When I first heard about this I jumped at the chance to read it, with it having numerous ingredients to whet my appetite to the point where I was salivating: heavy metal, demonic forces, a hedonistic band as the main protagonists, Catholic-bashing, and Vietnam, the most rock 'n' roll of all wars (at least in fiction, obvs in real life all war just flat-out sucks!!). And having read the Book of the Dead Vol. 1 & 2 as a feral child, I knew that The Scream wasn't going to skimp on the gory carnage when things go south.
So why only 3 stars? Well, to be fair, it isn't the story, the characters, or the "gory carnage" the latter of which you get in spades, but my own opinion of the first half of the book. It opens very well, and yanked my attention like two cold hands roughly gripping my cheeks, but somewhere not long afterwards I personally felt as though the plot meandered a little, however, I'm not sure if that's entirely accurate, I think the issue might have been the overwriting which tended to pop up here and there in various chapters, repeatedly derailing my attention, and therefore enjoyment of the advancing plot. This being a purely subjective criticism, I MUST point out that other readers might love the prose (and there really is some lovely writing here, I just think the editor should have reined in the language on occasion), and the story itself was very enjoyable: Jake Hamer is a tortured 'Nam vet and lead singer, who along with fellow ex-soldier and sax player Hempstead, are two members of the top-flight metal band, the Jacob Hamer Band, who along with the eponymous The Scream, and the rest of the '80's headbanging enthusiasts, find themselves targeted as the sinful, evil pariahs of youthful corruption by the hypocritical Pastor Furniss and his brainless and bible-thumping masses. However, The Scream are the real deal, they are sinful, they are evil, and their music truly is the product of the Devil.
Despite my wandering attention, from the mid-point on, this book really took off, and was very entertaining, all culminating in a truly great and blood-drenched climax, and as somebody who loves their horror stories to end with a satisfying body count I can't fault the finale.
In fact, screw it, playing it back in my head, I'm upping it to 4 stars. \m/