ARC received from Netgalley.
I'm so, so sorry to say this--but the book is bad. Really bad. It needed a LOT more developmental editing, and I hope it got it before going to publication; I only got the ARC the day before publication and it took me a couple of days to get through it. I think the problems can be broadly broken into three main categories: the worldbuilding, Coa, and Ife.
The Worldbuilding
This world--which is, I should say, our world makes no sense. Phenix lays out a structure in which, for some reason, every country except the United States and the UK has become some other country entirely, and some random people from the Artic (but NOT indigenous people from the Arctic) called the Allied Forces (who are they allied with? literally no one, it just one big group) have taken over everything except the USA/UK alliance. How did we get to this point? METEORS. Yup. That's the whole explanation. Well, not really. Phenix does a LOT of info dumping in this book, for pages upon pages at a time, but none of it actually makes sense, and every time she tries to explain something, it just makes everything make less sense. Honestly, this book would have been much better suited to a second-world setting, because then she could have just scrapped all of the attempts at "how did we get here" and could have leaned much more on a "this is the way the world is" logic. There is also an attempt at having magic in this book, which isn't super well-done, and also with the exception of one in every eight million people, all magic belongs to indigenous African and Inuit communities (there is much more emphasis on the African magic than the Inuit magic, though the Inuit magic is mentioned in the background of one minor supporting character) which...seems to really lean into the whole "African mysticism" stereotype and seems problematic. (It is worth noting that Ife, our only main character with African origins, does NOT have magical abilities of her own.) A second-world setting could have alleviated some of the "what do you mean there's magic involved here" of the whole book as well. Phenix definitely could have had a second-world setting while still drawing on the horrors of various genocides in our world to make a point.
There's also the whole setup of the Great Hunt, where the Allied Forces send "foreigners" (aka anyone who is not them) into an area to be shot at by AF snipers over seven days, all while the foreigners do Hunger Games-esque things to each other to try to get ahead. Why? Who knows. In this particular iteration of the Great Hunt, the Hunt is taking place on an African island that is...cursed? Hexed? Alive with magic? Unclear. It is a SEVERELY UNDERUTILIZED setting. There is setup that the island can be bargained with after making an appropriate sacrifice; nothing ever comes of this. There is setup that a giant typhoon is going to come and wreak havoc on the place; nothing is ever done with this. The typhoon DOES come, but only in the sense that main character Coa says "Oh it was really bad and took a while to pass," with "a while" being less than 24 hours. The typhoon could have been utilized as really dramatic set-dressing for a final climactic encounter, but no.
Coa
Coa is one of the two main characters, and the one that is introduced first in the book. She is a prisoner in a forced labor camp run by the Allied Forces. She is one of the people being forced to compete in the Great Hunt, and she wants to survive the Great Hunt because if she dies as part of it, her entire family will be executed as well. She can also breathe fire and shoot lightning out of her hands even though she has no apparent connections of any of the communities that have magic in this book.
Coa's story makes no sense from the start. We NEVER find out how she ended up in this labor camp. Early on it seems like there is going to be a bit of a dual timeline for Coa, with the Great Hunt story taking up the "present" portion and a "how did we get here" timeline for the past, but that ends pretty quickly with Coa and her adoptive family deciding they want to run away from Hallowell, their native country, for the United States. We never see them actually enact this plan or find out how they got caught by the Allied Forces and end up in a labor camp off the coast of Africa (which part of Africa is never specified, just that it's tropical). Note that I said Coa's ADOPTIVE family. This is a big plot hole. I am a big proponent of found family stories, but it doesn't work here because Coa's ENTIRE STATED MOTIVATION for the entire book is that if she dies, her family will be killed. However, there is no indication of how the AF would ACTUALLY KNOW they are her family. She's literally asked if she has family early on by the AF, she says no, and they believe her. There is mention of DNA tracking being how they enforce family kill orders, but Coa's family is not biologically related to her, and so that won't work. So how does her being in the Great Hunt actually endanger them? Also, she says they'll all be killed if she dies but she literally starts off the book by telling a soldier to kill her, she doesn't care, which doesn't really set her up as a smart person to root for throughout the book. And then at the end, she's saying she's ready to die during the Great Hunt, apparently forgetting her entire stated motivation of protecting her family. She never, ever makes a single smart or strategic decision. Ever. Also, her magic (breathing fire and shooting lightning from her hands) supposedly comes at the cost of burning her lungs and throat, and will eventually kill her. I say "supposedly" because she uses her magic at various points in the book with none of these consequences. They don't show up until about 80% of the way through, when it heightens the drama in one specific encounter for them to show up. All the other instances, she walks away from her magic usage with no consequences of it at all.
Ife
Ife, at first blush, seems to hold more promise than Coa as a character. She is Makarian, which is one of the made-up countries in Africa and the only one that has magic. But Ife doesn't have magic. She is also a princess, and is married to Maximus Stormbane, who is the heir to the Allied Forces. How did Ife end up here? WE NEVER FIND OUT. She says her own family hates her for not having magic and TRIED TO KILL HER until she ran away TO THE ARCTIC (where, as a reminder, EVERYONE WOULD WANT TO KILL HER TOO FOR NOT BEING ARCTIC HERSELF), and then she apparently...lived in the wilderness for three years until she randomly turned up at a Makarian embassy and got married to Maximus? Absolute nonsense. Logic? Fleshed-out backstory? Never heard of it. Ife supposedly married Maximus because she intends to assassinate him and wanted the insider access being his wife would give her. Ife never, at any point in this entire book, makes any move to kill Maximus OR to prepare to kill him, in any way, which ultimately renders her entire character as kind of pointless. I kept waiting for her to DO something...but she never did.
Final Thoughts
Phenix states in the author's note section that she wrote her first draft of the book when she was a sophomore in high school...and honestly, I think that explains a lot. This very much reads like a book that was written by a fifteen- or sixteen-year-old. She tries to tackle topics like genocide that her writing just doesn't have the maturity to do well. Let's be honest; would most of us want the world to read something we wrote in high school? PROBABLY NOT, because it was more than likely REALLY BAD. This is not a knock against Phenix specifically, but just that teenagers are generally not amazing novelists because they haven't had the time to develop the skills that go into writing a really great novel. A really good developmental editor could have helped with this, with giving the book structure, cleaning up the worldbuilding, and solidifying character motivations and actions, but despite an editor being listed and thanked, it really does not feel like that high-touch development happened. I kept reading even though I wanted to DNF early on because I kept thinking that SURELY there was going to be some twist or reveal that was going to make everything click together, but that just never happened. I have no interest in reading further books in this series after how bad this one was, but hopefully by the time Phenix gets to her next story, whatever that may be, she will have the experience and maturity to draft a stronger story to start with, and the editorial support to make sure it truly shines. I wish her the best.