What do you think?
Rate this book
Echo of the Blue Mountain: A Wuxia Martial Arts Fantasy
The last swordsman of Blue Mountain hovers between life and death.
While his allies do all they can to keep him alive, the Black Tigers swell in number. But the eyes of the emperor have been on the Southern Province for a long time, and he has dispatched his most fearsome general to deal with the rebellion.
She Who Pacifies the North, the White Crane General, searches for the Black Tiger and a powerful weapon that will end his cause. Thousands of innocents suffer in her wake, and the coming battle between these two fearsome foes will surely leave the Southern Province in ruins.
But even as the land burns, a long-lost friend returns from the past to aid the heroes of Blue Mountain in their hour of need. As Tao Jun deciphers the secrets of the Nine Dragon manual, Shu Yan trains under his tutelage.
But what can a group of swordsmen do against the fury of the White Crane and the cunning of the Black Tiger?
While his allies do all they can to keep him alive, the Black Tigers swell in number. But the eyes of the emperor have been on the Southern Province for a long time, and he has dispatched his most fearsome general to deal with the rebellion.
She Who Pacifies the North, the White Crane General, searches for the Black Tiger and a powerful weapon that will end his cause. Thousands of innocents suffer in her wake, and the coming battle between these two fearsome foes will surely leave the Southern Province in ruins.
But even as the land burns, a long-lost friend returns from the past to aid the heroes of Blue Mountain in their hour of need. As Tao Jun deciphers the secrets of the Nine Dragon manual, Shu Yan trains under his tutelage.
But what can a group of swordsmen do against the fury of the White Crane and the cunning of the Black Tiger?
548 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 8, 2024
7 people are currently reading
36 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews
January 31, 2024
The fourth installment of the Tales of the Swordsman sees Li Ming recovering from his catastrophic battle with the Black Tiger General at the Temple of Eastern Light. Shu Yan's training is taken over by Tao Jun and a ghost from Blue Mountain's past. And in the wider world the Black Tigers are on the run as a new ruthless enemy from the North threatens everyone in the Southern Province.
This book felt more like a cultivation novel than the previous three, with a lot of emphasis put on Shu Yan's training and development, which I really enjoyed. It was less heavy on the action than the previous books but the tension simmering in Blue Mountain and beyond, with the constant threat of imminent violence from one source or another drove the story forwards.
This is the first book in the second trilogy of the series, and with just two more books to go, I'm excited to see where Shu Yan, Li Ming, Tao Jun and the rest of these fabulous characters end up!
Thank you to JF Lee and Bookfunnel for providing me with an ARC copy of this book.
This book felt more like a cultivation novel than the previous three, with a lot of emphasis put on Shu Yan's training and development, which I really enjoyed. It was less heavy on the action than the previous books but the tension simmering in Blue Mountain and beyond, with the constant threat of imminent violence from one source or another drove the story forwards.
This is the first book in the second trilogy of the series, and with just two more books to go, I'm excited to see where Shu Yan, Li Ming, Tao Jun and the rest of these fabulous characters end up!
Thank you to JF Lee and Bookfunnel for providing me with an ARC copy of this book.
August 5, 2025
Wow I made a lot of notes on this one! Apologies for the lengthy rambling that follows.
It took me longer to start writing this review than the others because I found so many philosophical and moral quandries in this book, that I'm still unsure which side I'm on. The question has been brewing for a couple books on just how justified the "bad guys" are in this world. Whether a rebellion is morally justified or not in a story usually comes down to the other side being "worse". Which side is willing to commit the worst atrocities in order to win and which side doesn't believe the ends justify the means is usually an easy way to sort the villians and heroes. In the case of Tales of the Swordsman that line is getting a bit more unclear. We had already seen the "good" side of the rebels with Shu Yan spending time amongst them and her relationship with Feng Zemin, now we see the worst of the other side with the White Crane General. I'd been wondering for awhile about Li Mings animosity to the Black Tigers, and how much was tied into his personal hatred of Shazha Kui, and not a moral objection to their cause. With Li Ming full of ptsd this book, it's pretty clear he can't think rationally about the big picture. Which leads right into the emotional damage of this book. Without spoilers, it's amazing how quickly you can turn "poor Li Ming" into "what are you thinking you moron!" The last scene between Shu Yan and Li Ming had me a bit choked up. Yet at the same time it was a beautiful symmetry to Li Mings own past, and one of those moments you knew deep down had to happen. These types of divides and different views on honor vs duty make this, I think, the darkest book so far. And I mean that as a compliment! The grittiness and moral quandries that come with the life of a "hero" has always been interesting to me. In this jianghu world, death is dealt out almost casually, and more a matter of IF you can kill someone rather than SHOULD you kill someone. This book broadened that problem out to an even bigger question; how MANY can die? And for me the biggest example of the divide these questions cause is my favorite guy, Tao Jun. Sigh, I had trouble with my guy this book. I had viewed him as a man of three layers. The goofy obvious side that covers up for the hard as nails side, which is all in service to his inner loyal core. But this book... my guy is in a dark place that I hope is temporary and not his true inner core. (Fyi, there is a Tao Jun spin off series now on my TBR list)
Ok, on to the brighter side of things. Even in this, the darkest book, there was the funniest footnote of the series so far. No spoilers, but the Chronicle of the Roof Tile was strangely moving and would make a great Pixar short. Li Mings love affair with dumplings even in the middle of deep ptsd depression was a much needed moment for him. (And may have led to an unplanned doordash order ...) Granny Chen is also quickly becoming a go to for humor, and I'm really hoping to see more about her past. Maybe a prequel novella? Granny Chen also brought in something I had been interested in, the healing and herblore. There had been glimpses with Luoying, but her and Granny Chen really broadened the scope of it in this book. It was really interesting to see the interaction between the herbs side of healing and the Qi/Niegog side. Between Li Mings healing and Shu Yans training, you really start to understand just how the qi can work for different people. I like the idea that the "powers" are not just randomly granted to certain people, but something that can be learned if you're willing to devote yourself to the practice.
There is to be at least one other book in the Tales of the Swordsman series and I am definitely on board to see this story to the end. All in all for my first ARC and first wuxia series I was very impressed. Each book was better than the last, with the world deepening as it goes. I appreciate when an author doesn't just default to an info dump to explain the world. Instead, J.F Lee lets the reader gradually get deeper into the world as the characters get drawn in. Explanations are organic and come when relevant to the story. And I can't state enough how unexpected and great the humor is. Using footnotes as a punch line and information source I think is a great insight to the authors own enjoyment of the world and characters. Thank you for the ARC, and I'm along for the ride now!
It took me longer to start writing this review than the others because I found so many philosophical and moral quandries in this book, that I'm still unsure which side I'm on. The question has been brewing for a couple books on just how justified the "bad guys" are in this world. Whether a rebellion is morally justified or not in a story usually comes down to the other side being "worse". Which side is willing to commit the worst atrocities in order to win and which side doesn't believe the ends justify the means is usually an easy way to sort the villians and heroes. In the case of Tales of the Swordsman that line is getting a bit more unclear. We had already seen the "good" side of the rebels with Shu Yan spending time amongst them and her relationship with Feng Zemin, now we see the worst of the other side with the White Crane General. I'd been wondering for awhile about Li Mings animosity to the Black Tigers, and how much was tied into his personal hatred of Shazha Kui, and not a moral objection to their cause. With Li Ming full of ptsd this book, it's pretty clear he can't think rationally about the big picture. Which leads right into the emotional damage of this book. Without spoilers, it's amazing how quickly you can turn "poor Li Ming" into "what are you thinking you moron!" The last scene between Shu Yan and Li Ming had me a bit choked up. Yet at the same time it was a beautiful symmetry to Li Mings own past, and one of those moments you knew deep down had to happen. These types of divides and different views on honor vs duty make this, I think, the darkest book so far. And I mean that as a compliment! The grittiness and moral quandries that come with the life of a "hero" has always been interesting to me. In this jianghu world, death is dealt out almost casually, and more a matter of IF you can kill someone rather than SHOULD you kill someone. This book broadened that problem out to an even bigger question; how MANY can die? And for me the biggest example of the divide these questions cause is my favorite guy, Tao Jun. Sigh, I had trouble with my guy this book. I had viewed him as a man of three layers. The goofy obvious side that covers up for the hard as nails side, which is all in service to his inner loyal core. But this book... my guy is in a dark place that I hope is temporary and not his true inner core. (Fyi, there is a Tao Jun spin off series now on my TBR list)
Ok, on to the brighter side of things. Even in this, the darkest book, there was the funniest footnote of the series so far. No spoilers, but the Chronicle of the Roof Tile was strangely moving and would make a great Pixar short. Li Mings love affair with dumplings even in the middle of deep ptsd depression was a much needed moment for him. (And may have led to an unplanned doordash order ...) Granny Chen is also quickly becoming a go to for humor, and I'm really hoping to see more about her past. Maybe a prequel novella? Granny Chen also brought in something I had been interested in, the healing and herblore. There had been glimpses with Luoying, but her and Granny Chen really broadened the scope of it in this book. It was really interesting to see the interaction between the herbs side of healing and the Qi/Niegog side. Between Li Mings healing and Shu Yans training, you really start to understand just how the qi can work for different people. I like the idea that the "powers" are not just randomly granted to certain people, but something that can be learned if you're willing to devote yourself to the practice.
There is to be at least one other book in the Tales of the Swordsman series and I am definitely on board to see this story to the end. All in all for my first ARC and first wuxia series I was very impressed. Each book was better than the last, with the world deepening as it goes. I appreciate when an author doesn't just default to an info dump to explain the world. Instead, J.F Lee lets the reader gradually get deeper into the world as the characters get drawn in. Explanations are organic and come when relevant to the story. And I can't state enough how unexpected and great the humor is. Using footnotes as a punch line and information source I think is a great insight to the authors own enjoyment of the world and characters. Thank you for the ARC, and I'm along for the ride now!
November 6, 2025
While the other books got better as time went on, and the Trilogy was decent, this book was beautiful in its complexity and its action scenes.
The amount of detail and forethought put into every action, every person, just blew my mind. I loved the amount of history built around the blue mountain. I love the role models that Shu Yan found. Honestly, everything about this book was amazing.
This author hit it out of the park with this one. Not only did he hit his stride, but the world he created all came together perfectly. I didn't feel like any part of this book dragged. Yes it's long, but it's so action packed it doesn't feel long.
With all the drama, it can get hard to deal with. This book added fun and smiles through out. It blended perfectly and didn't feel cheesy. Great job to this author and I can't wait to read everything else he writes!!
The amount of detail and forethought put into every action, every person, just blew my mind. I loved the amount of history built around the blue mountain. I love the role models that Shu Yan found. Honestly, everything about this book was amazing.
This author hit it out of the park with this one. Not only did he hit his stride, but the world he created all came together perfectly. I didn't feel like any part of this book dragged. Yes it's long, but it's so action packed it doesn't feel long.
With all the drama, it can get hard to deal with. This book added fun and smiles through out. It blended perfectly and didn't feel cheesy. Great job to this author and I can't wait to read everything else he writes!!
October 11, 2025
4.75 ⭐️
Thanks to author, JF Lee, for sharing an ARC of this book!
This book is as good as the previous 3 of the series. It’s emotional, impactful, funny balanced. We get to see the development and how multilayered are the characters that we grew to love since the first book. It’s in this book when the politics and power dynamics of the realm start to intersect with the characters’ conflicts and relationships.
At first the book might feel slow, but the more the story progresses the more sense it makes and everything falls into place. This is such a good series and if you enjoy books about sword fighting, martial arts and Chinese culture, this is a must read!
Thanks to author, JF Lee, for sharing an ARC of this book!
This book is as good as the previous 3 of the series. It’s emotional, impactful, funny balanced. We get to see the development and how multilayered are the characters that we grew to love since the first book. It’s in this book when the politics and power dynamics of the realm start to intersect with the characters’ conflicts and relationships.
At first the book might feel slow, but the more the story progresses the more sense it makes and everything falls into place. This is such a good series and if you enjoy books about sword fighting, martial arts and Chinese culture, this is a must read!
January 20, 2024
This fourth book kicks off the second trilogy in the series, and it’s as good as I hoped.
If you’re thinking about buying this book, you’ve probably read the first three. Where the tone of those books was more carefree, this one really digs down to catch the essence of the residents of Blue Mountain. We saw some very deep cracks in the peace of Blue Mountain, but also immense growth with all its characters.
Up to now, the consequences of action have not been as severe; this instalment really ramps it up and makes the first three books seem like a peaceful Sunday dinner at Han Mama’s restaurant. Mr. Lee describes trauma like he’s lived with it reverberating inside his own head. It’s a poignant part of the book and is so well done.
Loved the addition of female role models for Shu Yan, and the history of Blue Mountain. Let’s not forget the action though. I stopped in the middle of one fight scene just to admire the handle that Mr. Lee has on the different aspects of throwing around qi at the same time as sharp swords and quick wit.
In addition to truly great fight scenes, there’s plenty to smile about. The fun is still there; Shu Yan and her relationship with her shifus is delightful. There’s the footnotes, which tell the story of an author who likes to poke fun. It makes one wish you and he could sit around for an evening of drink and swapping big lies.
I’d give this book more than five stars if I could.
If you’re thinking about buying this book, you’ve probably read the first three. Where the tone of those books was more carefree, this one really digs down to catch the essence of the residents of Blue Mountain. We saw some very deep cracks in the peace of Blue Mountain, but also immense growth with all its characters.
Up to now, the consequences of action have not been as severe; this instalment really ramps it up and makes the first three books seem like a peaceful Sunday dinner at Han Mama’s restaurant. Mr. Lee describes trauma like he’s lived with it reverberating inside his own head. It’s a poignant part of the book and is so well done.
Loved the addition of female role models for Shu Yan, and the history of Blue Mountain. Let’s not forget the action though. I stopped in the middle of one fight scene just to admire the handle that Mr. Lee has on the different aspects of throwing around qi at the same time as sharp swords and quick wit.
In addition to truly great fight scenes, there’s plenty to smile about. The fun is still there; Shu Yan and her relationship with her shifus is delightful. There’s the footnotes, which tell the story of an author who likes to poke fun. It makes one wish you and he could sit around for an evening of drink and swapping big lies.
I’d give this book more than five stars if I could.
February 24, 2024
First and foremost! This series goes in order and ends on cliffhangers! Major spoilers ahead if you haven't read the previous three volumes of this series!
*
*
*
*
"Death is the way of the jianghu." - Tao Jun
The Swordsmen of Blue Mountain have returned! Only it isn't a joyous occasion as Li Ming remains in a coma and Tao Jun bears the weight of his failures from the temple. All is not lost since Shu Yan was able to steal the Nine Dragon manual back and away from the Black Tigers! But the odds are beginning to stack against them with the presence of a fierce general. . .
She Who Pacifies the North has arrived and is leaving burned villages in her wake. General Peng is here to set things straight and flush out the Black Tigers but at what cost? Our ragtag team will have to come together and hopefully be enough for what's approaching. Shu Yan continuing her training, but something seems to be missing. Maybe the surprise of a long-lost-friend of Blue Mountain will help!
"We invented horses, so we didn't have to walk anywhere." - Tao Jun
"I don't think anyone invented horses." - Shu Yan
Okay so we all know about the reluctant father trope, i.e. Ciri and Garelt from The Witcher. But what about the reluctant uncle?! Like Scar from the Lion King! That's the type of vibe I felt between Tao Jun and Shu Yan. Our over-the-top-drama-queen-magistrate and the sassy-doesn't-back-down-from-a-challenge-ex-runaway. I laughed so much with the banter between Shu Yan and Tao Jun. Tao Jun realizing pretty quickly that they are both liars and able to con people.
This book has a lot of information and mini arcs happening, but it was very much worth it! Yin and Yang energies were very prominent and displayed beautifully throughout the entire read. Obviously, the male energies vs female energies and the difference between having each as a mentor/teacher. But also, the old belief systems vs the new beliefs. Realizing that this new perspective requires a different approach. Seeing the conflicts of all of the above was very interesting and engaging.
"Revenge never heals." - Granny Chen
Everyone is trying to heal from what happened when they faced The King Saber. Especially Li Ming. . . His arc was hard, and it really pulls at your heart strings. Suicide is mentioned a lot revolving around Li Ming and the losses that keep accumulating for him. We feel his depression and anxiety, our MC has very fresh trauma and the PTSD is crippling at times.
This installment contains a lot of healing arcs and arcs that are the start of a journey to recovery. Again, this book is thick, and a lot of things take place! Fast paced and constantly feeding you more! I still really love watching Shu Yan's growth and the other cast of characters beginning to realize she's growing into a woman no longer that scrawny child. Some of them having really thick skulls so it takes them a little longer.
"You're building character!" - Tao Jun
"I don't need more character! I'm already the hero in the story." - Shu Yan (breaking that fourth wall)
Shu Yan is a favorite character of mine and just I really cannot wait to see her "final" form by the end of the series! I've also fallen in love with several other characters as we get to understand them, and they are fleshed out more. We get a lot of backstories and history lessons! History lessons about Blue Mountain and how it came to be! The author really balances everything and has a lot of fantastic female characters. Like Shu Yan I was blown away by some of the history lessons and figures within said lessons!
JF Lee has brought the world of Wuxia (almost supernatural martial arts skills) to life in the best way! The comedy is phenomenal and will have you laughing out loud. While also feeling tears well in your eyes with certain scenes. I felt a whole spectrum of emotions as I read! Was cheering so hard for two characters in particular at the end of the book. I really love this author's writing style and with each new installment his writing just gets so much better! Love all of his works and really cannot wait for more!
This is a YA genre series. There is blood and gore along with depictions of what happens when a village is burned. Nothing over the top and stomach rolling. Dark pasts mentioned and what some had to see when raids occurred. A character deals with very active thoughts of suicide, depression, anxiety, and PTSD. Others seeing what that character is going through and not knowing how to approach or help. There's some language in the book but it's very mild. No real set POV since its third person POV and we kind of float from one person to another to help really grasp a scene.
The author spoils us with a list of main characters at the beginning of the book and brief descriptions. He also included a recap of the previous volumes at the start! We get a map at the beginning as well, so we know where we are! I really enjoyed and very much appreciated the author's little foot notes to help translate some of the phrases or words. He also included some commentary and thoughts that had me chuckling realizing I thought the exact same!
We do end with a cliffhanger and I'm so ready for more! Do enjoy this read with great fight scenes, training montages, and so much more! Don't forget to give the author some stars!
shutupandbookup.com
*
*
*
*
"Death is the way of the jianghu." - Tao Jun
The Swordsmen of Blue Mountain have returned! Only it isn't a joyous occasion as Li Ming remains in a coma and Tao Jun bears the weight of his failures from the temple. All is not lost since Shu Yan was able to steal the Nine Dragon manual back and away from the Black Tigers! But the odds are beginning to stack against them with the presence of a fierce general. . .
She Who Pacifies the North has arrived and is leaving burned villages in her wake. General Peng is here to set things straight and flush out the Black Tigers but at what cost? Our ragtag team will have to come together and hopefully be enough for what's approaching. Shu Yan continuing her training, but something seems to be missing. Maybe the surprise of a long-lost-friend of Blue Mountain will help!
"We invented horses, so we didn't have to walk anywhere." - Tao Jun
"I don't think anyone invented horses." - Shu Yan
Okay so we all know about the reluctant father trope, i.e. Ciri and Garelt from The Witcher. But what about the reluctant uncle?! Like Scar from the Lion King! That's the type of vibe I felt between Tao Jun and Shu Yan. Our over-the-top-drama-queen-magistrate and the sassy-doesn't-back-down-from-a-challenge-ex-runaway. I laughed so much with the banter between Shu Yan and Tao Jun. Tao Jun realizing pretty quickly that they are both liars and able to con people.
This book has a lot of information and mini arcs happening, but it was very much worth it! Yin and Yang energies were very prominent and displayed beautifully throughout the entire read. Obviously, the male energies vs female energies and the difference between having each as a mentor/teacher. But also, the old belief systems vs the new beliefs. Realizing that this new perspective requires a different approach. Seeing the conflicts of all of the above was very interesting and engaging.
"Revenge never heals." - Granny Chen
Everyone is trying to heal from what happened when they faced The King Saber. Especially Li Ming. . . His arc was hard, and it really pulls at your heart strings. Suicide is mentioned a lot revolving around Li Ming and the losses that keep accumulating for him. We feel his depression and anxiety, our MC has very fresh trauma and the PTSD is crippling at times.
This installment contains a lot of healing arcs and arcs that are the start of a journey to recovery. Again, this book is thick, and a lot of things take place! Fast paced and constantly feeding you more! I still really love watching Shu Yan's growth and the other cast of characters beginning to realize she's growing into a woman no longer that scrawny child. Some of them having really thick skulls so it takes them a little longer.
"You're building character!" - Tao Jun
"I don't need more character! I'm already the hero in the story." - Shu Yan (breaking that fourth wall)
Shu Yan is a favorite character of mine and just I really cannot wait to see her "final" form by the end of the series! I've also fallen in love with several other characters as we get to understand them, and they are fleshed out more. We get a lot of backstories and history lessons! History lessons about Blue Mountain and how it came to be! The author really balances everything and has a lot of fantastic female characters. Like Shu Yan I was blown away by some of the history lessons and figures within said lessons!
JF Lee has brought the world of Wuxia (almost supernatural martial arts skills) to life in the best way! The comedy is phenomenal and will have you laughing out loud. While also feeling tears well in your eyes with certain scenes. I felt a whole spectrum of emotions as I read! Was cheering so hard for two characters in particular at the end of the book. I really love this author's writing style and with each new installment his writing just gets so much better! Love all of his works and really cannot wait for more!
This is a YA genre series. There is blood and gore along with depictions of what happens when a village is burned. Nothing over the top and stomach rolling. Dark pasts mentioned and what some had to see when raids occurred. A character deals with very active thoughts of suicide, depression, anxiety, and PTSD. Others seeing what that character is going through and not knowing how to approach or help. There's some language in the book but it's very mild. No real set POV since its third person POV and we kind of float from one person to another to help really grasp a scene.
The author spoils us with a list of main characters at the beginning of the book and brief descriptions. He also included a recap of the previous volumes at the start! We get a map at the beginning as well, so we know where we are! I really enjoyed and very much appreciated the author's little foot notes to help translate some of the phrases or words. He also included some commentary and thoughts that had me chuckling realizing I thought the exact same!
We do end with a cliffhanger and I'm so ready for more! Do enjoy this read with great fight scenes, training montages, and so much more! Don't forget to give the author some stars!
shutupandbookup.com
June 24, 2024
J.F. Lee continues broadening his epic Wuxia world with his latest novel “Echo of the Blue Mountain.”
This fourth installment of his “Tales of the Swordsman” series really delves into the developing of the maturity of his main characters, both young and old.
Our main hero of the martial world, Li Ming, is suffering terribly from the life-threatening wounds he sustained in his duel with Shazha Kui, the Black Tiger General, who leads a rebellious faction against the current emperor. All he can do is lie comatose in the refuge of Blue Mountain, the home of his martial lineage, attended by the beautiful healer, Cha Luoying.
His martial brother, Tao Jun, wielder of the sword Joy, has taken over the training of Li Ming’s apprentice, the snarky teenage girl Shu Yan. She has thrived under the tutelage of both masters, learning much from their starkly different teaching methods. When their martial sister, Long Lijuan, arrives, she takes Shu Yan’s training even further in a way her martial brothers couldn’t impart to the girl.
Lee brings a lot of elements into this continuation, impressively building on the story threads he has begun weaving in his three prior books. This story is rife with intrigue. Loyalties are both called into question or acted on out of great respect and genuine concern. The humor is there. The personal friction is there. The action is there, riveting and pulse-pounding when it hits, and well paced.
New dangers are presented. We are introduced to Peng Hai Rong, the White Crane General. She is appropriately cold and dastardly, as she must be in a military field of men. Like Li Ming, she is solely intent on putting an end to Shazha Kui and the Black Tigers. She recognizes no allies and her commission for this operation gives her full authority to see it through without the use of any courtesies or considerations towards any other officials, especially a magistrate like Tao Jun. She’s so much fun to hate. (Wow. That’s a weird statement, but…yeah.)
Additionally, a plant that can help cure Li Ming’s wounds also has the potential to be used as a deadly biological agent in battle. (I love duality, and this is a very Yin & Yang aspect that is perfectly fitting within Asian mythos. I also see this playing out between the 2 antagonists: The Black Tiger general & the White Crane general. One’s male, one’s female. Black and white are opposite neutral colors. In martial animal styles, the tiger & crane are often found paired together; one style reflecting strength & ferocity; the other reflecting grace & fluidity.)
There is much more I could reveal, but I would do it a great disservice. I will say that I really enjoyed learning more of the past of the Blue Mountain. And the dynamics between the core characters is becoming more complicated. You want to root for them and yet you question their motives.
I predict things are trending towards a moment when enemies will have to temporarily set their differences aside to ally themselves against a greater threat. And oh, what secrets and treacheries will be revealed then? I also have a gut feeling someone’s going to die.
Sigh. Waiting on the fifth installment: “Wrath of the White Crane.”
This fourth installment of his “Tales of the Swordsman” series really delves into the developing of the maturity of his main characters, both young and old.
Our main hero of the martial world, Li Ming, is suffering terribly from the life-threatening wounds he sustained in his duel with Shazha Kui, the Black Tiger General, who leads a rebellious faction against the current emperor. All he can do is lie comatose in the refuge of Blue Mountain, the home of his martial lineage, attended by the beautiful healer, Cha Luoying.
His martial brother, Tao Jun, wielder of the sword Joy, has taken over the training of Li Ming’s apprentice, the snarky teenage girl Shu Yan. She has thrived under the tutelage of both masters, learning much from their starkly different teaching methods. When their martial sister, Long Lijuan, arrives, she takes Shu Yan’s training even further in a way her martial brothers couldn’t impart to the girl.
Lee brings a lot of elements into this continuation, impressively building on the story threads he has begun weaving in his three prior books. This story is rife with intrigue. Loyalties are both called into question or acted on out of great respect and genuine concern. The humor is there. The personal friction is there. The action is there, riveting and pulse-pounding when it hits, and well paced.
New dangers are presented. We are introduced to Peng Hai Rong, the White Crane General. She is appropriately cold and dastardly, as she must be in a military field of men. Like Li Ming, she is solely intent on putting an end to Shazha Kui and the Black Tigers. She recognizes no allies and her commission for this operation gives her full authority to see it through without the use of any courtesies or considerations towards any other officials, especially a magistrate like Tao Jun. She’s so much fun to hate. (Wow. That’s a weird statement, but…yeah.)
Additionally, a plant that can help cure Li Ming’s wounds also has the potential to be used as a deadly biological agent in battle. (I love duality, and this is a very Yin & Yang aspect that is perfectly fitting within Asian mythos. I also see this playing out between the 2 antagonists: The Black Tiger general & the White Crane general. One’s male, one’s female. Black and white are opposite neutral colors. In martial animal styles, the tiger & crane are often found paired together; one style reflecting strength & ferocity; the other reflecting grace & fluidity.)
There is much more I could reveal, but I would do it a great disservice. I will say that I really enjoyed learning more of the past of the Blue Mountain. And the dynamics between the core characters is becoming more complicated. You want to root for them and yet you question their motives.
I predict things are trending towards a moment when enemies will have to temporarily set their differences aside to ally themselves against a greater threat. And oh, what secrets and treacheries will be revealed then? I also have a gut feeling someone’s going to die.
Sigh. Waiting on the fifth installment: “Wrath of the White Crane.”
August 22, 2025
J.F. Lee’s Echo of the Blue Mountain of Joy is nothing short of breathtaking—a tale that takes everything established in the earlier volumes and expands it into a grand, empire-spanning conflict brimming with heart, honor, and devastating stakes. This is wuxia at its finest: duels crackling with energy, villains who embody both cunning and cruelty, and heroes who carry the impossible weight of justice on their shoulders.
At the center of it all is Li Ming, the last swordsman of Blue Mountain, caught between life and death. His near-absence from the battlefield forces his allies into the spotlight, and in doing so, Lee brilliantly shifts the focus outward, letting the ensemble shine. Shu Yan’s training under Tao Jun becomes a cornerstone of the novel, her journey from reckless runaway to disciplined warrior more compelling than ever. Tao Jun himself adds depth and gravitas, his work with the Nine Dragon manual tying the living fight to the wisdom of the past.
The introduction of the White Crane General, She Who Pacifies the North, is masterful. Cold, merciless, and relentless, she is every bit the equal of Shazha Kui yet entirely her own brand of terrifying. Her pursuit of the Black Tiger and the weapon that could decide the rebellion leaves a trail of innocents in her wake, raising the stakes from personal vengeance to the fate of the entire Southern Province. Watching the forces of the Black Tiger rebellion and the imperial might of the White Crane inevitably converge is like watching two storms collide—magnificent, destructive, and impossible to look away from.
What makes this entry so remarkable is its balance of scope and intimacy. While armies clash and kingdoms burn, the story never loses sight of the individuals at its core: Li Ming clinging to life, Shu Yan growing into her destiny, Tao Jun deciphering ancient secrets, and allies both old and new rallying against overwhelming odds. The return of a long-lost friend adds nostalgia and emotional weight, reminding us that this fight is not only about survival but about legacy.
Every scene is cinematic—sword duels full of grace and grit, battles described with sweeping energy, and quiet moments that ache with tension and humanity. Lee’s prose carries the lyrical cadence of classic wuxia tales while keeping the momentum sharp and modern.
At the center of it all is Li Ming, the last swordsman of Blue Mountain, caught between life and death. His near-absence from the battlefield forces his allies into the spotlight, and in doing so, Lee brilliantly shifts the focus outward, letting the ensemble shine. Shu Yan’s training under Tao Jun becomes a cornerstone of the novel, her journey from reckless runaway to disciplined warrior more compelling than ever. Tao Jun himself adds depth and gravitas, his work with the Nine Dragon manual tying the living fight to the wisdom of the past.
The introduction of the White Crane General, She Who Pacifies the North, is masterful. Cold, merciless, and relentless, she is every bit the equal of Shazha Kui yet entirely her own brand of terrifying. Her pursuit of the Black Tiger and the weapon that could decide the rebellion leaves a trail of innocents in her wake, raising the stakes from personal vengeance to the fate of the entire Southern Province. Watching the forces of the Black Tiger rebellion and the imperial might of the White Crane inevitably converge is like watching two storms collide—magnificent, destructive, and impossible to look away from.
What makes this entry so remarkable is its balance of scope and intimacy. While armies clash and kingdoms burn, the story never loses sight of the individuals at its core: Li Ming clinging to life, Shu Yan growing into her destiny, Tao Jun deciphering ancient secrets, and allies both old and new rallying against overwhelming odds. The return of a long-lost friend adds nostalgia and emotional weight, reminding us that this fight is not only about survival but about legacy.
Every scene is cinematic—sword duels full of grace and grit, battles described with sweeping energy, and quiet moments that ache with tension and humanity. Lee’s prose carries the lyrical cadence of classic wuxia tales while keeping the momentum sharp and modern.
February 9, 2024
As the last Blue Mountain swordsman hovers between life and death, the Black Tigers swell in number. The emperor has sent the White Crane General to quell the uprising in the southern province, prompting her search for the Black Tiger and a powerful weapon that will end his cause. She doesn't care who she harms in her search, so Tao Jun returns to aid the heroes of the Blue Mountain and train Shu Yan in their traditions.
Events directly follow Fall of the King Saber, and is in the same general universe as many of his other wuxia inspired novels. If you have read the first three novels, look them up. They're lots of fun, though we have a summary of the books as an opener if you've missed them. The White Crane General is ruthless and coldly efficient; we see that in the opening chapter so we know what the south is in for. In the meantime, Shu Yan is studying under Magistrate Tao Jun while Li Ming is in a coma. He has his own series of tales, which are hilarious, because he hates paperwork and will go on adventures solving mysteries to avoid it. At the same time, his tendency to talk means he explains the concepts that Li Ming never did. Shu Yan (and the reader) benefits from this, and we get a chance to see the training, the relationships among the Blue Mountain disciples, and learn about some of its secrets.
The characters have all been greatly affected by the events of the last novel's conclusion, and it's a slower wind up in this one as they try to recover. There are still battles, as well as discussions regarding honor, justice and the needs of the people. There are two more volumes in this series, and this book feels like a setup for those volumes. There were many emotional sequences, and Shu Yan's loyalties are tested by them. The finale of this series is definitely going to be a big one, with many players involved.
Events directly follow Fall of the King Saber, and is in the same general universe as many of his other wuxia inspired novels. If you have read the first three novels, look them up. They're lots of fun, though we have a summary of the books as an opener if you've missed them. The White Crane General is ruthless and coldly efficient; we see that in the opening chapter so we know what the south is in for. In the meantime, Shu Yan is studying under Magistrate Tao Jun while Li Ming is in a coma. He has his own series of tales, which are hilarious, because he hates paperwork and will go on adventures solving mysteries to avoid it. At the same time, his tendency to talk means he explains the concepts that Li Ming never did. Shu Yan (and the reader) benefits from this, and we get a chance to see the training, the relationships among the Blue Mountain disciples, and learn about some of its secrets.
The characters have all been greatly affected by the events of the last novel's conclusion, and it's a slower wind up in this one as they try to recover. There are still battles, as well as discussions regarding honor, justice and the needs of the people. There are two more volumes in this series, and this book feels like a setup for those volumes. There were many emotional sequences, and Shu Yan's loyalties are tested by them. The finale of this series is definitely going to be a big one, with many players involved.
February 8, 2024
This book continues the adventures of our favorite heroes Li Ming, Su Yan, and Tao Jun in a fantastic Wuxia world of J.F Lee’s creation; and may I just say that this is the best book of the series thus far.
Not only does this book have all the elements that make for an amazing Wuxia novel, but it also touched upon the darker parts of the human psyche when dealing with loss, war, and the repercussions for one’s own actions. These elements helped to further develop the characters we have come to know and love, and help to greatly round out the story.
Moreover, as always J.F. Lee does an incredible job with his descriptions of the world, and more importantly food. No spoilers, but there is a scene involving cod and pork dumplings that was so great I took a dumpling cooking class.
For those of you who stumbled upon this review and this book who are interested in Wuxia, I strongly suggest starting at the beginning with “Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy” the first book of this series, and to pay attention to the foot notes; the author uses them to provide context to those of us in the western world to many of the normal terms and social normalities that we may not be familiar with. Also, some of them are just hilarious.
5/5 would read again. Now back to my dumplings.
Not only does this book have all the elements that make for an amazing Wuxia novel, but it also touched upon the darker parts of the human psyche when dealing with loss, war, and the repercussions for one’s own actions. These elements helped to further develop the characters we have come to know and love, and help to greatly round out the story.
Moreover, as always J.F. Lee does an incredible job with his descriptions of the world, and more importantly food. No spoilers, but there is a scene involving cod and pork dumplings that was so great I took a dumpling cooking class.
For those of you who stumbled upon this review and this book who are interested in Wuxia, I strongly suggest starting at the beginning with “Sword of Sorrow, Blade of Joy” the first book of this series, and to pay attention to the foot notes; the author uses them to provide context to those of us in the western world to many of the normal terms and social normalities that we may not be familiar with. Also, some of them are just hilarious.
5/5 would read again. Now back to my dumplings.
February 7, 2024
This is IMHO Mr. Lee's best book yet! I really enjoyed it and the grand scope of the story is really coming together in an epic way. I made a point of rereading the prior three in preparation for this one. Some of my guesses during prior books are coming true and some of them have been way off target. =D The footnotes are such an enjoyable extra bit of 'seasoning.' I also really appreciated the chengyu/idioms included in this one.
There is a melancholy air to the book that if you've read the first three (and if you haven't, why not? Get to it!) you'll know has to be coming. The tension of conflicting loyalties is a theme across many bodies of warrior literature. It comes up in samurai and chivalric stories as well... and obviously wuxia literature is filled with it as well.
There are parallels to Li Ming's past as Shu Yan walks a similar but different path from her master. However, this is the next step for the heroine's growth where she can truly be the hero and not just an aspiring one.
There is a melancholy air to the book that if you've read the first three (and if you haven't, why not? Get to it!) you'll know has to be coming. The tension of conflicting loyalties is a theme across many bodies of warrior literature. It comes up in samurai and chivalric stories as well... and obviously wuxia literature is filled with it as well.
There are parallels to Li Ming's past as Shu Yan walks a similar but different path from her master. However, this is the next step for the heroine's growth where she can truly be the hero and not just an aspiring one.
September 20, 2025
This is a review of the fourth book in the tales of the swordsman series.
Again it is outstanding. Li Ming the first brother of the Blue Mountain sect is recovering. His spirit is crushed. He recovers from his battle but his spirit and his willingness to go on is challenged. There is hope however and we learn about the first Master of the Blue Mountain sect.
This is when all hope seems to be lost that at Li Ming’s new disciple starts to become their own great warrior.
This is the Hope that the readers have been looking for. JF Lee has written another outstanding novel and it is a real treat for general audiences, Kung Fu film enthusiasts,’ martial artists, and Chinese martial arts practitioners.
In my opinion essentially everybody!
As a Chinese martial arts practitioner for 33 years and a Kung Fu film fan it has my highest recommendation. Also look for the fifth book in the series The Wrath of the White Crane to be released on November 1st 2025! This series is one of the two best series of novels I have read in the last few decades and it is not to be missed!!
Again it is outstanding. Li Ming the first brother of the Blue Mountain sect is recovering. His spirit is crushed. He recovers from his battle but his spirit and his willingness to go on is challenged. There is hope however and we learn about the first Master of the Blue Mountain sect.
This is when all hope seems to be lost that at Li Ming’s new disciple starts to become their own great warrior.
This is the Hope that the readers have been looking for. JF Lee has written another outstanding novel and it is a real treat for general audiences, Kung Fu film enthusiasts,’ martial artists, and Chinese martial arts practitioners.
In my opinion essentially everybody!
As a Chinese martial arts practitioner for 33 years and a Kung Fu film fan it has my highest recommendation. Also look for the fifth book in the series The Wrath of the White Crane to be released on November 1st 2025! This series is one of the two best series of novels I have read in the last few decades and it is not to be missed!!
February 7, 2024
This 4th volume in the Tales of the Swordsman series takes Li Ming, the last swordsman of Blue Mountain, to places he's never been before and never wanted to experience. Li Ming's virtual absence pushes Tao Jun to step up and take a leadership role as teacher, mentor, and protector. A long lost sister help them stand against the external forces determined to tear the country apart. Everyone changes in this book except Granny Chen--though we do gain a much deeper appreciation for her role at Blue Mountain.
Lee has an amazing ability to make ancient China come alive and people it with fascinating characters whose goals and tribulations seem as real and immediate as our own. His books are mesmerizing and this one is no exception. I love his use of footnotes to both educate and amuse, in equal measures.
Lee has an amazing ability to make ancient China come alive and people it with fascinating characters whose goals and tribulations seem as real and immediate as our own. His books are mesmerizing and this one is no exception. I love his use of footnotes to both educate and amuse, in equal measures.
February 21, 2024
Wow! This starter to the second Trilogy surpassed any previous books by JF!
I love how this book focuses a lot on Blue Mountain, it’s background and Shu Yan’s training and his, Li Ming’s and Tao Jun’s character development. The ever growing conflict in the Southern Province and tension on Blue Mountain is palpable and makes me excited for things to come.
There are a few less action scenes, but boy are they breathtaking; every move is well thought out and beautifully executed. At the same time the play off between drama, witty humour and harrowing trauma is skilfully balanced and drives the story along at a good pace.
I can’t wait to find out what fate has in store for our heroes next!
I received this book as ARC copy free from the author and am leaving this review of my own volition.
I love how this book focuses a lot on Blue Mountain, it’s background and Shu Yan’s training and his, Li Ming’s and Tao Jun’s character development. The ever growing conflict in the Southern Province and tension on Blue Mountain is palpable and makes me excited for things to come.
There are a few less action scenes, but boy are they breathtaking; every move is well thought out and beautifully executed. At the same time the play off between drama, witty humour and harrowing trauma is skilfully balanced and drives the story along at a good pace.
I can’t wait to find out what fate has in store for our heroes next!
I received this book as ARC copy free from the author and am leaving this review of my own volition.
May 25, 2024
In Echo of the Blue Mountain, the swordsman teeters between life and death and a new foe joins the fight to keep the Emperor's control of the provinces. The arrival of an old friend shakes up the dynamic of the group, adding a pleasant perspective. The fight scenes are nicely constructed and the medical magic is intriguing. The characters continue to have good depth. Loyalty and morality are tested in this great continuation of this action-packed series.
August 21, 2025
as a start to another trilogy in the same universe, I'm happy to say it did not disappoint!
these books were definitely a step away from my usual stuff, but I'm so happy I picked this!
thank you to J.F. Lee, for this free copy. my thoughts are my own.
these books were definitely a step away from my usual stuff, but I'm so happy I picked this!
thank you to J.F. Lee, for this free copy. my thoughts are my own.
February 7, 2024
The heroes of Blue Mountain get the secrets of the Nine Dragon manual. As Tao Jun deciphers it, Shu Yan trains under his tutelage. Try to off set the white Crane the emperors general.
June 13, 2025
I love the whole world built out of Blue Mountain. Another great book
August 21, 2025
worth the read! I enjoyed it.
September 27, 2025
Great character development and plot. Loved the continuation of the story and all the action. J.F. Lee is so good at describing the scenery and events of the story, makes you feel like you are there.
October 15, 2025
honestly I think this one is my favorite so far
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews