I read "Spike into the light"..again...I want to say I'm dissapointed for this, because I was very excited about James Marsters getting back into Buffyverse. About the book,the art is great (is the possitive thing about the comics) because the story go exactly against the entire season 7, in every sense.The timeline was choosen very wrong (Scott Allie said it was at start of season 7) The characterisation was bobbing around a bit but mostly the problem was that the writing was pretty terrible and of course,off the character all time,this is nothing like Canonical Spike in the series. He beats up two humans at the beginning so he has no chip (no chip before season 7??) and as the previews showed, he has his coat which he doesn't get back until ep15 of Season7 in the series. It wouldn't work during the season either, especially later on, because he says he has gone there for a 'fresh start' and when he gets badly injured it states in the text it takes weeks to get better. Spike once dechipped/untriggered wouldn't have left like that, it would totally break a season arc of him Buffy relying on each other emphasised by her having asked him to stay (and doesn't match at all with Scott Allie saying it was a little over 24hrs). It just simply doesn't fit either pre or during S7 because Spike was crazy at that time. It seems they just wanted to place it within canon and didn't properly consider where it would actually work, particularly if Spike is talking in the story as if he has gone off for a 'fresh start'. It obviously doesn't matter to the canon story and is a stand alone and they haven't really worked out how it fits in or there wouldn't be so many inconsistencies. Any love interest in the timeline they picked its HORRIBLE to see for any BTVS fan...In that time Spike was fully in love with Buffy and dealing with the scene of "Seeing Red", so of course no one wants to see Spike getting puppy eyes from some random girl (James Marsters said Spike fall for this girl...that's absolutely ridiculous). After he come back from Africa, he is broken and trying to return to Buffy. Marsters ignore all Spike's guilt for what he did to Buffy in this timeline,that's a big problem with this comics. Spike got his soul for the slayer. I understand a comics between season 7 and 6 should be very emotional and Spuffy. It is a really wasted opportunity though,they could explore an interesing time in Spike's life. Also I believe Spike with a new love interest is not possible because Spike left this very clear for Buffy :"Yeah, I talk to people. Women. Talk to them 'cause I can't talk to you.So, yeah. I go and pass the time... with someone. But that's all it is is time, 'cause, God help me Buffy, it's still all about you." Spike and this chit called Dylan, kiss in Marsters comics. Marsters Not fit to canon because Spike didn't start speaking to women after he's out of the basement, not so crazy, and living with Xander. This comic IS NOT CANON,and NOT OFFICIAL,is just a fanfiction wrote by an actor.I think when you write a comics (and if you actually played the character) you have to do it to people enjoy it, I mean these HUGE mistakes cant happen.....this is like a fanfiction of Spike in AU .Effectively it is fanfic with an alternative shipping preference thrown in (a shipper not canonical with some random girl..and yes putting personal life into Spike's life is not professional ,fans are not happy for this. The most found it disrespecteful.) I'm surprised they even considered it because this story does not fit in anywhere. Is a shame the way this story was taken because everyone was very excited and happy for James Marsters getting into the BTVS, and they had all the tools to make a great product .....Everybody can write fanfictions going out from characters ,I personally don't like reading them if they are like that.I prefer fictions where Buffy and Spike personalities are respected but, it's true everyone can write what they want and make experiments,but these fan fics don't come from some trustworthy and authority source as James M is. James writing a fan fiction like this (with all these mistakes) is really wrong and most of the fans won't accept it. In my opinion, they can't expect to have a lot of success if they dont respect the things that define to the series and the characters. As Spuffy shipper (as the most of fandom is) You will get mad because James ignore all Spike/Buffy love conflict. Spike saying "I came here for a fresh start" in the start of season 7 left the message: "He did something very wrong but he just ignores it,and try to move on,so he get a soul to start a new life but he couldnt and thats why he returns to Buffy again,because his new life failed. Is not about his love for Buffy,no about redemption, no about being a better man and being forgiven. He backs to Sunnydale because the rest didnt work right." That's not the Spike we saw and love in the series,the Spike who fight at Buffy's side. If James intention was to give Spike a story what shows the character wanting to be good for himself and not kill off anyone to get what he wants, he failed horribly.That intention is not showed in this comics.If you are a huge Spike lover,considering the reason why Spike fought for his soul, what triggered it, which he is still reeling from at the beginning of S7, it is nonsense and perhaps somewhat crass to say he would act like he did in this comics ,if you are a big BTVS fan and you dont care to ship any couple, probably you gonna get frustrated anyway.. because this story Completely doesn't work .. (You only need to watch the first two episodes of S7 to see that this is not possible.) So..I think people who could apreaciatte this comics are: fans that can ignore the series and read this like AU (alternate universe, forget all you know about Spike, and about Spike love for Buffy,and forget the timeline and what happen in season 7..and read this like..just a story, the story of a vampire dealing with a soul that has nothing to do with BTVS or with Spike as well) because in other way (into the series) this story is pointless. The chip mistake,the love interest mistake, the coat mistake..even an error was the inclusion of a t-shirt that says “Little Miss Sunshine.” The movie came out in 2006, but the in between time far Season 6 and 7 of Buffy was in 2002...
If it was in a different time set like after Angel series, probably could do this a little more acceptable to read,just a little..The sunlight issue was just one of many writing weaknesses in the story but definitely one of the worst. It wasn't even that he just smoked a bit he was on fire but didn't dust despite being burnt raw all over that took weeks to recover from. The execution and detailing in this story is pretty bad. The humour was also pretty ropey. I liked the bit with the mirror in her flat but the whole "I need a witch/nerd/librarian" (or some such) was just awkward scripting and that kind of thing was dotted throughout. I believe in this case Joss Whedon's product and his story weren't respected, they are using it to personal promotion. And honestly is not right. It is not a comic I would recommend sadly.