This is the longest review I’ve written so please bear with me.
This book was a genre I never would’ve chosen to read on my own but art mixed with the Sicilian mafia, the Vatican and the prodigal son had me interested from the beginning! I had to know how the author was going to weave all this light and dark together and form a story of redemption.
The storyline flowed, keeping me engaged and wondering what was going to happen next. It took me into the lives of Italians and those in the Catholic religion. I am not a Catholic so it was interesting to me. however, there were a few areas that weren’t Biblical. I’m not one to argue religious beliefs but for me the Bible is the baseline upon which those beliefs are tested, and some statements within the story didn’t ring true.
Also, as a Christian fiction book a few elements seemed unnecessary. I can understand Orazio’s lifestyle choices written in given the parallels to the prodigal son and some of Orazio’s promiscuity and other actions could’ve been what the prodigal son did. but one thing I didn’t get were the many references to nudity, sexually provocative art or sculptures depicting rape. I didn’t see how some of these were necessary or glorified God, especially “Giotto’s girls” and the scene where he seems to be lusting and fantasizing about them. I get that the mafia life and historical art were depicted throughout but this seemed a bit much at times.
Also, although it was beautifully done, I felt there could’ve been a greater impact made with the gospel when Orazio went home and was received with open arms. Orazio briefly mentions that he realizes God loves him and he’s ready to confess his sins. However, I feel the impact could’ve been greater if there was some inner monologue written in perhaps as he was walking down the road to his father’s house and realizes how wrong his sinful life was and turns to Gods in repentance. This would’ve given him some time to really grasp (and show the reader) God’s love, grace, and forgiveness through Jesus, and how he now realizes God was waiting for him just as His family would be waiting for him to return home. There was a hint of this at the very end of the “behind the book” section but not within the actual story. My feedback for this would be if there’s an opportunity to tell the gospel, take it and drive it home (no pun intended).
Overall I enjoyed this book; it was well written with the perfect amount of storytelling, history, intrigue, and even a few suspenseful moments. There was sorrow and joy, brokenness and healing through forgiveness. I could feel Orazio’s sorrow at the end yet also felt his family’s love and grace bestowed upon him. It was beautifully done and that part brought me to tears.