8 years ago FBI agent Sarah Brightwater’s mother was murdered by a Dwight Spalding, a serial killer who also murdered 9 other single mothers. He was never caught and every time she’s sent out, she expects that it’s him.
2 bodies are dumped a week apart in a State Forrest not far from Sara’s home town. The corpses are rigorously cleaned in every possible way and the little finger of their left hand is missing.
The same day that she’s put on the case another body is found dumped next to the road from a driving car. Here the little finger is also cut off. Despite the many differences between both cases and Sarah’s gut feeling that this is a different killer, her bosses want to treat this as done by the same killer.
Tyler Ford a newspaper reporter receives letters from the alleged killer, who’s been dubbed ‘John the Baptist’. How unlikely this may sound, he and Sarah team up to discover what really is going on.
There’s an awful lot of twists, turns and the occasional bombshell that kept me guessing. Danny Kircher, Tyler’s intern was one of my first suspects. He came to the newspaper unexpectedly and is closely involved with the investigation. That’s something we have to look out for in this kind of stories, isn’t it? But then I thought, it’s too obvious, it can’t be this easy.
I thought ‘John the Baptist’ a very unusual and original alias for the killer. It sounds a lot better than ‘the pinkie thief’.
The story is told alternatingly from the POV of Tyler and Sarah. Despite their initial distrust and different interests (Sarah wants to catch the killer, while the journalist wants him caught as well his primary goal is to score an exclusive.) I doubt that reporters and FBI agents will team up and form such close bounds in real life, but for the sake of the story, it works as they’re both singled out by the murderer.
I don’t understand why the serial killers in books always have to play games with the police. Their pay off is to get away with murder without getting caught, so why would they give extra clues to police or newspapers. I know that it does happen in real life, but certainly not as frequent as writers make us think. But it makes a far more interesting story. And this murderer plays a long game that makes everything far more complicated than necessary.
Especially towards the end, things become very complicated and it all seems a bit far-fetched. That’s a shame as up to there the story was great. I was under the impression that the author tried to cramp in too many things into those last chapters. I understand that this might be necessary to connect the next books and this first one together as to form a firm base. I look forward to reading the next stories in this series.
I received a free ARC from the author; this is my honest and unbiased review of it.