3.5 Stars.
The Mary Poppins complete collection is a rollercoaster ride of a book. It features one of my most beloved characters, Mary Poppins, who is so unique and so interesting to read about. It features a family that you grow more and more infatuated with as the chapters progress.
It also has a host of side characters that vary from the mildly interesting to bland recurring nuisances. By the end of the novel I was just about ready to crack it every time Fred the Park Keeper appeared on the page. The same goes for the Policeman and Admiral Boom. Sadly, when it comes to the shortcomings of these stories, dull and repetitious characters are the just the tip of the iceberg.
Between the magical and intriguing gems that can be found throughout the six Mary Poppins books, there happens to be a lot of boring, repetitive filler that P. L. Travers regurgitated onto the page over and over again. For instance...
How many magical old women will sell the children something that is more than it seems?
Over the course of the first three novels we met Mrs. Corry with her gingerbread stars, The Balloon Woman with her personalized flying balloons, and Miss Calico, with her peppermint sticks that are actually flying horses (written remarkably similar to the balloon story...)
How many times will the children sneak out at night to find some congregation of magical people and/or creatures in the park or elsewhere?
- The first novel had the giant zoo party (ending in a dance).
- The second novel had the constellation circus (ending in a dance).
- The third novel featured both the magical gathering of sea creatures (ending in a dance) and the book characters and toys of the world congregating in the park (of course, ending in a dance).
- The fourth novel contains a party, in the park, consisting of peoples' escaped shadows. (Guess what? They dance.)
How many quirky relatives of Mary Poppins have a curse that activates on a certain kind of day?
- There's the lovable Uncle Arthur Wigg, who laughs himself to the ceiling every time his birthday falls on a Friday. He has a grumpy housekeeper who is shocked to witness this phenomenon.
- There's Mr. Turvey, whose world is turned upside down on the second Monday of the month. He has a grumpy housekeeper who is shocked to witness this phenomenon. Though she distinguishes herself from the others by accepting it and having a change of temperament.
- We're then introduced to Mr. Fred Twigley, Mary's cousin, whose wishes come true so long as it is "the first New Moon after the Second Wet Sunday, after the Third of May." He has a grumpy housekeeper intent on marrying him. She knows about his wishes, but is shocked when he uses them to spin her in a jewelry box. She wanted him to give her a golden castle.
- In the fourth book we meet Mary's other cousin, Mr. Mo, who is not cursed, but does somehow live in a plasticine park. And he's struggling with a grumpy woman demanding to be his wife. She wants him to build her a castle. Wait, wait, I've heard this one before...
And of course there's the chapters in which the children behave badly on a particular day of the week and are taught a lesson by being dragged into some magical world (alone), only to be saved by Mary Poppins at the last minute. Bad Tuesday, Bad Wednesday, Lucky Thursday... though at least these differ to some degree in the foes the children are made to face.
Then there's the typical filler chapter of each novel, in which P. L. Travers, bored of her usual characters, attempts to tell a fairy tale. These are by far my least favourite part of each Mary Poppins novel. The loveable characters you've grown accustom to are replaced by dull, limited-time-only, types. The Dancing Cow, Robertson Ay's Story, The Cat That Looked At A King, and Every Goose A Swan, in each of the four novels respectively. All left me rather unimpressed and impatient to get to the next chapter.
Each book inevitably includes some mention of stars, constellations and figures of Greek/Roman mythology. This didn't bother me so much, as each time it was approched in a different way. A child Christmas shopping, a trip into space, a statue coming to life and a Midsummer's Eve excursion to collect herbs. It was well done.
If I have children one day, I'm sure I'll read them these stories. But I'll break it up one chapter at a time, with other books in between. Because I honestly don't know how children could stay focused on characters that never develop, and chapters that drag on an on about something alarmingly similar to something they read a week before.
Despite it all, I still enjoyed this collection. In fact, I loved certain parts, and found it captured my imagination. But... overall? I just plain liked it. Had it not been stuffed full with so much filler, it would have been four stars. Sadly, there were just too many bland characters and chapters to save the good parts.