As a teacher with classes full of rather unmotivated students, this book was surely a lifesaver for me. I try to give them independent reading times as an attempt (or more so, a futile one, haha) to encourage reading in an engaging way. But they rarely work. I was very close to just eliminating reading time so the students could work on something that will directly impact their grade.
But this book changed my mind. The part that touched me the most was when the book noted the obsessive desire of the school system to rely so heavily on standardised testing to the point where the more lenient activities, such as independent reading, are often overlooked. It highlighted the very real flaws of the system, and how that leads to the faulty recruitment of professions in the long term. It is a very prominent issue, yet it seems like there are no alternatives that upholds the simplicity and the quality of our current standardised testing.
However, the examples of the author’s personal experiences with the students did show to be excessive in some parts. And in some cases, the author seemed to get carried away with his own experiences with a certain book or a student. I am in no way suggesting that personal experiences are unnecessary, in fact, it is often the opposite. But I also believe that logic and research should play the bigger part of this persuasion.
As much as I wish to rate this book a five star, I am inclined to stay impartial and truthful, as my rating may affect a desperate individual one day.
Was this book published recently? Yes. But my view of this book is not a victim of the recency bias.
I wish Jarred Amato good luck in his endeavours as a teacher, but also as an author.