What do you think?
Rate this book
The Luminaries #2
The Hunting Moon
9 hours, 52 minutes
The highly anticipated sequel to The Luminaries by New York Times bestselling author Susan Dennard.
Winnie Wednesday has gotten everything she thought she wanted. She passed the deadly hunter trials, her family has been welcomed back into the Luminaries, and overnight, she has become a local celebrity.
The Girl Who Jumped. The Girl Who Got Bitten.
Unfortunately, it all feels wrong. For one, nobody will believe her about the new nightmare called the Whisperer that's killing hunters each night. Everyone blames the werewolf, even though Winnie is certain the wolf is innocent.
On top of that, following her dad's convoluted clues about the Dianas, their magic, and what happened in Hemlock Falls four years ago is leaving her with more questions than answers.
Then to complicate it all, there is still only one person who can help her: Jay Friday, the boy with plenty of problems all his own.
As bodies and secrets pile up around town, Winnie finds herself questioning what it means to be a true Wednesday and a true Luminary—and also where her fierce-hearted loyalties might ultimately have to lie.
The highly anticipated sequel to The Luminaries by New York Times bestselling author Susan Dennard.
Winnie Wednesday has gotten everything she thought she wanted. She passed the deadly hunter trials, her family has been welcomed back into the Luminaries, and overnight, she has become a local celebrity.
The Girl Who Jumped. The Girl Who Got Bitten.
Unfortunately, it all feels wrong. For one, nobody will believe her about the new nightmare called the Whisperer that's killing hunters each night. Everyone blames the werewolf, even though Winnie is certain the wolf is innocent.
On top of that, following her dad's convoluted clues about the Dianas, their magic, and what happened in Hemlock Falls four years ago is leaving her with more questions than answers.
Then to complicate it all, there is still only one person who can help her: Jay Friday, the boy with plenty of problems all his own.
As bodies and secrets pile up around town, Winnie finds herself questioning what it means to be a true Wednesday and a true Luminary—and also where her fierce-hearted loyalties might ultimately have to lie.
10 pages, Audiobook
First published November 7, 2023
316 people are currently reading
16399 people want to read
About the author
Susan Dennard
24 books9,400 followersSusan Dennard is the award-winning, New York Times bestselling author of the Witchlands series (now in development for TV from the Jim Henson Company), and the Something Strange and Deadly series, in addition to various other fiction published online.
Before becoming an author, she got to travel the world with her M.Sc. in marine biology. She also runs the popular newsletter for writers, the Misfits and Daydreamers. When not writing or teaching writing, she can be found rolling the dice as a Dungeon Master or mashing buttons on one of her way too many consoles.
You can learn more about Susan on her website, blog, newsletter, Twitter, or Pinterest.
Before becoming an author, she got to travel the world with her M.Sc. in marine biology. She also runs the popular newsletter for writers, the Misfits and Daydreamers. When not writing or teaching writing, she can be found rolling the dice as a Dungeon Master or mashing buttons on one of her way too many consoles.
You can learn more about Susan on her website, blog, newsletter, Twitter, or Pinterest.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,324 reviews
November 30, 2023
The Hunting Moon was one of my most anticipated releases of 2023, I’ve been craving it since the moment I read the last page of The Luminaries.
But unfortunately, I think my expectations were a little too high and I ended up a bit disappointed.
What bothered me the most, is how slow it was, nothing really happened in the first half of the book, except for Winnie to whine about how no one cares about the death of Grayson Friday or how they make light of what she went through in the forest, and I get her, I too would be pissed if someone went around saying I’m the Girl Who Jumped or The Girl Who Got Bitten, but she whines so much about it that it became a bit annoying.
Fortunately by the second half of the book things started to pick up and I was reminded of why I loved The Luminaries so much, there’s something so compelling about this world that Susan created, not only the vibes of the early 2010 YA books but how she truly knows how to evoque this mystical magical atmosphere.
The end was really surprising and I can’t honestly wait to read the next one, hopefully there’ll be more world building, which was something I felt lacked in this one and something that I really want to know more about.
Thanks Netgalley and Daphne Press for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review
But unfortunately, I think my expectations were a little too high and I ended up a bit disappointed.
What bothered me the most, is how slow it was, nothing really happened in the first half of the book, except for Winnie to whine about how no one cares about the death of Grayson Friday or how they make light of what she went through in the forest, and I get her, I too would be pissed if someone went around saying I’m the Girl Who Jumped or The Girl Who Got Bitten, but she whines so much about it that it became a bit annoying.
Fortunately by the second half of the book things started to pick up and I was reminded of why I loved The Luminaries so much, there’s something so compelling about this world that Susan created, not only the vibes of the early 2010 YA books but how she truly knows how to evoque this mystical magical atmosphere.
The end was really surprising and I can’t honestly wait to read the next one, hopefully there’ll be more world building, which was something I felt lacked in this one and something that I really want to know more about.
Thanks Netgalley and Daphne Press for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review
December 14, 2024
"The Hunting Moon" is even better than "The Luminaries." Susan Dennard has outdone herself again and I can't wait for this book to be released on November 7 so everyone can read it, and for the sequel coming next year. I will have a more in-depth review to come, once I have recovered from how blown away I am. (1/10/23)
Review #1:
I’ve stared at my cursor for so long trying to think about how to start…
Susan Dennard is the best YA writer. From the moment I had the word doc of The Hunting Moon on my Kindle, I only stopped reading when I had to; every second away from this book I was thinking about it and wanted to return to it.
The Hunting Moon is the perfect sequel to The Luminaries. Sooz had everything I wanted in this sequel, everything I didn’t know I wanted, and things I didn’t expect AT ALL and was blown away by. Jaw dropped. Heart racing. Sooz took my brain, heart, body, and soul into Winnie Wednesday’s world and didn’t let me go until there was nothing left. The Hunting Moon is the Empire Strikes Back of this trilogy. It is dark and haunting and funny. Its romance is perfect. The lore deepens. The characters are changed and change even more and so many secrets are revealed (some I guessed, most I didn’t).
I’m not allowed to say much about the book (yet), but I will say that with The Hunting Moon, Susan Dennard has cemented Winnie Wednesday as one of my favorite fictional characters of all time. I think I have said before that she is up there with Ahsoka Tano when it comes to characters that are important to me. I see so much of myself in Winnie. I will never ever get tired of reading these books, I will never ever get tired of following Winnie as she figures stuff out.
In many ways, Winnie is most at home when she is in the forest that surrounds Hemlock Falls. In many ways, I feel at home when I am there with her. I wish I had a better way to express how much these books mean to me, how much I love them, how desperately sad I am going to be when this trilogy comes to an end.
You either trust the forest or you don’t.
You either trust Sooz to give you a wild ride, break your heart and mend it, warp your brain while you read and then slot all the puzzle pieces into place and blow your mind, or you don’t.
I trust the forest and I trust Sooz. You all should too. (1/11/23)
Review #1:
I’ve stared at my cursor for so long trying to think about how to start…
Susan Dennard is the best YA writer. From the moment I had the word doc of The Hunting Moon on my Kindle, I only stopped reading when I had to; every second away from this book I was thinking about it and wanted to return to it.
The Hunting Moon is the perfect sequel to The Luminaries. Sooz had everything I wanted in this sequel, everything I didn’t know I wanted, and things I didn’t expect AT ALL and was blown away by. Jaw dropped. Heart racing. Sooz took my brain, heart, body, and soul into Winnie Wednesday’s world and didn’t let me go until there was nothing left. The Hunting Moon is the Empire Strikes Back of this trilogy. It is dark and haunting and funny. Its romance is perfect. The lore deepens. The characters are changed and change even more and so many secrets are revealed (some I guessed, most I didn’t).
I’m not allowed to say much about the book (yet), but I will say that with The Hunting Moon, Susan Dennard has cemented Winnie Wednesday as one of my favorite fictional characters of all time. I think I have said before that she is up there with Ahsoka Tano when it comes to characters that are important to me. I see so much of myself in Winnie. I will never ever get tired of reading these books, I will never ever get tired of following Winnie as she figures stuff out.
In many ways, Winnie is most at home when she is in the forest that surrounds Hemlock Falls. In many ways, I feel at home when I am there with her. I wish I had a better way to express how much these books mean to me, how much I love them, how desperately sad I am going to be when this trilogy comes to an end.
You either trust the forest or you don’t.
You either trust Sooz to give you a wild ride, break your heart and mend it, warp your brain while you read and then slot all the puzzle pieces into place and blow your mind, or you don’t.
I trust the forest and I trust Sooz. You all should too. (1/11/23)
Want to read
October 2, 2024I'm not feeling it rn, going to try it again later 😔
January 12, 2025
The Hunting Moon is the second book in the Luminaries trilogy and picks up straight where book one left us.
Winnie Wednesday has achieved so much since the start of the series: she's passed the Hunter Trials, recovered her family's standing in the community, and proven their loyalty and allegiance and isn't an outcast anymore. But all the attention she's receiving from becoming known as 'the girl who jumped' after the events at the end of book one, she's pretty overwhelmed by it all. Still, nobody believes her about the new dangerous nightmare 'the whisperer', and they're still all hunting for a werewolf that Winnie knows is innocent of the horrific deaths that have occurring. As Winnie pieces together clues left for her from her father (cast out as a traitorous Diana four years ago) and grows closer to one of her ex best friends, Jay, Winnie uncovers more secrets, more questions and more dangers to find out the truth. I did guess at one of the revelations in this book and have a feeling about a teaser towards the end with the crow, and I'm jumping straight into the third and final book right now. This series has had me hooked and is very easy to fly through. The characters are all likeable, and I love the layers peeling back in the plot. I also love the artwork included in the book, which helps visualise the many different nightmares within the story.
Winnie Wednesday has achieved so much since the start of the series: she's passed the Hunter Trials, recovered her family's standing in the community, and proven their loyalty and allegiance and isn't an outcast anymore. But all the attention she's receiving from becoming known as 'the girl who jumped' after the events at the end of book one, she's pretty overwhelmed by it all. Still, nobody believes her about the new dangerous nightmare 'the whisperer', and they're still all hunting for a werewolf that Winnie knows is innocent of the horrific deaths that have occurring. As Winnie pieces together clues left for her from her father (cast out as a traitorous Diana four years ago) and grows closer to one of her ex best friends, Jay, Winnie uncovers more secrets, more questions and more dangers to find out the truth. I did guess at one of the revelations in this book and have a feeling about a teaser towards the end with the crow, and I'm jumping straight into the third and final book right now. This series has had me hooked and is very easy to fly through. The characters are all likeable, and I love the layers peeling back in the plot. I also love the artwork included in the book, which helps visualise the many different nightmares within the story.
October 1, 2023
I want to preface this review by saying that while I enjoyed the first Luminaries book, I am much more a fan of Dennard's Witchlands series. This series feels a lot younger, aimed at younger teens as opposed to the YA/Adult crossover vibe of the Witchlands. Which is fine, I'm just less into it.
So that being said, I don't feel like Hunting Moon is quite as good as Luminaries. It's perfectly fine as a sequel, moves some plot points forward, develops a bit of a romantic relationship, and tells us a bit more about the world. The thing is, this romance feels very young and as I am quite far from the teen years myself, I'm not particularly invested. The plot reveals weren't super surprising and were about what I expected given the hints in book 1. The world-building elements in the series are also very heavy on different magical creatures and monsters, which also isn't really my thing. All of that to say, this is a perfectly good version of the book that it is. It's just not something I'm particularly excited about. I will probably read the next book when it comes out, but I just don't think I'm the target audience for this series. I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
So that being said, I don't feel like Hunting Moon is quite as good as Luminaries. It's perfectly fine as a sequel, moves some plot points forward, develops a bit of a romantic relationship, and tells us a bit more about the world. The thing is, this romance feels very young and as I am quite far from the teen years myself, I'm not particularly invested. The plot reveals weren't super surprising and were about what I expected given the hints in book 1. The world-building elements in the series are also very heavy on different magical creatures and monsters, which also isn't really my thing. All of that to say, this is a perfectly good version of the book that it is. It's just not something I'm particularly excited about. I will probably read the next book when it comes out, but I just don't think I'm the target audience for this series. I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
September 25, 2023
Thank you Daphne Press and NetGalley for providing me an e-arc in exchange for an honest review. My review is my own and not influenced by others.
I really liked the first book The Luminaries, the atmosphere, the mysteries, the vibes and of course the nightmares. It was something that I really enjoyed. So, I was very exited to read this second book.
And while I really enjoyed the first book, I just couldn’t feel involved with this second book. It’s not that this book is bad, because it’s not and it has the suspensions and the pacing is good but I just didn’t really care anymore. Which is a disappointment because I really was looking forward to read this book. I think I just couldn’t care much about the characters anymore and it made me feel a disconnection with them and the story.
I really liked the first book The Luminaries, the atmosphere, the mysteries, the vibes and of course the nightmares. It was something that I really enjoyed. So, I was very exited to read this second book.
And while I really enjoyed the first book, I just couldn’t feel involved with this second book. It’s not that this book is bad, because it’s not and it has the suspensions and the pacing is good but I just didn’t really care anymore. Which is a disappointment because I really was looking forward to read this book. I think I just couldn’t care much about the characters anymore and it made me feel a disconnection with them and the story.
October 5, 2023
Okay, but YA fantasy done right hits differently.
Winnie Wednesday has gotten everything she thought she wanted. She passed the deadly hunter trials, her family is welcomed back into the Luminaries, and she has become a local celebrity. But it all feels wrong.
Still, nobody will believe her about the new nightmare called the Whisperer as everyone is busy blaming the werewolf, even though Winnie is certain the wolf is innocent.
Not to mention, she has her dad’s clues to follow and figure out.
Thank you to Bonlinda audio for sending the audiobook arc in exchange for an honest review!
Of course, it was very obvious in book one that Jae was the werewolf, so seeing his withdrawal and anxiety in the background of Winnie’s whirlwind of a life is both fascinating and tearing-out-your-hair frustrating.
I went in with lower expectations as I remember liking book one for a perfect quick autumn fantasy but then all the more nitpicking reviews came out.
However, I still found myself really enjoying this!
Winnie has such a realistic teenage protagonist voice. The first person perspective just works so well, and is written with such finesse that Winnie is such a vivid character despite it being developed in only two relatively short books.
Yes, it did annoy me about the sudden focus on dressing up and make up and parties amidst the panic and increasing deaths, but Winnie’s perception on it matches mine completely.
I am sad to report, there is still a lot of teeth clicking. And pushing glasses up your nose. But to be fair, as someone who does wear glasses, that is a full time job.
Bookstagram
Winnie Wednesday has gotten everything she thought she wanted. She passed the deadly hunter trials, her family is welcomed back into the Luminaries, and she has become a local celebrity. But it all feels wrong.
Still, nobody will believe her about the new nightmare called the Whisperer as everyone is busy blaming the werewolf, even though Winnie is certain the wolf is innocent.
Not to mention, she has her dad’s clues to follow and figure out.
Thank you to Bonlinda audio for sending the audiobook arc in exchange for an honest review!
Of course, it was very obvious in book one that Jae was the werewolf, so seeing his withdrawal and anxiety in the background of Winnie’s whirlwind of a life is both fascinating and tearing-out-your-hair frustrating.
I went in with lower expectations as I remember liking book one for a perfect quick autumn fantasy but then all the more nitpicking reviews came out.
However, I still found myself really enjoying this!
Winnie has such a realistic teenage protagonist voice. The first person perspective just works so well, and is written with such finesse that Winnie is such a vivid character despite it being developed in only two relatively short books.
Yes, it did annoy me about the sudden focus on dressing up and make up and parties amidst the panic and increasing deaths, but Winnie’s perception on it matches mine completely.
I am sad to report, there is still a lot of teeth clicking. And pushing glasses up your nose. But to be fair, as someone who does wear glasses, that is a full time job.
Bookstagram
June 6, 2024
4.5 stars
This is such a solid fantasy series. The world building and plot are unique, yet still easy to follow. The pacing is just about perfect and keeps you reading. The characters are a little cliche at times, but very likeable. And the mysteries reveal themselves at the perfect pace. I can't say this is a 5 star read, as it's missing that special something, but it's so solid and underrated.
This is such a solid fantasy series. The world building and plot are unique, yet still easy to follow. The pacing is just about perfect and keeps you reading. The characters are a little cliche at times, but very likeable. And the mysteries reveal themselves at the perfect pace. I can't say this is a 5 star read, as it's missing that special something, but it's so solid and underrated.
January 1, 2024
Despite me guessing quite a few twist plot points (which tbf I think adds to the writing as it’s like solving a mystery with little clues!!) i LOVED this sequel so much! I can’t wait for a third book. I had SO much fun with this, learning about new forest creatures, the Diana magic system, it was so cool. Can’t wait to visit hemlock falls again and see what Winnie gets up to next. PLUS that end chapter ahhhhhh no way!
Read
November 7, 2023DNF @ 22%
I have lost all interest in this series, and I have no patience for the generic YA drama that is happening. I don't care enough about the mythology or the mysteries to keep going. Not rating.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ARC.
I have lost all interest in this series, and I have no patience for the generic YA drama that is happening. I don't care enough about the mythology or the mysteries to keep going. Not rating.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ARC.
August 21, 2023
I have been anxiously awaiting this sequel for awhile now. I was lucky enough to get my hands on an ARC and I devoured it in one sitting. Question, does anyone know how long this series is? Trilogy? I can't seem to find any information about it.
Anyway, diving back into this world was easy (it helped that I reread The Luminaries right before this) and I immediately was back with Winnie as she tried to uncover the truth of the world around her. Much like the first book, Winnie struggles with belonging. While all she wanted was to be back in the Luminary fold, she's finding that her mind just won't settle and she starts questioning everything around her. And also if being a Luminary is what she really wants.
In this second installment, we get to dive deeper into the histories of both the Luminaries and the Diana's. We learn more about the different paths the two groups have taken and just how dark the Diana's seem to be. I don't want to spoil anything, but we get a lot more Diana content here and I was loving it. Bring on all the mysteries!
But there was one thing that I wasn't surprised about - there was a big reveal that fell short to me because it felt very obvious. Like to the point where I was even wondering if it was supposed to be a surprise or not. It didn't hinder my enjoyment because I actually liked what came because of it, but it just wasn't as shocking as I had hoped it would be.
The one issue with reading arc's is that you almost always have to wait extra long until the next book comes out. I don't even think it's been announced yet. I just really hope there is another one because I have more questions than I did coming out of the first book.
Anyway, diving back into this world was easy (it helped that I reread The Luminaries right before this) and I immediately was back with Winnie as she tried to uncover the truth of the world around her. Much like the first book, Winnie struggles with belonging. While all she wanted was to be back in the Luminary fold, she's finding that her mind just won't settle and she starts questioning everything around her. And also if being a Luminary is what she really wants.
In this second installment, we get to dive deeper into the histories of both the Luminaries and the Diana's. We learn more about the different paths the two groups have taken and just how dark the Diana's seem to be. I don't want to spoil anything, but we get a lot more Diana content here and I was loving it. Bring on all the mysteries!
But there was one thing that I wasn't surprised about - there was a big reveal that fell short to me because it felt very obvious. Like to the point where I was even wondering if it was supposed to be a surprise or not. It didn't hinder my enjoyment because I actually liked what came because of it, but it just wasn't as shocking as I had hoped it would be.
The one issue with reading arc's is that you almost always have to wait extra long until the next book comes out. I don't even think it's been announced yet. I just really hope there is another one because I have more questions than I did coming out of the first book.
November 14, 2023
This review was originally posted on Books of My Heart
Review copy was received from . This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
The Hunting Moon is the second book of The Luminaries series, following one of the Luminaries on her journey to restore her family name and not get killed in a Forrest full of magical creatures her family has been fighting for generations.
Winnie Wednesday is an expert at not doing what is expected of her and finding trouble at every corner. She and Jay Friday were the best of friends as kids but had a falling out when Winnie's family was excommunicated for something her father was accused of. But what if he was innocent? What if everything the Hunters of the Luminaries thinks is true, just isn't. Winnie was outcast long enough to question everything and wonder if what everyone assumes is true about the Luminaries (the good guys), the Diana's (the bad guys) and the Woods of Hemlock Falls is right.
In this second book of the series, we get deeper dive into what it means to be a Luminary and some of the history. We also get to see some Diana's in action so we understand how they are a bit different than everyone Winnie Wednesday grew up with. There is a lot of focus on trying to find the wolf that everyone believes is responsible for recent deaths of hunters in the woods. Winnie, knows the wolf isn't responsible; she is sure there is something else going on and she seems to be only one that ever sees it. There is also some lovely longing and teenage romance blooming but it plays a slight back seat to everything else happening. Also if you were paying attention in the first book you will already know who the wolf is and probably at least one of the Dianas. But, the slow tease out of information is fun and I enjoyed spending time in Winnie's head as she tries to juggle the responsibility of saving her family's name and trying to be a normal teenager.
This is a fun YA series. The Hunting Moon did suffer from a few slow pacing issues at the beginning of the book. But once the action starts happening it is a good time and didn't really seem to slow much after that. Winnie is an actual teenager; she never seems like she is really 20 which I've found some other YA books to suffer from. There is enough mystery that I really can't wait to find out what is going on in Hemlock Falls and with the addition of a few characters in the book I think we will get some great answers later in the series.
Narration:
Caitlin Davies is an accomplished narrator of over 250 titles and well known to me as she has narrated some of my favorite YA UF novels. She is fantastic as capturing the voice of a younger PoV and her narration performances for those characters are wonderful. I have completely enjoyed other series by her and was not let down in this performance. I was able to listen at my usual 1.5x speed.
Listen to a clip: HERE
Review copy was received from . This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
The Hunting Moon is the second book of The Luminaries series, following one of the Luminaries on her journey to restore her family name and not get killed in a Forrest full of magical creatures her family has been fighting for generations.
Winnie Wednesday is an expert at not doing what is expected of her and finding trouble at every corner. She and Jay Friday were the best of friends as kids but had a falling out when Winnie's family was excommunicated for something her father was accused of. But what if he was innocent? What if everything the Hunters of the Luminaries thinks is true, just isn't. Winnie was outcast long enough to question everything and wonder if what everyone assumes is true about the Luminaries (the good guys), the Diana's (the bad guys) and the Woods of Hemlock Falls is right.
You either trust the Forrest of you don't.
In this second book of the series, we get deeper dive into what it means to be a Luminary and some of the history. We also get to see some Diana's in action so we understand how they are a bit different than everyone Winnie Wednesday grew up with. There is a lot of focus on trying to find the wolf that everyone believes is responsible for recent deaths of hunters in the woods. Winnie, knows the wolf isn't responsible; she is sure there is something else going on and she seems to be only one that ever sees it. There is also some lovely longing and teenage romance blooming but it plays a slight back seat to everything else happening. Also if you were paying attention in the first book you will already know who the wolf is and probably at least one of the Dianas. But, the slow tease out of information is fun and I enjoyed spending time in Winnie's head as she tries to juggle the responsibility of saving her family's name and trying to be a normal teenager.
This is a fun YA series. The Hunting Moon did suffer from a few slow pacing issues at the beginning of the book. But once the action starts happening it is a good time and didn't really seem to slow much after that. Winnie is an actual teenager; she never seems like she is really 20 which I've found some other YA books to suffer from. There is enough mystery that I really can't wait to find out what is going on in Hemlock Falls and with the addition of a few characters in the book I think we will get some great answers later in the series.
Narration:
Caitlin Davies is an accomplished narrator of over 250 titles and well known to me as she has narrated some of my favorite YA UF novels. She is fantastic as capturing the voice of a younger PoV and her narration performances for those characters are wonderful. I have completely enjoyed other series by her and was not let down in this performance. I was able to listen at my usual 1.5x speed.
Listen to a clip: HERE
October 13, 2023
This was an enjoyable book. The reason for the 3.5 star rating is more so because the YA vibe of it. I'm in my mid 30s so I just couldn't connect to it as well. Probably a lot better for those younger in nature or spirit than I am. It did have some intense moments and twists that kept me on my toes. The storyline itself was good and I enjoyed the author's writing style. Just several bits of it didn't connect well with me due to the youthful vibe. I loved the first book in this series, like LOVED. This one just didn't do it for me as well as the first one did.
I received this ARC from NetGalley to read and review. All of the statements above are my true opinions after fully reading the book.
I received this ARC from NetGalley to read and review. All of the statements above are my true opinions after fully reading the book.
November 30, 2023
This is the second installment in Susan Dennard's series The Luminaries and we pick up right where book one leaves off. There will be some spoilers for the first book! After surviving the Trials and achieving her dream of becoming a Hunter, restoring her family back into the ranks of the Luminaries and surviving a werewolf bite, Winnie finds herself a bit of a celebrity around Hemlock Falls. While everything she has wanted and worked for has come to be and she is happy in that sense, she does not like the celebrity and something still feels wrong. Winnie is sure that the werewolf is innocent and that a bigger threat is out there, but the community doesn't want to listen to her. They believe the werewolf is responsible for recent hunter's deaths, but Winnie knows there's something bigger at play. We dive more into the history of the Luminaries and the Diana's. I was really happy to get more Diana content, I am super intrigued by their whole deal. As Winnie learns more she makes ties and connections to an overall bigger picture. If you paid attention in the first book, you likely know who the werewolf is already so that reveal wasn't very exciting. But it was still a fun lead up. And of course, the usual high school drama of parties and crushes and friendships are sprinkled in.
It's a fun YA series and is definitely targeted to a YA audience. Winnie consistently feels like an actual teenager and there is no spice. I adore the world that this takes place in and the whole idea of the nightmares and the Luminaries protecting us normal people without us even knowing, but that was all explained and played up in book one. So the same enjoyment of learning the world was not present in book two. There is enough mystery and intrigue to keep me going and want to know what is happening. Originally I rated this 3 stars, but I have to remember that it's YA. Just because some YA feels much more adult than the YA category, doesn't mean I should punish the ones that stick true to the "young" part of "young adult". It is the actual targeted audience, not my old ass.
It's a fun YA series and is definitely targeted to a YA audience. Winnie consistently feels like an actual teenager and there is no spice. I adore the world that this takes place in and the whole idea of the nightmares and the Luminaries protecting us normal people without us even knowing, but that was all explained and played up in book one. So the same enjoyment of learning the world was not present in book two. There is enough mystery and intrigue to keep me going and want to know what is happening. Originally I rated this 3 stars, but I have to remember that it's YA. Just because some YA feels much more adult than the YA category, doesn't mean I should punish the ones that stick true to the "young" part of "young adult". It is the actual targeted audience, not my old ass.
December 7, 2025
3.5 stars!
Once again, I love love LOVE the realistic characters Dennard portrays throughout this series. Smart, emotional, and realised 16-year-olds who respond in the same dumb ways 16-year-olds would.
The story is a little obvious (it's YA, I can't really poke holes in that aspect) but still holds so many interesting twists and turns that it keeps things exciting, and Winnie's determination and ambition just keeps growing into a more satisfying aspect of her character the longer this goes on.
Once again, I love love LOVE the realistic characters Dennard portrays throughout this series. Smart, emotional, and realised 16-year-olds who respond in the same dumb ways 16-year-olds would.
The story is a little obvious (it's YA, I can't really poke holes in that aspect) but still holds so many interesting twists and turns that it keeps things exciting, and Winnie's determination and ambition just keeps growing into a more satisfying aspect of her character the longer this goes on.
September 28, 2024
I really liked to fall back in this original story. I love this world and all the secrets it hides. The characters are so mysterious and the plot exciting! I can't wait for the last book to be published! I chose to give this book 4 stars because I was a little bit annoyed by the Venn theory that seems a bit... sloppy to me.
November 13, 2023
4.5 Stars
The second instalment in Susan Dennard’s the Luminaries series was just as lush and beautifully atmospheric as the first, with more monsters (and mysteries) to delve into.
Continuing on where book one left off, we once again follow Winnie Wednesday who, having passed her trials (and survived a werewolf bite) has become a bit of celebrity in Hemlock Falls. And yet, despite finally getting what she’s always wanted, Winnie isn’t satisfied. The Whisperer, is still out there and Winnie can’t make anyone believe in its existence.
With former best friend Jay Friday the only person she can turn to, and mysterious clues left by Winnie’s father, she might just get answers to the events that took place four years ago— and maybe even find proof of his innocence.
But with the fate of Hemlock Falls resting in the balance and secrets growing (along with the bodies left in The Whisperer’s wake) Winnie finds herself questioning everything she thought she knew about being a Luminary. And answering some of the most difficult questions of all: where do her loyalties lie, and what is she willing to risk for them?
I really enjoyed this! The stakes are still high and the action still deliciously intense. Plus, we get more stunning illustrations of the Nightmares Winnie encounters— which was one of my favourite aspects of book one. But, I admit loved Winnie (and the emotional development we see her undergo) the most.
Having secured her family’s place among the Luminaries (and Clan Wednesday) once more, Winnie’s rose tinted glasses have been well and truly removed. Giving us a front row seat to some of the complex, morally grey politics that make up the organisation. We don’t delve into this too heavily though but, given how things transpire in that phenomenally explosive ending— I’m looking forward to (hopefully) exploring it in more depth in the next book.
I was a little disappointed that Winnie’s newfound friends (Bretta, Emma and Fatima) aren’t nearly as present as I would’ve liked. As Winnie spends a lot of time emotionally detached from the people around her, both in an effort to solve the clues left by her father, and work through the trauma she endured during the hunting trials. I did however love the slow burn intensity still simmering between Winnie and brooding former bestie (and love interest) Jay.
Their chemistry is incredible and seeing Winnie finally open up to someone after years of closing herself off emotionally was really gratifying. As was watching their paranormal investigations begin to unravel some of the unanswered questions I had at the end of The Luminaries.
Though I admit, I did manage to guess the identity of the werewolf, so wasn’t all that surprised when my suspicions were confirmed. I did however love how nuanced and emotionally charged Winnie’s reaction to the news was.
Overall, an incredibly enjoyable YA fantasy (and solid sequel) that has me eagerly anticipating the next book already.
Also, thanks to Blackcrow PR and Daphne Press for this stunning finished copy.
The second instalment in Susan Dennard’s the Luminaries series was just as lush and beautifully atmospheric as the first, with more monsters (and mysteries) to delve into.
Continuing on where book one left off, we once again follow Winnie Wednesday who, having passed her trials (and survived a werewolf bite) has become a bit of celebrity in Hemlock Falls. And yet, despite finally getting what she’s always wanted, Winnie isn’t satisfied. The Whisperer, is still out there and Winnie can’t make anyone believe in its existence.
With former best friend Jay Friday the only person she can turn to, and mysterious clues left by Winnie’s father, she might just get answers to the events that took place four years ago— and maybe even find proof of his innocence.
But with the fate of Hemlock Falls resting in the balance and secrets growing (along with the bodies left in The Whisperer’s wake) Winnie finds herself questioning everything she thought she knew about being a Luminary. And answering some of the most difficult questions of all: where do her loyalties lie, and what is she willing to risk for them?
I really enjoyed this! The stakes are still high and the action still deliciously intense. Plus, we get more stunning illustrations of the Nightmares Winnie encounters— which was one of my favourite aspects of book one. But, I admit loved Winnie (and the emotional development we see her undergo) the most.
Having secured her family’s place among the Luminaries (and Clan Wednesday) once more, Winnie’s rose tinted glasses have been well and truly removed. Giving us a front row seat to some of the complex, morally grey politics that make up the organisation. We don’t delve into this too heavily though but, given how things transpire in that phenomenally explosive ending— I’m looking forward to (hopefully) exploring it in more depth in the next book.
I was a little disappointed that Winnie’s newfound friends (Bretta, Emma and Fatima) aren’t nearly as present as I would’ve liked. As Winnie spends a lot of time emotionally detached from the people around her, both in an effort to solve the clues left by her father, and work through the trauma she endured during the hunting trials. I did however love the slow burn intensity still simmering between Winnie and brooding former bestie (and love interest) Jay.
Their chemistry is incredible and seeing Winnie finally open up to someone after years of closing herself off emotionally was really gratifying. As was watching their paranormal investigations begin to unravel some of the unanswered questions I had at the end of The Luminaries.
Though I admit, I did manage to guess the identity of the werewolf, so wasn’t all that surprised when my suspicions were confirmed. I did however love how nuanced and emotionally charged Winnie’s reaction to the news was.
Overall, an incredibly enjoyable YA fantasy (and solid sequel) that has me eagerly anticipating the next book already.
Also, thanks to Blackcrow PR and Daphne Press for this stunning finished copy.
March 23, 2024
I've been excited for this sequel since the revelations at the end of book one, but I did feel a bit let down in some aspects. I was really happy that we learned about the Dianas, as well as saw more Nightmares. The monsters in the woods are what I love about the series, they're so interesting and creepy.
Winnie whines a lot in this, pines over Jay some more, and generally panics a lot and overthinks everything. There's one part where she gets put in her place and I mentally cheered. Winnie is only sixteen and there's a lot she doesn't know about the world, even if she thinks she's the one with all the answers.
One of the reveals was super obvious and I was hoping it would end up going another direction, but oh well. I did like the bit at the end and have hopes for a good final book to wrap it all up.
Winnie whines a lot in this, pines over Jay some more, and generally panics a lot and overthinks everything. There's one part where she gets put in her place and I mentally cheered. Winnie is only sixteen and there's a lot she doesn't know about the world, even if she thinks she's the one with all the answers.
One of the reveals was super obvious and I was hoping it would end up going another direction, but oh well. I did like the bit at the end and have hopes for a good final book to wrap it all up.
September 18, 2024
3.5-4
Una vez más, una historia trepidante que me ha dejado prácticamente con más preguntas de las que tenía al comenzarlo... Aunque living con los personajes, la verdad.
Una vez más, una historia trepidante que me ha dejado prácticamente con más preguntas de las que tenía al comenzarlo... Aunque living con los personajes, la verdad.
December 24, 2023
★ 4.75 / 5
SPOILERS AHEAD
I read The Hunting Moon in roughly a day, and I don't know how I'll be capable of waiting for the third book. These first two books in the trilogy overall have been a breath of fresh air for me. They remind me of nostalgic YA from my youth, and that's such an indescribable, wonderful feeling to behold. So I truly treasure these books.
The relationships were my favorite part of The Hunting Moon, notably Winnie's friendships and romantic relationship. Darian and Winnie's mother didn't really shine bright in this sequel, but that's because they are so wrapped up in the possibility of their banishment from the Luminaries being rescinded that they don't notice Winnie acting weird and hunting for clues. I do believe Winnie's immediate family is going to have its moment in the third book. Her dad, while never physically on page, will probably make his first appearance there, and it's gonna cause chaos for this particular Wednesday family. I'll talk more about Winnie's dad later though because the reveals around him started slowly streaming into the plot.
Back to the friends/romance though—I really appreciate Winnie opening up in this book. She was extremely isolated during The Luminaries because of her trials and desire to become a hunter. She hid that from everyone, and even though Jay was teaching her hunter skills on the side, Winnie still didn't give him much room back into her life. The Hunting Moon is not significantly different, but it's enough to show her growth, particularly after what happened during the last trial with Emma/Winnie falling into the waterfall due to the Whisperer/werewolf event. Fatima, Emma, and Bretta are closer to Winnie than before. They are actually the first people period to notice Winnie's resistance to Luminaries cheering her on for going up against a werewolf. When the hunters howl at Winnie, her friends see her discomfort (PTSD honestly) and support her always after that first initial display of trauma. They're her backbone as she starts questioning the Luminaries ideologies too because they humanize the hunters that ignore the death and destruction of every night hunting. When the girls help Winnie write her paper in the Sunday library even, you can see how its these moments where Winnie is able to catch her breath and relax.
Which somewhat and kinda also applies to Jay Friday.
The difference in his and Winnie's relationship throughout this sequel is APPARENT. Winnie officially comes clean about the clues her dad left behind to Jay. He's the only one who knows the full situation, and thankfully, he respects her decisions not to go forward to the Tuesdays or any hunters. Even though Jay is the new Lead Hunter of the Fridays, he chooses her over the Luminaries (LOVE HIM!). His willingness to hear Winnie and trust in her instincts was wonderful. It made the cracks in their relationship start to heal over—not fully but we're getting there at least—and this secret ultimately gives readers some of the best scenes in the books so far.
Notably this scene—Winnie and Jay investigate the smaller x marked on Winnie's dad's library map (Winnie forgot to mark this x on her drawn version and the big X represents where Grayson Friday died allegedly by a werewolf at the end of book one), and it leads them to this random granite hole in the earth. There appears to be similar trauma to the scene like what happened to Grayson Friday, so the two believe the Whisperer may have murdered someone else in that spot. But the granite is not in Grayson's death area. While the two run into a completely different nightmare while in this scene, the Whisperer does eventually appear in the granite hole. The two left before witnessing this because Winnie is poisoned by the previously mentioned nightmare (a stag nightmare but can't recall the name). Jay has to drag/carry her miles and miles back to the Friday estate where she ingests melusine liquid/venom, which completely heals her wound and makes Winnie incredibly high. I did cringe at first during this scene because Winnie was not acting like herself, but I also cackled and screamed, kicking my feet in the air with a deep gleeful giggle. It was TOO GOOD. I think that moment is still my favorite of the entire series so far. It allowed Jay and Winnie to break down their barriers because all of their history was semi-removed since Winnie was so giggly and high.
Plus, Jay's werewolf status is officially confirmed at the end of this book. Susan, I was starting to think you'd pull another fast one on us and not confirm it, but thank the heavens, she did. Winnie has to throw caution to the wind and essentially high tail her ass through the forest to save Jay in his werewolf form after he is tranquilized essentially by six volts to the chest by Winnie's aunt. This entire scene will make everyone so anxious. Winnie runs into a changeling, which was such a traumatic scene to watch. She's getting sucked dry as the changeling ingests her blood to turn into her, and once she escapes, she sees her naked body behind her because the changeling got soooo close to killing her. Then, Dianas appear (again, I'll talk about this later in the paragraph about Winnie's dad) in the forest searching for the werewolf. Now three separate people are looking for him: Luminaries that shot him, Dianas for some scary reason, and Winnie to save him. I was expecting Winnie to be clumsy or get attacked by another being and be revealed to the Dianas, but LUCKILY they don't bother her until the near end when she's arguing with Aunt Rachel over what to do with Jay in his werewolf form.
By the way, still don't know how I feel about Rachel Wednesday. She fibs and stretches the truth when it fits her goals, and even though she let Jay go this time, I don't know quite were she falls. Is she wholly loyal to the Luminaries like she previously did, or does Rachel now feel protective over Winnie and her family? Your guess is as good as mine. She did take the two pieces of Diana magic to the torso to protect Winnie, but I'm still unsure.
Finally, the main event.
Winnie's dad is single handedly the most interesting character of these books. He has so much mystery to him, and I want answers stat! The fact that he only left clues for Winnie is interesting. Are he and Winnie just that similar that she'd be the only one prepared to hunt for the clues, or is Winnie somehow different to the rest of her family? Does she have magic of some sort? I've had this theory for a while that Winnie's dad comes from both Diana and Luminarie ancestors, so he's a mixed bag. Maybe the magic doesn't transfer to descendants always, so only Winnie has it? We find out in this book that the Whisperer is actually a piece of Diana magic meant to destroy anything in its way. Currently, its target appears to be Winnie because it only appears when she is in the forest but that isn't confirmed. Just my alleged theory. That leads me to think the Dianas want Winnie or someone close to Winnie (partially why I think they went after Jay besides the fact that he's a werewolf). But also the Whispere may not even be a full Diana mechanism—more on that later. The biggest surprise, besides the Dianas, was the final chapter in this book where a crow watches over the ongoing confrontation/conversation between Winnie, Jay, and Erica before traveling to watch Winnie's mother at the diner. Obviously, we assume it is Winnie's dad, but whether he was turned into a crow permanently or uses the crow to see his family from afar... we've yet to learn.
Now I want to talk about Erica's role in this book. She is in second place behind Winnie's dad now as the most mysterious character. Winnie and Erica have two good interactions in this sequel where the two try to help the other, but it is revealed that Erica has ties to Dianas... Kinda. She is most likely the unnamed opening chapter of this sequel, and she declares that she wants to crush both the Dianas and the Luminaries, particularly after the death of her sister Jenna. She blames both groups for Jenna's death and seems to seek vengeance. Her sister also appears to have been a Diana before her death. Her sister passed away roughly three weeks or so after Winnie's dad disappeared/ Winnie's family banishment. Erica's sister could definitely have been a part of the Dianas who framed Winnie's dad. Maybe he found out about the Whisperer spell (Erica mentions using her sister's spell that was left behind as a way to hurt the Luminaries) and needed to be stopped, so Erica's sister did so. I'm curious if Erica knows part of Winnie's dad's past because of his ties to Jenna possibly. There's a lot of IFs going on right now, but that truly shows how lacking we are in Erica's situation/goals. We do know that Erica stole the dampener/source, Winnie's Venn Diagram notes, and her dad's birthday clues from Winnie's bedroom, and I think that's enough to show Erica has something to do with the Whisperer. Although, I'm currently leaning towards the Diana and Whisperer being separate plots. I think Erica is controlling the Whisperer with her sister's instructions, but she's also doing something to hurt the Dianas, which is why they're in the Luminaries forest. Not a perfect theory but it feels right for now.
I'm completely at a loss for the Dianas plot. I don't know who the woman with the grey hair in the crow mask is. My best guess would maybe be Erica's mom, but also, I cannot recall anyone with grey hair. It's a small detail to remember and also try to find back in the book without rereading. Maybe I'll look out for it during a reread before the third book's release.
Lastly, I have one mini complaint about something. I'm getting a bit annoyed with the adults reading and reviewing YA books on social media. I've seen a number of people comment negative reviews because this series does not have the same tone/feel of The Witchlands. To that I say—it's younger YA! The lead is newly 16, turned 16 right at the start of The Luminaries. Don't read this trilogy then if you don't like the age range. It's so annoying for people to expect all of YA to be the same, particularly upper YA.
Now that I got that off my chest, this sequel was somehow even better than the first book. It's definitely more research and theory-based rather than hunting-based like the previous book. I could see some people getting bored because of the bias into thinking vs. hunting, but I still think the plot pieces coming together are far more interesting than just Winnie hunting some more. And even then, we still get some kick-ass scenes of Winnie battling some nightmares. But we also see some moments where Winnie realizes some nightmares may not be the monsters Luminaries make them out to be—notably the will-o-wisps, werewolf, and melusine. She's starting to question the Luminaries ideologies, so it makes sense that this book centers on her internal indecision.
Thank you to Tor Teen for the ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
SPOILERS AHEAD
I read The Hunting Moon in roughly a day, and I don't know how I'll be capable of waiting for the third book. These first two books in the trilogy overall have been a breath of fresh air for me. They remind me of nostalgic YA from my youth, and that's such an indescribable, wonderful feeling to behold. So I truly treasure these books.
The relationships were my favorite part of The Hunting Moon, notably Winnie's friendships and romantic relationship. Darian and Winnie's mother didn't really shine bright in this sequel, but that's because they are so wrapped up in the possibility of their banishment from the Luminaries being rescinded that they don't notice Winnie acting weird and hunting for clues. I do believe Winnie's immediate family is going to have its moment in the third book. Her dad, while never physically on page, will probably make his first appearance there, and it's gonna cause chaos for this particular Wednesday family. I'll talk more about Winnie's dad later though because the reveals around him started slowly streaming into the plot.
Back to the friends/romance though—I really appreciate Winnie opening up in this book. She was extremely isolated during The Luminaries because of her trials and desire to become a hunter. She hid that from everyone, and even though Jay was teaching her hunter skills on the side, Winnie still didn't give him much room back into her life. The Hunting Moon is not significantly different, but it's enough to show her growth, particularly after what happened during the last trial with Emma/Winnie falling into the waterfall due to the Whisperer/werewolf event. Fatima, Emma, and Bretta are closer to Winnie than before. They are actually the first people period to notice Winnie's resistance to Luminaries cheering her on for going up against a werewolf. When the hunters howl at Winnie, her friends see her discomfort (PTSD honestly) and support her always after that first initial display of trauma. They're her backbone as she starts questioning the Luminaries ideologies too because they humanize the hunters that ignore the death and destruction of every night hunting. When the girls help Winnie write her paper in the Sunday library even, you can see how its these moments where Winnie is able to catch her breath and relax.
Which somewhat and kinda also applies to Jay Friday.
The difference in his and Winnie's relationship throughout this sequel is APPARENT. Winnie officially comes clean about the clues her dad left behind to Jay. He's the only one who knows the full situation, and thankfully, he respects her decisions not to go forward to the Tuesdays or any hunters. Even though Jay is the new Lead Hunter of the Fridays, he chooses her over the Luminaries (LOVE HIM!). His willingness to hear Winnie and trust in her instincts was wonderful. It made the cracks in their relationship start to heal over—not fully but we're getting there at least—and this secret ultimately gives readers some of the best scenes in the books so far.
Notably this scene—Winnie and Jay investigate the smaller x marked on Winnie's dad's library map (Winnie forgot to mark this x on her drawn version and the big X represents where Grayson Friday died allegedly by a werewolf at the end of book one), and it leads them to this random granite hole in the earth. There appears to be similar trauma to the scene like what happened to Grayson Friday, so the two believe the Whisperer may have murdered someone else in that spot. But the granite is not in Grayson's death area. While the two run into a completely different nightmare while in this scene, the Whisperer does eventually appear in the granite hole. The two left before witnessing this because Winnie is poisoned by the previously mentioned nightmare (a stag nightmare but can't recall the name). Jay has to drag/carry her miles and miles back to the Friday estate where she ingests melusine liquid/venom, which completely heals her wound and makes Winnie incredibly high. I did cringe at first during this scene because Winnie was not acting like herself, but I also cackled and screamed, kicking my feet in the air with a deep gleeful giggle. It was TOO GOOD. I think that moment is still my favorite of the entire series so far. It allowed Jay and Winnie to break down their barriers because all of their history was semi-removed since Winnie was so giggly and high.
Plus, Jay's werewolf status is officially confirmed at the end of this book. Susan, I was starting to think you'd pull another fast one on us and not confirm it, but thank the heavens, she did. Winnie has to throw caution to the wind and essentially high tail her ass through the forest to save Jay in his werewolf form after he is tranquilized essentially by six volts to the chest by Winnie's aunt. This entire scene will make everyone so anxious. Winnie runs into a changeling, which was such a traumatic scene to watch. She's getting sucked dry as the changeling ingests her blood to turn into her, and once she escapes, she sees her naked body behind her because the changeling got soooo close to killing her. Then, Dianas appear (again, I'll talk about this later in the paragraph about Winnie's dad) in the forest searching for the werewolf. Now three separate people are looking for him: Luminaries that shot him, Dianas for some scary reason, and Winnie to save him. I was expecting Winnie to be clumsy or get attacked by another being and be revealed to the Dianas, but LUCKILY they don't bother her until the near end when she's arguing with Aunt Rachel over what to do with Jay in his werewolf form.
By the way, still don't know how I feel about Rachel Wednesday. She fibs and stretches the truth when it fits her goals, and even though she let Jay go this time, I don't know quite were she falls. Is she wholly loyal to the Luminaries like she previously did, or does Rachel now feel protective over Winnie and her family? Your guess is as good as mine. She did take the two pieces of Diana magic to the torso to protect Winnie, but I'm still unsure.
Finally, the main event.
Winnie's dad is single handedly the most interesting character of these books. He has so much mystery to him, and I want answers stat! The fact that he only left clues for Winnie is interesting. Are he and Winnie just that similar that she'd be the only one prepared to hunt for the clues, or is Winnie somehow different to the rest of her family? Does she have magic of some sort? I've had this theory for a while that Winnie's dad comes from both Diana and Luminarie ancestors, so he's a mixed bag. Maybe the magic doesn't transfer to descendants always, so only Winnie has it? We find out in this book that the Whisperer is actually a piece of Diana magic meant to destroy anything in its way. Currently, its target appears to be Winnie because it only appears when she is in the forest but that isn't confirmed. Just my alleged theory. That leads me to think the Dianas want Winnie or someone close to Winnie (partially why I think they went after Jay besides the fact that he's a werewolf). But also the Whispere may not even be a full Diana mechanism—more on that later. The biggest surprise, besides the Dianas, was the final chapter in this book where a crow watches over the ongoing confrontation/conversation between Winnie, Jay, and Erica before traveling to watch Winnie's mother at the diner. Obviously, we assume it is Winnie's dad, but whether he was turned into a crow permanently or uses the crow to see his family from afar... we've yet to learn.
Now I want to talk about Erica's role in this book. She is in second place behind Winnie's dad now as the most mysterious character. Winnie and Erica have two good interactions in this sequel where the two try to help the other, but it is revealed that Erica has ties to Dianas... Kinda. She is most likely the unnamed opening chapter of this sequel, and she declares that she wants to crush both the Dianas and the Luminaries, particularly after the death of her sister Jenna. She blames both groups for Jenna's death and seems to seek vengeance. Her sister also appears to have been a Diana before her death. Her sister passed away roughly three weeks or so after Winnie's dad disappeared/ Winnie's family banishment. Erica's sister could definitely have been a part of the Dianas who framed Winnie's dad. Maybe he found out about the Whisperer spell (Erica mentions using her sister's spell that was left behind as a way to hurt the Luminaries) and needed to be stopped, so Erica's sister did so. I'm curious if Erica knows part of Winnie's dad's past because of his ties to Jenna possibly. There's a lot of IFs going on right now, but that truly shows how lacking we are in Erica's situation/goals. We do know that Erica stole the dampener/source, Winnie's Venn Diagram notes, and her dad's birthday clues from Winnie's bedroom, and I think that's enough to show Erica has something to do with the Whisperer. Although, I'm currently leaning towards the Diana and Whisperer being separate plots. I think Erica is controlling the Whisperer with her sister's instructions, but she's also doing something to hurt the Dianas, which is why they're in the Luminaries forest. Not a perfect theory but it feels right for now.
I'm completely at a loss for the Dianas plot. I don't know who the woman with the grey hair in the crow mask is. My best guess would maybe be Erica's mom, but also, I cannot recall anyone with grey hair. It's a small detail to remember and also try to find back in the book without rereading. Maybe I'll look out for it during a reread before the third book's release.
Lastly, I have one mini complaint about something. I'm getting a bit annoyed with the adults reading and reviewing YA books on social media. I've seen a number of people comment negative reviews because this series does not have the same tone/feel of The Witchlands. To that I say—it's younger YA! The lead is newly 16, turned 16 right at the start of The Luminaries. Don't read this trilogy then if you don't like the age range. It's so annoying for people to expect all of YA to be the same, particularly upper YA.
Now that I got that off my chest, this sequel was somehow even better than the first book. It's definitely more research and theory-based rather than hunting-based like the previous book. I could see some people getting bored because of the bias into thinking vs. hunting, but I still think the plot pieces coming together are far more interesting than just Winnie hunting some more. And even then, we still get some kick-ass scenes of Winnie battling some nightmares. But we also see some moments where Winnie realizes some nightmares may not be the monsters Luminaries make them out to be—notably the will-o-wisps, werewolf, and melusine. She's starting to question the Luminaries ideologies, so it makes sense that this book centers on her internal indecision.
Thank you to Tor Teen for the ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
![Profile Image for julia ☆ [owls reads].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1636739475i%2F5520447._UX200_CR0%2C0%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
November 2, 2023
The Hunting Moon didn't give me the same 2000s YA PNR vibes as the first book, but this was still such a fun read! Susan Dennard did a wonderful job at expanding the world-building here and adding even more details to the world of the Luminaries. The writing was engaging and easy to follow and I still loved Winnie's perspective quite a bit.
The overall plot progression here was also really good! The middle of the book dd drag a little bit for me, but I liked how much progress Winnie made in regard to the situation with her Dad and, further, with Jay. She also changed quite a bit as a main character and it was fun going through that with her and reading about her grow into herself a little more.
The romance bits were also very well balanced with all the other supernatural and investigation elements! I did miss a few of the characters introduced in the previous book here, as they seemed to get a bit sidelined, but I do hope they have more page time as the series goes on. This brought some interesting questions as well that I want answers to!
The overall plot progression here was also really good! The middle of the book dd drag a little bit for me, but I liked how much progress Winnie made in regard to the situation with her Dad and, further, with Jay. She also changed quite a bit as a main character and it was fun going through that with her and reading about her grow into herself a little more.
The romance bits were also very well balanced with all the other supernatural and investigation elements! I did miss a few of the characters introduced in the previous book here, as they seemed to get a bit sidelined, but I do hope they have more page time as the series goes on. This brought some interesting questions as well that I want answers to!
August 18, 2024
3.5 stars
This one was a bit slow going for me, but finally kicked in around 60%.
A bit more world building, a few answers, and some (very obvious) reveals. The ending left the story at a firm stopping place, but really with a pin in it.
Overall, a classic second book of a trilogy. I'm eager to finally get all of the answers.
**Huge thanks to the publisher for providing the arc free of charge**
This one was a bit slow going for me, but finally kicked in around 60%.
A bit more world building, a few answers, and some (very obvious) reveals. The ending left the story at a firm stopping place, but really with a pin in it.
Overall, a classic second book of a trilogy. I'm eager to finally get all of the answers.
**Huge thanks to the publisher for providing the arc free of charge**
January 14, 2025
Ein zweiter Band, der mir gut gefallen hat. Spannende Szenen, freundschaftliche Momente und eine kleine Romance sorgen für eine schöne Ausgewogenheit und ein kurzweiliges Leseerlebnis. 3,5 *
October 21, 2023
✨ 𝐁𝐨𝐨𝐤 𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰 ✨
𝐓𝐢𝐭𝐥𝐞: The Hunting Moon
𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫(𝐬): Susan Dennard
𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠: 3.5/5
“𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘴𝘵𝘰𝘳𝘺 𝘣𝘦𝘨𝘪𝘯𝘴 𝘸𝘪𝘵𝘩 𝘢 𝘧𝘶𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘢𝘭 𝘪𝘯 𝘢 𝘵𝘰𝘸𝘯 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘭𝘰𝘤𝘢𝘭𝘴 𝘥𝘰𝘯’𝘵 𝘣𝘶𝘳𝘺 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘪𝘳 𝘥𝘦𝘢𝘥. 𝘈𝘧𝘵𝘦𝘳 𝘢𝘭𝘭, 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘯𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘣𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘴𝘶𝘤𝘩 𝘢 𝘯𝘢𝘴𝘵𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘣𝘪𝘵 𝘰𝘧 𝘸𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘣𝘰𝘥𝘪𝘦𝘴 𝘣𝘢𝘤𝘬 𝘶𝘱 𝘢𝘨𝘢𝘪𝘯.”
🖤 𝗬𝗔 𝗳𝗮𝗻𝘁𝗮𝘀𝘆
🌫️ 𝗠𝗼𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗲𝗿 𝗳𝗶𝗹𝗹𝗲𝗱 𝗳𝗼𝗿𝗲𝘀𝘁
🖤 𝗙𝗮𝘀𝘁 𝗽𝗮𝗰𝗲𝗱
🌫️ 𝗦𝗲𝗰𝗼𝗻𝗱 𝗶𝗻 𝗮 𝘀𝗲𝗿𝗶𝗲𝘀
🖤 𝗦𝗹𝗼𝘄 𝗯𝘂𝗿𝗻 𝗿𝗼𝗺𝗮𝗻𝗰𝗲
The best thing about this book is the first two sentences (quoted above). I gave the first installment in The Luminaries a 3/5 and I would say that The Hunting Moon is marginally better.
I felt that the first book was all exploration and no resolutions and this book is some exploration and some resolutions. Although, unfortunately, not enough conclusions for me to feel satisfied and content. The premise for this series remains as fabulous as ever, however, I truly feel like this entire series could be one book.
Just like it’s predecessor, The Hunting Moon is fast paced and addictive. I feel that the writing has elevated somewhat in this novel, perhaps that’s because the first novel is a lot of foundational building whereas this book feels like the threads are beginning to form and the author has more creative freedom with the plot and dialogue as she moves forward through the story.
Whilst it felt like I really got to know the characters in the first novel, I felt as though I was being held at arms reach with this novel, even with Winnie, I felt almost detached. Perhaps that’s because the main character consistently removes herself from social interactions, and instead the focus on the slow burn romance between Winnie and Jay are prioritised here. But they’re both keeping so many secrets from each other that their romance felt more like a strain than something they could both relax into.
I love the Nightmare Compendium and how Winnie interacts with it. It’s probably my favourite part about this entire series. If anyone has played Witcher: The Wild Hunt and flicked through the bestiary or watched Grimm and seen it’s book of lore, it’s exactly like that, and I’m very much all for it.
Would I read the last book in the series? Yes, I would. Is it going to become one of my favourite series? No, probably not. But it still has the potential to sweep me off my feet.
—Kayleigh🤍
♡ 𝐈𝐧����𝐭𝐚𝐠𝐫𝐚𝐦
♡ 𝐓𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐭𝐞𝐫
𝐓𝐢𝐭𝐥𝐞: The Hunting Moon
𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫(𝐬): Susan Dennard
𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠: 3.5/5
“𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘴𝘵𝘰𝘳𝘺 𝘣𝘦𝘨𝘪𝘯𝘴 𝘸𝘪𝘵𝘩 𝘢 𝘧𝘶𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘢𝘭 𝘪𝘯 𝘢 𝘵𝘰𝘸𝘯 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘭𝘰𝘤𝘢𝘭𝘴 𝘥𝘰𝘯’𝘵 𝘣𝘶𝘳𝘺 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘪𝘳 𝘥𝘦𝘢𝘥. 𝘈𝘧𝘵𝘦𝘳 𝘢𝘭𝘭, 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘯𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘣𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘴𝘶𝘤𝘩 𝘢 𝘯𝘢𝘴𝘵𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘣𝘪𝘵 𝘰𝘧 𝘸𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘣𝘰𝘥𝘪𝘦𝘴 𝘣𝘢𝘤𝘬 𝘶𝘱 𝘢𝘨𝘢𝘪𝘯.”
🖤 𝗬𝗔 𝗳𝗮𝗻𝘁𝗮𝘀𝘆
🌫️ 𝗠𝗼𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗲𝗿 𝗳𝗶𝗹𝗹𝗲𝗱 𝗳𝗼𝗿𝗲𝘀𝘁
🖤 𝗙𝗮𝘀𝘁 𝗽𝗮𝗰𝗲𝗱
🌫️ 𝗦𝗲𝗰𝗼𝗻𝗱 𝗶𝗻 𝗮 𝘀𝗲𝗿𝗶𝗲𝘀
🖤 𝗦𝗹𝗼𝘄 𝗯𝘂𝗿𝗻 𝗿𝗼𝗺𝗮𝗻𝗰𝗲
The best thing about this book is the first two sentences (quoted above). I gave the first installment in The Luminaries a 3/5 and I would say that The Hunting Moon is marginally better.
I felt that the first book was all exploration and no resolutions and this book is some exploration and some resolutions. Although, unfortunately, not enough conclusions for me to feel satisfied and content. The premise for this series remains as fabulous as ever, however, I truly feel like this entire series could be one book.
Just like it’s predecessor, The Hunting Moon is fast paced and addictive. I feel that the writing has elevated somewhat in this novel, perhaps that’s because the first novel is a lot of foundational building whereas this book feels like the threads are beginning to form and the author has more creative freedom with the plot and dialogue as she moves forward through the story.
Whilst it felt like I really got to know the characters in the first novel, I felt as though I was being held at arms reach with this novel, even with Winnie, I felt almost detached. Perhaps that’s because the main character consistently removes herself from social interactions, and instead the focus on the slow burn romance between Winnie and Jay are prioritised here. But they’re both keeping so many secrets from each other that their romance felt more like a strain than something they could both relax into.
I love the Nightmare Compendium and how Winnie interacts with it. It’s probably my favourite part about this entire series. If anyone has played Witcher: The Wild Hunt and flicked through the bestiary or watched Grimm and seen it’s book of lore, it’s exactly like that, and I’m very much all for it.
Would I read the last book in the series? Yes, I would. Is it going to become one of my favourite series? No, probably not. But it still has the potential to sweep me off my feet.
—Kayleigh🤍
♡ 𝐈𝐧����𝐭𝐚𝐠𝐫𝐚𝐦
♡ 𝐓𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐭𝐞𝐫
July 30, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read this.
I loved the first book in this series and no surprise, I loved this too. It’s just the right amount of spooky for me.
I didn’t know how many books this series would be when I started this book. To be honest, I didn’t realize the first book wasn’t a stand alone until that ending! But knowing that this is a trilogy is important to note. This book did its job of bridging the gap between a strong opening and the ending well. I feel like we got a lot of the needed back story to the world of the nightmares here in an organic way.
The romance is very slow burn and I think it is very suitable for younger YA audiences. I also love the almost found family vibes we’re getting with Erica.
I will most certainly continue this series.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I loved the first book in this series and no surprise, I loved this too. It’s just the right amount of spooky for me.
I didn’t know how many books this series would be when I started this book. To be honest, I didn’t realize the first book wasn’t a stand alone until that ending! But knowing that this is a trilogy is important to note. This book did its job of bridging the gap between a strong opening and the ending well. I feel like we got a lot of the needed back story to the world of the nightmares here in an organic way.
The romance is very slow burn and I think it is very suitable for younger YA audiences. I also love the almost found family vibes we’re getting with Erica.
I will most certainly continue this series.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
April 25, 2025
This girl needs to stop clicking her teeth
September 30, 2023
This is a highly engaging sequel that surpasses its predecessor in both storytelling and character development. Winnie Wednesday's journey continues as she navigates newfound fame, challenges within the hunter society, and a growing mystery that threatens her community and family. As the secrets build and tensions mount, Winnie's internal struggle to define her identity as a Wednesday and a Luminary becomes a central theme.
Winnie continues to evolve. She's now a celebrity after passing the hunter trials, but her newfound status doesn't sit right with her. Her determination to uncover the truth about the Whisperer, a new threat to the hunters that no one else has seen, showcases her tenacity and sense of justice. Her refusal to simply blame the werewolf, despite popular opinion, is a testament to her strong moral compass. The mystery surrounding the Dianas, their magic, and the events in Hemlock Falls four years ago deepens, adding layers of intrigue. Dennard skillfully weaves these elements into the story, creating a suspenseful atmosphere.
The world-building in "The Hunting Moon" is expanded, providing a richer backdrop for the story. The vivid descriptions of the living forest and the atmospheric gothic vibes continue to be a highlight of the series for me.
While this is an obvious young adult novel in its writing, it offers entertainment and depth that will appeal to readers of all ages. Loved the narration; the audiobook is the correct choice for this one.
Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC. This is an honest review.
Winnie continues to evolve. She's now a celebrity after passing the hunter trials, but her newfound status doesn't sit right with her. Her determination to uncover the truth about the Whisperer, a new threat to the hunters that no one else has seen, showcases her tenacity and sense of justice. Her refusal to simply blame the werewolf, despite popular opinion, is a testament to her strong moral compass. The mystery surrounding the Dianas, their magic, and the events in Hemlock Falls four years ago deepens, adding layers of intrigue. Dennard skillfully weaves these elements into the story, creating a suspenseful atmosphere.
The world-building in "The Hunting Moon" is expanded, providing a richer backdrop for the story. The vivid descriptions of the living forest and the atmospheric gothic vibes continue to be a highlight of the series for me.
While this is an obvious young adult novel in its writing, it offers entertainment and depth that will appeal to readers of all ages. Loved the narration; the audiobook is the correct choice for this one.
Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC. This is an honest review.
November 2, 2023
This middle book, The Hunting Moon ( The Luminaries #2) by Susan Dennard, of the series finds Winnie Wednesday on more adventures and shenanigans. There’s different creatures, a possible boyfriend and a key back to the kingdom, so to speak. Clues left by Winnie’s Dad heightens the mystery. A song might further the relationship between Winnie Wednesday and Jay Friday. The ending had me begging for more as it should. Thanks to Tor Teen and NetGalley for the ARC. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 30, 2023
3.5 rounded up. A bit slower to start compared to book 1, but still gave similar vibes and was fun overall particularly in the second half. There were some parts that hiccupped for me in the first half, and I wish we got more answers in this entry. But at the end of the day, I really enjoyed the dynamics of Jay and Winnie here so I'm a happy camper. I initially thought this was going to be a duology at first, but I look forward to book 3!
November 7, 2023
4.5 Stars
I really enjoyed the first book in this series "The Luminaries", so I was super excited for this book. For some reason Waterstones posted it to me 2 weeks before the publication date so I feel pretty lucky about that! Zero spoilers in this review!
The Hunting Moon pretty much carries on where The Luminaries ended. If you haven't read the first book, it is about a town that is populated by people called Luminaries. They are people that hunt "Nightmares" in local woodland to protect themselves and others. Nightmares are a whole range of weird, creepy, scary and rather amazing creatures that attack humans. The story follows a girl named Winnie who has had a tough life but things are starting to get better...or are they?
This second book looks more deeply into the nightmares which I thoroughly enjoyed and focuses on Winnies's investigation into her Dad. There is also the rather mysterious and wonderful young man Jay who Winnie can't help but be drawn to.
I did feel this second book was much slower in pace, and less complex in storyline than the first book, especially in the first half. However it definitely picked up in the second half and has set up a lot for the final book, which I am very excited about. I did guess a few of the twists but also didn't see many of them coming so I was still utterly gripped, especially in the second half.
Winnie is a fantastic character and I loved her even more in this book. We don't really see many more characters other than her and Jay, and I wish there had been a few more scenes with side characters added in. However Jay adds so much to this book and the relationship between the two of them is as electric as the first book, if not more.
The writing is fantastic. Susan Dennard has a way of capturing my imagination and holding my attention so much so I race through her books, and thus series is no exception. The atmosphere and imagination is fantastic and definitely makes this book the success it is.
Overall, a great second installment and I think we are in for a mind blowing final book. I love this series for it's imagination and characters and am already desperate for book 3! I highly recommend this series to all YA fantasy readers.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series "The Luminaries", so I was super excited for this book. For some reason Waterstones posted it to me 2 weeks before the publication date so I feel pretty lucky about that! Zero spoilers in this review!
The Hunting Moon pretty much carries on where The Luminaries ended. If you haven't read the first book, it is about a town that is populated by people called Luminaries. They are people that hunt "Nightmares" in local woodland to protect themselves and others. Nightmares are a whole range of weird, creepy, scary and rather amazing creatures that attack humans. The story follows a girl named Winnie who has had a tough life but things are starting to get better...or are they?
This second book looks more deeply into the nightmares which I thoroughly enjoyed and focuses on Winnies's investigation into her Dad. There is also the rather mysterious and wonderful young man Jay who Winnie can't help but be drawn to.
I did feel this second book was much slower in pace, and less complex in storyline than the first book, especially in the first half. However it definitely picked up in the second half and has set up a lot for the final book, which I am very excited about. I did guess a few of the twists but also didn't see many of them coming so I was still utterly gripped, especially in the second half.
Winnie is a fantastic character and I loved her even more in this book. We don't really see many more characters other than her and Jay, and I wish there had been a few more scenes with side characters added in. However Jay adds so much to this book and the relationship between the two of them is as electric as the first book, if not more.
The writing is fantastic. Susan Dennard has a way of capturing my imagination and holding my attention so much so I race through her books, and thus series is no exception. The atmosphere and imagination is fantastic and definitely makes this book the success it is.
Overall, a great second installment and I think we are in for a mind blowing final book. I love this series for it's imagination and characters and am already desperate for book 3! I highly recommend this series to all YA fantasy readers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,324 reviews