Stolen Christmas is part of the ‘Camp Bay’ series. It stars Eric, ex-con and maintenance man, and Max, a pediatrician. This is told in first person from Eric’s pov.
I don’t know what to make of this story. I felt like I got dropped into the plot and romance midway. It starts with Eric anxiously awaiting the return of Max to Camp Bay Chalet for the Christmas holiday. They had a one time fling the year before and Max left without speaking to Eric. But the two got to know each other for years before their fling when Max and his then husband, Wilson, visited every Christmas holiday. So, Eric and Max already had a talking relationship. But us readers never get to see that growing relationship happen; it happens off page. We’re dropped into Max’s return and the men trying to establish a connection but there are misunderstandings. They’re still attracted to each other, but there’s always a cloud between them because Eric is afraid that Max will despise him when he finds out that Eric is an ex-con.
Besides the abrupt plunge into Max and Eric’s ‘relationship,’ there was also someone stealing items from the other guests. That scenario reminded me of Dirty Dancing. Anyway, it didn’t really add anything except temporarily move the pace of the story a bit and create a scene about Eric’s past. Maybe the author’s writing style isn’t for me, but in my opinion, this story plodded along. It was a lot about Eric’s guilt, how he tried to avoid other guests, how he wanted to be with Max but feared how Max would see him once Eric told him what he’d done in the past. There wasn’t any excitement, it was kind of blah. But maybe that’s the way it was meant to be since it's all from Eric’s pov.
As to the characters, Eric is guilt ridden. He still believes he should be punished for a past crime, even though his probation is over and he’s been a model citizen. He sleeps in a basement room with no windows or decoration. It’s like a cell, and I hadn’t noticed the symbolism until Max brought it up. For me, that’s the one interesting item in this book. Nothing else stood out. Eric can’t move past his past, he is stuck. Max is Eric’s bright spot. Even though, when Max found out what Eric did, his immediate reaction was unkind. Max is cheerful, giving, and he tries his best to get Eric to give their relationship a go. Unfortunately, there wasn’t enough romance to make me believe in Max and Eric as a couple.
I wasn’t convinced about the logic used at the end of the story about Eric leaving the Chalet to feel like he was reborn or set free. The Chalet was a new freedom from prison. Eric chose to punish himself, not his bosses or the other workers. Eric punished himself probably because he was an innately good person, knew right from wrong and tried to be a good person, but had ended up making some mistakes through association.
Overall, this was an okay story. Dropping readers into a relationship that happened off page and into a plot involving people from what felt like some other book, didn’t work for me. Eric’s voice was dull as was his emotions. This was frankly a kind of depressing story and the mystery of the stolen items wasn’t that much of a mystery. I don’t know if it was just this book, or if the author’s writing style isn’t for me, but I wouldn’t recommend this. I give, Stolen Christmas, 2 Stars.