What do you think?
Rate this book


400 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 1, 2024
2.5☆. spoilers ahead.
I'm not sure what happened with this installment, but it might have had something to do with the utter lack of focus on the plot for at least 75% of the book. For all intents and purposes, the process of defeating the antagonist whose name I can't spell and do not intend to look up wasn't that bad, even if the plot itself was generic. The problem, for me at least, was why I had to sit through an entire novel of Emma bouncing back and forth between hating Aiden and being with her friends. I didn't care at first because I thought it'd feel like my personal favorite section of A Court of Wings and Ruin, wherein the protagonist was acting as a spy in her old home, but then it led to a whole lot of nothing happening beyond everyone talking about how they were planning on taking out the antagonist and not doing much else. Well, I shouldn't say nothing--there were a few questionably written smut scenes thrown in there to fill the pages.
Then there were the random Fynn and Cora POVS, of which there were a maximum of three--combined, not each--throughout the book. I don't know why that was done if we weren't going to get a nicely fleshed out sub-romance plot between the two of them. Instead, one POV was used to essentially show that they decided to be together, and the other two were just responses to Emma and Kye's deaths. Or Kye's death, I guess. About 75% of the way in, as well, there was a fight with the antagonist that felt like it should've been the last fight with him because of how climactic it felt, but instead, Emma just ends up in a random coma for a very long time... and then there's another fight, and that's the end. It was all very weird.
I do still enjoy these characters--when Kye died I was genuinely sad, and the scraps of Fynn and Cora's relationship that were actually in this installment were super fun to read. I didn't understand why Aiden was turned into an entirely irredeemable character by the end of this when he could've been a much more nuanced villain, but the moments where he was more than an open-and-shut misogynist were nice. Emma's journey to valuing herself was, I think, still well done--or, at least, better than the rest of the plot--and Draven... I wish I had something significant to say about him, but really, he was on "you're mine/don't touch her" mode the entire time. Which is not very interesting.
If I'm being honest, Soul of Salvation took all the wind out of my sails when it came to this series--not necessarily surprising since so many lesser known fantasies have poor sequels--so I don't think I'll come back for a reread like I originally thought I would, but I still think this series is a better example of something in this genre that many smaller authors try and fail to pull off. As someone who has made myself sit through books like Fairydale, that means something.