I have read and enjoyed one other Francine Prose novel, but, despite her wonderful gifts as a writer, I just didn't feel this one worked as well.
It is built around a gimmick that is only partially successful. Vera Perl works for This Week, a supermarket tabloid whose internal motto is to make sure that no story it writes comes close to the truth. It features lots of stories about werewolves, yeti, Bigfoot and Elvis sightings, and Vera, despite her early dreams of being a legitimate journalist, has become one of the paper's mainstays.
One day, the paper's photographer brings in a picture of kids selling lemonade in Brooklyn. Vera makes up a story to go with it. She invents names for the children and parents and says the water from their house is the fountain of youth and has created a sensation in the neighborhood. The next thing she knows, she is being summoned to a meeting with the editor and lawyers because it turns out every item she made up matches the facts -- the names of the kids and parents, their address and even the father's occupation as a cardiologist. When she goes to visit the family (without telling the lawyers), their home's yard is nothing but dirt because of the crowds of people who have begged water from them ever since the story appeared.
I won't tell you what happens to Vera as a result of this visit, but it's not really the point of the book, and that's where I think this noble effort failed. Vera's feckless husband, Lowell, shows up in her life again, and her 10 year old daughter Rosalie, fascinated by dancing and Dungeons and Dragons, seems to barely tolerate her. Her retired father, a lefty who fought in the Spanish Civil War, wants her after all these years to get a real job, and her best friend Louise turns out not to be the lifeline she had hoped.
It all ends up with Vera attending a meeting of the cryptobiologists -- scientists who study mythical creatures using the inductive method -- on the edge of the Grand Canyon.
I think Prose intended to create a poignant story about life's unexpected surprises and how to find real love and hope in the midst of often depressing events, all built on this obviously fantastical premise, and in the end, it didn't quite work.