Date: 1 May 2024
#WhenHopeSank #NetGalley #DeniseWeimer
The book is the third in the series, A Day to Remember.
Such research went into this book. Like many history buffs (I’m one via my genealogy research and no, I didn’t have anyone on the Sultana.), I’ve read about the Sultana tragedy and wondered if it was an accident, poor judgment, or what we would call today a terrorist act. This is a novel based on a historical event. The Sultana remains the worst maritime disaster in United States history.
The novel, When Hope Sank, is a window into what happened, the survivors and those who cared for them. The Civil War had ended only days before (April 9th). Soldiers were coming home. Those who hated still hated — whether Union or Confederate.
One passenger on board the Sultana was a doctor, Lt. Cade Palmer, who was freed from Andersonville Prison. His best friend, James Caldwell, had also survived and Cade knew he wouldn’t have made it without James. The ship was overcrowded. Massively so. The upper deck had been braced with heavy wooden beams. A blast tore through the boat and Cade stopped worrying about the sick & injured on board. Now it was about getting as many off the ship as he and James could do plus saving themselves. The fires were moving fast and time was of the essence.
Those ashore heard the blasts and ran toward the Mississippi to see what happened. Those who thought a moment came more prepared with wagons and blankets to transport the injured. Lucy Livingston’s Uncle Chad was one of those. Lucy worked at her uncle’s establishment, River Rest, an inn with a private room where meetings were not always ones where what was discussed was meant for anyone outside the room to hear.
Dr. Palmer was taken along with many others including James to River Rest with a badly injured hand, the hand that he needed to continue to do surgery. Lucy became Dr. Palmer’s primary caretaker. Lucy worked at River Rest, but was treated, especially by “aunt” Susanna like a servant, not as a niece. Lucy held her tongue because she had no way to provide for herself and her younger brother, Jacob. Also part of River Rest were Martha and her daughter Mika now freed but nothing had changed about their lives and working conditions.
Before you jump to the conclusion this is a romance …
This story has that element but is far more. There’s the older doctor who is caring for the injured and considers Dr. Palmer an upstart and his insistence about the treatment of his hand to be wrong. Wrong. Wrong. There’s the daughter of Uncle Chad but who is more like her mother Susanna. A girl whose jealousy has her make bad decisions which impact others. The young man who everyone thinks is Lucy’s “intended” returns from the war uninjured in body but is not the same man she knew. And most important, a mystery entwined throughout that could cost Lucy her life.
I highly recommend When Hope Sank. A novel but an educational one. This book is number three in the “A Day to Remember” series. I am now eager to read the previous two books. The series features “historic American disasters that transformed landscapes and multiple lives. Whether by nature or by man, these disasters changed history and were a day to be remembered.“
Barbour Publishing’s mission is “to inspire the world with the life-changing message of the Bible” and this story meets that goal. Faith brings the doctor and Lucy together. You will feel with the doctor his concern about his best friend James, an unbeliever. The words are never hammered at the reader but are gently part of that person’s persona. To this reviewer, the best way to present our Lord’s message.
I received a complimentary DRC (digital review copy) of When Hope Sank via NetGalley from the publisher, Barbour. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Rating: 5 stars
Series: A Day to Remember, #3
Cover: Absolutely perfect!!!!!!!
Pages: 259
Publish Date: 1 May 2024
#WhenHopeSank #NetGalley #DeniseWeimer
June 4, 2024
The setting of this exciting novel is Mounds City, Arkansas, shortly after the Civil War. I didn’t realize that even after the war ended, espionage and sabotage were still actively pursued by disgruntled Southerners. I appreciated reading about the area and people, and saddened by the explosion and sinking of the Sultana, the worst maritime disaster in the United States.
Lily and her younger brother Jacob lived with their uncle and aunt, Thad and Susanna, after their parents died. Their cousin, Beth, was about Lily’s age, but the two girls weren’t close friends. Susanna and her daughter Beth were strong Southern sympathizers. Thad was moderate, as the parents of Lily and Jacob had been. Thad and Susanna owned River Rest Inn that included a kitchen, bar, and dining room. A good businessman, Thad stayed out of arguments about slavery and secession.
One night Lily went to the private dining room with drinks for a special group. Beth was already there, showing an interest in the men’s conversation. One man talked about ships that were carrying Northern POWs homeward from confederate prisons, and how easy it would be to cause a boiler explosion that could kill most soldiers on board. Lily was shocked, but Beth insisted it was just talk.
A couple weeks later, the steamship Sultana was going up the river, heavily overloaded with several paying passengers and many released Union POWs. Carrying double its capacity, the steamship was destroyed by a boiler explosion late at night, in the river at Mounds City. People were killed from the steam, the fire, by drowning, or being crushed from collapsing ship components. Anyone who could, went to the river to help get survivors from the water and get medical and other needs met.
People were taken to River Rest Inn until all its rooms were full. Lily and James helped Cade Palmer and his friend James out of the river; Lily had even fallen in an eddy trying to help. They didn’t know it, but Cade was a skilled surgeon who enlisted with the Union after college. Cade had stopped talking with God quite some time ago, as had Lily, each for their own reasons. Cade’s right hand was severely damaged when trying to save his friend, and he worried if he would ever operate again. Lily is convinced the accident and deaths were her fault as she didn’t tell the provost marshal about the conversation she overheard.
The characters almost come to life as we learn about them by their realistic conversations and behaviors. I especially like Lily and Cade, and appreciated their spiritual and life struggles. I could well understand how Lily could pray for others but not herself, and liked how she began to encourage, then nurture, Cade’s return to faith and how she tried to understand Beth rather than hate her.
This novel was very well written, with suspense, history, and two people who became willing to seek the Lord again. I appreciated how the assassination of President Lincoln was included, and how the author explained the plots and espionage. I enjoyed reading about how messages were changed into codes, also. There were surprises with the resolutions of circumstances, including Uncle Thad’s actions throughout the war. I highly recommend this novel to fans of women’s Christian fiction, sweet romance, and those who enjoy real historical events in America.
From a thankful heart: I received an uncorrected ARC of this novel from the publisher through NetGalley and Celebrate Lit, and this is my honest review.
Lily and her younger brother Jacob lived with their uncle and aunt, Thad and Susanna, after their parents died. Their cousin, Beth, was about Lily’s age, but the two girls weren’t close friends. Susanna and her daughter Beth were strong Southern sympathizers. Thad was moderate, as the parents of Lily and Jacob had been. Thad and Susanna owned River Rest Inn that included a kitchen, bar, and dining room. A good businessman, Thad stayed out of arguments about slavery and secession.
One night Lily went to the private dining room with drinks for a special group. Beth was already there, showing an interest in the men’s conversation. One man talked about ships that were carrying Northern POWs homeward from confederate prisons, and how easy it would be to cause a boiler explosion that could kill most soldiers on board. Lily was shocked, but Beth insisted it was just talk.
A couple weeks later, the steamship Sultana was going up the river, heavily overloaded with several paying passengers and many released Union POWs. Carrying double its capacity, the steamship was destroyed by a boiler explosion late at night, in the river at Mounds City. People were killed from the steam, the fire, by drowning, or being crushed from collapsing ship components. Anyone who could, went to the river to help get survivors from the water and get medical and other needs met.
People were taken to River Rest Inn until all its rooms were full. Lily and James helped Cade Palmer and his friend James out of the river; Lily had even fallen in an eddy trying to help. They didn’t know it, but Cade was a skilled surgeon who enlisted with the Union after college. Cade had stopped talking with God quite some time ago, as had Lily, each for their own reasons. Cade’s right hand was severely damaged when trying to save his friend, and he worried if he would ever operate again. Lily is convinced the accident and deaths were her fault as she didn’t tell the provost marshal about the conversation she overheard.
The characters almost come to life as we learn about them by their realistic conversations and behaviors. I especially like Lily and Cade, and appreciated their spiritual and life struggles. I could well understand how Lily could pray for others but not herself, and liked how she began to encourage, then nurture, Cade’s return to faith and how she tried to understand Beth rather than hate her.
This novel was very well written, with suspense, history, and two people who became willing to seek the Lord again. I appreciated how the assassination of President Lincoln was included, and how the author explained the plots and espionage. I enjoyed reading about how messages were changed into codes, also. There were surprises with the resolutions of circumstances, including Uncle Thad’s actions throughout the war. I highly recommend this novel to fans of women’s Christian fiction, sweet romance, and those who enjoy real historical events in America.
From a thankful heart: I received an uncorrected ARC of this novel from the publisher through NetGalley and Celebrate Lit, and this is my honest review.
June 5, 2024
When Hope Sank by Denise Weimer was another one of her excellent Historical Fiction tales. I have read a few books by her now and I have enjoyed every single one of them. Her writing style is easy to follow. It gives great detail about history, but not to the point of boredom. Weimer always does such a great job in capturing the history of the story, while still keeping it fictional. Of course, there is usually a romance in the making with her books as well, but she does it so subtly that there is no reason for caution when reading her works. This book is part of a historical history, with real events in mind. However, all the books can stand by themselves in part of this series, so there is no need to read the previous ones to catch on to what is going on in this book. It would not hurt to read them, but it is not necessary. The book follows the sinking of the ship the Sultana, hence where the title of the book comes from.
Lily is the main female character of this book and what a life she has had to deal with. She has seen and lived through so much tragedy in her life. She has lost her parents, brother and even her home all due to the Civil War. She is just trying to do what she can to help her uncle, while working at his inn. She has strong faith, so that is what is getting her through. She tried speaking about her strong held beliefs, but she feels it cost her too much, now she is not willing to stir that up again, so she just keeps her thoughts to herself.
Dr. Cade Palmer is one of the people aboard the Sultana. He is put on the ship to make his way to the North, where the Union is. When the ship explodes, he is left wounded pretty badly. He may not be able to perform surgery on another person again because of his sustained injuries, so he must try to come to terms with this.
Lily and Cade meet during his time of recovery and there seems to be some sparks there. However, she thinks that she may have been able to prevent the explosion of the Sultana, if she would have just spoken her mind, with information that there was a possible person trying to sabotage the ship. Since she decided not to do that, she feels she may be at least part of the blame. She is struggling with telling Cade that she is thinking this, but she is naturally afraid that he will push her away. Now the man returns with coded messages, and she must decide what she will do with this information.
This book was so, so good, I read it in just three short sittings. I would have devoured it faster, but life calls and I had to put it down at times when I did not want to. This book will have you in all the feels. It is a book about loss and tragedy, but it is also a book about second chances and redemption, which reminds us that God gives every one of us a second chance and many times more than that. We can be redeemed through Christ, but sometimes it takes many chances to get there. Weimer has told a historical fiction story with a good bit of faith involved, but like all her books, it is just the right amount. She does not shy away from it, but she is not overly in your face about it either. Excellent read, you will definitely not be disappointed for picking this one up!
I received a complimentary copy from the author through Celebrate Lit, for my honest opinion.
Lily is the main female character of this book and what a life she has had to deal with. She has seen and lived through so much tragedy in her life. She has lost her parents, brother and even her home all due to the Civil War. She is just trying to do what she can to help her uncle, while working at his inn. She has strong faith, so that is what is getting her through. She tried speaking about her strong held beliefs, but she feels it cost her too much, now she is not willing to stir that up again, so she just keeps her thoughts to herself.
Dr. Cade Palmer is one of the people aboard the Sultana. He is put on the ship to make his way to the North, where the Union is. When the ship explodes, he is left wounded pretty badly. He may not be able to perform surgery on another person again because of his sustained injuries, so he must try to come to terms with this.
Lily and Cade meet during his time of recovery and there seems to be some sparks there. However, she thinks that she may have been able to prevent the explosion of the Sultana, if she would have just spoken her mind, with information that there was a possible person trying to sabotage the ship. Since she decided not to do that, she feels she may be at least part of the blame. She is struggling with telling Cade that she is thinking this, but she is naturally afraid that he will push her away. Now the man returns with coded messages, and she must decide what she will do with this information.
This book was so, so good, I read it in just three short sittings. I would have devoured it faster, but life calls and I had to put it down at times when I did not want to. This book will have you in all the feels. It is a book about loss and tragedy, but it is also a book about second chances and redemption, which reminds us that God gives every one of us a second chance and many times more than that. We can be redeemed through Christ, but sometimes it takes many chances to get there. Weimer has told a historical fiction story with a good bit of faith involved, but like all her books, it is just the right amount. She does not shy away from it, but she is not overly in your face about it either. Excellent read, you will definitely not be disappointed for picking this one up!
I received a complimentary copy from the author through Celebrate Lit, for my honest opinion.
May 29, 2024
“Who said anything about love?” She stepped around him, passing close as she reached for the door. “It’s not something I’ve dared to even hope for … until now.”
Barbour has come out with some of the best series! This one, A Day to Remember, involves six different obscure American tragedies. Each can be read without reading the others, but if you read one, you’ll want to read the rest!
Book three, When Hope Sank, is NOT about the Titanic! Rather, Denise Weimer recounts the disastrous 1865 journey of the steamboat the Sultana. The Sultana is carrying pardoned Union POW soldiers from Southern prisons up the Mississippi River. Cade Palmer, a doctor, and his close friend, James Caldwell, are two men on that ill-fated, massively overloaded boat, made to carry 500, but carrying over 2,000. A sudden explosion sends many men straight into eternity. Others are lost in the flaming boat and river debris as they try to escape.
Lily Livingston, living with her strongly Southern sympathizing aunt, cousin, and more moderate uncle, finds herself helping to rescue Cade and James from the river. As she cares for Cade’s injuries, she begins to care for the man himself.
Personal growth comes for both Cade and Lily, but painfully, slowly. Cade comes to realize evil is not just in those whose hatred causes untold death and destruction, but even in his own choices he makes that are self-serving. “…God allowed people a choice, and many in every generation chose evil. Because serving oneself was, in reality, serving evil instead of God.”
“He always thought his optimism and good works would get him into heaven. He never seemed to realize there are no good people, just as my father used to say, only bad people who can either choose justice or grace.” I found this quote from Cade describing someone else ironic. Yes, Cade has already chosen God’s grace of salvation. But… the crux of the novel is… will he choose to extend God’s grace or try to visit His wrath on others he deems unworthy?
Conflict and great personal angst threaten as Lily and James deal with things they failed to do in the past. Their failures affect the people around them and guilt bears down. Will their faith rise to the occasion or will they sink under the enormity of all they’ve lost? Can God really use such a horrendous tragedy for good?
I highly recommend this novel! I received a copy from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. I also bought my own ecopy. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Pain is pain. It just hurts.” … “But it hurts a little less if you share it.”
“It’s hardly a crime to want others to think well of you.” He dropped her hand and lowered his gaze. “Not until you want it so much you put that above what God thinks.”
“By her own admission, she shared his ideals, and more importantly, his faith. Both of them clung to their spiritual heritage despite all they’d been through, and somehow, they strengthened each other in it. Believed for each other where they no longer could do so for themselves.”
“Better to be alone than to keep company with the wrong people.”
Barbour has come out with some of the best series! This one, A Day to Remember, involves six different obscure American tragedies. Each can be read without reading the others, but if you read one, you’ll want to read the rest!
Book three, When Hope Sank, is NOT about the Titanic! Rather, Denise Weimer recounts the disastrous 1865 journey of the steamboat the Sultana. The Sultana is carrying pardoned Union POW soldiers from Southern prisons up the Mississippi River. Cade Palmer, a doctor, and his close friend, James Caldwell, are two men on that ill-fated, massively overloaded boat, made to carry 500, but carrying over 2,000. A sudden explosion sends many men straight into eternity. Others are lost in the flaming boat and river debris as they try to escape.
Lily Livingston, living with her strongly Southern sympathizing aunt, cousin, and more moderate uncle, finds herself helping to rescue Cade and James from the river. As she cares for Cade’s injuries, she begins to care for the man himself.
Personal growth comes for both Cade and Lily, but painfully, slowly. Cade comes to realize evil is not just in those whose hatred causes untold death and destruction, but even in his own choices he makes that are self-serving. “…God allowed people a choice, and many in every generation chose evil. Because serving oneself was, in reality, serving evil instead of God.”
“He always thought his optimism and good works would get him into heaven. He never seemed to realize there are no good people, just as my father used to say, only bad people who can either choose justice or grace.” I found this quote from Cade describing someone else ironic. Yes, Cade has already chosen God’s grace of salvation. But… the crux of the novel is… will he choose to extend God’s grace or try to visit His wrath on others he deems unworthy?
Conflict and great personal angst threaten as Lily and James deal with things they failed to do in the past. Their failures affect the people around them and guilt bears down. Will their faith rise to the occasion or will they sink under the enormity of all they’ve lost? Can God really use such a horrendous tragedy for good?
I highly recommend this novel! I received a copy from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. I also bought my own ecopy. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Pain is pain. It just hurts.” … “But it hurts a little less if you share it.”
“It’s hardly a crime to want others to think well of you.” He dropped her hand and lowered his gaze. “Not until you want it so much you put that above what God thinks.”
“By her own admission, she shared his ideals, and more importantly, his faith. Both of them clung to their spiritual heritage despite all they’d been through, and somehow, they strengthened each other in it. Believed for each other where they no longer could do so for themselves.”
“Better to be alone than to keep company with the wrong people.”
March 9, 2024
When Hope Sank
By Denise Weimer
Publisher: Barbour Publishing
Series: A Day to Remember, Book 3
Rated: 4-5
Obtain: Borrow or buy
Back of the Book: “Can Hope Resurface After Evil Tries to Drown It?
The Civil War has taken everything from Lily Livingston—her parents, her twin brother, her home. Now she works at her uncle’s inn and keeps her head down. Speaking up for her beliefs proved too costly in a part of Arkansas split by conflicting loyalties and overrun by spies and bushwhackers.
Emaciated in body but resilient in spirit, Lieutenant Cade Palmer is crowded onto the Sultana with other paroled Andersonville and Cahaba POWs for the journey north. But a fiery explosion on April 27, 1865, rends the steamer and empties two thousand men into the frigid Mississippi River.
Recovering from wounds that might end his career as a surgeon but clinging to his faith, Cade threatens both Lily’s defenses and her heart. How can she tell him she might’ve prevented the tragedy if only she’d reported a suspected saboteur’s claims? And when the man returns to town and encoded messages pass through the hotel, will Lily follow her convictions to prevent another tragedy?”
Impressions: Although this is part of a series, these books are not connected, and this can be read as a standalone novel. The first two books in this series are great and worth reading at some point. I am excited about this series and the different historical events that are being explored. This book explores an event I’d never heard of- the sinking of the Sultana. After reading this I feel like I’ve got a better idea of the tensions that were part of day-to-day life following the civil war. It was not as simple as returning home and picking up where life left off. Many soldiers were broken inside and out, their homes were no more, and their families were gone. What trauma it must have been to face all this and still face animosity when trying to move forward. The romance was unexpected for the characters but what makes their romance all the more beautiful. This was an enjoyable story to read.
Quotes: “God allowed people a choice, and many in every generation chose evil. Because serving oneself was, in reality, serving evil instead of God.”
I received an ARC of this book via the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review shared here.
By Denise Weimer
Publisher: Barbour Publishing
Series: A Day to Remember, Book 3
Rated: 4-5
Obtain: Borrow or buy
Back of the Book: “Can Hope Resurface After Evil Tries to Drown It?
The Civil War has taken everything from Lily Livingston—her parents, her twin brother, her home. Now she works at her uncle’s inn and keeps her head down. Speaking up for her beliefs proved too costly in a part of Arkansas split by conflicting loyalties and overrun by spies and bushwhackers.
Emaciated in body but resilient in spirit, Lieutenant Cade Palmer is crowded onto the Sultana with other paroled Andersonville and Cahaba POWs for the journey north. But a fiery explosion on April 27, 1865, rends the steamer and empties two thousand men into the frigid Mississippi River.
Recovering from wounds that might end his career as a surgeon but clinging to his faith, Cade threatens both Lily’s defenses and her heart. How can she tell him she might’ve prevented the tragedy if only she’d reported a suspected saboteur’s claims? And when the man returns to town and encoded messages pass through the hotel, will Lily follow her convictions to prevent another tragedy?”
Impressions: Although this is part of a series, these books are not connected, and this can be read as a standalone novel. The first two books in this series are great and worth reading at some point. I am excited about this series and the different historical events that are being explored. This book explores an event I’d never heard of- the sinking of the Sultana. After reading this I feel like I’ve got a better idea of the tensions that were part of day-to-day life following the civil war. It was not as simple as returning home and picking up where life left off. Many soldiers were broken inside and out, their homes were no more, and their families were gone. What trauma it must have been to face all this and still face animosity when trying to move forward. The romance was unexpected for the characters but what makes their romance all the more beautiful. This was an enjoyable story to read.
Quotes: “God allowed people a choice, and many in every generation chose evil. Because serving oneself was, in reality, serving evil instead of God.”
I received an ARC of this book via the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review shared here.
March 5, 2024
🌟 A Riveting Civil War Tale of Hope and Romance: When Hope Sank 🚢
In Denise Weimer's When Hope Sank, the echoes of the Civil War resonate through a story of tragedy, mystery, and the undying flame of hope. Set against the backdrop of the devastating explosion of the steamer "The Sultana," this historical romance immerses readers in a world of danger, intrigue, and the enduring power of faith.
📖 Plot and Pacing: A Masterful Blend of Fact and Fiction
From the first page, I was drawn into the gripping narrative that Weimer expertly weaves. The story unfolds at a brisk pace, never letting go of its hold on the reader until the final, heart-pounding moments. The historical backdrop of the Sultana disaster adds a layer of authenticity and depth, prompting me to delve deeper into this lesser-known event in history.
🎭 Characters: Vibrant, Heartfelt, and Relatable
Lily Livingston and Lieutenant Cade Palmer are characters that leaped off the page, their struggles and triumphs becoming deeply personal to me as a reader. Lily's resilience in the face of loss and uncertainty is inspiring, while Cade's unwavering faith and determination left a lasting impression. The romance that blossoms between them amidst the chaos and danger is tender, heartfelt, and beautifully portrayed.
🕵️♂️ Mystery and Suspense: Unraveling Secrets in the Midst of Chaos
The mystery element of When Hope Sank kept me on the edge of my seat, eagerly turning pages to uncover the truth alongside Lily and Cade. The presence of a suspected saboteur, encoded messages, and the looming threat of another tragedy added layers of tension and intrigue that had me guessing until the very end.
🙏 Themes of Faith and Resilience: A Testament to the Human Spirit
Throughout the story, the themes of faith, resilience, and the power of hope shine brightly. Weimer seamlessly integrates Christian elements into the narrative, reminding readers of the strength that can be found in faith during the darkest of times. Lily's journey of self-discovery and Cade's unwavering belief in the face of adversity serve as poignant reminders of the human spirit's ability to persevere.
📚 Final Thoughts: A Captivating Journey Through History
Denise Weimer’s talent for storytelling is on full display in the compelling narrative of When Hope Sank. It is a captivating blend of history, romance, mystery, and faith that will linger in the hearts of readers long after the final page is turned. I highly recommend this novel to anyone seeking an immersive and unforgettable reading experience.
When Hope Sank is a riveting Civil War tale that tugs at the heartstrings, challenges the mind, and ultimately leaves a profound impact. Denise Weimer's meticulous research, vivid prose, and compelling characters shine in this must-read for fans of historical fiction, romance, and Christian literature.
I received an eARC of When Hope Sank from Barbour Fiction through NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review in any way or for any reason. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the great writing and story’s fantastic content, ensuring transparency and reliability.
In Denise Weimer's When Hope Sank, the echoes of the Civil War resonate through a story of tragedy, mystery, and the undying flame of hope. Set against the backdrop of the devastating explosion of the steamer "The Sultana," this historical romance immerses readers in a world of danger, intrigue, and the enduring power of faith.
📖 Plot and Pacing: A Masterful Blend of Fact and Fiction
From the first page, I was drawn into the gripping narrative that Weimer expertly weaves. The story unfolds at a brisk pace, never letting go of its hold on the reader until the final, heart-pounding moments. The historical backdrop of the Sultana disaster adds a layer of authenticity and depth, prompting me to delve deeper into this lesser-known event in history.
🎭 Characters: Vibrant, Heartfelt, and Relatable
Lily Livingston and Lieutenant Cade Palmer are characters that leaped off the page, their struggles and triumphs becoming deeply personal to me as a reader. Lily's resilience in the face of loss and uncertainty is inspiring, while Cade's unwavering faith and determination left a lasting impression. The romance that blossoms between them amidst the chaos and danger is tender, heartfelt, and beautifully portrayed.
🕵️♂️ Mystery and Suspense: Unraveling Secrets in the Midst of Chaos
The mystery element of When Hope Sank kept me on the edge of my seat, eagerly turning pages to uncover the truth alongside Lily and Cade. The presence of a suspected saboteur, encoded messages, and the looming threat of another tragedy added layers of tension and intrigue that had me guessing until the very end.
🙏 Themes of Faith and Resilience: A Testament to the Human Spirit
Throughout the story, the themes of faith, resilience, and the power of hope shine brightly. Weimer seamlessly integrates Christian elements into the narrative, reminding readers of the strength that can be found in faith during the darkest of times. Lily's journey of self-discovery and Cade's unwavering belief in the face of adversity serve as poignant reminders of the human spirit's ability to persevere.
📚 Final Thoughts: A Captivating Journey Through History
Denise Weimer’s talent for storytelling is on full display in the compelling narrative of When Hope Sank. It is a captivating blend of history, romance, mystery, and faith that will linger in the hearts of readers long after the final page is turned. I highly recommend this novel to anyone seeking an immersive and unforgettable reading experience.
When Hope Sank is a riveting Civil War tale that tugs at the heartstrings, challenges the mind, and ultimately leaves a profound impact. Denise Weimer's meticulous research, vivid prose, and compelling characters shine in this must-read for fans of historical fiction, romance, and Christian literature.
I received an eARC of When Hope Sank from Barbour Fiction through NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review in any way or for any reason. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the great writing and story’s fantastic content, ensuring transparency and reliability.
June 7, 2024
When Hope Sank is book three in the Day to Remember series. The series is written by multiple authors and are all tied together by the historic event theme. This book is written by Denise Weimer. The author has done some careful research to bring this historic event to light.
The Civil War is over. Prisoners of War are being bused back where they can muster out of the Army. Tensions are still high, especially in the Southern states. Lily lives with her uncle and helps with his business. Her parents have passed and she is grateful to have somewhere to live. Her feelings about the war are different than her uncles, but she has learned to do as she is told. Her cousin, Beth, is a little more outspoken. She is sleeping one day when she is awoken by screams and shouts.
Cade is a doctor in the army. He is so happy to be released and cannot wait to get back to Northern soil. He is on the steamship coming home when suddenly it blows to pieces. His medical training kicks in and he tries to get as many to safety as he can.
Lily and her brother go down and try and help. When they find Cade and an unconscious man on a door Lilly sheds her garments and jumps in. She helps to bring them to shore. Cade has broken bones and burns all on his backs. However it becomes clear he does not want to be in the company of Southern Sympathizers. He buts heads with the towns doctor. Lily and her calming nature continues to try and help Cade.
I really liked the characters. They had hurt and pain from the war that has effected how they feel about people. I loved Lily's patience. She has great attention to detail and understands different medical terms to assist.
I love how the author captured how those might have felt after the war. Tensions were still high. I went and looked up this event and the author did a great job at keeping in important historical details. The book is well written. The storyline is engaging. I have been loving this whole series.
Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book - all thoughts are my own.
The Civil War is over. Prisoners of War are being bused back where they can muster out of the Army. Tensions are still high, especially in the Southern states. Lily lives with her uncle and helps with his business. Her parents have passed and she is grateful to have somewhere to live. Her feelings about the war are different than her uncles, but she has learned to do as she is told. Her cousin, Beth, is a little more outspoken. She is sleeping one day when she is awoken by screams and shouts.
Cade is a doctor in the army. He is so happy to be released and cannot wait to get back to Northern soil. He is on the steamship coming home when suddenly it blows to pieces. His medical training kicks in and he tries to get as many to safety as he can.
Lily and her brother go down and try and help. When they find Cade and an unconscious man on a door Lilly sheds her garments and jumps in. She helps to bring them to shore. Cade has broken bones and burns all on his backs. However it becomes clear he does not want to be in the company of Southern Sympathizers. He buts heads with the towns doctor. Lily and her calming nature continues to try and help Cade.
I really liked the characters. They had hurt and pain from the war that has effected how they feel about people. I loved Lily's patience. She has great attention to detail and understands different medical terms to assist.
I love how the author captured how those might have felt after the war. Tensions were still high. I went and looked up this event and the author did a great job at keeping in important historical details. The book is well written. The storyline is engaging. I have been loving this whole series.
Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book - all thoughts are my own.
June 11, 2024
When Hope Sank tells the story of the fateful day when the Sultana ship was carrying the POWs of the Union side back north. What happened was devastating as the ship blew up sending many of these soldiers to their deaths. What happened? Was it sabotage? Negligence? Or just a freak accident? As always, the author's notes at the back give us some insight as to what history says.
The war is over, but Lincoln has been assassinated, and the country has been torn apart. Reeling from its wounds we get a fictional account of the lack of trust on both sides of the North and South. Lieutenant Cade Palmer was a Union army surgeon and POW on his way back to the Union side, when his already turned up life becomes more so. Suffering from agonizing wounds, he is saved by the pretty Lily Livingston and taken to her Uncle's Inn in Arkansas.
Overhearing something she shouldn't have; Lily feels guilty about what happened. She is in a tough spot as all her immediate family accept her younger brother, has died. Now she is responsible for herself and him. When she saves Cade's life, little does she know her life will be forever changed.
This story really showed the realism of people's feelings when the country was just beginning the healing process from its war wounds and how could anyone trust the other side again. Both sides were devastated from death and war, and to have this unbelievable disaster that caused more tragic deaths and harm, was unthinkable. Who was at fault? Understandably this tragedy still showed how vulnerable the country still was. And for both Lily and Cade, some big decisions needed to be made and a lot of forgiveness needed to begin.
I have really been enjoying this series. I like that the authors are bringing one day disasters attention again, so that we may learn a bit more about history and what others had gone through before us.
I was provided a copy of this novel from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
The war is over, but Lincoln has been assassinated, and the country has been torn apart. Reeling from its wounds we get a fictional account of the lack of trust on both sides of the North and South. Lieutenant Cade Palmer was a Union army surgeon and POW on his way back to the Union side, when his already turned up life becomes more so. Suffering from agonizing wounds, he is saved by the pretty Lily Livingston and taken to her Uncle's Inn in Arkansas.
Overhearing something she shouldn't have; Lily feels guilty about what happened. She is in a tough spot as all her immediate family accept her younger brother, has died. Now she is responsible for herself and him. When she saves Cade's life, little does she know her life will be forever changed.
This story really showed the realism of people's feelings when the country was just beginning the healing process from its war wounds and how could anyone trust the other side again. Both sides were devastated from death and war, and to have this unbelievable disaster that caused more tragic deaths and harm, was unthinkable. Who was at fault? Understandably this tragedy still showed how vulnerable the country still was. And for both Lily and Cade, some big decisions needed to be made and a lot of forgiveness needed to begin.
I have really been enjoying this series. I like that the authors are bringing one day disasters attention again, so that we may learn a bit more about history and what others had gone through before us.
I was provided a copy of this novel from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
March 15, 2024
Note: Thank you to NetGalley, Barbour Publishing, and Denise Weimer for the advanced reader copy of the book. This review will also be posted on NetGalley. What follows is my unbiased review of the book.
Taking a largely overlooked event at the end of the Civil War, author Denise Weimer has managed to craft a compelling story of personal sacrifice and building bridges in the face of unimaginable loss.
Lily Livingston lost everything in the War; her parents, her home, and her twin brother. She and a younger brother now live with her aunt and uncle and help them run the inn they own on the Arkansas side of the Mississippi River.
Cade Palmer is a Union soldier just trying to get home after having been imprisoned at Andersonville. He was an Army surgeon captured during the war along with his childhood friend, James. The two are being brought back to Ohio to be mustered out of the service on board the Sultana. While they are traveling upriver, there is an explosion. Cade and James manage to get off of the doomed vessel after being severely burned.
Lily’s uncle, Thad, and others living in Mound City hear the explosion and attempt to rescue as many as they can from the water. Lily and her brother, Jacob, are only supposed to be there to assist. However, when she hears cries coming from the water, she feels she must help, and ends up pulling James and Cade from the water.
As Cade heals from his wounds at the Inn, Lily and Cade bond. However, her sweetheart, a Confederate partisan, is on his way home. As things are breaking down at the end of the War, some men haven’t given up the battle, yet. Lily is afraid her inaction possibly resulted in men being killed, while Cade struggles with his own place in the world, especially since his hand was shattered. All the while, threats seem to loom around them.
To read my full review, please go to When Hope Sank by Denise Weimer
Taking a largely overlooked event at the end of the Civil War, author Denise Weimer has managed to craft a compelling story of personal sacrifice and building bridges in the face of unimaginable loss.
Lily Livingston lost everything in the War; her parents, her home, and her twin brother. She and a younger brother now live with her aunt and uncle and help them run the inn they own on the Arkansas side of the Mississippi River.
Cade Palmer is a Union soldier just trying to get home after having been imprisoned at Andersonville. He was an Army surgeon captured during the war along with his childhood friend, James. The two are being brought back to Ohio to be mustered out of the service on board the Sultana. While they are traveling upriver, there is an explosion. Cade and James manage to get off of the doomed vessel after being severely burned.
Lily’s uncle, Thad, and others living in Mound City hear the explosion and attempt to rescue as many as they can from the water. Lily and her brother, Jacob, are only supposed to be there to assist. However, when she hears cries coming from the water, she feels she must help, and ends up pulling James and Cade from the water.
As Cade heals from his wounds at the Inn, Lily and Cade bond. However, her sweetheart, a Confederate partisan, is on his way home. As things are breaking down at the end of the War, some men haven’t given up the battle, yet. Lily is afraid her inaction possibly resulted in men being killed, while Cade struggles with his own place in the world, especially since his hand was shattered. All the while, threats seem to loom around them.
To read my full review, please go to When Hope Sank by Denise Weimer
Displaying 1 - 30 of 98 reviews