What do you think?
Rate this book
The Witching Wind
Eleven-year-old Roxie was excited to start sixth grade... until a mortifying incident at a pool party turns her into a middle school laughingstock. Roxie can't imagine enduring a full year of bullying and body shaming, so when her country music star Granny invites Roxie to join her on tour, she jumps at the chance to leave her troubles behind. But then Granny--who's been struggling with memory loss--goes missing, leaving Roxie without an escape plan... and without her best friend.
Grayson doesn't mind being sent to yet another foster home. Her older sister, Beanie, is about to turn eighteen, which means she'll be able to become Grayson's guardian. It won't be long until they live in the same house again. It won't be long until they get to be a real family. But when Beanie's birthday finally arrives, she doesn't show up to collect Grayson. She doesn't respond to calls or texts. It's almost like she's just... vanished.
Roxie knows Granny would never leave without saying goodbye. And Grayson is certain Beanie would never abandon her. So when the new friend learn about the Witching Wind that "steals" what people love most, Roxie and Grayson are certain they've discovered the truth. Granny and Beanie didn't just disappear--they were taken. And it's up to Roxie and Grayson to outwit the Witching Wind before it's too late.
Grayson doesn't mind being sent to yet another foster home. Her older sister, Beanie, is about to turn eighteen, which means she'll be able to become Grayson's guardian. It won't be long until they live in the same house again. It won't be long until they get to be a real family. But when Beanie's birthday finally arrives, she doesn't show up to collect Grayson. She doesn't respond to calls or texts. It's almost like she's just... vanished.
Roxie knows Granny would never leave without saying goodbye. And Grayson is certain Beanie would never abandon her. So when the new friend learn about the Witching Wind that "steals" what people love most, Roxie and Grayson are certain they've discovered the truth. Granny and Beanie didn't just disappear--they were taken. And it's up to Roxie and Grayson to outwit the Witching Wind before it's too late.
349 pages, Hardcover
First published September 3, 2024
42 people are currently reading
6370 people want to read
About the author
Natalie Lloyd
13 books533 followersNatalie Lloyd is the New York Times Bestselling Author of novels for young readers (and the young at heart).
Her first novel, A Snicker of Magic (2014), was an ALA Notable Book, a New York Times Book Review Editors’ Choice, a top 10 Kids Indie Next Pick and an NPR, iBooks and Parents Magazine best book of the year for children. The book has been optioned for television by Sony Tristar. Natalie’s other novels include The Key to Extraordinary (Scholastic 2016), The Problim Children series (HarperCollins/Katherine Tegen 2017), and Over the Moon (Scholastic 2019). These novels have won accolades from Entertainment Weekly, Junior Library Guild, SIBA, Amazon and Bank Street College of Education, among others. Silverswift, her first Audible Original, was published in 2020. Hummingbird, her seventh (and most personal) novel for kids, was published in August 2022. In January 2023, it was awarded a Schneider Family Honor Award by the American Library Association. Her next novel, The Witching Wind, will be available in Fall 2024.
Natalie writes in the shadows beside a sunny window in Chattanooga, Tennessee. She loves adventuring with her husband, Justin, and their dogs.
Her first novel, A Snicker of Magic (2014), was an ALA Notable Book, a New York Times Book Review Editors’ Choice, a top 10 Kids Indie Next Pick and an NPR, iBooks and Parents Magazine best book of the year for children. The book has been optioned for television by Sony Tristar. Natalie’s other novels include The Key to Extraordinary (Scholastic 2016), The Problim Children series (HarperCollins/Katherine Tegen 2017), and Over the Moon (Scholastic 2019). These novels have won accolades from Entertainment Weekly, Junior Library Guild, SIBA, Amazon and Bank Street College of Education, among others. Silverswift, her first Audible Original, was published in 2020. Hummingbird, her seventh (and most personal) novel for kids, was published in August 2022. In January 2023, it was awarded a Schneider Family Honor Award by the American Library Association. Her next novel, The Witching Wind, will be available in Fall 2024.
Natalie writes in the shadows beside a sunny window in Chattanooga, Tennessee. She loves adventuring with her husband, Justin, and their dogs.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews
November 18, 2024
I went in expecting a book about witches, because of the title and synopsis, and came out charmed by a story about friendships and family. The magic here is delicate and ephemeral, but the story about growing up and finding out who you are is powerful.
June 3, 2024
The Witching Wind is a middle-grade magical realism novel based around a magical wind that blows in with a monarch butterfly as the only warning to batten down the hatches. The story follows two girls, one who is disabled and a foster child, the other who is just trying to navigate entry into middle school and the loss of friendships. The representation in this book will impact the students who read it as well as the adults who share it with them. The Witching Wind touches on all the things middle school-aged children struggle with bullying, body shaming, missing people, strokes, loss of grandparents, older siblings moving on, and so much more. One thing that irked me was the lack of closure for Beanie and her sister Grayson; Grayson spends the whole novel waiting for her older sister to come and be a family with her, and I get the age difference and wanting not to have the responsibility of raising a younger disabled sister from how Grayson talked about the love and connection the two sisters had I expected a final conversation from Beanie explaining her side of the story. The Witching Wind will be a great read to share when it releases in September 2024.
July 6, 2025
**Book Review: The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd**
Natalie Lloyd has a way of weaving magic into her stories, and The Witching Wind is no exception. The enchanting charm that captivated readers in her previous works is definitely present here. The interwoven stories of Roxie and Grayson are heartfelt and moving, their journey together touching on themes of friendship, courage, and self-discovery. The friendships they form with others throughout the book evoke memories of the Daisy Brigade from The Key to Extraordinary- a group of characters who feel like old friends by the end.
Lloyd’s signature elements are back, too—crows, wind, and flowers play important roles in the story, reminding me of why The Key to Extraordinary remains my favorite of her books. These natural elements add an extra layer of magic and mystery to the tale, making it all the more special.
However, I did find the book to be a bit lengthy. While the story is rich and engaging, I felt it could have been trimmed down to maintain a tighter pace. Some sections dragged a little, making it feel longer than necessary.
That said, I still found myself deeply moved by the book. Lloyd's exploration of friendship and the bonds of family had me wiping away tears on more than one occasion. The Witching Wind is a story filled with warmth, heart, and the kind of magic that leaves a lasting impression.
3.5 stars
***I won an ARC through a giveaway and my review is that of the ARC, not the final version. ***
Natalie Lloyd has a way of weaving magic into her stories, and The Witching Wind is no exception. The enchanting charm that captivated readers in her previous works is definitely present here. The interwoven stories of Roxie and Grayson are heartfelt and moving, their journey together touching on themes of friendship, courage, and self-discovery. The friendships they form with others throughout the book evoke memories of the Daisy Brigade from The Key to Extraordinary- a group of characters who feel like old friends by the end.
Lloyd’s signature elements are back, too—crows, wind, and flowers play important roles in the story, reminding me of why The Key to Extraordinary remains my favorite of her books. These natural elements add an extra layer of magic and mystery to the tale, making it all the more special.
However, I did find the book to be a bit lengthy. While the story is rich and engaging, I felt it could have been trimmed down to maintain a tighter pace. Some sections dragged a little, making it feel longer than necessary.
That said, I still found myself deeply moved by the book. Lloyd's exploration of friendship and the bonds of family had me wiping away tears on more than one occasion. The Witching Wind is a story filled with warmth, heart, and the kind of magic that leaves a lasting impression.
3.5 stars
***I won an ARC through a giveaway and my review is that of the ARC, not the final version. ***
September 22, 2024
Not quite meeting the high bar of Hummingbird, but still lovely. A charming, heartfelt novel with a touch of magic about finding your people. The main characters were well-drawn, and the grandmother storyline was particularly poignant & a good introduction to kids who may be navigating the onset of dementia for an aging loved one.
July 19, 2025
Magical and such a good read.
June 27, 2024
These characters! Their stories! The legends and folklore behind the Witching Wind!
The storytelling by Natalie Lloyd is just magical!
This book has heart and meaning while helping to deliver some truths about life and what it means to be a human in this world. It is also adventurous and honors those deep and special friend groups you can form (for me especially so in middle school like the characters).
One I will for sure recommend to my students and add to my library collection.
The storytelling by Natalie Lloyd is just magical!
This book has heart and meaning while helping to deliver some truths about life and what it means to be a human in this world. It is also adventurous and honors those deep and special friend groups you can form (for me especially so in middle school like the characters).
One I will for sure recommend to my students and add to my library collection.
September 12, 2024
No one writes heartwarming and magical stories quite like Natalie Lloyd. The Witching Wind is wonderful.
March 17, 2024
“Love’s the only magic worth anything, Roxie.”
💨
Roxie was so excited to start sixth grade, until an embarrassing incident leaves her feeling sad and lonely. Her Granny is her favorite person and they make a deal to go out on tour together, that way Roxie can escape the ridicule she’s sure to face on the first day of school. Unfortunately before they can leave, Granny goes missing. Grayson is headed to a new foster home, again. Only this time she only has to be there for two days until her sister, Beanie, turns eighteen and can take care of her. But when Beanie never shows up, Grayson is convinced she vanished. Both girls find it odd that their loved ones both went missing on the same day that the Witching Wind was the worst it’s been in years. Did the wind take them away and how can Grayson and Roxie get them back?
🌪️
Oh, my heart. If there’s one author who can win the prize for best MG magical realism I’m giving it to the amazing @natalielloydbooks She writes with such heart; it was pouring from every page because she has such a great heart. The representation in this book will make such an impact on the students who read it (and the adults too). This novel releases September 17 and I can’t wait to book talk it to my readers!
I received a free copy for an honest review. @scholastic
CW: physical disability, bullying, body shaming, missing person, stroke, hospitalization, memory loss, abandonment, adoption, fostering
💨
Roxie was so excited to start sixth grade, until an embarrassing incident leaves her feeling sad and lonely. Her Granny is her favorite person and they make a deal to go out on tour together, that way Roxie can escape the ridicule she’s sure to face on the first day of school. Unfortunately before they can leave, Granny goes missing. Grayson is headed to a new foster home, again. Only this time she only has to be there for two days until her sister, Beanie, turns eighteen and can take care of her. But when Beanie never shows up, Grayson is convinced she vanished. Both girls find it odd that their loved ones both went missing on the same day that the Witching Wind was the worst it’s been in years. Did the wind take them away and how can Grayson and Roxie get them back?
🌪️
Oh, my heart. If there’s one author who can win the prize for best MG magical realism I’m giving it to the amazing @natalielloydbooks She writes with such heart; it was pouring from every page because she has such a great heart. The representation in this book will make such an impact on the students who read it (and the adults too). This novel releases September 17 and I can’t wait to book talk it to my readers!
I received a free copy for an honest review. @scholastic
CW: physical disability, bullying, body shaming, missing person, stroke, hospitalization, memory loss, abandonment, adoption, fostering
January 9, 2025
Grayson Patch is my favorite Natalie Lloyd character yet. I love her outlook on life!!
September 16, 2024
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd has Roxie and Grayson trying to find their loved ones.
Will Roxie and Grayson save Granny and Beanie from the Witching Wind?
Roxie Darling
Roxie Darling is twelve years old, and she's not having a great start on her middle grade experience. She's already been bullied by the most popular girl in their class, and she doesn't know why. Not only that, but Roxie's Granny has gone missing. Besides that, the young girl is now shy, unlike how she was before being bullied. Roxie is resilient, though. I like Roxie and how she deals with everything happening to her.
Grayson Patch
Grayson Patch is in the same grade as Roxie, but unlike Roxie, Grayson is in foster care. She also needs a walker to get around because her bones are brittle, and she's small for her age. I do feel bad for Grayson for a lot that she has to endure. Grayson is one of those characters who doesn't care about what anyone thinks of her. She has one of those faces where she looks mad when she isn't. I do like Grayson and how she figures out a lot about herself.
The Story
Roxie and Grayson, and four other characters become the least likely friends. This group of friends help each other navigate the treachery of middle school in the first couple of weeks. Roxie, Grayson, and their friends also help each other get the stuff they lost to the wind. I loved Roxie and Grayson's friends since they helped each other out a lot and trusted each other. Another thing that I liked was how easily they got along and brought each other up when they were down or convinced someone that a guy like likes them.
Four Stars
The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd brings together a bunch of people that one wouldn't think could be friends and has them solve the mystery of the Witching Wind. I loved this story a lot, and I give it four stars. Ms. Lloyd is a great author, and this book brought back memories of sixth grade and how having a group of friends that has your back is worth it to stand up to a bully.
Thank you for dropping by! I hope you enjoyed this review of The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd.
Until the next time,
Happy Reading!
This review was originally posted on Baroness' Book Trove
The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd has Roxie and Grayson trying to find their loved ones.
Will Roxie and Grayson save Granny and Beanie from the Witching Wind?
Roxie Darling
Roxie Darling is twelve years old, and she's not having a great start on her middle grade experience. She's already been bullied by the most popular girl in their class, and she doesn't know why. Not only that, but Roxie's Granny has gone missing. Besides that, the young girl is now shy, unlike how she was before being bullied. Roxie is resilient, though. I like Roxie and how she deals with everything happening to her.
Grayson Patch
Grayson Patch is in the same grade as Roxie, but unlike Roxie, Grayson is in foster care. She also needs a walker to get around because her bones are brittle, and she's small for her age. I do feel bad for Grayson for a lot that she has to endure. Grayson is one of those characters who doesn't care about what anyone thinks of her. She has one of those faces where she looks mad when she isn't. I do like Grayson and how she figures out a lot about herself.
The Story
Roxie and Grayson, and four other characters become the least likely friends. This group of friends help each other navigate the treachery of middle school in the first couple of weeks. Roxie, Grayson, and their friends also help each other get the stuff they lost to the wind. I loved Roxie and Grayson's friends since they helped each other out a lot and trusted each other. Another thing that I liked was how easily they got along and brought each other up when they were down or convinced someone that a guy like likes them.
Four Stars
The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd brings together a bunch of people that one wouldn't think could be friends and has them solve the mystery of the Witching Wind. I loved this story a lot, and I give it four stars. Ms. Lloyd is a great author, and this book brought back memories of sixth grade and how having a group of friends that has your back is worth it to stand up to a bully.
Thank you for dropping by! I hope you enjoyed this review of The Witching Wind by Natalie Lloyd.
Until the next time,
Happy Reading!
This review was originally posted on Baroness' Book Trove
June 26, 2024
It’s been a rainy week, but for those of us who are bookworms, we’ve used some of the extra time inside as an excuse to READ! Natalie Lloyd’s Hummingbird is one of my top 10 of all time, so curling up with an ARC of The Witching Wind is such a joy that I can’t even begin to describe it. 💕
- - -
“There are so many things in the world powerful people can control, but weather isn’t one of them. And Grayson thinks that’s kinda profound—no matter how strong or rich or powerful you are, the wind can still take you down anytime it wants.”
“Sometimes I wonder if dogs are the way God hugs us while we’re here on earth.”
“I’ll wait in the darkness for you.”
“I don’t think people always realize how loud whispers can be. How your heart’s hearing is even better than your ears.”
“You okay?”
“Oh yeah. Your party was really fun. And I don’t typically like parties.”
“Same,” Grayson says.
party. I love dogs. I tolerate people.”
“Do you have a dog?”
She shakes her head. “I wish. No pets yet, but that’s one of my life goals— to love and be loved by a dog.” When Grayson Elizabeth Palmetto Patch says these true and perfect words, I make a decision: I will be her friend. She will be mine. Anybody who believes that truth, which is surely one of the best in the universe, is the kind of person I want to know.
“You gotta shine. Then shine a little harder.“
“You’re freaking fearless.”
If you have a sister, you’ll do anything -anything- to get her back with you.”
“Doesn’t the world know how to be sad? Stupid, stupid sunshine.”
“The real magic was the people who came to the mountain. The ones brave enough to believe they mattered, even when people told them they didn’t. The ones who knew they had a story to tell. Or who believed their story would get better.”
“There’s always somebody who will try to silence your story. But there is also, always, somebody who wants to hear it. Somebody who’ll give you a safe place to sit. And share. And send your words into the world, however you want them said.”
“Gone from this world? A while now. Gone from here?” She taps her heart. “Never.“
“Love is just bigger than all the bad stuff.”
- - -
“There are so many things in the world powerful people can control, but weather isn’t one of them. And Grayson thinks that’s kinda profound—no matter how strong or rich or powerful you are, the wind can still take you down anytime it wants.”
“Sometimes I wonder if dogs are the way God hugs us while we’re here on earth.”
“I’ll wait in the darkness for you.”
“I don’t think people always realize how loud whispers can be. How your heart’s hearing is even better than your ears.”
“You okay?”
“Oh yeah. Your party was really fun. And I don’t typically like parties.”
“Same,” Grayson says.
party. I love dogs. I tolerate people.”
“Do you have a dog?”
She shakes her head. “I wish. No pets yet, but that’s one of my life goals— to love and be loved by a dog.” When Grayson Elizabeth Palmetto Patch says these true and perfect words, I make a decision: I will be her friend. She will be mine. Anybody who believes that truth, which is surely one of the best in the universe, is the kind of person I want to know.
“You gotta shine. Then shine a little harder.“
“You’re freaking fearless.”
If you have a sister, you’ll do anything -anything- to get her back with you.”
“Doesn’t the world know how to be sad? Stupid, stupid sunshine.”
“The real magic was the people who came to the mountain. The ones brave enough to believe they mattered, even when people told them they didn’t. The ones who knew they had a story to tell. Or who believed their story would get better.”
“There’s always somebody who will try to silence your story. But there is also, always, somebody who wants to hear it. Somebody who’ll give you a safe place to sit. And share. And send your words into the world, however you want them said.”
“Gone from this world? A while now. Gone from here?” She taps her heart. “Never.“
“Love is just bigger than all the bad stuff.”
December 18, 2025
I loved how well this book straddled the line between fantasy fiction and magical realism. This book gave me so much more than I expected going into it. I loved the characters, the story, and all the magical elements woven throughout.
It also provided a refreshing perspective on dealing with bullies. *Spoiler* In the end, Roxie neither retaliates nor seeks revenge, unlike many middle-grade books. I loved that choice. I also love the moment when she and Grayson carabiner together. That made me cry a bit. Told in alternating voices and chapters, this story deeply moved me.
"Love's the only magic worth anything."
It also provided a refreshing perspective on dealing with bullies. *Spoiler* In the end, Roxie neither retaliates nor seeks revenge, unlike many middle-grade books. I loved that choice. I also love the moment when she and Grayson carabiner together. That made me cry a bit. Told in alternating voices and chapters, this story deeply moved me.
"Love's the only magic worth anything."
August 28, 2024
Natalie Lloyd's books are the literary equivalent of your grandmama’s blueberry crunch cobbler fresh out of the oven. They’re a little bit magic and a whole lotta heart.
Roxie and Grayson will tug at your heartstrings with their inner strength and innate kindness even when the world is throwing hard things at them. And that pilfering Witching Wind will definitely steal your heart and fill it up with hope.
Roxie and Grayson will tug at your heartstrings with their inner strength and innate kindness even when the world is throwing hard things at them. And that pilfering Witching Wind will definitely steal your heart and fill it up with hope.
August 16, 2025
I adore Natalie Lloyd’s writing style and her ability to create the sweetest characters and friendships. The found family in her stories is so sweet. She has such a sweet voice to narrate her books as well. This story definitely didn’t end where I thought it would, but it was all the better for it. If I would have read this one instead of listening to audio there would have been so many parts I would have highlighted! Her stories are so sweet.
December 5, 2024
I think I've said this about EVERY book that Natalie Lloyd wrote and I'm going to say it again. She is an AMAZING author. I loved this book, it was beautiful. It makes you cry, laugh, and want to scream at certain characters. If I could get a mentor in creative writing, the first person I would want to go to is Natalie Lloyd. (Sorry if that sounds weird)
October 17, 2024
Natalie Lloyd is magical! The Witching Wind once again has characters, Roxie and Grayson, who find a place in our hearts. They will stick with me for a long time. Highly recommend reading her latest novel!
October 28, 2024
Natalie Lloyd’s brand of magic always feels so organic and unique. The Witching Wind is no exception! Grayson, Roxie and their friends are so sweet and supportive of each other. I loved that what they found wasn’t quite what they spent so long looking for, but each was exactly what they needed. 🦋
April 1, 2025
For myself, this would be closer to a 3 star read but I’m giving it 4 stars because I think it will resonate with its middle grade target audience.
May 14, 2025
I keep trying and keep continuing to dislike magical realism.
It would have been just fine without it.
It would have been just fine without it.
December 7, 2024
Magic exists in Natalie’s books. Her words inspire imagination and hope. I felt that there was a bit of Snicker and Hummingbird in this novel, and for that, I’m grateful.
September 16, 2025
Not at all what I thought this book was going to be like. It is so good!! 😭 Yes, it's about 6th graders trying to find their way in middle school, but the messages of self-worth, family, and love are good for people of all ages. I listened to the audiobook. It was very well narrated.
November 17, 2024
This was so beautiful and moving, an amazing adventure filled with wonderful characters who felt so real to me. I'm sitting here crying after finishing it. I borrowed this from my library and now I think I have to buy a copy because it was so wonderful. Roxie and Grayson have my heart forever.
October 2, 2024
My favorite Lloyd has written yet!!
March 14, 2025
Okay but can we talk about how I basically just sobbed for the last 10% of this book?
Natalie writes so beautifully, both about her characters and the world around them. She makes these characters who you hope are real. You hope there are people who are just good for the sake of being good out there.
I loved Gray and Roxie so much. So SO much. They were two completely different young women who both needed a little of the other to make themselves complete. Their friend group by the end of the book was just an adorable group that I loved watching on page.
Natalie also always gives us a diverse cast of characters and I love the way she tells the story of her differently abled characters. This is so important (especially in mid-grade) to not only give these kids a way to see themselves represented in the media they love to consume, but also to help other kids learn that just because someone doesn't have the same abilities as we do, doesn't mean that they're any less of a person. And she shows how strong these kids can be when they stick together and learn to love themselves and see the beauty in those around them.
I will forever and always continue to pick up Lloyd's books. And probably sob during those too.
Natalie writes so beautifully, both about her characters and the world around them. She makes these characters who you hope are real. You hope there are people who are just good for the sake of being good out there.
I loved Gray and Roxie so much. So SO much. They were two completely different young women who both needed a little of the other to make themselves complete. Their friend group by the end of the book was just an adorable group that I loved watching on page.
Natalie also always gives us a diverse cast of characters and I love the way she tells the story of her differently abled characters. This is so important (especially in mid-grade) to not only give these kids a way to see themselves represented in the media they love to consume, but also to help other kids learn that just because someone doesn't have the same abilities as we do, doesn't mean that they're any less of a person. And she shows how strong these kids can be when they stick together and learn to love themselves and see the beauty in those around them.
I will forever and always continue to pick up Lloyd's books. And probably sob during those too.
July 20, 2024
Natalie Lloyd is an absolute magician.
October 18, 2024
Some narrative structure issues and some major slumps in momentum, but very cute and sweet.
October 3, 2025
Silas County has unusual storms of super strong winds called the Witching Wind. There are special sirens and alerts for it, locals all wear carbineers to keep themselves and their belongings secure when the lower winds whip up, and know to run for shelter when the higher ones are coming. (If a butterfly shows up, it is time to run.) The wind definitely takes things each time it goes through, and there are rumors that the wind can steal people too, and it takes them to a cave up in the mountains. Grayson Patch is new to town. She’s not bothering to really settle in at school, even if the Welcome Wagon Club she was forced to join is kind of surprising cool with a group of kids she likes, nor is she getting comfortable with her new foster family (even if they are surprisingly nice) because on Saturday her older sister Beanie turns 18 and she’s going to move to New York City with her. But Beanie’s birthday comes and goes, and Grayson is still there. But others aren’t.
Roxie has had a rough start to the schoolyear. An incident at the pool party for 6th graders has her feeling self-conscious and wishing she didn’t have to go to school (except for club time, which is a respite from the rest). And then her beloved Grannie goes missing after the most recent wind, even though Grannie promised to take Roxie on a tour with her very soon.
Soon the Welcome Wagon Club kids are convinced they can find Grayson’s sister, Roxie’s grandma, a missing cat, some tomato plants, and more if they can find the legendary cave where the Witching Wind takes things. In the process, they may find something else entirely.
Natalie Lloyd once again weaves a story with heart, about finding healing, and being stronger with a loving community around you. The town feels mostly realistic except for a few touches of magic. The club at school is basically a catchall for the kids who don’t make the cut/signed up too late for the more popular clubs, but it turns out to be just what this group of kids needs. They are so good for each other. Grayson is a foster kid with a tough exterior but a good heart way deep down. She also has brittle bone syndrome and uses a walker. (And I love her foster family who are kind Christians, not pushy, but authentic.) Roxie didn’t slim down as puberty hit and she feels uncomfortable in her own skin, especially as she has a bully harassing her. Her Grannie going missing helps her find a bit more confidence, and Grayson and gang really help. Ernie, a boy in the club is in a wheelchair. Ameera is new in town and Muslim (which is unusual in a small Appalachian town). And Eli lives in the rich part of town but is very down to earth and kind. These kids break down all sorts of barriers in the friendships they form. As they chase the wind they discover the origin of the Witching Wind legends, and find a beautiful story there too. Overall, another heartwarming, feel-good read from Natalie Lloyd.
Notes on content:
Language: None
Sexual content: None
Violence: People are in danger from the storm, but no one is seriously hurt.
Ethnic diversity: Most of the town are white Appalachian Americans, but there are some people of color like Ameerah who is of Middle Eastern heritage, one of the kids uses a walker, and another uses a wheelchair. Characters come from a variety of religious backgrounds (all are portrayed respectfully).
LGBTQ+ content: None specified
Other: There’s some online and in-person verbal bullying. Several of the kids feel unwanted and unseen. Lots of battling insecurity.
Roxie has had a rough start to the schoolyear. An incident at the pool party for 6th graders has her feeling self-conscious and wishing she didn’t have to go to school (except for club time, which is a respite from the rest). And then her beloved Grannie goes missing after the most recent wind, even though Grannie promised to take Roxie on a tour with her very soon.
Soon the Welcome Wagon Club kids are convinced they can find Grayson’s sister, Roxie’s grandma, a missing cat, some tomato plants, and more if they can find the legendary cave where the Witching Wind takes things. In the process, they may find something else entirely.
Natalie Lloyd once again weaves a story with heart, about finding healing, and being stronger with a loving community around you. The town feels mostly realistic except for a few touches of magic. The club at school is basically a catchall for the kids who don’t make the cut/signed up too late for the more popular clubs, but it turns out to be just what this group of kids needs. They are so good for each other. Grayson is a foster kid with a tough exterior but a good heart way deep down. She also has brittle bone syndrome and uses a walker. (And I love her foster family who are kind Christians, not pushy, but authentic.) Roxie didn’t slim down as puberty hit and she feels uncomfortable in her own skin, especially as she has a bully harassing her. Her Grannie going missing helps her find a bit more confidence, and Grayson and gang really help. Ernie, a boy in the club is in a wheelchair. Ameera is new in town and Muslim (which is unusual in a small Appalachian town). And Eli lives in the rich part of town but is very down to earth and kind. These kids break down all sorts of barriers in the friendships they form. As they chase the wind they discover the origin of the Witching Wind legends, and find a beautiful story there too. Overall, another heartwarming, feel-good read from Natalie Lloyd.
Notes on content:
Language: None
Sexual content: None
Violence: People are in danger from the storm, but no one is seriously hurt.
Ethnic diversity: Most of the town are white Appalachian Americans, but there are some people of color like Ameerah who is of Middle Eastern heritage, one of the kids uses a walker, and another uses a wheelchair. Characters come from a variety of religious backgrounds (all are portrayed respectfully).
LGBTQ+ content: None specified
Other: There’s some online and in-person verbal bullying. Several of the kids feel unwanted and unseen. Lots of battling insecurity.
September 19, 2024
“She imagines her heart, broken. Covered in crackly fault lines. But love still shines, even through the broken places. There’s plenty of love-light to share, too. So that’s what she does.”
This is another magical realism book from Lloyd, and the things that often shine in her books are present in spades here.
First is the characters. Every character in this book shines, even some characters that never have “on-screen” time and are only mentioned. The side characters, even a toddler and the elementary school librarian, come to life and make everything feel like I could be put right in the middle of their school and point out the people I recognize. I also loved how while the grown-ups are flawed, they aren’t completely useless either. Parents tell kids they want to hear what their kid is struggling with, and adults listen when they point out things that need work.
Our two main characters are different, with different voices, personalities, and struggles. I often struggle with books with multiple POVs because it’s often hard for me to distinguish between them, but that isn’t the case here. Grayson manages to have an incredibly positive attitude despite her many disappointments and setbacks. Roxie is self-conscious and sad about what happened with her ex-best friend. Both need people to understand them beyond their defense mechanisms, and the way they view each other in their respective points of view help build the characters in a way you don’t often get to see in a single POV book.
The kids in this book might get to see some magical happenings, but they aren’t spared from how hard life can be. They’re dealing with body shaming, missing family members, growing up, disabilities, and class in the rural Appalachian Tennessee background. They have to learn how to deal with grief when what they’re hoping for isn’t magically solved.
The magic in this book doesn’t cure or fix, which is something I love. Too often, the magic comes in and solves all the problems. In this case, the magic helps them understand themselves and life a little better. The magic is well balanced with the real world, so I was never confused about what might be magic and what wasn’t, which can be tricky in magical realism books. The magic also fits well with the setting. Families having a “knack” for certain things is exactly the kind of magic that fits so well in Appalachia.
The other thing I can’t help but love is Natalie Lloyd’s prose. I often find myself highlighting sentences because they’re just so beautiful. I still think of one particular line from “A Snicker of Magic,” and I think there are a few sentences from this book that might stick in my head too.
Occasionally, the book was a little too sweet and idealistic for me as an adult reader, but I think it will resonate well with many readers.
Overall, this is another magically sweet story about things that are missing and finding ourselves.
This is another magical realism book from Lloyd, and the things that often shine in her books are present in spades here.
First is the characters. Every character in this book shines, even some characters that never have “on-screen” time and are only mentioned. The side characters, even a toddler and the elementary school librarian, come to life and make everything feel like I could be put right in the middle of their school and point out the people I recognize. I also loved how while the grown-ups are flawed, they aren’t completely useless either. Parents tell kids they want to hear what their kid is struggling with, and adults listen when they point out things that need work.
Our two main characters are different, with different voices, personalities, and struggles. I often struggle with books with multiple POVs because it’s often hard for me to distinguish between them, but that isn’t the case here. Grayson manages to have an incredibly positive attitude despite her many disappointments and setbacks. Roxie is self-conscious and sad about what happened with her ex-best friend. Both need people to understand them beyond their defense mechanisms, and the way they view each other in their respective points of view help build the characters in a way you don’t often get to see in a single POV book.
The kids in this book might get to see some magical happenings, but they aren’t spared from how hard life can be. They’re dealing with body shaming, missing family members, growing up, disabilities, and class in the rural Appalachian Tennessee background. They have to learn how to deal with grief when what they’re hoping for isn’t magically solved.
The magic in this book doesn’t cure or fix, which is something I love. Too often, the magic comes in and solves all the problems. In this case, the magic helps them understand themselves and life a little better. The magic is well balanced with the real world, so I was never confused about what might be magic and what wasn’t, which can be tricky in magical realism books. The magic also fits well with the setting. Families having a “knack” for certain things is exactly the kind of magic that fits so well in Appalachia.
The other thing I can’t help but love is Natalie Lloyd’s prose. I often find myself highlighting sentences because they’re just so beautiful. I still think of one particular line from “A Snicker of Magic,” and I think there are a few sentences from this book that might stick in my head too.
Occasionally, the book was a little too sweet and idealistic for me as an adult reader, but I think it will resonate well with many readers.
Overall, this is another magically sweet story about things that are missing and finding ourselves.
May 27, 2024
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
Roxie Darling's grandmother, Ruthie Diamond Darling, was a folk singer when she was younger, and Roxie wants to follow in her footsteps. Since Ruthie wants to hit the road again, Roxie is excited, especially after an unfortunate incident at a school pool party has left her feeling "less than" and caused her to be estranged from her best friend, Loretta. Grayson Patch also has a complicated life; she's in foster care and uses a walker because of her brittle bone disease, but she is hopeful that her older sister Beanie will connect with her on the sister's 18th birthday, and the two will get an apartment in New York City together. For now, Grayson is being cared for by the Cottons, who have a three year old daughter, Freya. In the girls' Tennessee town, there is a Witching Wind that causes a lot of distress, and this season has seen more and stronger winds pummel the town. When Granny Ruth goes missing, Roxie's cousin Collette (along with her pet groundhog) helps Roxie look for her, and also tells Roxie some of the history of the wind, which is tied to the True sisters who lived on Monarch Mountain. Grayson struggles with the fact that her sister won't text her back, and reaches out to a social worker, Donna for help. At school, the girls realize that they are both dealing with someone who is missing, as well as unfriendly people at school, and end up together with a supportive group called the Yeehaws. After Granny Ruth, is found in the woods, she doesn't remember Roxie. The medical professionals claim that she had a stroke, but Roxie is determined that the wind has stolen her memories. The Yeehaws plans a camping trip on the mountain to find out the secret of the Whispering Wind. The Cottons agree to let Grayson go. Roxie is also struggling with her self esteem, and is given negative messages about her weight again and again, especially by school personnel. She gets better messages from Grayson, who informs her that "every body is a swimsuit body". Once on the mountain, Roxie meets Addison True, who says that Ruth had visited her recently in order to obtain something for Roxie. Will Roxie be able to find out the truth about the wind, and will Grayson be able to make peace with her family situation?
Like Lloyd's other titles (The Key to Extraordinary and A Snicker of Magic), this has a quirky, Southern setting and strong themes of female empowerment, family ties, and everyday magic that resonate with a lot of people. Expect to see a lot of love for this new story. At 368 pages, it is a bit longer than other middle grade magical realism titles.
Roxie Darling's grandmother, Ruthie Diamond Darling, was a folk singer when she was younger, and Roxie wants to follow in her footsteps. Since Ruthie wants to hit the road again, Roxie is excited, especially after an unfortunate incident at a school pool party has left her feeling "less than" and caused her to be estranged from her best friend, Loretta. Grayson Patch also has a complicated life; she's in foster care and uses a walker because of her brittle bone disease, but she is hopeful that her older sister Beanie will connect with her on the sister's 18th birthday, and the two will get an apartment in New York City together. For now, Grayson is being cared for by the Cottons, who have a three year old daughter, Freya. In the girls' Tennessee town, there is a Witching Wind that causes a lot of distress, and this season has seen more and stronger winds pummel the town. When Granny Ruth goes missing, Roxie's cousin Collette (along with her pet groundhog) helps Roxie look for her, and also tells Roxie some of the history of the wind, which is tied to the True sisters who lived on Monarch Mountain. Grayson struggles with the fact that her sister won't text her back, and reaches out to a social worker, Donna for help. At school, the girls realize that they are both dealing with someone who is missing, as well as unfriendly people at school, and end up together with a supportive group called the Yeehaws. After Granny Ruth, is found in the woods, she doesn't remember Roxie. The medical professionals claim that she had a stroke, but Roxie is determined that the wind has stolen her memories. The Yeehaws plans a camping trip on the mountain to find out the secret of the Whispering Wind. The Cottons agree to let Grayson go. Roxie is also struggling with her self esteem, and is given negative messages about her weight again and again, especially by school personnel. She gets better messages from Grayson, who informs her that "every body is a swimsuit body". Once on the mountain, Roxie meets Addison True, who says that Ruth had visited her recently in order to obtain something for Roxie. Will Roxie be able to find out the truth about the wind, and will Grayson be able to make peace with her family situation?
Like Lloyd's other titles (The Key to Extraordinary and A Snicker of Magic), this has a quirky, Southern setting and strong themes of female empowerment, family ties, and everyday magic that resonate with a lot of people. Expect to see a lot of love for this new story. At 368 pages, it is a bit longer than other middle grade magical realism titles.
July 10, 2025
Told from multiple points of view, this middle grade novel is full of legend and adventure and themes of friendship, family, and finding your place in this world.
Roxie’s 6th grade year began with a mortifying splash at the local pool in front of all her classmates. When her music star Granny invites her to join her on a tour, Roxie’s thrilled at the idea of leaving “the incident” behind. But then Granny goes missing…
Grayson is heading to a new foster home, but she doesn’t plan on staying long. Her older sister Beanie is about to turn 18 and has promised be become Grayson’s legal guardian. But when Beanie’s 18th birthday comes and goes and is nowhere to be found, Grayson can’t believe she’d just vanish.
Could it be that the legendary Witching Wind stole them both?
An incredible story about what it means to be a good human in this world filed with mesmerizing storytelling.
Some favorite lines:
Page 22
Sometimes I wonder if dogs are the way God hugs us while we’re here on earth.
Page 59
I don’t think people realize how loud whispers can be. How your heart’s hearing is even better than your ears. How the words people say can stick and stay forever, even when they don’t mean for them to.
Page 88
Nobody should apologize for taking up space in the world, according to Beanie.
Page 89
Grayson figures the world would be way nicer if people looked out for other people – no matter what they wore, how they got around, what kind of family they came from. Whatever. If we could all act like one big family full of weirdos, maybe we’d all be better off.
Page 168
Maybe it takes a catastrophe for people to realize that we have heart stuff in common. We all have tender places. We’re all hurting over something, or somebody. I wish it didn’t take a tragedy to do that, though. I wish we could be kind to one another on all the regular days, too.
Page 256
The way people love – and the decisions they make – that’s what shapes their nature. That’s what Grayson believes, anyway.
Page 306
“… There’s always somebody who will try to silence your story. But there is also, always, somebody who wants to hear it. Somebody who’ll give you a safe place to sit. And share. And send your words into the world, however you want them said.”
Roxie’s 6th grade year began with a mortifying splash at the local pool in front of all her classmates. When her music star Granny invites her to join her on a tour, Roxie’s thrilled at the idea of leaving “the incident” behind. But then Granny goes missing…
Grayson is heading to a new foster home, but she doesn’t plan on staying long. Her older sister Beanie is about to turn 18 and has promised be become Grayson’s legal guardian. But when Beanie’s 18th birthday comes and goes and is nowhere to be found, Grayson can’t believe she’d just vanish.
Could it be that the legendary Witching Wind stole them both?
An incredible story about what it means to be a good human in this world filed with mesmerizing storytelling.
Some favorite lines:
Page 22
Sometimes I wonder if dogs are the way God hugs us while we’re here on earth.
Page 59
I don’t think people realize how loud whispers can be. How your heart’s hearing is even better than your ears. How the words people say can stick and stay forever, even when they don’t mean for them to.
Page 88
Nobody should apologize for taking up space in the world, according to Beanie.
Page 89
Grayson figures the world would be way nicer if people looked out for other people – no matter what they wore, how they got around, what kind of family they came from. Whatever. If we could all act like one big family full of weirdos, maybe we’d all be better off.
Page 168
Maybe it takes a catastrophe for people to realize that we have heart stuff in common. We all have tender places. We’re all hurting over something, or somebody. I wish it didn’t take a tragedy to do that, though. I wish we could be kind to one another on all the regular days, too.
Page 256
The way people love – and the decisions they make – that’s what shapes their nature. That’s what Grayson believes, anyway.
Page 306
“… There’s always somebody who will try to silence your story. But there is also, always, somebody who wants to hear it. Somebody who’ll give you a safe place to sit. And share. And send your words into the world, however you want them said.”
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews