TL;DR:
5/5, really great stories, each with a message hidden if you sit with them. Not always to one's liking, but always impressive.
I really enjoyed this collection of short stories. Not all of them grabbed me in the same way, but I liked every story had something to tell. Some stories have a better impact and demand your time to just let them sink in, but that largely depends on how much you liked the story in question. Some stories are about peoples view of themselves, others pose existential questions.
Sidenote: the additional artwork is stunning! Some drawings will be etched into my memory.
(English isn't my first language, so there may be some typo's in here...)
In total the book contains 12 stories en 2 poems. I’ll give my thoughts one each individual story:
#1 Two robots at the end of the world
5/5, amazing character work and a tragic tale. Will never forget it.
Read this during a rather long journey by train. Brought me to litteral tears once I finished it. Great tale, lot of lovely character in such a sort span of pages. To me, it was a story about relationship (kind of parental in this one) and about letting go. It’s also a tale about curiosity and its potential dangers.
#2 The life and death of Lucia’s library
4/5, not really for me, but a cool exporation on the everlasting presence of death.
This story gets alluded to on the back of the book and it has an interesting hook. Lucia’s family has a book that records the lifespan of every family member. Once a crow nestles on your branch, your time is up. It shows how family members each deal with death in their own way. Some follow previous genrations, some think death has taken enough… All in all a gripping dive into dealing with death.
#3 The exclusion clause in the small print of life
4,5/5, interesting story, but I can see how its message can be confusing.
Hope is a fickle thing, isn't it. When Silas, the janitor of a ship full of cryogenically frozen people, finds out that the planet they were heading towards isn't all it was promised to be, he has an impossible choice to make. You can see where the story is heading and it ends on a hopeful note. However, as most stories in this collection tend to do, you're left with a lingering thought about "what if this doesn't happen". To me, this is a story about finding purpose and hope.
#4 The funeralists; or hate in five parts (SPOILERS - just to be sure)
5/5, absolutely amazing. Only downside I can think of is that is a short story.
I watched a video on Tim's YouTube channel where he read pieces of this story and I was hooked immediately! This story, at least to me, is about humanity. About us as a species. The main character and her sisters are collectors of stories that will be forgotten ti time. Whenever a story, either on paper or stone tablet, get's destroyed, lost or otherwise forgotten, they are there. She starts of as a little naive, with eyes full of wonder. However, by the time World War Two comes around and she has to witness humans burning books in Germany, she turns resentful and bitter towards humanity and its ability to be so infinitely cruel. After what is arguably one of the more hard hitting parts in the snowy woods (iykyk). She learns to keep her spite and hate in a little pocket and to take it out when necessary. To be honest, this change came a little too soon. I would've liked more examples of the funeralist being spiteful of the stories she needs to collect. Eventually, the hate gets replaced with a more complex emotion, a great ending.
The footnotes really kick this story up a notch. It shows that this is a meta reading of the story before some earth ending catastrophe. How and why is unknown. They're a nice touch.
#5 Roger, go at throttle up
5/5 Loved it, greatly depends on your taste in poetry though.
A poem consisting of peoples last words. Fitting for this collection of stories. I haven't looked up any of these lines (just did a quick search and found out one was Marilyn Monroe's), but the notion that these were the last words uttered before people died hit me. Some lines in particular stay in your mind.
One tiny downside: there appear to be some words blacked out on purpose. I believe the reader is meant to see these filled in on the next page as a surprise, but some are already visible on the same page as the poem. Doesn't take away the impact, but was worth mentioning.
#6 Constellations of flesh, bone, and memory
3/5 maybe a little on the nose, didn't grab me as much as some others
To be blunt, this one reminded me of the Theseus Paradox... It probably isn't the intent, but still. Are you still the same person when most of you has been replaced? A good story, but ultimately not one of my favorites.
#7 A worm beneath the skin
5/5 hit me in the feels.
On the one hand a disclaimer about sensitive subject material would be nice, on the other hand it could unwillingly send you down a train of thought. As a teacher myself, this story had me gripped from the moment I learned the main character was a teacher. I read this as a story about self-harm and being unhappy with yourself or your life. Through her own experience the main character identifies similar behavior and tries to break the cycle she herself is trapped in. Intense story.
#8 On the beach of forgotten things
4/5 great tale about neglect and connection
This one took me by surprise. The emotional weight creeped up on me. At first I thought the little girl walked into the ocean herself, but it turns out it's something much worse (or is it?). I adore the concept of this story, but had to connect most dots myself and I am not sure I connected them correctly. It was more the idea of the story (a beach where all things forgotten wash up to be collected) than the story itself that I enjoyed. I give it a 4, because I am just not sure if the message it tries to convey actually lands. Still, great stuff.
#9 A thousand kinds of silence
5/5 amazing poem about parenthood and letting go
I am by no means a parent myself, but somehow I understood everything this poem had to say. I wanted to catch up with my own parents and grandparents immediately after finishing it. Written from the perspective of a parent, this grabs you and doesn't let go until the final stanza.
#10 Flight of the ten million moths
4/5 great tale about mysteries being, well, mysteries
Some things we'll never really understand. I feel like this idea is front and center in this story. A lot of questions are answered in it, but only to raise more questions. Read it, liked it, but didn't stick with me as much as other stories.
#11 Just dust in the light
3,5/5 an interesting story about projected importance and religion
There is something very cruel about the randomness of death. The twin brother of the main character died in a collapse just when he had something to tell his sister. Before they could speak he died. The entire story is about her search for his diary, so she can find out what he wanted te tell her. I won't spoil the contents of the diary, but will tell you that just having it is more important.
Underneath this search is a discussion on religion and how one loses it, once they don't think it's important anymore. This leaves the reader with some questions about what is actually important and what not.
Or maybe I am reading to much into it... (no pun intended).
#12 Panstellar
4/5 A little confusing at times, but still amazing
This is a story with tho sides to it. One side is about the main character's quest for knowledge about why the stars are going out and her desire to stop it. The other side is about two cosmic (?) beings observing this character hoping she can figure out how to stop it. It throws up ethical questions about experimenting and the - considering most stories, highly negative - outcome of said experiment.
The way both sides intercut throughout the story can be a little confusing. Once you get a grip on it, it's a really cool story.
#13 Trickle down lobotomies
4,5/5 easily the longest story of the collection, you kinda feel that
A lot of fiction dives into the question of what would happen if men became God. Some are comedies (looking at you, Bruce Almighty) and some are Trickle down lobotomies. This story has utilitarianism literally written all over it. It also, strangely, reads as a critique of raging capitalism, before it becomes a story about reworking yourself just so you can be happy with the certain circumstances.
Once this message settles in, the story starts to drag a little bit. As the reader, you can feel where this is going. Chekhov's gun certainly doesn't miss in this one.
#14 A catalogue for the end of humanity
4/5 short but interesting. Reminded me of the end of Matt Smith's doctor who.
"We are all different people all through our lives" is one of the lines by Matt Smith's eleventh doctor before regenerating into a new person. This story reminded me of this a lot. If you could choose an archetype version of yourself from a previous chapter, who would you choose? The child, the battle-hardened soldier or your current self. Liked the concept, but had my suspicions on which version the character would choose.
There you have it. Would love to know what others fought and what your takeaways are on the individual stories!