What do you think?
Rate this book
Wither on the Vine
Eachann and Galanta fell in love almost two thousand years ago. Their love was star-crossed and tragic and ended in her betrayal and his death. After hundreds of lifetimes of separation, Galanta has finally found the incantation that will bring Eachann back to life. When that happens, will he still want revenge?
385 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 15, 2024
61 people want to read
About the author
Andrea Jenelle
38 books299 followersI write steamy small town romance (Willow Creek series), paranormal romantasy (Sons & Daughters of Lir) and Victorian era historical romance (Wainwright Sisters) with heat and heart.
I'm a 2X HOLT Award Winning Author (2023, No Regrets- Best First Book; 2025, No Excuses - Best Short Contemporary) who's had characters begging me to tell their love story since I was thirteen years old. I'm finally letting them have a voice.
I wrote my first story, about a giant who befriended a lady bug when I was in the second grade.
I live on a peaceful farm with my spouse and love nothing more than sitting on my porch with a glass of wine and plotting.
You can subscribe to my newsletter via my author website, ANDREAJENELLEROMANCE at https://andreajenelleromance.com/ or see what I'm up to on Instagram and TikTok via my handle @authorandreajenelle
I'm a 2X HOLT Award Winning Author (2023, No Regrets- Best First Book; 2025, No Excuses - Best Short Contemporary) who's had characters begging me to tell their love story since I was thirteen years old. I'm finally letting them have a voice.
I wrote my first story, about a giant who befriended a lady bug when I was in the second grade.
I live on a peaceful farm with my spouse and love nothing more than sitting on my porch with a glass of wine and plotting.
You can subscribe to my newsletter via my author website, ANDREAJENELLEROMANCE at https://andreajenelleromance.com/ or see what I'm up to on Instagram and TikTok via my handle @authorandreajenelle
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
June 18, 2024
Beautiful and tragic! This book was a whirlwind of emotions from romance to betrayal to death and prophecies. There’s so much packed into this book it was impossible to put down from the start. I loved Galanta and Eachann’s story!
Galanta had such a beautiful soul. I adored her character and loved how she grew and strengthened throughout the novel.
Eachann was sunlight amidst the storm. His character was easy to fall in love with. His growth was different with the struggles he faced, but he came out more stronger for them in the end just as their relationship did.
This book was perfect for lovers of enemies to lovers, betrayal, second chances, prophecies, magic, gods/goddesses, protective MMC, strong FMC, forbidden love, star crossed lovers, and so much more!
Galanta had such a beautiful soul. I adored her character and loved how she grew and strengthened throughout the novel.
Eachann was sunlight amidst the storm. His character was easy to fall in love with. His growth was different with the struggles he faced, but he came out more stronger for them in the end just as their relationship did.
This book was perfect for lovers of enemies to lovers, betrayal, second chances, prophecies, magic, gods/goddesses, protective MMC, strong FMC, forbidden love, star crossed lovers, and so much more!
July 16, 2024
I liked it better than the first book. some of the writing was confusing especially In conversations with more than 3 people and the speaker wasn't clearly identified. I did enjoy the dark themes of the book and was glad to see galantas story
July 22, 2024
Andrea Jenelle delivers her second fantasy romance in two parts: where we get a tail of fated mates and star-cross lovers part one, and a tail of redemption and happily ever after and part two!
Galanta he is almost a Cinderella character living and serving her brutal stepfather and stepbrothers. She is a descendant of the green goddess is able to harness the trees and forest for healing. Considered a witch by her community she was ostracized.
Eachann is a prince and heir of the Lir Kingdom of the each uisge; a population of water horse shifters. He is betrothed to the princess of the Selkie Kingdom but once his beast has found his mate in Galanta- he will have no other.
The story was filled with drama and magical Celtic elements. The story spans through time and has an interesting dynamic of historical and present day fantasy. Being the second book in the series, I found that the lore was well described and written in a way the new readers could easily jump in, but having read book one, I was excited to see returning characters and updates on their HEA.
Wither on the Vine is a high fantasy romance bursting with steam, drama and intrigue!
Galanta he is almost a Cinderella character living and serving her brutal stepfather and stepbrothers. She is a descendant of the green goddess is able to harness the trees and forest for healing. Considered a witch by her community she was ostracized.
Eachann is a prince and heir of the Lir Kingdom of the each uisge; a population of water horse shifters. He is betrothed to the princess of the Selkie Kingdom but once his beast has found his mate in Galanta- he will have no other.
The story was filled with drama and magical Celtic elements. The story spans through time and has an interesting dynamic of historical and present day fantasy. Being the second book in the series, I found that the lore was well described and written in a way the new readers could easily jump in, but having read book one, I was excited to see returning characters and updates on their HEA.
Wither on the Vine is a high fantasy romance bursting with steam, drama and intrigue!
August 7, 2024
Wither on the Vine was a lot more emotional than the first book. Eachann and Galanta met and fell in love. Their relationship was absolutely forbidden, but they couldn't seem to stop. Galanta was abused by her stepfather and stepbrothers and Eachann was the first person, since her mother, to show her any kindness. When she falls pregnant and he proposes marriage, life couldn't get any better.
So what happens when that love is betrayed?
Galanta spent a thousand years trying to figure out how to resurrect Eachann and I felt the pain of her loss. I felt the pain of her isolation and I was so happy that the women of the family took her under their wing, giving her companionship and encouragement. Especially when Eachann came back and was an absolute meanie towards her.
Seeing these characters make their way back to each other was magic itself. I loved how the author highlighted their individual suffering and gave us so much warmth as well. These stories are well-written and entertaining, and I'll be looking forward to the next one.
So what happens when that love is betrayed?
Galanta spent a thousand years trying to figure out how to resurrect Eachann and I felt the pain of her loss. I felt the pain of her isolation and I was so happy that the women of the family took her under their wing, giving her companionship and encouragement. Especially when Eachann came back and was an absolute meanie towards her.
Seeing these characters make their way back to each other was magic itself. I loved how the author highlighted their individual suffering and gave us so much warmth as well. These stories are well-written and entertaining, and I'll be looking forward to the next one.
September 27, 2024
Wither on the Vine is a historical romantic fantasy that is set in past and present timelines, it has fated mates, lost gods, and betrayal (I literally cannot think of a more perfect blend of fictional elements) and is one of my absolute faves from Andrea thus far, I adored every single minute of reading it!
I am a glutton for fated mates and second chance romance and this was perfection with all the pining and chemistry that comes with it. Beyond that, the story in itself was so meaningful to me, there was so much I adored from the themes of individual growth and reparations, to the magic system in a world with gods & goddesses, to a true enemies to lovers filled with angst and fiery resentment, a love that defies all odds and more importantly the powerful depiction of defiance in an era where women, branded as witches, endured religious persecution at the hands of oppressive men!
As with all Andrea Jenelle novels, the writing flowed impeccably, the characters endearing, and the story itself extremely captivating, I cannot wait for more installments in this series!
I am a glutton for fated mates and second chance romance and this was perfection with all the pining and chemistry that comes with it. Beyond that, the story in itself was so meaningful to me, there was so much I adored from the themes of individual growth and reparations, to the magic system in a world with gods & goddesses, to a true enemies to lovers filled with angst and fiery resentment, a love that defies all odds and more importantly the powerful depiction of defiance in an era where women, branded as witches, endured religious persecution at the hands of oppressive men!
As with all Andrea Jenelle novels, the writing flowed impeccably, the characters endearing, and the story itself extremely captivating, I cannot wait for more installments in this series!
August 10, 2024
This book has an interesting plot and the characters are different enough to be refreshing. I did struggle to get into the writing style since it's a lot more formal than I typically prefer, and some of the dialogue was annoying to try to figure out. But I love mushy fated mates, and this certainly has them.
July 19, 2024
Tragic, beautiful, emotional... the love was loving and the betrayal was just *chef kiss*. One moment I'm tearing up, the next I'm smiling like a fool trying not to squeal.
It was enjoyable and I couldn't put it down (read it in 2 days).
It was enjoyable and I couldn't put it down (read it in 2 days).
August 11, 2024
This story was not what I was expecting at all. I've read a little romantasy here and there, but it wasn't really for me. I decided to give this book a try as another chance and boy was I so happy that I did.
This was book 2 in the series but can be read as a standalone.
"The golden prince of the sea and a witch with the forest in her veins. We were destined to me mortal enemies but fell in love instead."
Eachann and Galanta's story is so heartwarming and gut wrenching at the same time. Galanta had gone through so much pain and torture in her life at the hands of her stepfather, step-brothers, and priest. When Eachann came into her life... I thought "finally. someone to have her back and help her seek vengeance for all the wrong that was done to her." I never expected for this story to go down the path it did. I sobbed through most of this story, as my heart kept breaking for Galanta over and over. Eachann's decision over vengeance when he was brought back had me gut wrenched. I didn't want that for her after everything she had been through. "I never stopping love you, Eachann. I gave up everything for you. And when I finally atoned for all my mistakes, you threw my love in my face and treated me like nothing more than a vessel."
The last chapter of the book had me at the edge of my seat. After all that had happened, I couldn't predict which path the story was going to take and wasn't sure how to prepare myself. I cannot wait for the next book in this series. This one was a little hard for me to get into at the beginning. But I'm so glad I stuck with it.
If you like *romantasy, *fated mates, *lovers to enemies to lovers again, *dual pov, *spice, *paranormal aspects..... I definitely recommend giving this a read!!!
A few of my favorite quotes from the story:
"It means I will carry you to my kingdom upon my back. It means you will bear my sons. It means that I am wholly yours and you are wholly mine. That I will honor and protect you with my lifespan. Whether it be five hundred years or ten thousand."
"We were never meant to be a tragedy. And I vow, mo chridhe fiadhaich, my green girl, my sweet, savage witch, this is not our ending. I will find you if I must crawl on my knees to the gods and drag you back with the power of the music you gave back to me. Just as Orpheus sought out Eurydice."
This was book 2 in the series but can be read as a standalone.
"The golden prince of the sea and a witch with the forest in her veins. We were destined to me mortal enemies but fell in love instead."
Eachann and Galanta's story is so heartwarming and gut wrenching at the same time. Galanta had gone through so much pain and torture in her life at the hands of her stepfather, step-brothers, and priest. When Eachann came into her life... I thought "finally. someone to have her back and help her seek vengeance for all the wrong that was done to her." I never expected for this story to go down the path it did. I sobbed through most of this story, as my heart kept breaking for Galanta over and over. Eachann's decision over vengeance when he was brought back had me gut wrenched. I didn't want that for her after everything she had been through. "I never stopping love you, Eachann. I gave up everything for you. And when I finally atoned for all my mistakes, you threw my love in my face and treated me like nothing more than a vessel."
The last chapter of the book had me at the edge of my seat. After all that had happened, I couldn't predict which path the story was going to take and wasn't sure how to prepare myself. I cannot wait for the next book in this series. This one was a little hard for me to get into at the beginning. But I'm so glad I stuck with it.
If you like *romantasy, *fated mates, *lovers to enemies to lovers again, *dual pov, *spice, *paranormal aspects..... I definitely recommend giving this a read!!!
A few of my favorite quotes from the story:
"It means I will carry you to my kingdom upon my back. It means you will bear my sons. It means that I am wholly yours and you are wholly mine. That I will honor and protect you with my lifespan. Whether it be five hundred years or ten thousand."
"We were never meant to be a tragedy. And I vow, mo chridhe fiadhaich, my green girl, my sweet, savage witch, this is not our ending. I will find you if I must crawl on my knees to the gods and drag you back with the power of the music you gave back to me. Just as Orpheus sought out Eurydice."
June 19, 2024
✨ Wither On The Vine by Andrea Jenelle ✨
Ok I'm gonna start by saying that I thought this one was gonna take me a day to read it since I had been waiting for it since last year but not only did that not happened but it also reminded me that my English can sometimes be very basic lol.
Now to the book review. I thought this one would have a backstory of how they started and then pick up where Way Down We Go left off but surprisingly it didn't. For a minute I thought I was reading a whole different plot which was pretty cool in a way.
So many things I enjoyed about this one. This one gave us a more detailed view on their kingdom as well as their enemies. Tell me why I would love to have a novella or something about the king and queens love story. The little snippet that was given had me wanting more!
I was devouring reading how their love story blossomed all the way up to the events that were mentioned in WDWG and after that my emotions were going rampant. Eachann was set on retribution and he had his eyes set on the witch that betrayed him. I do want to say that in Mily opinion Eachann needed to do some more groveling for how mean he was with Galanta cause my heart was hurting for her. But overall I enjoyed this and can't wait for the next one.
“I have lived a long life, though not all of it as mortal or even human. But it is more than I ever expected when you rescued me from the flames. Of course I want more. But the one person I would give my eternity to cannot bear the sight of me.”
“We were never meant to be a tragedy. And I vow, mo chridhe fiadhaich, my green girl, my sweet, savage witch, this is not our ending. I will find you if I must crawl on my knees to the gods and drag you back with the power of the music you gave back to me. Just as Orpheus sought out Eurydice.”
If you love
💫 Fated Mares
💫 Paranormal Romance
💫 Enemies to Lovers
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Stand Alone or Series: Sons and Daughters of Lir.
💋naj_ana_reads💋
Mood Reader
TikTok l Instagram l Goodreads l Amazon l Audible Reviews
Ok I'm gonna start by saying that I thought this one was gonna take me a day to read it since I had been waiting for it since last year but not only did that not happened but it also reminded me that my English can sometimes be very basic lol.
Now to the book review. I thought this one would have a backstory of how they started and then pick up where Way Down We Go left off but surprisingly it didn't. For a minute I thought I was reading a whole different plot which was pretty cool in a way.
So many things I enjoyed about this one. This one gave us a more detailed view on their kingdom as well as their enemies. Tell me why I would love to have a novella or something about the king and queens love story. The little snippet that was given had me wanting more!
I was devouring reading how their love story blossomed all the way up to the events that were mentioned in WDWG and after that my emotions were going rampant. Eachann was set on retribution and he had his eyes set on the witch that betrayed him. I do want to say that in Mily opinion Eachann needed to do some more groveling for how mean he was with Galanta cause my heart was hurting for her. But overall I enjoyed this and can't wait for the next one.
“I have lived a long life, though not all of it as mortal or even human. But it is more than I ever expected when you rescued me from the flames. Of course I want more. But the one person I would give my eternity to cannot bear the sight of me.”
“We were never meant to be a tragedy. And I vow, mo chridhe fiadhaich, my green girl, my sweet, savage witch, this is not our ending. I will find you if I must crawl on my knees to the gods and drag you back with the power of the music you gave back to me. Just as Orpheus sought out Eurydice.”
If you love
💫 Fated Mares
💫 Paranormal Romance
💫 Enemies to Lovers
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Stand Alone or Series: Sons and Daughters of Lir.
💋naj_ana_reads💋
Mood Reader
TikTok l Instagram l Goodreads l Amazon l Audible Reviews
July 14, 2024
Wither on the Vine is the second book in the Sons and Daughters of Lir series. A romantasy that I was able to read as a standalone.
I absolutely loved this book and thought the cover was beautiful. This author writes in multiple genres and there hasn’t been a book of hers that I haven’t enjoyed. I enjoy her storytelling and connection to characters and this one hit the mark again. I also normally keep to historical romance but have read a lot of Highlander stories that makes references to Celtic folklore and mythology and so it was enjoyable to read a story that was immersed in that.
Both the MC were lovable, definitely had more empathy for Galanta in the beginning for enduring the treatment she receives from everyone around her and yet she continues to help others. I’m wary about fated mates but I loved that this big strong warrior was smitten as soon as he met her and essentially made his soul sing. I also liked he still worked to get to know her and had to resolve other issues before getting to be with her.
The story is broken into two parts and the second part was gut wrenching. The emotions they were both dealing with was devastating but there is a HEA. Galanta is told the correct time will come when she has the patience to endure and by the time came she had the patience of saint.
This was outside my normal reading but was still tied to what I enjoy. I’m glad I stepped out of my comfort zone for this one and recommend it for those looking for something different.
Content warning below may contain spoilers.
There were four encounters. The scenes aren’t overly long but still detailed and steamy. There’s also a few edging scenes I didn’t count as an encounter.
I received an advanced ebook via BookSirens. All opinions are my own.
CW: miscarriage.
I absolutely loved this book and thought the cover was beautiful. This author writes in multiple genres and there hasn’t been a book of hers that I haven’t enjoyed. I enjoy her storytelling and connection to characters and this one hit the mark again. I also normally keep to historical romance but have read a lot of Highlander stories that makes references to Celtic folklore and mythology and so it was enjoyable to read a story that was immersed in that.
Both the MC were lovable, definitely had more empathy for Galanta in the beginning for enduring the treatment she receives from everyone around her and yet she continues to help others. I’m wary about fated mates but I loved that this big strong warrior was smitten as soon as he met her and essentially made his soul sing. I also liked he still worked to get to know her and had to resolve other issues before getting to be with her.
The story is broken into two parts and the second part was gut wrenching. The emotions they were both dealing with was devastating but there is a HEA. Galanta is told the correct time will come when she has the patience to endure and by the time came she had the patience of saint.
This was outside my normal reading but was still tied to what I enjoy. I’m glad I stepped out of my comfort zone for this one and recommend it for those looking for something different.
Content warning below may contain spoilers.
There were four encounters. The scenes aren’t overly long but still detailed and steamy. There’s also a few edging scenes I didn’t count as an encounter.
I received an advanced ebook via BookSirens. All opinions are my own.
CW: miscarriage.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 12, 2024
In Life or Death
Wither on the Vine brings us a thousand or so years into the past to the events that started us off in Way Down We Go. This book follows Eachann, twin brother to Callum and heir to the throne, and Galanta, a witch who is shunned by her stepfather and stepbrothers in a very strict religious village.
The writing for this book is more historical fantasy with a dabble of paranormal. The focus is not so much on the shifter portion, but on the world at the time of their love story. This is a time where women are not highly regarded and those that work as healers or with apothecary sciences are tried as witches. The village fears the shifter race as demons.
Eachann’s and Galanta’s souls call to each other, yet they have to meet in secret and as they plan to be together, betrayal occurs and Eachann is k!led and Galanta gives her life into service to the Morrigan in hopes of reuniting with her love once more when the time is right.
Fast forward a thousand years later and we pick up with the end of Way Down We Go with Galanta trying to find the spell to bring Eachann back. When she succeeds she finds herself face to face with her love, now nothing more than an enemy who despises her. The E2L part is strong and the spice kicks up with the desire and denial. Andrea really knows how to write this aspect and it makes you just as frustrated as the characters but the payoff is so worth it! I loved their journey back to one another and proof that their love could withstand de@th and the depths of their hearts would always beat for one another.
The twist at the end is a good one and it does lead into what’s to come in Book 3 and I’m excited to see where the story goes from here.
Wither on the Vine brings us a thousand or so years into the past to the events that started us off in Way Down We Go. This book follows Eachann, twin brother to Callum and heir to the throne, and Galanta, a witch who is shunned by her stepfather and stepbrothers in a very strict religious village.
The writing for this book is more historical fantasy with a dabble of paranormal. The focus is not so much on the shifter portion, but on the world at the time of their love story. This is a time where women are not highly regarded and those that work as healers or with apothecary sciences are tried as witches. The village fears the shifter race as demons.
Eachann’s and Galanta’s souls call to each other, yet they have to meet in secret and as they plan to be together, betrayal occurs and Eachann is k!led and Galanta gives her life into service to the Morrigan in hopes of reuniting with her love once more when the time is right.
Fast forward a thousand years later and we pick up with the end of Way Down We Go with Galanta trying to find the spell to bring Eachann back. When she succeeds she finds herself face to face with her love, now nothing more than an enemy who despises her. The E2L part is strong and the spice kicks up with the desire and denial. Andrea really knows how to write this aspect and it makes you just as frustrated as the characters but the payoff is so worth it! I loved their journey back to one another and proof that their love could withstand de@th and the depths of their hearts would always beat for one another.
The twist at the end is a good one and it does lead into what’s to come in Book 3 and I’m excited to see where the story goes from here.
September 24, 2024
🤍 Book Review 🤍
📖 Wither On The Vine By Andrea Jenelle 📖
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️
My Thoughts ~ This is Book 2 in the series but can be read as a stand alone as well.
The way Andrea writes and how she elevates words just leaves you immersed in the story.
At first I will admit I was a bit confused with how it started off I thought it was a different storyline all together but soon realized that the book does pick up where Way Down We Go the first book in the series left off.
Eachann and Galanta where do I start, Galanta has been through so much pain and trauma at the hands of her stepfather hoping one day to be able to break free of the life she is currently living. she is also a witch but she has to keep it hidden for if anyone was to find out her suffering would be much more. Eachann is a prince and an heir of Lir Kingdom, He will need to find a mate a When he sees Glalanta he’s immediately mesmerized by her.
There love is nothing short of sparks that are forbidden to ignite but when they know they have fallen for each other, after that the rest of the book is a world win of love,passion,drama,hardship,tragedy so many emotions and events that occur within there relationship and around them.
Quotes
“A golden Prince of the sea and a witch with a forest in her veins. We were destined to be mortal enemies but fell in love instead.”
“I Vow you are the only home I’ve ever truly wanted.”
“You are my music.”
“I have lived a Long life, though not all of it as mortal or even human. But it is more than I ever expected when you rescued me from the flames. Of course I want more. But the one person I would give my entirety to cannot bear the sight of me.”
“All is fair in love and war, Witch. And this is war.”
📖 Wither On The Vine By Andrea Jenelle 📖
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️
My Thoughts ~ This is Book 2 in the series but can be read as a stand alone as well.
The way Andrea writes and how she elevates words just leaves you immersed in the story.
At first I will admit I was a bit confused with how it started off I thought it was a different storyline all together but soon realized that the book does pick up where Way Down We Go the first book in the series left off.
Eachann and Galanta where do I start, Galanta has been through so much pain and trauma at the hands of her stepfather hoping one day to be able to break free of the life she is currently living. she is also a witch but she has to keep it hidden for if anyone was to find out her suffering would be much more. Eachann is a prince and an heir of Lir Kingdom, He will need to find a mate a When he sees Glalanta he’s immediately mesmerized by her.
There love is nothing short of sparks that are forbidden to ignite but when they know they have fallen for each other, after that the rest of the book is a world win of love,passion,drama,hardship,tragedy so many emotions and events that occur within there relationship and around them.
Quotes
“A golden Prince of the sea and a witch with a forest in her veins. We were destined to be mortal enemies but fell in love instead.”
“I Vow you are the only home I’ve ever truly wanted.”
“You are my music.”
“I have lived a Long life, though not all of it as mortal or even human. But it is more than I ever expected when you rescued me from the flames. Of course I want more. But the one person I would give my entirety to cannot bear the sight of me.”
“All is fair in love and war, Witch. And this is war.”
August 20, 2024
Galanta is a witch in hiding. Ever since her mother forfeited her own life for Galanta she must hide her true self from her stepfather and brothers. Her mother warned her that if anyone would find out about their spells and power they could risk imprisonment or worse torture followed by death.
Living a sheltered and dominated life Galanta dreams of escaping. Her dreams seem to be granted when one day she meets a sea creature that has stolen her heart, Echann. Their star-crossed love soon endures trials and tribulations that end with one or both dead. Can they overcome centuries apart or will vengeance and misunderstandings separate them from completing their prophecy?
Overall rating 3/5
Just finishing the first book in this series I was truly excited to delve into the love story of Echann and Galanta. I so badly wanted Galanta to become a powerful witch ready to avenge her lover. However, we were left with a docile and complacent woman. Then when Echann is brought back into the story I was so disgusted with the actions he inflicted upon the woman he supposedly loved. It was nothing short of domestic violence that was glorified. I was so let down by this aspect of the story that it changed my whole opinion of the book. Also how Galanta made this behavior “ok, or exceptable” made me want to reach into the story and save this poor woman who deserved so much better.
*Thank you to Andrea Jenelle, and BookSirens for the ARC copy. I am freely leaving my honest review.
Living a sheltered and dominated life Galanta dreams of escaping. Her dreams seem to be granted when one day she meets a sea creature that has stolen her heart, Echann. Their star-crossed love soon endures trials and tribulations that end with one or both dead. Can they overcome centuries apart or will vengeance and misunderstandings separate them from completing their prophecy?
Overall rating 3/5
Just finishing the first book in this series I was truly excited to delve into the love story of Echann and Galanta. I so badly wanted Galanta to become a powerful witch ready to avenge her lover. However, we were left with a docile and complacent woman. Then when Echann is brought back into the story I was so disgusted with the actions he inflicted upon the woman he supposedly loved. It was nothing short of domestic violence that was glorified. I was so let down by this aspect of the story that it changed my whole opinion of the book. Also how Galanta made this behavior “ok, or exceptable” made me want to reach into the story and save this poor woman who deserved so much better.
*Thank you to Andrea Jenelle, and BookSirens for the ARC copy. I am freely leaving my honest review.
June 30, 2024
Wither on the Vine is an absolutely exceptional romance, combining fantasy and mythology retelling to create a tale of forbidden love, loss, magic, death and reunion, against the impending prophecy that threatens to once again tear apart our MCs.
I just could not stop reading this incredible story. I was completely lost within the pages of this beautiful romance, captivated by the love Galanta and Eachann share. It is an epic love story that spans over a thousand years, with our MCs torn apart by tragedy and loss, sending me on a rollercoaster ride of emotions, that had me laughing one moment, crying the next and squealing for joy all over again!
This novel glows with its vivid imagery and in-depth character development, placing the reader right at the centre of the story. The pace and writing style allow you to savour every single moment of Galanta and Eachann’s journey. Andrea’s dedication to exploring Celtic mythology through this series, her incredible storytelling ability, and passion for delivering truly beautiful and evocative stories shines throughout this story.
I did not want this story to end, as I was wrapped up in every aspect of its novel. This book was a true whirlwind of emotions, and this series has become one of my obsessions. I cannot wait for book 3. This book is a must-read for fantasy enthusiasts, romance readers and mythology lovers alike.
I just could not stop reading this incredible story. I was completely lost within the pages of this beautiful romance, captivated by the love Galanta and Eachann share. It is an epic love story that spans over a thousand years, with our MCs torn apart by tragedy and loss, sending me on a rollercoaster ride of emotions, that had me laughing one moment, crying the next and squealing for joy all over again!
This novel glows with its vivid imagery and in-depth character development, placing the reader right at the centre of the story. The pace and writing style allow you to savour every single moment of Galanta and Eachann’s journey. Andrea’s dedication to exploring Celtic mythology through this series, her incredible storytelling ability, and passion for delivering truly beautiful and evocative stories shines throughout this story.
I did not want this story to end, as I was wrapped up in every aspect of its novel. This book was a true whirlwind of emotions, and this series has become one of my obsessions. I cannot wait for book 3. This book is a must-read for fantasy enthusiasts, romance readers and mythology lovers alike.
August 2, 2024
"This is the story of how we found and lost each other. And found each other again."
tropes:
▸Celtic mythology
▸dual POV
▸star-crossed lovers
▸forbidden love
▸fated mates
▸second chances
▸prophecies
▸gods/goddesses
▸touch her and d1e
Eachann and Galanta fell in love almost two thousand years ago. Their love was star-crossed and tragic and ended in her betrayal and his death. after hundreds of lifetimes of separation, Galanta has finally found the incantation that will bring Eachann back to life. then he returned from the dead, he thinks she killed him, and now he's coming for her.
I love reading a book that inspired from a mythology. and this book was inspired from Celtic mythology. because from a myth you can learn more a tale or magical creature from any different country or places, so I enjoyed reading it. this book has two parts, the first part told us how they found each other, loved each other, and the second part was a heartwrenching part that still left me a 'pang' feel in my chest even after this book ends. oh it ends with HEA but still, it's beautiful yet tragic that drown us to feel their misery. it's worth the read, recommended!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. thank you to author and Booksirens♥️
August 16, 2024
Thank you to BookSirens for the e-ARC!
I did not know that this book was a part of a series prior to reading it, so I had not read Book 1 before this one. While each book focuses on a different couple there is an overarching plot/idea that continues throughout the books. To get a better understanding of the mythology I do recommend reading Book 1 first.
This book has magical Viking vibes to me and I loved the experience. I especially liked the guide at the beginning to introduce the main players and magical beings. The guide was helpful as an introduction to this world. They both have different types of magic and come from different social settings, so it was nice to see that play up. The beginning is set in Viking times, while the ending is about present-day. So, you will see a change in background and technology use.
In terms of the lovers-to-enemies-to-lovers, that is done well and is entertaining. I think all the banter between the main couple is wonderful. You do see the couple from Book 1 in the book, and get an overview of the couple for Book 3 and potentially Book 4.
“I have every reason to be jealous, witch. I am jealous of the sun that touches your shoulders when I cannot. I am jealous of the rain that feathers kisses across your lips when I cannot. I am jealous of the moonlight that bathes your body as my mouth wishes to do.”
I did not know that this book was a part of a series prior to reading it, so I had not read Book 1 before this one. While each book focuses on a different couple there is an overarching plot/idea that continues throughout the books. To get a better understanding of the mythology I do recommend reading Book 1 first.
This book has magical Viking vibes to me and I loved the experience. I especially liked the guide at the beginning to introduce the main players and magical beings. The guide was helpful as an introduction to this world. They both have different types of magic and come from different social settings, so it was nice to see that play up. The beginning is set in Viking times, while the ending is about present-day. So, you will see a change in background and technology use.
In terms of the lovers-to-enemies-to-lovers, that is done well and is entertaining. I think all the banter between the main couple is wonderful. You do see the couple from Book 1 in the book, and get an overview of the couple for Book 3 and potentially Book 4.
“I have every reason to be jealous, witch. I am jealous of the sun that touches your shoulders when I cannot. I am jealous of the rain that feathers kisses across your lips when I cannot. I am jealous of the moonlight that bathes your body as my mouth wishes to do.”
June 20, 2024
The way I'm OBSESSED with this series! I'll forever tell anyone that will listen to read everything Andrea Jenelle writes. I've been waiting for this book since before I even knew it was going to be written. I had too many questions about these two during book one, and I was definitely not disappointed.
Wither on the Vine is the second book in the Sons and Daughters of Lir series. Eachann and Galanta are everything I thought they would be and more. We go back to the beginning of their story, and it's so perfectly written. Even though you know what's coming for their near future (if you've already read the first book), you still don't expect what happens throughout the book. I love how detailed these books are without being over the top. I feel like I'm there, watching the story unfold. I fall in love with her characters in every single book. Eachann's heart is the kindest, even when he wishes the opposite.
This is a series I never want to end. I laughed & I definitely cried.. but heart was so full by the end of the book. I look forward to reading what's next for their family.
Wither on the Vine is the second book in the Sons and Daughters of Lir series. Eachann and Galanta are everything I thought they would be and more. We go back to the beginning of their story, and it's so perfectly written. Even though you know what's coming for their near future (if you've already read the first book), you still don't expect what happens throughout the book. I love how detailed these books are without being over the top. I feel like I'm there, watching the story unfold. I fall in love with her characters in every single book. Eachann's heart is the kindest, even when he wishes the opposite.
This is a series I never want to end. I laughed & I definitely cried.. but heart was so full by the end of the book. I look forward to reading what's next for their family.
June 29, 2024
I want to start by saying I dove into this book not having read book one as this can be read as a standalone. Looking back on it, I would recommend reading book one to gain some additional information, especially for all my fantasy peeps out there!
This book has a little bit of everything! There was love, heartbreak, magic, death, prophecies and soooo many tropes! It will take you on quite the emotional journey! I laughed, I gasped, I cried! It. Was. Amazing! Eachann and Galanta aren’t the only ones who fell in love, because as the story went on, I fell in love with them too! Eachann truly has the sweetest of hearts!
I don’t want to give anything away, and it’s taken me a hot minute to write this without spoilers! That being said, go read this book! As someone who doesn’t typically read fantasy, Wither on the Vine was absolutely phenomenal! Andreas writing is simply beautiful and she builds this world in a way that even I, a non fantasy reader, could really understand and appreciate! Not only that, there is a pronunciation guide and glossary for the book in the beginning and it came in handy and should be included in all works of fantasy for people like me!
This book has a little bit of everything! There was love, heartbreak, magic, death, prophecies and soooo many tropes! It will take you on quite the emotional journey! I laughed, I gasped, I cried! It. Was. Amazing! Eachann and Galanta aren’t the only ones who fell in love, because as the story went on, I fell in love with them too! Eachann truly has the sweetest of hearts!
I don’t want to give anything away, and it’s taken me a hot minute to write this without spoilers! That being said, go read this book! As someone who doesn’t typically read fantasy, Wither on the Vine was absolutely phenomenal! Andreas writing is simply beautiful and she builds this world in a way that even I, a non fantasy reader, could really understand and appreciate! Not only that, there is a pronunciation guide and glossary for the book in the beginning and it came in handy and should be included in all works of fantasy for people like me!
August 6, 2024
This book has everything I absolutely adore, dual POV, enemies to lovers, fated mates, A PRONOUNCIATION GUIDE(nobody knows just how much I adore this)??
This book was filled with yearning and sadness and growth. Our main characters may have been destined to be, but their positions in the present time couldn't have been more different. Eachann is the next in line to a throne and his father is insistent on marrying him off to strengthen his power as soon as possible. Galanta lives a miserable existence, nearly exiled for her powers and hated by her step father, who believes she's the cause of her mother's death. She has the scars to prove the life she endures, yet she feels little drive to change anything about it. Thinking this might just be what she deserves.
The tragedy, romance, and magic in this book is woven together in such a beautiful and at points eerie way. I was truly engaged every step of the way and turn of the page. I'd read it all over again. The celtic mythology was woven in so perfectly. This truly is one of my favorite books of the year.
I can't recommend it enough. Thank you so much BookSirens for a copy of this ARC in exchange of an honest reiview.
This book was filled with yearning and sadness and growth. Our main characters may have been destined to be, but their positions in the present time couldn't have been more different. Eachann is the next in line to a throne and his father is insistent on marrying him off to strengthen his power as soon as possible. Galanta lives a miserable existence, nearly exiled for her powers and hated by her step father, who believes she's the cause of her mother's death. She has the scars to prove the life she endures, yet she feels little drive to change anything about it. Thinking this might just be what she deserves.
The tragedy, romance, and magic in this book is woven together in such a beautiful and at points eerie way. I was truly engaged every step of the way and turn of the page. I'd read it all over again. The celtic mythology was woven in so perfectly. This truly is one of my favorite books of the year.
I can't recommend it enough. Thank you so much BookSirens for a copy of this ARC in exchange of an honest reiview.
August 22, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
🌶🌶🌶/5
Not gonna lie, I was never big on Romantsy/Fantasy. Andrea truly just has beautiful writing that draws you in almost instantly.
The pronunciation and guide at the beginning REALLY helped me out 😆 My brain is mush at this point in my life, so I loved that I could flip back for a reminder if I forgot. 🙃
This is book number 2 in the series [The Sons and Daughters of Lir], but it can be read as a standalone.
This book follows Eachann (Callums twin brother) and Galanta (a witch who hasn't had life easy, at all).
'𝐈 𝐟𝐞𝐞𝐥 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐥𝐚𝐰𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐞𝐥𝐝𝐫𝐢𝐭𝐜𝐡 𝐤𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐚𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝 𝐦𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐫𝐨𝐚𝐭, 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐫𝐨𝐨𝐭𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐞𝐬, 𝐝𝐫𝐚𝐠𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐦𝐞 𝐭𝐨 𝐦𝐲 𝐠𝐫𝐚𝐯𝐞.'
Andrea has always written such amazing love stories, and this one is no different. The way Eachann and Galantas souls call to each other is absolutely divine.
“𝐘𝐨𝐮 𝐜𝐚𝐧𝐧𝐨𝐭 𝐬𝐡𝐨𝐰 𝐦𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐬 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐈’𝐥𝐥 𝐛𝐞 𝐜𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐚𝐧𝐲𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐥𝐞𝐬𝐬. 𝐌𝐚𝐤𝐞 𝐦𝐞 𝐟𝐞𝐞𝐥 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐈’𝐦 𝐲𝐨𝐮𝐫𝐬.”
This book has so much heartbreak, betrayal, and gives love a second chance. The ending will enter book 3 perfectly, and I'm dying to see what happens next! 🥹✨️🌱
𝐓𝐑𝐎𝐏𝐄𝐒:
✨️ Fated Mates
✨️ Paranormal Romance
✨️Enemies to Lovers
🌶🌶🌶/5
Not gonna lie, I was never big on Romantsy/Fantasy. Andrea truly just has beautiful writing that draws you in almost instantly.
The pronunciation and guide at the beginning REALLY helped me out 😆 My brain is mush at this point in my life, so I loved that I could flip back for a reminder if I forgot. 🙃
This is book number 2 in the series [The Sons and Daughters of Lir], but it can be read as a standalone.
This book follows Eachann (Callums twin brother) and Galanta (a witch who hasn't had life easy, at all).
'𝐈 𝐟𝐞𝐞𝐥 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐥𝐚𝐰𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐞𝐥𝐝𝐫𝐢𝐭𝐜𝐡 𝐤𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐚𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝 𝐦𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐫𝐨𝐚𝐭, 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐫𝐨𝐨𝐭𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐞𝐬, 𝐝𝐫𝐚𝐠𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐦𝐞 𝐭𝐨 𝐦𝐲 𝐠𝐫𝐚𝐯𝐞.'
Andrea has always written such amazing love stories, and this one is no different. The way Eachann and Galantas souls call to each other is absolutely divine.
“𝐘𝐨𝐮 𝐜𝐚𝐧𝐧𝐨𝐭 𝐬𝐡𝐨𝐰 𝐦𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐬 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐈’𝐥𝐥 𝐛𝐞 𝐜𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐚𝐧𝐲𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐥𝐞𝐬𝐬. 𝐌𝐚𝐤𝐞 𝐦𝐞 𝐟𝐞𝐞𝐥 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞 𝐈’𝐦 𝐲𝐨𝐮𝐫𝐬.”
This book has so much heartbreak, betrayal, and gives love a second chance. The ending will enter book 3 perfectly, and I'm dying to see what happens next! 🥹✨️🌱
𝐓𝐑𝐎𝐏𝐄𝐒:
✨️ Fated Mates
✨️ Paranormal Romance
✨️Enemies to Lovers
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 26, 2024
Complex, beautiful, and Tragic ❤️ the perfect balance between traumatized dark souls and rejuvenation! Oh, and a twist of elegant Paranormal Romance, Prophecies, Love and Betrayal! What a wonderful full circle.
NOTE: While this is a second book of the series, it can be read independently as a sole book.
I adored how Galanta willed herself and grew throughout the story along with how generally lovable Eachann dispute the expectations of him and his kind.
My emotions grew and fell as their relationship grew, twisted, and altered. Betrayal, Death, Reincarnation/Back from the Dead! Love versus Revenge. Only time will tell what will happen next 💕
Overall, a wonderful and enticing read! Oh, and there are lovely vocabulary choices as well!
📖Paranormal Romance - Mythology/Mythical Beings
Star Crossed Lovers - Forbidden Lovers
🌶️🌶️ 🌶️
Graphic and Explicit descriptions, Common Happenings
TRIGGERS: Death, References to war, Religion Slander/Prosecution
NOTE: While this is a second book of the series, it can be read independently as a sole book.
I adored how Galanta willed herself and grew throughout the story along with how generally lovable Eachann dispute the expectations of him and his kind.
My emotions grew and fell as their relationship grew, twisted, and altered. Betrayal, Death, Reincarnation/Back from the Dead! Love versus Revenge. Only time will tell what will happen next 💕
Overall, a wonderful and enticing read! Oh, and there are lovely vocabulary choices as well!
📖Paranormal Romance - Mythology/Mythical Beings
Star Crossed Lovers - Forbidden Lovers
🌶️🌶️ 🌶️
Graphic and Explicit descriptions, Common Happenings
TRIGGERS: Death, References to war, Religion Slander/Prosecution
June 28, 2024
“This is the story of how we found and lost each other. And found each other again.”
This book is honestly perfection. It is beautifully written and I was hooked from the prologue! But grab your tissues because this book will not only make you laugh but you will definitely cry.
Galanta was so empowering. She has an amazing personality. The author definitely put their all into writing this character (and obviously the book🤭). I love how Galanta knows her power and it’s dangers
Eachann was such an interesting character. The book starts off with him knowing that he has a duty to his family but we watch as love prevails. I love that he knows he’ll hear music when he meets the perfect person for him.
This book is perfect if you like enemies to lovers, fated mates, forbidden love, touch her and ☠️.
I highly recommend picking up this series! You will not be sorry.
This book is honestly perfection. It is beautifully written and I was hooked from the prologue! But grab your tissues because this book will not only make you laugh but you will definitely cry.
Galanta was so empowering. She has an amazing personality. The author definitely put their all into writing this character (and obviously the book🤭). I love how Galanta knows her power and it’s dangers
Eachann was such an interesting character. The book starts off with him knowing that he has a duty to his family but we watch as love prevails. I love that he knows he’ll hear music when he meets the perfect person for him.
This book is perfect if you like enemies to lovers, fated mates, forbidden love, touch her and ☠️.
I highly recommend picking up this series! You will not be sorry.
June 19, 2024
Needless to say this was yet another 5 star read for me from Andrea. This book has betrayal and loss. An epic story to be told.
Galanta and eachann were destined for each other. I was swooning as he tried to convince her to be his. Her being a green which an he a uisge was forbidden. Galanta is mistreated by the whole town including her own stepfather and stepbrothers finds love only for tragedy to strike. Now thousands of years later she has to convince her once love that she did not betray him. I loved this book so much. Andrea has a way of building this beautiful place and making you feel like you are in it. I could not put this book down it was so delish. Can’t wait to add this book to my collection 😍 Def recommend 10 out of 10 🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽
Galanta and eachann were destined for each other. I was swooning as he tried to convince her to be his. Her being a green which an he a uisge was forbidden. Galanta is mistreated by the whole town including her own stepfather and stepbrothers finds love only for tragedy to strike. Now thousands of years later she has to convince her once love that she did not betray him. I loved this book so much. Andrea has a way of building this beautiful place and making you feel like you are in it. I could not put this book down it was so delish. Can’t wait to add this book to my collection 😍 Def recommend 10 out of 10 🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽
June 20, 2024
I've been waiting for this book since I read the first one last year.
This is a story of love, death, lore, magic, and happiness. The love between Galanta & Eachann is so strong you can feel it through the pages. Their characters were both so strong and when brought together, made them both stronger.
This book had me on a roller coaster of emotions with so many different scenes. The part of their first meeting had me giggling, Eachann returning had me feeling hopeful, the sacrifice scene had me in tears. Every scene evoked a new emotion and I loved it.
This was such an epic story and Andrea did an absolutely amazing job writing this. I can't wait to see what happens next in this world.
This is a story of love, death, lore, magic, and happiness. The love between Galanta & Eachann is so strong you can feel it through the pages. Their characters were both so strong and when brought together, made them both stronger.
This book had me on a roller coaster of emotions with so many different scenes. The part of their first meeting had me giggling, Eachann returning had me feeling hopeful, the sacrifice scene had me in tears. Every scene evoked a new emotion and I loved it.
This was such an epic story and Andrea did an absolutely amazing job writing this. I can't wait to see what happens next in this world.
June 20, 2024
Forgive me as I'm writing my review with my emotions reeking havoc on me after finishing reading this book. I was not planning on bawling my eyes out, then turning around, trying not to squeal in joy. My brain is everywhere at once, and a jumbled mess. The whole story of Eachann and Galanta will be a major favorite of mine. Through the turmoil, tragedies, love lost and won, I was fully immersed into a tail of wonders. I was lost within the pages of a romance transcending through time. Learning how fickle God's and Goddesses can be all while hoping they would step in to stop what I feared to come. I just can't speak enough on how fantastic this books was. I originally found Andrea Jenelle through her Willow Creek series. Now I'm officially hook on The Sons and Daughters of Lir series.
July 19, 2024
The beautiful cover drew me in and I'm so glad that it did!
I really liked the POV's and the different timelines. It reads as an old tragedy with a lot of love (fortunately) and a hard fought HEA.
I didn't read the first book and I think that for some more explanation (especially during the second part of the book) it would be of some help. But you can read it as a standalone as well and I did follow the story perfectly fine.
I really liked Galanta and she deserved way better! I liked Eachann a little less because he was so ready to believe, based on nothing, that the love of his life betrayed him. This story gave me all the feels and had tears in my eyes towards the end.
Thank you for the ARC Booksirens and Andrea Jenelle!
I really liked the POV's and the different timelines. It reads as an old tragedy with a lot of love (fortunately) and a hard fought HEA.
I didn't read the first book and I think that for some more explanation (especially during the second part of the book) it would be of some help. But you can read it as a standalone as well and I did follow the story perfectly fine.
I really liked Galanta and she deserved way better! I liked Eachann a little less because he was so ready to believe, based on nothing, that the love of his life betrayed him. This story gave me all the feels and had tears in my eyes towards the end.
Thank you for the ARC Booksirens and Andrea Jenelle!
July 14, 2024
Yet again the Author has written another great story. This is the second book in the series & I throughly enjoyed it as much as the first one. It definitely had me as the reader interested and invested from the first to the last page. Eachann and Galanta. These two characters will definitely stay with me for quite sometime. This story was a roller skating rink of emotions as well. The Author definitely knows how to draw the reader in and take you in the adventure of the characters. That is one thing I absolutely love about this author. Cannot wait to read more from her in the near future.
August 5, 2024
I have been in love with this book since the first chapter. This story is full of drama, magic, intrigue, lore, heartbreak, death romance and so many emotions. Some touch her and 💀 oh and don’t forget the spice.
Galanta a witch, healer, herbalist and descendant of the green goddess.
Eachann the prince of the each uisge and is betrothed to another, but his beast has found his mate in Galanta and he will have no other.
They are both strong characters but when together, they are so much stronger.
Galanta a witch, healer, herbalist and descendant of the green goddess.
Eachann the prince of the each uisge and is betrothed to another, but his beast has found his mate in Galanta and he will have no other.
They are both strong characters but when together, they are so much stronger.
August 7, 2024
This was a gutwrenching and heartbreaking love story. A forbidden love that grew despite all the obstacles against them. Galanta was physically saved, but can she be mentally whole after what she has suffered. I did shed a few tears, I will admit at the end of book 1. Book 2 tortured my soul to read. A second chance wasted???? I think I cried the whole way through to the end. What an emotional journey. I voluntarily read a free copy of this book provided by book sirens and am giving an honest opinion.
August 11, 2024
This book took me places I never expected. The highs and lows between the two main characters were at times unexpected, yet well written.
I found myself feeling for her, and could identify with alot of the emotions she was working through. I was torn about my outlook on him for alot of the book.
Loved the way the story came together. Not many loose ends, nothing leaving me freling finished.
Would definitely recommend. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I found myself feeling for her, and could identify with alot of the emotions she was working through. I was torn about my outlook on him for alot of the book.
Loved the way the story came together. Not many loose ends, nothing leaving me freling finished.
Would definitely recommend. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews